The Brewers have hired Billy Eppler as a special advisor, according to a report from Andy Martino of SNY. Eppler’s full title is Special Advisor, Scouting and Baseball Operations.
The role marks Eppler’s return to baseball after being placed on the ineligible list just over a year ago. That placement lasted only through the end of the 2024 World Series, and he’s been eligible to return to an MLB front office in the months since then. Eppler’s suspension was, in the words of MLB at the time of its announcement, for “improper use of Injured List placements, including the deliberate fabrication of injuries; and the associated submission of documentation for the purposes of securing multiple improper Injured List placements during the 2022 and 2023 seasons.”
Eppler’s violation occurred during his tenure as Mets GM, which lasted from shortly after the 2021 season until shortly after the conclusion of the 2023 campaign. Eppler was the club’s head of baseball operations during the vast majority of his tenure, but immediately after the 2023 season concluded the Mets announced the hiring of president of baseball operations David Stearns, who was set to take the reins and push Eppler into a number two role. That arrangement lasted a matter of only days, however, as Eppler almost immediately stepped down from his role with the Mets when news of MLB’s investigation into improper use of the injured list by the Mets first became public.
So-called “phantom IL” stints have been commonplace in the league for decades and have occurred on every team at one point or another, with some players even openly admitting that they aren’t actually injured while on the shelf. More nebulous diagnoses such as soreness or fatigue can be used by a club to offer a struggling player a physical and mental reset while clearing their roster spot for a period of time. The practice is technically illegal, but those rules have not typically been strictly enforced by the league. This made MLB’s investigation into the Mets and subsequent suspension of Eppler a cause for confusion for both many fans and even some within the game.
With Eppler’s suspension now a thing of the past, he’ll join a Brewers front office headed by GM Matt Arnold that was, coincidentally, run by Stearns until he eventually stepped down as the club’s top decision-maker and later took over baseball operations from Eppler. The specific duties of Eppler’s role as special advisor to Arnold are not yet clear, though his title falls in line with his past experience. Prior to serving as Mets GM, Eppler served as GM of the Angels from 2015 to 2020 and as assistant GM and director of pro scouting for the Yankees from 2005 to 2015.
Eppler’s teams have had relatively little success in the past, with his tenure as Angels GM going by without any playoff appearances while his two years with the Mets were split between a 100-win campaign and a missed postseason. Overall, that’s good for a 508-524 record and a .492 winning percentage over his seven seasons leading a baseball operations department. Even with that somewhat middling track record, the 49-year-old sports a long resume of high-level front office work, and his decades of experience figure to be a valuable resource for the Brewers going into the 2025 campaign.
There has to be more to the story, because teams use the DL list prolifically, but I doubt we will hear of it. Presumably there was something that was too much even for MLB’s high tolerance.
Someone had a bone to pick with Eppler.
Luis Guillorme Sr. Aka Karen Guillorme.
I got a feeling it had to be a concrete complaint to MLB by a player that did not want placement on IL.
What SHEA said, or Billy had been previously and sternly warned.
It was always weird to me that Eppler’s Mets were accused(and apparently convicted)of (illegally) manipulating the I.L when virtually every Major League team does this to various extents.
Phantom IL stints are a necessity so Eppler being punished was always odd. Maybe he overused it, too much for MLB to brush aside? We’re probably never going to know.
Tons of people cheat on taxes and they cannot go after everyone. Hence, they tend to focus on making examples that will then be publicized and used as a warning for folks to toe the line.
Eppler and the Mets were probably somewhat bolder and less careful to cover their tracks in their approach and left themselves open to be the example.
@Carver..”They cannot go after everyone”..Good point. You’re probably right.
Of course, as we are now squarely in the Roy Cohn / DFT era of “deny everything, and repeat the same lies over and over again” and the b0neheads will believe you, perhaps it is surprising that Eppler was punished for his much lesser sins. Perhaps he missed the memo…
May be just coincidence but IIRC there were rumors that allegations were coming from a certain pitcher who had a prominent role with the MLBPA, around the time of their last CBA negotiations with MLB.
Some teams (Dodgers) did it to the extreme that MLB had to amend the rules so the same players couldn’t be recalled every few days to take an “injured” players spot, effectively acting as a 27th man on the roster
of course you have evidence to share with us…
google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j…
Thank you.
Did Eppler’s suspension prior to last season keep any other GM from potentially misusing the IL in 2024?
Didn’t seem like it. Seemed like just as many finger nail, aches and muscle tweaks etc as ever.
Maybe the punishment isn’t harsh enough to stop the alleged misuse, or maybe there is a lot more to the Billy Eppler / Mets story and MLB chose to only put one alleged crime on the docket to protect other parties.
So the moral is be a complete cheating scumbag like Rose or Eppler and somehow as long as you whine enough or your pathetic family does, welcome back.
Good Lord what is your deal
“What is your deal”..A lot of very unhappy people apparently use this site, too.
Because the comment section is loosely moderated I think some people get off on posting inflammatory and/or outrageous comments just to get people riled up. In many cases I don’t even think they believe what they write. When I identify those posters I mute them. Thankfully the mute system here is very effective.
Great points Tiger, and I’ll add that if you consider yourself of average intellect (like most of us here would), then that correlates to 50% of humanity being dumber than you. Lots of dummies out there… and I believe *some* actually do believe what they write here. The bottom-of-the-barrel big dummies do not post anything, for… reasons.
They clearly need some pizza
Patrick corbin had 19 losses with at least 2 more starts remaining. Then it was reported he had a back injury and would not pitch again in 2022. Should mike Rizzo have gotten into trouble because this looked very fishy.
As I replied to a post in this thread, the only reason I can think of MLB investigating and taking action is a player not agreeing to the placement and filing an actual complaint. It’s hard to argue sores etc when said player directly contradicts the reason, particularly with medical proof.
So many experts. So little knowledge.
InEppler is probably the worst GM that I’ve ever seen. I wouldn’t even have him “special advise” a 7 and under women’s softball league, let alone a major league franchise
Upvote for proper nicknaming
😉
Every post of his is unhinged. TerribleMetsFanIn7 is more like it.
He won’t have any decision-making capacity in Milwaukee. I assume he’s just there to help Arnold make connections.
Eppler for Stearns essentially.
The attached QOs on the FOBOs went MIA.
Billy Eppler is a good guy that’s guilty of nothing more than what every other GM does. Is he good at his job? Meh. Not much success at all. But is he a bad guy? Not in the least, he’s actually a pretty decent, approachable person.
A friend of mine who I played with in the minors who now works in a front office said when Eppler was suspended for that, “who did he p**s off?” It was quite known that it was common practice.
Exactly. And it’s difficult to know who he pissed off because he’s just so unassuming, easy going, and warm individual. He’s a family man that loves surfing and scouting. It’s hard to picture that profile of a man needing to be the target of any disciplinary action.
Eppler is the twerp who is so bad at his job he offered Alonso the 7/158m extension.
Epper is also the only GM in MLB history to be trolled by the team that fired him.
He was so bad at procuring pitching while with the Angels that the first draft after he was booted, the team drafted ONLY pitching. No position players, anywhere. That had never happened before, in any MLB draft. It was genuinely extremely funny. Fans in the know picked up on what the Angels were doing, and especially in the later rounds the cheering was off the charts as the Angels picked another pitcher, then another, then another….
It was brilliant.
Yeah, let them all back in.
Rose…meh….
Shoeless Joe, For Sure.
and while we are at it let’s pretend the Astros are legitimate World Series Champs.
Should never have been suspended. I guess the Brewers are wanting to be a below .500 teams under his leadership.
Except they didn’t hire him for a leadership role. They hired him in a consulting role, specifically in scouting, which is an area in which he actually seems somewhat competent.
Eppler is not competent in scouting. His time as a GM of the Angels proves that.
in all fairness, i’m sure Arte’s meddling didn’t help much.
@geofft
That’s a leadership role. They are expecting him to be in a consulting role specifically in scouting, some someone is expecting him to have leadership in this role. It’s not like he’s flipping burgers during the game.
Saying it’s a leadership role is tenuous. He’s not in charge of anything; he’s just another voice.
Eppler did work for two big market
Organizations which had a few large contracts or major trades. Probably proving contract negotiations or insight to a club that doesn’t sign a lot a big name free agents.
and both teams have meddling owners.
Fall Guy