The Guardians optioned second baseman Juan Brito and outfielders Angel Martínez and Johnathan Rodríguez to Triple-A Columbus. It’s most notable regarding Brito, who entered camp with a good chance to secure the second base job.
Cleveland created a hole at the position when they dealt Andrés Giménez to Toronto to offload the nearly $100MM remaining on his contract. Last year’s first overall pick Travis Bazzana is the expected long-term answer. He hasn’t gotten beyond High-A, so he’s unlikely to be a factor before the second half at the earliest.
The 23-year-old Brito was a much more realistic candidate to break camp. He’s been on the 40-man roister since the Guardians swapped Nolan Jones to Colorado to acquire him during the 2022-23 offseason. Brito spent all of last season on optional assignment to Triple-A Columbus. He hit .256/.365/.443 with a robust 13.5% walk rate against a modest 16.1% strikeout percentage. He popped 21 homers and stole 13 bases.
Brito doesn’t have huge physical tools, but the well-rounded offensive profile and ability to play in the middle of the diamond landed him among the league’s Top 100 prospects at FanGraphs. The switch-hitter had a bizarre Spring Training. He hit four home runs in 39 trips to the plate, but those accounted for all but three of his total hits. He hit .189 with a .231 on-base percentage that wasn’t enough to grab an Opening Day job.
The Guardians will seemingly go with a combination of Tyler Freeman, Daniel Schneemann and potentially Gabriel Arias at the keystone. The righty-hitting Freeman owns a modest .223/.304/.329 slash in parts of three seasons, but he’s been on fire this spring (.278/.381/.583 in 14 games). Schneemann, a lefty bat, hit .218/.303/.368 in 73 games as a 27-year-old rookie last season. He’s also had a big showing in camp (.265/.342/.559 over 14 contests). Schneemann has moved all around the infield and outfield and only logged 59 innings at second base between Triple-A and the majors last year.
Arias is out of options and needs to make the team or be exposed to waivers. The 25-year-old utilityman has hit a couple homers this spring but has only a .275 OBP in 15 games. His plate discipline has been a major problem over his three big league seasons. He’s a .212/.274/.350 hitter with a 32.3% strikeout rate over 563 plate appearances.
Britos numbers went down every season as he advanced through the minor leagues. He’s 23. Needs another season at triple A to see if he can catch up.
I know they will out Arias there to start but Freeman looks like a candidate to take that job on full time. His approach is different that it has been in the last two years.
Freemann Schneemann.
is literally a thing.
Poor Johnathan Rodriguez getting stuck in this organization so in love with displaced middle infielders playing Guards ball. His wOBA the last 3 years was never under 4 — on a team desperate for power no less. Trade the man.
He has a .932 ops in over 700 AAA PAs and going back for more after having been given just 40 MLB PA. Meanwhile Arias, Schneemann and Freeman have had over 1400 PA of sub .650 ops production. A team should only put up with two of such feeble offerings, not three.
Okay, at least they addressed that 3 MI thing with the Freeman trade. I wish it’d have been Arias’s departure instead. Oh well.