“A really, really freak accident” is now Spencer Arrighetti described the batting-practice incident that resulted in a broken right thumb for the Astros pitcher. Last Monday, Arrighetti was in the outfield playing catch while the Mariners were taking BP, and a line drive from the batter’s box struck the right-hander before Arrighetti could properly react. As the pitcher told MLB.com’s Brian McTaggart, he instinctively covered his head with his hands after someone called out about the incoming line drive, only for the ball to hit Arrighetti’s thumb.
While a broken thumb is still a tough outcome, Arrighetti said “the road back is really clear-cut….We’re going to continually image it over the course of the next few weeks, and as soon as we feel it’s in a place where I’m ready to throw the ball, I’ll throw the ball again.” Houston general manager Dana Brown said on Friday that the team believes Arrighetti can be back in action in around six weeks’ time, if all goes well with the recovery process.
With Arrighetti sidelined, Ryan Gusto received the opportunity for his first MLB start, though things didn’t exactly go swimmingly for Gusto in Houston’s 4-1 loss to the Angels yesterday. Gusto allowed three earned runs over his four innings (72 pitches) of work, with two of those runs coming early when Gusto surrendered hits to his first three batters of the game.
The Astros have an off-day on Thursday, so the team technically doesn’t need a fifth starter again until April 22 if the other four starters are kept on their regular rest schedule. This gives the Astros some time to determine if Gusto will get another start, or if they could return him to bullpen action and use another starter in his stead. As noted by the Houston Chronicle’s Sam Warren, Brown said on Friday that Triple-A starter Colton Gordon could be called up (in what would be Gordon’s big league debut) to start if the club ultimately decides to keep Gusto in a relief role.
Gusto also made his MLB debut earlier this season, and he posted a 1.13 ERA over his first eight innings and four appearances out of Houston’s pen. While the Astros don’t want to close the door on Gusto’s potential as a starter in the near term, there is obvious appeal in deploying him as a quality multi-inning reliever. The fact that Arrighetti will miss at least the next six weeks does allow the Astros some flexibility in figuring how exactly they’ll address the fifth starter spot, as there’s enough time for Gusto to start games and then get moved back into a long relief or swingman role.
Brendan Rodgers hasn’t played in either of the Astros’ last two games due to some left hip soreness, manager Joe Espada told Matt Kawahara of the Houston Chronicle and other reporters. The injury appears to be pretty minor, as Rodgers felt well enough to take some grounders before Saturday’s game. Rodgers is off to a respectable start (.250/.351/.313) over his first 37 plate appearances in a Houston uniform, as he went from minor league signing to starting second baseman due to the Astros’ decision to use Jose Altuve primarily as a left fielder.
I think that sound I heard in the distance was the Astros’ window closing for the very last time. It was a very good run, though.
This same thing was being said at this point last year.
“The same thing”…And it was true then too wasn’t it? In my honest opinion, the Astros will not be a serious title contender again before the year 2030.
I’m not suggesting the Astros will not ever make the playoffs again. I’m suggesting they won’t be legitimate title contenders again for a very long time.
If you’re counting just making the playoffs, then you’ll have to remember that under the new playoff format, both the Reds and Marlins have made the playoffs in the last 5 years too.
I agree with you and not just because I am a Rangers fan. The division is much tighter and the Astros are no longer a power house. Every year it will be a battle and the Astros are assured of nothing.
“I agree with you..Rangers fan”…You actually summarized what I was trying to say, better than I did.
Haha. Our best hitters have started very, very slow. They will turn the corner shortly and we are a whole whopping 2 games back. That window isn’t nearly as closed as you may think. I don’t want to hear about our far system either. Look at all the Astros farmhands spread around the league and killing it. We’ve never had an acclaimed farm system but we put some damn good players in ML rosters. Guys many of you have no idea that we’re drafted by the Astros.
Honestly surprised more injuries don’t occur during batting practice.
Better the thumb than taking one off the dome but standing in front of MLB hitter taking batting practice is a good way to get hurt.
Arrighetti? More like argghhhighetti. Amirite?
Betting on pure starters like Arrighetti is fine—until you need flexibility. Gusto’s early success out of the bullpen suggested a valuable swingman profile, but forcing him into a starter’s mold feels more reactive than strategic. If Houston keeps shuffling arms without matching role to skillset, they risk bleeding winnable games by June. It’s not just about who’s injured—it’s about how they’re replacing them.
It’s not just about
It’s not just about
It’s not just about
All of your AI written slop sounds the same pal
He/it had like 4 or 5 comments in a row using the same phrase, ‘nobody’s discussing this, because’
I wonder if he gets bored
maybe he’s a bot?
Does MLBTR have bots? They’ve become something of the new common pest
They didn’t have a choice. They couldn’t plan on Areghetti’s thumb. Next time they’ll bring up a starter. It does show how shallow their depth is.
It has been one heck of a run for the Astros. I don’t think they can scrap and start all over again like they did before because of the long-term commitments they have to Alvarez and Altuve. And that in itself creates a bit of a conundrum because you cannot have two designated hitters.
Perhaps five years of mediocrity are coming