The Diamondbacks have received recent trade interest from a couple teams in Jordan Montgomery, reports John Gambadoro of 98.7 FM in Phoenix. There’s no indication that a pre-Opening Day deal is likely, but it’s notable those conversations have continued with the regular season eight days away.
As has been the case all offseason, the contract is the big impediment. Montgomery will play this year on a $22.5MM salary. That’s a sum no team was going to take in full. It’s especially difficult to offload a significant portion of the money at this point. Most teams have neared or reached the payroll at which they’re willing to spend before the season.
That’s reflected in the comparatively low costs of free agent starting pitching. Jose Quintana and Andrew Heaney — both of whom are coming off better seasons than Montgomery just had — signed one-year deals worth less than $6MM after camp opened. Kyle Gibson, Spencer Turnbull and Lance Lynn remain unsigned and are presumably looking at even lesser guarantees. It makes a Spring Training deal difficult to pull off. Other teams would presumably want Arizona to pay Montgomery’s contract down to a few million dollars while accepting a middling return.
The Diamondbacks haven’t shown that level of desperation to deal the veteran lefty, though they’d clearly welcome an opportunity to make a move. Montgomery pitched his way out of last year’s rotation. He finished the year with a 6.23 earned run average over 117 innings. His strikeout rate fell from roughly league average to a career-worst 15.6% clip.
Things weren’t quite so bleak on a per-pitch basis. Montgomery got whiffs on 12.3% of his offerings, which is in line with his career average. He’d posted three consecutive sub-4.00 ERA showings with solid peripherals between 2021-23. Montgomery didn’t sign until Opening Day last year after a frustrating free agent sequence, presumably leading to some level of rust. The context provides hope he can at least recapture back-of-the-rotation form, but he won’t have a path to the Opening Day rotation in the desert.
Arizona added Corbin Burnes to a staff that already included Zac Gallen, Merrill Kelly, Eduardo Rodriguez and Brandon Pfaadt. Righty Ryne Nelson might be pushed to Triple-A to begin the season. Nelson had a 3.23 ERA in the second half last season. The Snakes stuck with him in the rotation down the stretch while pushing Montgomery to the bullpen. Even if he begins the season in the minors, Nelson will probably be the first choice if any of Arizona’s top five starters suffer an injury. Montgomery has more than enough service time to refuse a minor league assignment, so he’s likely to work in long relief if he begins the season with the Diamondbacks.
The 32-year-old southpaw would presumably welcome a trade that gives him a clearer path back to rotation work. Montgomery will be a free agent next offseason. His future earning power will be greater if he pitches well as a starter rather than spending most or all of the season in low-leverage relief. Arizona owner Ken Kendrick was also publicly critical of the signing last fall, saying it was “a horrible decision to have invested that money in a guy that performed as poorly as he did.” (Kendrick directed the criticism for the move at himself rather than the front office, saying he pushed GM Mike Hazen to pursue the deal.)
Montgomery has only taken the ball twice this spring. His first start couldn’t have gone much worse. The Reds blitzed him for five runs on two hits, two walks and a hit batter. He recorded only one out. Montgomery pitched much more effectively this afternoon, working 2 2/3 scoreless frames with a couple strikeouts against the Rockies.
Sure if the D-Backs pay 90 percent of his remaining salary and don’t expect any decent prospects back.
Yes, his value really can’t go any lower so they might as well keep him around and hope for an uptick.
I think about the flipside. If any team is willing to take on most of his salary, he could be had for practically nothing prospect-wise. He’s effectively on a one year deal. Prior to last year’s disaster, he had three straight very solid years. And last year he was hurt by a .351 BABIP despite an EV in line with his career averages. Any team with a little wiggle room payroll-wise ought to at least check in.
He should already be an Oriole. He’s even succeeded in that division. It’s a shame for him he had that injury at the start of camp. A full ramp up could have saved him from long relief purgatory.
Please list me the teams that are at least 22.5MM below the next tax level that would actually need him. Not the NYY. They’re not paying 110% on a gamble pitcher. Not Texas. That’s why they signed Corbin. Doubt the Mets want to pay 110% on him either. Arizona is going to have to pay it down.
“Check in on him, ….and pay his salary”
Any team would rather sign one of the 4+ available free agents, who are comparable, for 1/5 of his salary. As the article states in so many words. Why do you think a team would do this?
Get him, Yankees!
I am sure they are one of the usual suspects.
literally what I was thinking. with all the injuries and Schmidt potentially going to IL, might as well
He’s done so well in spring training…. after that wonderful season last year. And he’s only making $22.5 million. Guess I’m trying to say NFW.
With the luxury tax they would be paying double what he’s making.. if the DBacks paid 10 million of his contract the Yankees would be paying 20 million for him.
$22.5 million total salary.
$10.0 million Dbacks
$12.5 million Yankees
$12.5 million + 110% penalty
Yanks pay $26.25 million for Montgomery with the penalties.
This money with the penalties adds up to around the same amount of Gerrit Coles insurance payout.
I had the same thought but it likely won’t happen.
Rumors: Yes, that’s exactly why I don’t believe it will happen. But, at this rate, they’re going to need someone. Their pitchers are going down like the men on Hamburger Hill.
For some reason I think the Yankees had an issue with them and that’s why he was a goner but they could really use the old him now for hopefully not much $$.
In 2022, they had Gerritt Cole, Frankie Montas, Nestor Cortes, Domingo German, Luis Severino, James Taillon, and Clarke Schmidt in AAA. Monty was not going to start in the playoffs so they traded him for Harrison Bader.
After the trade: “I’ve got no bad blood,” Montgomery said. “The Yankees drafted me. Gave me seven good years of being in the big leagues. I’ve got a lot of really good relationships still over there. I got nothing but respect for ‘em.”
I could see the Mets taking the diff on a deal for Marte.
The Dbacks OF is pretty stacked, very doubtful they want Marte.
Mets already have enough SPs.
And…
Manaea will be back in April.
Montas will be back in early June.
And…. Yeah nobody wants Marte for anything more than a couple million.
They’re holding onto him until summer, when injuries hit other teams hard. By June or July, some playoff hopeful will lose a starter and get desperate. Free agents will be gone, and trades will cost a lot. Then, Arizona can eat part of Montgomery’s salary—say, drop it to $10 million—and suddenly he’s a steal compared to what’s left. They could trade him for a great young player, way better than the small offers they’d get today.
Come July Monty is only owed $10MM anyhow, but generally speaking I like your hypothetical situation.
Owed 10. But potentially worth much more. Who will be shocked if he bounces back ?
The only pushback I would give to that is that the DBacks themselves will be making a playoff pitch. If he’s pitching well enough to garner trade interest, they could just keep him and fight for a playoff spot.
The mexico city chihuahuas (of the Mexican independent league) are willing to trade a months supply of empanadas for Montgomery
If the Yankees wanted Monty back they would have traded for him already. Plain and simple he’s contract is too expensive unless Yankees do addition by subtraction. I don’t think Yankees have anyone Arizona wants
The Yankees have PTBNL stashed in the minors. That’ll be who Arizona gets for Montgomery. The rest of the negotiation is over how much of the contract the Dbacks will eat.
By the time the trade deadline rolls around, someone in the minors will have established themselves as a prospect worth a few million to offset some of the salary.
That’s Los Diablos Rojos to you, gabacho.
Either of the NY teams could shell out about $15-17 million to acquire Montgomery in a trade. DBacks could supplement $5-7 million and pick up some decent help in such a trade. Both NY teams are in desperate need of starting pitching help.
Both teams have to double down on Monty’s salary though… (CBT penalties)
Yeah the days of teams like the Yankees taking on everyone mistakes in free agency are over with the tax penalties. Nobody is picking up a guy who makes 22 million to pay him 45 million actually with the penalties.
We found the Dbacks PR department burner account.
as a dbacks diehard fan makes no sense to trade him yet unless someone eats half the contract. We have 3 injury prone pitchers so don’t trade yet.
I know a few folks in AZ’s front office and they have confirmed that TAKERDBACKS is none other than Ken Kendrick himself
Why did Strom get canned?
Old
What’s wrong with saying we?
Fans count as “we”
Calm down Miss Harris.
harrisstan
You don’t work or play for them.
=======================
Nonsense.
The royal “we” helps to determine whether the poster is speaking as a BB fan or as a team fan. That, in turn, makes a difference on how the reader of the opinion assesses that opinion.
We won! They lost. This is how it usually goes with fans.
It’s rumors of teams doing their due diligence.
With Ranger hurt and Walker being Walker, the Phillies probably are one of those teams.
I just dont see a desperation trade by the Dbacks right now. They could have eaten salary and received a middling return months ago. Imo, they have been waiting all off-season for SP injuries to cause a contender to reach out in desperation. Perhaps that time is now. In all likelihood, Montgomery starts the season as a long reliever and moves into the Dbacks rotation due to injury or is traded at the deadline.
There were alot more options, and better options, out there at the time though
If Montgomery is healthy, the Diamondbacks would find it in their interest to put him in the rotation to reestablish his value. Its just not going to help his value as a long man.
Montgomery appears to be healthy now, but he had a setback early in camp (index finger) that has limited him to two appearances. As he has not built up the innings/stamina to start, he will begin the season as a long man out of the pen. I concur Montgomery can best reestablish his value by starting, so I think once he’s properly built up, he will be the Dbacks first choice to enter the rotation in the event of a SP injury. That said, imo Nelson is the better SP right now and going forward. Unfortunately for Nelson, he has options so may start the season in Reno.
Monty had one bad season. Very likely it was due to missing spring training.
His career has been solid if not amazing . A fresh start elsewhere might do him some good, after he was bashed by an owner like that. I predict he will be more like his old self this year, wherever he pitches.
Nobody is going to pay $22.5 million to see if he can turn it around.
I mean, the DBacks are!
Touche. No one is *willingly* going to pay $22.5 million.
Yanks obviously
Brewers are suddenly looking pretty thin in the SP department in the early-going here, and we just so happen to have a large also expiring contract in Rhys Hoskins that we could swap for Montgomery.
Where would Rhys play, perma-DH? They traded for Josh Naylor already…
Yes, he’s better suited for DH duties. But also given that Naylor doesn’t really hit LHP, and Rhys mashes LHP, I don’t think the fit is all that bad.
Three way deal can be worked out. Yanks send Stroman to Brewers, Arizona sends Monty to the Yanks. Brewers send Hoskins to Arizona.
Love the creativity, but the Dbacks have no need for Hoskins. Barring injury, the Dbacks have 1B, DH and OF comfortably covered. They are on the lookout for high leverage RP.
Hoskins is carrying the load of -0.2 bWAR from last season. Extremely limited trade value. Pitchers who have bad seasons are a more valuable asset than a limited player like Hoskins. Just my opinion.
You’d have to replace Hoskins with Megill. Arizona would want a closer
Montgomery straight up to the Mets for Starlin Marte ?
0% chance I do this if I’m in Arizona, 100% chance you’re a Mets fan!
No thanks.
~This Mets fan
Arizona don’t need an OF. They’ll want a late inning reliever
Rangers
Quite possibly? Corbin isn’t blocking another add… maybe the $$$ is the only thing holding this up.
The Dbacks spent big money on Monty now they want their Monty back.
Jordan Montgomery for Javier Baez.
I wanted my Braves to go after him but now I’m out. .1 inning in spring training 5 runs. U should care about spring stats but.. his struggle bus isn’t gone…
Arrenado for Montgomery needs a hard look and fine details both ways
D’Backs have no use for Arenado, now if St. Louis would say Hensley that definitely would get the D’Backs attention.
It’s not about use vs getting bad blood out of the club house. Definitely a necessary evil for both.
I’m going to have to call BS on this one. I know they credited a source but their Source isn’t that reliable. The rest of this article is that the Diamondbacks have had interest but they can’t name anyone? Sounds like somebody’s trying to drum up some interest.
Montgomery being traded will come down to how bad is the remaining FA’s that have not signed compared to paying for Montgomery. The more the D’Backs pay on the contract the more expensive the compensation will get for the other team. If the Phillies or Mets see themselves with having to sign a FA pitcher who they know don’t have the record that Montgomery has except for last year, will they just say they can lose the NL East without Montgomery or they can win the NL East with him. The DBacks will make a deal concerning Montgomery it all depends how much they are willing to paydown his contract, and the other team willing to give up, the Dbacks can wait.
I don’t see ANY team that would be willing to take on Monty unless Arizona eats $17.5M of his $22.5M contract. Betting $5M on Monty is still a high risk, but that is most likely the ceiling for any team in MLB right now.
Even with Arizona eating this much money, they won’t get much back in prospect capital either. They’ll just get $5M in salary relief.
As a resident of Denver it is quite funny to me that he got shelled and got one out in his first appearance, then he was scoreless against the useless Rox