Of MLBTR’s top 20 free agents, Alex Bregman is the only one who remains unsigned. The star third baseman is reportedly sitting on multiple six-year offers but hasn’t found a price to his liking.
One of those is from the incumbent Astros. Houston has reportedly had a standing six-year, $156MM offer for much of the winter. Jon Heyman of the New York Post writes that the Astros have bumped that number higher, though specifics on the new proposal aren’t clear. In any case, it doesn’t seem that it was a dramatic jump. Ari Alexander of KPRC 2 reports that Houston’s increased offer is still unlikely to result in a deal.
The Tigers are still pursuing Bregman after agreeing to a two-year deal with Jack Flaherty over the weekend. The Blue Jays have an opening at third base. The Red Sox have shown interest, though Alex Speier of the Boston Globe has suggested they were reluctant to go beyond four years. The Sox have stayed in contact with the Cardinals regarding Nolan Arenado as well. MLB.com’s John Denton writes that Boston would “prefer” to sign Bregman over an Arenado trade, though that’s difficult to envision unless they push the length beyond their comfort zone.
While players like Flaherty and Pete Alonso have moved to short-term deals to conclude extended free agent stays, Bregman still seems committed to a longer contract. Agent Scott Boras said as much last month. Heyman writes that Bregman expects to sign for at least six years, though he has received offers on shorter terms.
The Astros dipped below the luxury tax threshold when they traded Ryan Pressly to the Cubs, offloading $8.5MM of his $14MM salary. RosterResource estimates their tax number around $237MM, about $4MM below the base threshold. They’d need to go well beyond the tax line to sign Bregman but otherwise prefer to stay under the $241MM marker. If they don’t re-sign Bregman, they’ll have Isaac Paredes at third base. That’d likely leave Jose Altuve as the primary second baseman with a left field mix that could occasionally feature Altuve alongside Mauricio Dubón, Ben Gamel and Zach Dezenzo.
OMG, much like Alonso, it’s inevitable. If he wanted to leave, he would have already. Alonso never wanted to leave and went crawling back
Seems like perfect fit. Is this Bryant Baez Story 2.0 or Astros just bidding against themselves? His swing is for Houston. He’s a superstar there. Anywhere else he is good not great guy who cheated with trashcan.
Well put.
Bregman cheated on whom with a trashcan??
He cheated on his professional respect and reputation with the trashcan. He’ll always have the memories of his time with the trashcan, but his professional respect and reputation left him, and it’s never coming back.
It wouldn’t let me reply to ignorant SOB so I will do it here.
Your Mom. He cheated on your mom with a trash can.
He also cheated on MLB teams. The most outrageous victim of Houston’s cheating was the Yankees.
WadeBoggsWildRide
If you love trash cans so much why don’t you marry one?
Sarcasm font on
I am trash enough on my own. I don’t need anything trying to contain me.
Yeah, but Alonso settled for a two year contract that is basically a one-year contract. Bregman seems to want six years. I certainly would not give him anywhere near that.
It’s a 2 year contract if he has a year like last year.
But it’s a one year contract if he hits like he did in any other season.
For sure, go back to Houston the trash cans are lined up and ready
Tell us about Shoeless Joe next!
He’s a victim of circumstances. Ignorant farm boy taken advantage of by his teammates. Of all the players not in the HOF, he’s the most deserving. His sentence ended 70 years ago.
I agree that Shoeless Joe Jackson’s sentence ended 70 years ago, and I’ve heard that he might have been innocent (i.e. may not have participated in the reverse cheating).
However, Jackson was 32 in 1920. Bregman was 23 in 2017. Which one was closer to being a boy?
Are you suggesting a 23 year old, doesn’t have the capacity to make adult choices?
No. I’m actually suggesting the opposite.
My point was that Bregman was a man at 23, and since 32 is older than 23 then obviously Jackson was also a man. Additionally, a grown adult person from a rural background shouldn’t be assumed to be too naive to make adult choices.
But on the other hand, I’m not sure that Jackson was guilty. I’m not saying that about Bregman.
(Although I would say it regarding Altuve. Ironically, Altuve gets the most heat despite multiple sources saying that he’s the only 2017 Astros hitter who didn’t cheat.)
I’m glad you clarified..I get it now
Bluejays please
They “won” the Springer sweepstakes
As long as that interest doesn’t guarantee anything past two years, even at a premium, that would be fine. Let his window close with the rest of the Cleveland Connection’s construction. In other words, I’m fine with the Jays being his last resort.
Vlad wants to join his Dad in the HOF. If Jays want to go long on a contract, start with extending him. AAV is what it is but front-loading a longer deal with the understanding that you will probably be paying for a full-time DH somewhere down the road will be helped along by “hidden heritage” value later that will sell tickets as he reaches significant milestones.
Surround him with professionals and you might even win something!!!
This reads like the Titanic welcoming the iceberg.
Here’s my impression of one of the band members on Titanic as the boat is sinking.
“If only I didn’t miss that b note”
He just wants money because he knows he is super overated and this is his only chance to fool teams
Could have just stopped at money or because
@misty, I agree, he is being a money grubber. I mean, the market bears what it bears. Ain’t $156MM enough, especially if no one else is really calling? What a chump. He is an Astro for life. Enough said.
“He just wants money”
“he is being a money grubber”
How dare a player try to get the most money he can??
gbs42: Because for the 99% out there who would think ONE million is a lot of money (let alone Houston’s offer of $26 million PER YEAR), he IS a money grubber. There are limits to what people really “need”.
jammin464,
The same can be said about owners. If they weren’t also money grabbers, they would reduce prices on tickets, concessions, parking, and merchandise so most fans could afford to attend games.
Cry to your mom not the internet. Work harder. Be better at something than someone else. Yes the cards are stacked against you.
Another Boras client waiting until spring training to sign.
Quite the pep talk wade
This is what he gets for signing that 4 year extension, 2 years prior to reaching free agency. He could have received $250M+ had he become a free agent at age 29, but now he’s 31 and coming off a low walk, low OPS season. I still find it hard to believe any team, including Houston, is willing to sign him for 6 years at all. The max he should get is 4 years at a sizable AAV. Tack on a vesting option if need be, but 6 guaranteed years at $26M+ per year seems like a bad decision to me.
I’m bored with it. 3 months and still can’t make a decision. MLB off-season sucks.
75% of this delay is Scott Boras.
Sounds like the delay is Bregman. He could take a better offer but he only wants to play for one team and wants them to give him the highest offer.
You misspelled “100”
Hur dur need instant gratification
That’s on you and many others. Just no interest in having discussion. No interest in minor signings and trades. Moves I find most interesting no one even shows up for.
I have interest, just not 3 months of it, because certain players and agents want to play games.
No it is exciting unlike the crappy free agency in NFL NBA and NHl where everything is done in one day. I wish it would go on until opening day.
Franco27: How are you harmed by it?
Without all the distraction of MLB transactions and phone notifications, Franco27 is forced to gaze inward and it’s a scary abyss of darkness and alienation to behold.
A lot of lonely nights in that hole.
Life is probably hard for Franco27. I am seeing indications.
MLB needs to establish a time frame for both trades and free agent signings in the off season. This BS has been going on since November. All of these moves should have been done by early January. There is plenty of blame to go around like greed and stupidity but there needs to be a change.
Why? Because you say so?
If Bregman believes he’s getting much more than 6 yrs./$156 mill., he must think it’s still December rather than a week before pitchers/catchers report! It’s time to just sign the best contract that has been presented!
Either another team is stupid or Boras just playing the Astros. They didn’t pull their offer so lets see if we can get them to increase it! No need to hurry the way the Astros negotiate.
Astros dont go over 5-year deals so they may have bumped up the AAV but probably isn’t probably beating the total guarantee of a 6-year offer.
Astros offer was 6/156 according to what has been reported.
I know. It’s in the article. I just don’t believe it especially coming from Heyman.
Heyman is not the only was that has reported that number.
I’ve clicked through other article links and the only other one is Nightengale. I’m not convinced that the Astros have 6-years.
@yankees, read the article bro.
Perhaps deferredoneu was partially moved increasing the AAV.
I still don’t think it’s happening unless Bregman overrules Boras, as Boras is going to want out years and Houston doesn’t play those games.
Man I hate this guy. Rooted for him because he wore the H, but he’s the worst. Smug as they come. Really wish Dana would retract all offers as opposed to upping it.
He’s damaging his legacy big time. He talked a good game months ago about how he just wanted to win and he loved Houston, and top dollar was not his main concern. The Astros have already offered him the biggest contract in franchise history after already giving him a $100 million extension after two huge years he never came close to repeating, and a future HoF teammate has offered to change positions in his mid-30s to make it happen, and he’s still out there in February demanding more. My respect is gone.
BK – He’s always been known as a jerk, but fans tend to be very forgiving and forgetful.
Completely agree with you. Not to mention the fact that if he comes back it means moving Paredes from where he thought he was playing and moving Altuve to the outfield just to accomodate Bregman.
Screw him, and screw Brown for not withdrawing the offer long ago.
How does any of that hurt the team? Paredes is a better 2B than 3B and than Altuve. Altuve can’t be worse in LF than he was at 2B and Alvarez being a DH might keep his balky knees from cutting his season short. Bregman is a better player and 3B than Paredes.
Signing Bregman back makes the team better. That he didn’t do it on your time table is just too damned bad for you. Didn’t effect who he is as a person or a ballplayer. WTH is wrong with you as fans? Actual, honest to goodness fans want their team to do everything they can to get better. Why don’t you? Why would you rather hate on a man for trying to do what is best for him and his family?
I stopped reading your nonsense when you said Paredes is better than Altuve at 2nd.
That’s not what they said, but do you.
Why do I have to explain myself to you? What’s wrong with you?
I don’t like him and haven’t since 2018. I have my reasons. You can feel however you’d like about him. The bulk of Astros fans that liked him are just now being put off by the way he conducts himself. Some people are really surprised
His family won’t ever notice the difference between 156 million and 200 million. They will notice the difference if they are all displaced from their friends and city where they’ve spent their life. Bregman is a great teammate and baseball player with a balky elbow and streaky hitting history playing at max ability. Doubt he’s going to age well on an extended contract. 6 years 156M or 4/110 with opt outs after 2 years has him well set for life.
He’s already earned over $100 million. How much is left, only he, and his interpreter know for sure, but the money would certainly seem to be as symbolic as anything.
Hahahaha
I have no idea how good Paredes will be at 2b, but I would bet meaningful, folding money that he will be better than Altuve.
It’s refreshing seeing Stros fans holding him accountable.
You mean BORAS hasn’t found a deal to his liking? I’m sure ALL of the deals are enough for Bregman.
Really? Which one works for the other? If any deal was enough for Bregman, he would have signed already!
kod – Pretty sure he wants top dollar from his team of preference. That’s the reason for the delay.
If he had a better deal he would have already taken it, I don’t know who they think they are fooling.
Apparently the Astros!!!!
They should retract the offer and tell him to take the “other” 6-plus-year offer.
Every photo of him makes me instinctively check to see if my wallet is still there.
This news excites me, as a Cub fan.
It makes me feel safer that the Cubs won’t fight over him. I’m not even sure I want him any longer, even on a one year deal.
I enjoy seeing his ego, twist in the wind – to the sound of ‘the drum’.
Hopefully Jed sees this and stops kicking the tires on Bregman. Would rather give Shaw a shot at the 3B job.
Dog–I agree. I’m still a little puzzled how accurate the reports in Chicago really are. In essence, Bregman would basically be a straight up trade for Nico at a much stiffer cost.
The Berti, Brujan, Lopez etc signings have me wondering if there is an extended health concern with Nico’s timeline. (who I guess would be odd man out and tradeable with Shaw slotting at 2b)
I still think to complete the offseason bingo card the Cubs have to do something to get Taillon into the #4 slot in the starter pecking order.
They’ve addressed everything else: impact bat, bullpen–backend and depth, bench (to an extent….I’m a believer that those guys are roster spots 19-24 and a name is just a name. Whether it’s Sogard or LaStella or Madrigal or Berti–it doesn’t matter)
@mike127
Yeah, the bench spots for the most part are really interchangeable and of lesser importance. The true replacements would likely come from giving their minor league guys, opportunities to show how ready they really are.
Sorry not sorry, Clip!
res.cloudinary.com/ybmedia/image/upload/c_crop,h_6…
There is zero chance the Astros are better in 2025 without him, especially now that it is being reported that Altuve will transition to LF (a move I wholeheartedly support) regardless.
There are simply no options left in FA and the Astros don’t have the ammo to trade w/o weakening the current roster to do it.
At least a case can be made for 2026, but my opinion is that resigning him is a positive (2.5+ WAR) for at least 4 years and likely the entire 6.
*by positive I am talking about whether he would be a positive player, and better than the other likely player(s) they put at 3b if Paredes is at 2b. That is regardless of whether he is worth $26M+ per season.
I see no benefit to pulling the offer. Unfortunately, Boras knows this too and therefore has no urgency to take it.
Gonna keep swinging for the fences and hoping to get a hold of one and eventually take the Astros offer if no other team caves in.
Seems he and the Astros are destined for reunion. I feel like they are each other’s best fit.
What about Seattle’s 6-month $500,000 offer?
Is that still in the running?
Post of the day; you got this M’s fan to laugh out loud
Maybe Bregman knows that Houston is a sinking ship.
200 million he would play on the Titanic
Honestly forget the guy. I’ve wanted him all offseason but the longer it lingers I wish we’d just turn somewhere else. The alternative is not that bad—Jung at 3rd with vierling and Ibanez. We can find a right handed bat elsewhere or at the deadline. Not worth ruining the team chemistry with this diva and sinking the payroll for 6 years.
D grade if Tigers sign him. If they were in Frankfurt or Florence ot would be a F.
So the bidding just started. Astros, Tigers, and Red Sox. Jays may jump into the fray with “interest”.
Astros would be wise to walk away at this point. Bregman is on the downtrend anyway.
Who cares
Show me the money.
Screw him, don’t need him.
Everyone should forget him and move on. It can’t be collusion because there are lots of offers. Everyone should rescind their offers or give him a deadline.
Yeah, time for the Cubs to pull back and let the other teams haggle. Give Shaw a chance to play 3B. Bregman and Boras have overstayed their welcome in trade rumors
Know your worth Alex.
Springers gone, correas gone, Brantley’s gone, Altuves gone, and tuckers gone. If they aren’t paying you to be robin go yordans bat man use ball at them.
I really wish more of these guys were scared of being jobless in spring training/season. Demand plays. Sometimes you have to play it out yourself.
Altuve is still with the Astros
Sorry total brain fart sue me
Where do I send the certified mail?
Is it worth it though? Can’t imagine a judge hearing that one out haha
And Brantley retired as an Astro
Yes he did but again if you aren’t gonna pay the man go let him be the man.
Bregmans due what he’s owed clear as day.
Not that good, better than average, yes. Not worth that kind of money!
Wow houston bumped it up from $156mil and breg still says no
Astros should move on
Meanwhile breg will be alonso 2.0 in FA
So they’re bidding against themselves? I can’t see Bregman having a better offer elsewhere.
Astros front office must really like Bregman. No one is seriously giving him 6 or 7 year offers. Not with Spring Training a few days away…
Obviously several someone’s have.
Please advise your source which confirms that “several other teams have made 6-7 year offers.”
Mystery source. Mystery team.
I never said “several other teams have made 6-7 year offers”, I said no one is giving him 6-7 year offers. If he had several offers as it’s supposedly claimed, he would have signed by now.
From what I understand the initial offer was a pay cut from last years salary, so the new one may have rectified that.
Scott Boras & Bregman have drawn a line in the sand and taken a clear, firm stand.
They are willing to hold out for as long as necessary to make the Astros decrease their final offer.
Clearly, Bregman & Boras want one of those 2-year, 1st year opt out deals like the one Boras scored for Alonso. You have to admire Bregman’s willingness to forgo $150M+ to bet on himself.
It was clear as soon as he climbed into bed with Boras and he’s always known that these were going to be the possible outcomes. Same for Alonso, Chapman, Snell, Monty, and Belli. I don’t get why the Boras hate falls so heavily on him. There are plenty of other agents around who are more risk-averse and don’t wait until February to sign.
@ybc
Me personally I think this falls more on the player, all boars can do is tell them the offers and give advice on the offers. Ultimately it’s up to the players to say yes or no and some players over value themselves or the market.
sees headline
clicks link
sees the name heyman
exits without reading
I love free agency. It’s a game of chicken in this case. Recommend Houston just tell him to go ahead and take someone else’s offer.
If there weren’t holdouts like this and all rosters were fixed by now there would be little for people to talk about.
A long article that tells us that Bregman has an offer higher than the 6/156 that the Astros initially offered. He wants to continue playing in Houston so he came to them and said here is what I have been offered. Match it and I will sign today. They came back with an offer above 6/156 but not as high as his other offer. So does he take the higher offer or the one in Houston, his wife’s hometown?
How do you know he wants to continue in Houston ?
How do you know he came to them and told them what he had been offered ?
How do you know he said he would sign today if they matched it ?
How do you know they offered more but did not match his other offer ?
Bottom line :You don’t know if any of this actually happened.
You seem to live in a land of conjecture.
Any Arenado trade better not include Casas or the Redsox fans will go insane. I think Breslow realizes that fact hopefully.
They don’t care what fans think just as long as they keep giving them $
Why would StL want a 1B? I think you’re safe.
Astros are bidding against themselves for a guy that’s going to average 20 hrs and a .260 average for around 3 years before falling off a cliff into replacement level status with over 100 mil left of the books. 4 years at 26/per is about his real value.
11-12 wins for 4/$104m is the right neighborhood.
It’s hard to believe Bregman’s going to be worth a regular lineup spot when he’s 35-36.
Because being able to sign 1 person vs 3 isn’t the same. They aren’t the LA Deferrals who can just sign everyone.
Then they don’t have Walker. See how it works?
Although I think Tucker will get more $ for more years than Walker.
Jeez Louise Bregman, that’s the highest offer you’re gonna get…take it, and play for your team bro!
I’m assuming they won’t go past $200M in principle and that it wasn’t by like a token $1M per season, so I’m assuming the offer is now like 6 years/$166.5M or something.
He ain’t getting $200M+
Even 156m means the Astros would need around 18 wins to break even, and if that’s the over / under they’re going to be under a lot more than they’re over.
It’s easier to see Bregman putting up 3.4, 2.7, 1.9, 1.1 wins then hanging it up than it is to see him going 4, 3.5, 3, 2.5, 2, 2, 1 then retiring after his age 36 season—and the latter set are the median results on the field for a $156m deal.
Does anything really think he’s going to put up 4, 3.5, 3.5, 3, 3, 2.5, 2, 2. 2, 2, 1 and retire at 42, which is the flip side of the first set of numbers?
On 18 wins I’ll take the under, and give odds.
If it was my money, he’d only be looking at shorter-term offers as his best option already.
It can be argued how much but, since some of his value (and, notably, some of his PEAK value) resides in a trashcan buried deep inside the Astros organization, it is certainly curious, if not stupid/greedy or both, that he hasn’t made a final choice yet.
He’s a good player who will make any team better from an ability standpoint. His judgement leaves room to question how positive his presence will be otherwise.
He’s definitely going back to Houston. If he wanted to leave he would have already signed so he could start to look for a new place to live in a new city, etc.
As a Tigers fan. I would have liked to seen him in our every day lineup.
Doesn’t follow. When you’re rich you call a service and within hours a lush apartment or house is furnished to your specifications.
The team will arrange to have your immediate necessaries flown to that residence by a private jet, and they’ll move all your things to that city also within hours.
Or if he prefers, he won’t be looking for a new place himself–someone will do that for him, then he and his wife will be chauffered to the finalists, assuming they wouldn’t prefer a complete video tour then just write the down payment remotely.
I don’t think so, he won’t take the Astros offer and Boras is going to want to pivot to a shorter deal with out years, and Astros owner doesn’t do out years.
If the rumor is true about the Tigers having the largest offer but him not truly wanting to play in DET and is waiting out other teams to match it, then the Tigers need to move on! You can’t make a guy want to play in your city, and no matter what, that contract isn’t going to age well. At this point in his career he is not worth what he is asking, and if you look at the numbers closely, Matt Vierling is just about as good offensively than Bregman. I say let him sign elsewhere and see what we have with Jung at 3rd and if he flops sign a 3B next offseason or trade for one at the deadline.
In his shoes, I’m going to a particular place, first. If they are still in at a reasonable rate when the time comes to make a final decision …done.
You don’t want a guy who doesn’t want to play in your city. If you are still in on him, any team will be risking an uninspired player, probably at an inflated rate.
Why would Astros increase an offer that was already likely far beyond any other offer Bregman is getting? Being sentimental is no way to runaway MLB team. Unless the owner is demanding they bring back AB, the GM should be fired.
Crane loves Bregman. I also have this notion that Bregman may end up as the Stros manager one day. Possibly player/manager. He’s already a coach on the field.
It’s possible they’ve increased their offer….and possible this is just another negotiating ploy. But if the Astros really are willing to bust a CBT threshold, that still doesn’t mean they want to escalate beyond what the player is worth..
ahh yes, an absolute favorite at LSU, turned respected division opponent, turned annoying division opponent. they’ve got parades, send bregman to toronto or something, they’re no threat and they want to spend money. M’s and Rangers are gonna vie for the west.
Bro, if that deal has been increased he needs to take it. That’s a huge chunk of change and he isn’t getting any better.
According to Fangraphs, Alex has been worth about $200M more than he has made so far in his career.
I have no issue with him continuing to let his agent work for him trying to get a bigger/better deal.
That’s the right he has earned by getting to FA.
And it’s not like he’s holding out during the season. It’s still the off season.
Mr. Boras likes to pretend the players have all the power.
If were up to me, there would be a complete boycott of the entire MLB system, until they bring back free beer like it useed to be in the old days.
When the Skinnies played the Fats….the players did NOT WORRY about millions of dollars, there were no agents like Boras taking advantage, there were no Manfreds screwing everything up…there WAS NO NEED….WHY SHOULD THEY?
Players got a free beer as they rounded third base….they were happy. There was no whining about millions of dollars. Everyone was content.
BRING BACK THE OLD DAYS!
BRING BACK – FREE BEER!
Someone needs to tell Alex that he isn’t Juan Soto !!
Bregman’s arm is still not 100% from the end of last season. He wants this long-term deal because he knows it may be his last when his arm gives out on him. It’s Jeff Bagwell all over again.
Reality check… Bregman the offer the Stros have given you is pretty damn good,enough with you want to be an Astro, if that was the case you would have signed… GREED
3y/90m…. Call it a career
Why does the headline say that a deal with Houston seems “unlikely”? Who does it seem unlikely to? That’s just the Astros trying to bargain. If they are offering 6 years and they increased the dollars, the headline should be that a deal with Houston is “inevitable.” I call BS on Boras claiming that Bregman is sitting on multiple 6-year offers. That’s Boras seeking leverage to get Astros to pay more or go to a 7th year. This is very similar to the Alfonso negotiations. Please stop writing that a deal seems unlikely. It takes away your credibility as a writer!
At this point, he should just accept whatever they are offering, but insist on an opt out after this season. He can try free agency again next offseason without a QO attached to him.
Up to Boras.
Bregman obviously wants to go back to the Stros. He’s just holding out for as much as he can get from them….
Unfortunately he cannot help the greed it is in his blood
Why bother to link to articles we can’t read?
Not with Houston, Crane doesn’t do out years.