As the Yankees continue to looking for infield help, the team has shown interest in Enrique Hernandez and Yoan Moncada, the New York Post’s Mark W. Sanchez reports. Moncada may or may not still be on the Yankees’ radar, as Sanchez writes that the club asked for Moncada’s medicals “early in the offseason,” but a source says “the Yankees have [since] not re-engaged” on the former White Sox third baseman.
This isn’t the first time that the Yankees have been linked to Hernandez, as New York was a finalist for the veteran utilityman’s services when he was a free agent last winter. Hernandez instead re-signed with the Dodgers to a one-year, $4MM deal, and the decision paid off in the form of another championship ring. The Yankees got a direct look at Hernandez during the postseason, when he hit .278/.316/.389 over 20 plate appearances during the Dodgers’ five-game triumph over the Bronx Bombers in the World Series.
There hasn’t been any public buzz about Hernandez’s free agent market this offseason, which could due to the perception (as Sanchez notes) that a reunion with the Dodgers is inevitable. Los Angeles could be waiting until Spring Training opens and roster space can be created when players are shifted to the 60-day injured list, but until that happens, another team could theoretically able to swoop in and make Hernandez a more attractive offer.
For instance, New York could offer Hernandez more playing time than he might find on the crowded L.A. roster. The right-handed hitting Hernandez could complement Jazz Chisholm Jr. or Cody Bellinger (both left-handed bats) on the infield or in center field, or complement the switch-hitting Jasson Dominguez in left field. Hernandez’s versatility gives the Yankees even more flexibility in figuring out Chisholm’s eventual position at either second base or third base, and in deciding how DJ LeMahieu, Oswaldo Cabrera, and Oswald Peraza all fit into the roster picture.
Hernandez’s offense has tended to ebb and flow over the course of his 11-year MLB career, balancing out at a .238/.308/.405 slash line and 93 wRC+ over 3896 career PA. Come October, however, Hernandez has surged to hit .278/.353/.522 in 259 postseason PA with the Dodgers and Red Sox, earning the 33-year-old a reputation as a big-game player. This kind of production from an unheralded spot on the roster could be just what the Yankees need to take that final step towards another title after falling short to Los Angeles this past season.
Moncada hasn’t played second base since the 2018 season, so he would more directly slot into the third base mix if he indeed ended up joining the Yankees. The Mariners, Cubs, and Blue Jays are among the clubs who have also been linked to Moncada’s services this offseason, as he begins a new chapter in his career after the White Sox declined their $25MM club option on the infielder last fall.
Chicago’s decision came as no surprise given how Moncada played in only 12 games in 2024 due to a left adductor strain, though that total could’ve been bumped up by a few games had the White Sox not sparingly used Moncada after he was activated from the 60-day injured list in mid-September. It marked a tough end to an up-and-down eight-season run for Moncada on the South Side, as he hit .254/.332/.425 over 3122 PA in a White Sox uniform. Much more was expected given Moncada’s past status as an elite prospect, and the five-year, $70MM extension he signed with the Sox prior to the 2020 season.
Now looking to rebuild his value after a few injury-marred seasons, Moncada would be stepping into a high-pressure situation even as a part-time player on a Yankees team expected to win now. Still, the amount of interest Moncada has received indicates that multiple teams think he has change-of-scenery potential once removed from what became an increasingly dismal situation in Chicago.
rocky7
Hernandez will wait to get the call from the Dodgers, so if I was the Yankees I wouldn’t waste my time trying to engage him….besides, given his time in Beantown….he was a very below average player offensively and only offered them defensive flexibility given that he can play multiple positions…..Moncado….might be worth taking a harder look at but is he really better than any internal options from opening day up until the trade deadline when there will surely be players available should internal options really be dragging the team down……
rocky7
Check my comment about Hernandez time in Beantown….he had 1 pretty decent year and 1 that you can forget about pretty quickly….just to modify my comment…..still think he’s destined to sit and wait for the Dodgers to call……
MLB Top 100 Commenter
Kike Hernandez can dislocate Cody Bellinger’s shoulder again. Those who do not study baseball history are doomed to repeat it.
Zerbs63
Kiki’s value is not as a starter. He’s an above avg defender at many positions, but a below avg hitter during the regular season. This has been shown during his time with the Red Sox.
His value is to a team like the Dodgers who value and utilize his def versatility. When you get injuries at different positions he can fill in for short periods of time. He for whatever reason is also a stud in the playoffs with the bat. He has had multiple clutch postseason HRs and RBIs throughout his Dodger postseason career.
Kiki wants to be back as a Dodger and understands his role. The Dodgers want him back, but with 40 man roster full until spring training. After that they can put people on the 60 day IL. This is when the Dodgers will sign him similar to last year.
Bivouac-Sal
the Dodgers 60-day IL will be made up of pitchers. they are full up on position players unless they send Pages to AAA or somehow unload CT3. Neither is likely.
Zerbs63
The roster was full last year as well in spring training. Then they signed him in late Feb 2024. I agree the Dodgers have less flexibility, but someone will be hurt or moved.
BlueSkies_LA
I can see the Dodgers packaging Taylor together with someone out of their massive starting pitching depth and finding Taylor a new home without a lot of difficulty. Then they’d have room. Gonna happen? I wouldn’t say so. But thinking the Dodgers already have an informal deal in place for Hernandez? I wouldn’t assume that either.
phenom48
I think he returns after Taylor trade/dfa. After getting his eyes fixed, he was far superior to what Taylor has become. His ability to pitch in blowouts shouldn’t be discounted either.
DavRz
I’d stay away from K-machine Moncada..Hernandez value is in his versatility and shows up in big games like playoffs and WBC classic.
wvsteve
Feb 1 = you better get busy
mlbnyyfan
I’m tired of all the yankee rumors. All talk and no action.
Childish Bambino
Exactly..
DigglinDickers
If the Yankees want a team clown who can’t hit for average, Kike is your man.
abcrazy4dodgers
It’s that kind of discounting that breaks hearts and minds in October.
DigglinDickers
Is Kike not a team clown who doesn’t hit for average?
BleedingLABlue
Kike is versatile during the regular season and clutch in the playoffs. He had better offensive numbers than Judge in the World Series, was dependable in the field, and is a clubhouse guy with great team chemistry.
It’s obvious why the Yankees want him but he’s not going anywhere.
DigglinDickers
How will LA make room for Kike?
BlueSkies_LA
Finally, somebody asks the right question. The assumption that the Dodgers are just playing for time with Hernandez is likely wrong. The only way the Dodgers find a roster spot for him is if they can move Taylor. Otherwise, both the IF and OF depth are already set.
PiratesFan1981
Deferred money
slimray
they pay him 15 million to play in aaa and defer 14 million and if someone gets hurt,hes there for insurance
KnicksFanCavsFan
Obviously, “looking into” doesn’t mean “seriously considering.” That being said, other than Jose Iglesias or a supremely shorter signing, I’m good with going into ST with Cabrera, DJ, or Peraza. Why go over the highest threshold and pay double the contract value of whomever you sign if they aren’t likely to perform better offensively than any in- house option? I could absolutely see Cabrera hitting 15 hrs whey a .230/.300/.400 slash if given 500 AB. Also, DJ was decent in 2023. He suffered thru a good injury, which required Sydenham in the off-season. It’s not hard to imagine him providing solid defense and a .700 OPS if healthy. Hal/Cash need to resist temptation to look busy because the media and loco fans want them to spend more than the Dodgers and Mets as if that somehow wins you something. If Bregman at 6/$156 mil was a bad idea in December, then what’s changed? I don’t see his market falling down to a 3/$75 mil level with rumors, or he has another 6 year deal from a team he might be lukewarm over. He may not want to go to that team, but it’s he going to walk away from that offer to something the Yanks might feel is more to their valuation? Keep in mind that even if they signed him for 3/$75 million with the tax, it’s really 3/$150 million.
Salzilla
I’d grab Iglesias too over these guys.
KnicksFanCavsFan
please forgive the typos, and I hope you can comprehend what I meant. I’ll try and proofread before submitting.
Salzilla
All good, it happens. And while I wouldn’t mind Bregman, I don’t want him to complete the spending of others. You have spending on what makes sense. I think the Yanks did a great job this winter with that, but we missing a few pieces. 3rd base needs a longterm solution abd he isn’t on the roster. Bregman would indeed accomplish that.
whyhayzee
Kike would replace Error in Judgement in the postseason as an upgrade. Much better hitter and he can actually catch easy pop flies.
Plus he won’t waste his teammate’s time working on stupid home run celebrations.
KnicksFanCavsFan
@Why
Is that a snipe towards Judge?
Salzilla
This is a take all right. I’d take Judge into every postseason over Kike and it’s not even close.
whyhayzee
Kike’s OPS is over 100 points higher.
Salzilla
Quite literally I don’t care. Not in a million years would I play Kike over Judge, lol.
whyhayzee
Kike Hernandez has played in 86 games, Error in Judgement in 58, so maybe he will catch up.
Salzilla
I can’t take anything you say seriously if you need to constantly refer to a player like so.
Joemo
While Judge is clearly the better hitter, I suggest you go look at their actual postseason stats.
Judge, being the better hitter, has more potential but hasn’t delivered in the postseason.
Salzilla
I suggest that no manager would take out out their best hitter for Kike. Did the Dodgers take out Ohtani? Nope, but he struggled, too.
Zerbs63
Ohtani is a DH
Salzilla
They are talking hitting more than anything and Judge is a fine fielder. That inning was a disaster, but I wouldn’t change anything because of it. $#!+ happens.
Fraham_
Pathetic 300 million payroll and “Yoan Moncada” would be their starting 3B
Salzilla
Said no one. Neither would be starter, just part of the mix to look at different options on different days.
Fraham_
DJLM or Oswaldo aren’t inspiring either
Salzilla
I’d easily play them over Yoan.
Fraham_
The last time DJLM and Cabrera went into the season as starters they had 50 something wRC+
coocoo20
@Fraham_ Oswaldo hasn’t played enough to make that call. And Dj has batting titles so the inspiration is there
Salzilla
Exactly.
Fraham_
DJ was arguably the worst player in baseball last year and only getting older. Cabrera was a below average neither last year about being one of the worst players in 2023. Not taking either those guys by a large margin over Moncada.
Salzilla
DJ has also had a litany of injuries to overcome, which isn’t anything to overlook. Cabrera is still young and hasn’t had enough ABs to fully quantify a judgement as coocoo said.
Joe says...
I’ve heard that Moncada doesn’t really like playing baseball. Kinda like Rendon. Don’t know how true it is. Any White Sox fans have some insight?
Aaron Sapoznik
Many White Sox fans felt that Yoan Moncada was more interested in furthering his music career than his job as a full time baseball player. youtube.com/watch?v=fm8V46BfynM
That said, if he continues to injure himself, dancing might not be his best vocation either.
YankeesBleacherCreature
Will he take a paycut if a team can guarantee him a spot on Dancing with the Stars?
cwsOverhaul
Moncada and Eloy didn’t put much effort into improving their games from one season to the next. Eloy got paid off hype-Moncada got extended off the 1 good juiced ball year in ’19 where he was HOF against rebuilding Tigers/KC pitching. 1 positive is he defended well at 3B-he’d have to stick there. Should be minor league invite like Eloy in TB-make them earn it.
NYCityRiddler
Interested for what, to drive the team bus? They’re both hacks, HARD PASS, next! Ahahahahaha!
MoneyBallJustWorks
as they should be. Going into the season with DJ or Cabrera at 3B didn’t work last year, why would it this year?
KnicksFanCavsFan
@Money
DJ got hurt in ST and then suffered thru a hip injury for most of the year.
bernbabybern
Yuck.
ny papi
Totally irrelevant to the subject but decided to bring it up reading about Moncadas medicals, I saw a post earlier about Roki Sasaki and how he was recommended to get Tommy John surgery a couple years ago and that’s why he decided to come play in the mlb before it came down to that. Not sure how true it is since I saw it on instagram but def interesting news
Joe says...
It’s basically true from Sasaki himself. He said people were telling him to wait until he turned 25 to come to MLB so he’d get paid but he said he wanted to come now because there were no guarantees. And he did opt not to get TJ surgery.
Salzilla
I’d take Kike just because of his versatility. Hard pass on Moncada, that ship has sailed imo.
unglar
What a joke.
Bregman is out there for the taking. Hit him with 6/175 and stay competetive. This lineup needs a low K high OBP bat, power is not a must. And Bregman has 3 years of being a high quality bat before 2 years of average and 1 year of below avg if he follows his ZIPS projection. Yankees should be doing things like the brand they built promised. They should be spending money on other teams stars and stacking the deck in their favor.
Next year they better get Tucker. I’d like to see them trade for Tucker and or Yandy Diaz if the cubs and rays are not in it at the deadline.
Joe says...
He ain’t there for the taking. He’s there for the overpaying. There’s a reason 30 teams haven’t signed him.
highflyballintorightfield
Kike’ has some additional value for non-contending teams as the Dodgers will come calling for him at the trade deadline. For example, the Nats could use him as a placeholder at 3B while waiting for House then flip him for a Dodgers prospect in July.
He’s less of a value proposition for a contending team that has to carry him on the roster for a whole regular season.
For his fit on the Dodgers, I don’t think the problem is the 40-man roster as it is the active roster when the season starts. They seem to be full up on position players, and they don’t need his defensive flexibility and strikeout totals when they already have Taylor. Better to let some other team pay for him for 4 months and go get him closer to the playoffs.
TennMan
I feel like I see these “showing interest” articles every other day. Neither option seems like an upgrade over what we have. I know Cabrera’s bat isn’t great or even good, but he has good marks on defense and can run well. DJLM is pretty bad but we are stuck with him. And it’s finally time to see what Peraza can do. I’m fine with having those 3 battle. All 3 are capable fielders at 3rd and 2nd and it is obvious that this front office is prioritizing defense and run prevention. I am more worried about the LH bullpen piece
KnicksFanCavsFan
To fellow Yankee fans:
If the Yanks brought in someone at 3rd whom, if healthy, could theoretically give you some production around 20 dbls, 15 homers, a .240/.330/.390 slash with a solid glove and some versatility in the infield, and very little impact on the payroll, would you be happy?
TennMan
I would sign up for that production but I don’t see Kike giving you that. In the past 3 years, he hasn’t looked any better than what we got from Cabrera last year. Moncada definitely has a much higher ceiling and better bat but he is always injured and I have about as much confidence in him as I do in DJLM reverting to his 2023 form (I.e, not very confident but could happen)
rocky7
If you’re referring to Hernandez…I suggest you take a. look at his 2024 regular season slash line which is well below what you have described….not debating that in the 2024 playoffs and WS….he blossomed into an integral part of why the Dodgers won, but you still have to play 162 just to get there and given the slash line of .240, with 15 doubles, and 15 home runs, you’re pretty much describing Yankee internal options which doesn’t cost them anything other than their current payroll numbers….and who’s to say that one of them might blossom into just as integral a part of success you saw with Hernandez…..plus the internal options are younger, cheaper, and have better legs than a 33 year old going on 34……
KnicksFanCavsFan
@Tenn @rocky
Nope…. Russia almost exactly what DJ have is 2 year ago in 2023. He stayed the year off with a toe injury in ST that kept him out until early May and then he suffered thru a hip injury for the the rest of the year up until finishing in the DL. If he’s healthy, then there’s a good probability that he can rebound.
KnicksFanCavsFan
that’s=Russia… weird auto correct
pjc1966
Eugenio Suarez might be obtainable from AZ.
DavRz
Absolutely, sign Hernandez today.
YankeesBleacherCreature
Yoan Moncada is interesting but something tells me he won’t sign for a low base guarantee plus high incentives after he made almost $30M (incl. buyout) last year. I’m not sure that the Yankees want to gamble on paying a high base plus 110% tax.
Acoss1331
Moncada is a headcase at times, he’s not bad at third base but you guys just had Gleyber with his baserunning lapses. I don’t think Boone would be the one to correct Moncada.
bighiggy
What if the cards finally budge and trade arenado, and matz for say stroman, d.j and a top 15 prospect in the Yankees system? Yankees get better and save money this year without losing a top prospect. Cards save money in the long run while having two potential rebound trade chips and get a prospect?
YankeesBleacherCreature
The Yankees don’t want Matz because they have enough starters. DJL has no value currently. The Cards want value back for Arenado and will eat salary for the right prospects. The Yankees don’t want to part with those prospects. Arenado may not waive his NTC to the Yankees. The Cards may not want Stroman and his high salary because he may not make them a better team. Lots of moving parts.
l9ydodger
Can’t understand why the Yankees or Red Sox haven’t worked something out for Bregman or Arenado yet. Everyone’s busy complaining about the Dodgers. What are the other owners doing about making their teams better for their fans?
Showing interest in bargain basement shopping.
Salzilla
You say nothing wrong here. Honestly the Yankees should go for Bregman and call it a dau.
pjc1966
It’s certainly odd. They must be convinced he’s really gonna fall off a cliff offensively.
Joe says...
Sal, Bregman’s batting profile doesn’t mesh well with Yankee Stadium.
Salzilla
Maybe, but good players adapt and it’s hard to say he’s not that. He’d absolutely make this team better. We need a longterm solution ar 3rd and right now we don’t have it.
Joe says...
That’s the question though. Is he that good or is he playing in a favorable park? Think about Didi Gregorious. His numbers went up because of Yankee Stadium. Obviously Bregman is better than Didi but my point remains. I’d rather go with in house options right now and revisit 3b at the deadline if necessary.
Fernando P
Neither guy should be an option. It’s been about three years with an above average OPS+
BigRedMachine
I think that the Yanks should look at Jose Iglesias,. Can play all infield positions, puts the ball in play, and stays healthy. The same cannot be said for Y. Moncada….
top jimmy
God, Cashman is an idiot. There have been so many better options this offseason. Even with what little is left, Jose Iglesias and Brendan Rodgers would be better options than these guys. Unlike the types of players Cashman always targets, these guys play elite defense and don’t strike out half the time. The Yanks defense and inability to play small ball gets them beat in the playoffs every year, and Cashman is going to make it happen again this year.