While the majority of attention figures to be focused on the outfield market in the aftermath of Juan Soto’s decision to sign with the Mets on a record-shattering deal last night, one other beneficiary of the failed suitors’ expected aggressiveness on the rest of the free agent market could be third baseman Alex Bregman. Rob Bradford of WEEI reported last night that the Red Sox may “immediately be prioritizing” a pursuit of Bregman in the aftermath of Soto’s signing as they look to use those funds to sign other top free agents, while USA Today’s Bob Nightengale reports this morning that the Yankees are “expected” to make a run at free agency’s top infielder as well.
The Red Sox were previously reported as a potential suitor for Bregman earlier this winter, but their level of interest has not been clear to this point. Now, it appears they may have more significant interest in adding the 30-year-old veteran to their roster after failing to land Soto. Bregman certainly makes plenty of sense for the Red Sox, as he’d help to balance a heavily left-handed lineup as a right-handed hitter with a career .277/.367/.494 slash line against southpaws. What’s more, the club’s crowded outfield mix makes the infield perhaps the most obvious place for Boston to add to the lineup, though they’ve seemingly prioritized adding pitching help (aside from their pursuit of Soto) to this point in the offseason.
Perhaps the biggest obstacle to Bregman landing in Boston is a somewhat questionable positional fit. Bregman has spent virtually his entire big league career at the hot corner, which is currently occupied by Rafael Devers at Fenway Park. That said, it’s easy to see how the Red Sox could fit Bregman into their plans if they’re sufficiently motivated to do so. Bregman has expressed a willingness to slide over to second base if his new team so desires, and the Red Sox have also reportedly considered shifting Devers off third base into either a first base or DH role. There’s potential flaws in either of those plans given the presence of top prospect Kristian Campbell as a potentially big league ready long-term solution at the keystone and Devers’ reported desire to remain at third base for the foreseeable future, but those are issues that could surely be worked around if Boston were sufficiently motivated.
The Yankees, meanwhile, have been a speculative fit for Bregman’s services but have not previously been reported to have interest in the veteran. The club is sure to be aggressive in upgrading its roster now that Soto has landed elsewhere, and an infield that sports little certainty outside of Jazz Chisholm Jr. and Anthony Volpe is an obvious place to start. The club had reported interested in shortstop Willy Adames as a candidate to play either second or third base before he signed with the Giants over the weekend, and Bregman is certainly a logical fit to fill that same role.
Chisholm played third base for the Yankees down the stretch and into the postseason after being acquired from the Marlins last summer but has far more experience at the keystone, so adding a proven third baseman like Bregman could upgrade the club on both sides of the ball by allowing Chisholm to move back to his natural position while adding a reliable hitter who’s never posted a wRC+ lower than 114 in a season to their lineup. One theoretical roadblock to the Yankees signing Bregman could be discontent due to the third baseman being part of the 2017 Astros squad that was implicated in the infamous sign-stealing scandal, though the same could be said for shortstop Carlos Correa and GM Brian Cashman’s front office didn’t let that stop them from pursuing him when he was a free agent three years ago.
Of course, the longtime archrivals of the AL East are hardly the only suitors for Bregman’s services. The Phillies, Blue Jays, and Tigers all reportedly have at least some level of interest in the veteran infield this winter, and the incumbent Astros are perhaps his most obvious suitor of all. Houston has already made an offer to Bregman’s camp this winter, which was reportedly in the range of six years and $156MM. He’s reportedly looking for a deal in the $200MM range, however, and that gap could create room for one of his other suitors to swoop in and pull him away from the Astros. That’s led the club to explore contingency plans in case Bregman signs elsewhere such as infielder Jorge Polanco and first baseman Christian Walker, GM Dana Brown made clear in an appearance on MLBNetwork Radio yesterday that retaining their star third baseman remains the club’s top priority.
“We’re working on it… we’re having a lot of conversations with Scott [Boras], and, you know, we’re optimistic,” Brown said of their pursuit of Bregman. He went on to make clear that, even if they don’t re-sign Bregman in free agency this winter, he expects the club to seek outside help at third base. Brown noted that he believes the club’s internal infield solutions to be anywhere from six months to a year away from being ready for big league action, indicating that at least a stopgap solution at the hot corner such as Polanco will be necessary for Houston should they fail to bring Bregman back into the fold.
Rocker49
Good! Take him, don’t need the Astros wasting $200+ million on him.
Big whiffa
Right ! And he’s a terrible fit in Boston too. I defend the Red Sox a lot here, mainly against Red Sox fans Rotf, but if they sign Bergman, I’m giving up on em. Over next 5 years Cases > Bregman
User 1939973770
He’s 100% not signing with Houston
Seaver rules
He will be a Yankee by dinner time. Bellinger or Christian Walker will be his 1B.
ClevelandSteelEngines
I’d love a soon to be aging overpaid player for the Yankees!
Yankee Clipper
I hope not. This would not be a good signing, imho.
hyraxwithaflamethrower
All depends on the money and years. I don’t think Bregman is worth $30M/yr, like I’ve seen projected a couple times. I really hope he doesn’t get that because of what it means for certain small-market teams (or teams who act like they’re in a small market). But Soto’s deal is bound to have ripple effects and as they say, flags fly forever. He’s still a well-above average ballplayer for now, so I can see a team not regretting it if they sign him for 5 years and win a title in part because of him.
Astrosfn1979
I agree that Bregman is not worth $30M per year, if this was 2021 money.
But in 2024-25 MLB FA, a player who was worth $20M per season 5 years ago is worth $30M now.
That’s simply current economics.
And is it worth a bet that $30M now is equal to $35M or $40M 5 years from now?
Or that as an aging player declines, he sustains his value more than a player who will be signed in the future because the AAV is less?
Sad.Sox 3
Everyone has to stop worrying about the actual dollar value of these contracts, not a single team is losing money.
That said, the worry about money is balancimg against the tax, and/or, freezing g yourself out of other signings. A good GM or POBO can do that, but the actual dollar figure is irrelevant.
JoeBrady
Everyone has to stop worrying about the actual dollar value of these contracts,
========================
Which is fine if you have an unlimited budget. But say we only spend up to the $241M, any wasted spending means less we can spend on someone else.
Sad.Sox 3
See paragraph 2
Dogleg62
I think the Red Sox land Bregman before the Yankees. There’s the Houston connection there with Cora and he gives them flexibility in the infield. If he’s slotted to play 3rd, Devers moves to 1b/DH and they can offer Casas in any trades to improve the club elsewhere. Or, if Bregman IS open to playing 2b, then he slots there and Devers can stay put. Walker (or original 2007 draft pick Rizzo?) would be their backup plan for 1b if they do trade Casas for pitching help.
deweybelongsinthehall
Not Rizzo. Would love if not Walker, Goldie for one year should Casas be dealt.
Dogleg62
If course, Pete Alonso is still available too, assuming the Mets are going to move on from him after the Soto deal.
ClevelandSteelEngines
Red Sox don’t want to pay him, they barely want to pay anyone, let alone an aging cheater
yukongold
4 years of Casas and mid level prospect for 1 year of Guerrero. Any takers?
ctguy
Blue Jays should be able to do much better than that.
Big whiffa
lol. What are you talking about ? Cases is a proven big leaguer. His value alone is greater than Vlad
junior25
To get him out of Toronto and still in same Division your going to have to give up alot more than that
This aint MLB the Show!
hyraxwithaflamethrower
Blue Jays are still looking to buy. If a few of the other top FA’s sign elsewhere, they may pivot into sell mode, but they’re not there yet.
ClevelandSteelEngines
team already has plenty of useless defenders, even if the bat is good, his linedrives will just hit the monstah
Mehmehmeh
BOS sounds plausible. Bregman has talked about modeling his game after Pedroia when he was younger. What HOU fans have referred to as his “MMP swing” should work in Fenway.
I suspect HOU is out of the bidding at this point and I’m happy with that.
G.M. Ima Scapegoat
Where Bregman lands probably depends on guaranteed years. If Boston isn’t willing to go 7, I think it’s highly unlikely.
deweybelongsinthehall
Depends on the money. The higher the AAV, the shorter the years they will commit to.
cwsOverhaul
Kyle Tucker will benefit more than Bregman when he is a FA next offseason. Wonder if Astros would want to trade him now “if” they have no appetite for what will be a bidding war. Might be a Yankee solution replacement to pair w/Judge in ’26.
JediLuc
Astros need a retooling. Trade Pressly, Tucker, and Valdez. Grab some great prospects and try to contend again.
deweybelongsinthehall
CWS, I just can’t see the Astros trading Tucker to the Yankees.
cwsOverhaul
Me neither. A wise guy like Dodgers could rent him a year simply b/c they can and let him walk……comes down to whether Astros would either get a lesser but decent veteran player back that has more years left on its deal.
Tough needle to thread.
ClevelandSteelEngines
Yeah it’s hard to see the Astros accepting the Yankees’ turds.
Larry D.
The Yankees might not be interested in him because of the “sign stealing scandal”? Yeah ok.
Old York
Good. I hope the Sox sign him and tie up a bunch of money on a bat that’s in decline.
Poolhalljunkies
That sounds bitter..axe to grind?
Old York
@Poolhalljunkies
No, he just doesn’t look good anymore. His bat is in decline and if anyone signs him, they’ll regret it, unless it’s a super team friendly contract, which I doubt it will be, given Soto’s contract.
Poolhalljunkies
Ok thanks for clarifying…initially looked like you were hoping the man would do poorly and the red sox would tie up money on a poor performance you would take pleasure in
Old York
@Poolhalljunkies
I hope I’m wrong but from what I see, I don’t think his bat lasts much longer than maybe 2 to 3 years.
hyraxwithaflamethrower
He had two excellent years in 2018 and 2019. Other than that, his OPS has been between .768 and .827 every year of his career. He’s walking a little less, but his SLG in 2024 was his second highest since 2020. If he starts taking walks again, his bat will go back up. Glove is still good. Nobody knows for sure how quickly he’ll decline when he starts to, but I don’t think it’s fair to say he’s already falling off.
Poolhalljunkies
From what ive mainly seen posted here he benefits from the short porch in right in hou..might be similar if he chooses fenway.but if the deal is 5 years i suppose every team bakes in some decline
deweybelongsinthehall
Fenway does not have. short porch in right.
Poolhalljunkies
I miss typed ..Meant left…crawford boxes and green monster might have similar impact for him
Pedro Cerrano's Voodoo
Boston fans do NOT want him and he’s had nothing but bad things to say about the Sox during his career. Boston already has a morally questionable signing in Chapman, let’s not make them a villainous team.
Ignorant Son-of-a-b
Boston has a morally questionable field manager as well
Swingandamiss
Bellinger to Boston for Kyle Teel.
alan.kawadler@verizon.net 2
haha
Poolhalljunkies
That would never happen..boston says no because they have no need of a cf or 1b regardless of the fact you arent getting a catching prospect who also happens to be a top 25 prospect in all mlb for what amounts to a big contract and 1 year of control for bellinger
DirtyWater04
Only if you throw in a few hits off whatever you’re smoking over there.
hyraxwithaflamethrower
Red Sox are more likely to trade Roman for Crochet (and even as a White Sox fan, I know that’s not happening).
deweybelongsinthehall
Roman is not going anywhere nor is Campbell. If the team trades from their top tier, such appears to be Mayer or Teal (for pitching).
ClevelandSteelEngines
Teel isn’t that great and the White Sox already have a solid catcher prospect in Quero. I doubt they want to double up when there are so many spots to fill. They’d be better off trying to worm Mayer because Montgomery isn’t likely a SS long term while Mayer is. Not sure if the Sox even want to give up Mayer tho, he’s close to a 6. I image the Sox will continue to peddle Abreu
soxshortstop
agree with most here – why Bregman?. Forcing a round peg in a square hole and too much $$$$ spent in the wrong direction. Address the other pressing needs as other mentioned – 2 pitchers and a right handed bat. Come on….focus RS! After that is completed…nip and trim roster.
sad tormented neglected mariners fan
No word about Pete Alonso? Yankees might go after him as vengeance
SadMsFan
Hey Mariners, here’s a guy that doesn’t strike out much, and can hit anywhere he goes. But I’d love the Yankees to get Bregman and then get either Bellinger or Walker. I wouldn’t like it if he went to the Red Sox, and I would hate for the Astros to get anyone good, though I’m not mad at them at all for the sign stealing scandal. That was just stupid, cause they got caught. Good cheaters don’t get caught, so the whole thing is pretty funny.
JediLuc
The hard part about Bregman is he is a great player but he is in decline. I really believe he could have been even better than he is but the sign scandal aftermath messed with his head. He’s a smart player, gritty, and has several years left in the tank, but offering more than 5 years is going to cost a team in the end. I’m an Astros fan, would love to have him back… but the money he’s asking for would hamper the team. Houston needs to let him go, Trade Tucker and Valdez and recoup prospects for another run. If they don’t it will be a long time back to contention.
hyraxwithaflamethrower
Sign Bregman, trade Campbell to the White Sox as the centerpiece of a Crochet deal. Upgrade both pitching and offense. With Soto choosing the other NYC team, this is a good time for the Red Sox to be aggressive. I don’t think the O’s will swing any big trades as they value their prospects too much and nobody knows how their new ownership group will spend. Yankees will be aggressive, but that’s all the more reason to take Bregman off the table before they get to him, Crochet as well, for that matter. Rays will probably be better as their pitchers are healthy again, but not sure they’re real contenders instead of just WC hopefuls. Jays could pivot into sell mode if they lose out on a couple of their other top FA targets, which takes another competitor out of it. Boston has a lot to gain here if they’re aggressive enough.
DirtyWater04
How about sign Bregman and Teoscar, trade Abreu and prospects to CWS for Crochet, and sign Buehler, Burnes, or Fried. Attach Grissom to Yoshida in a trade to offset the underwater value on Yoshi’s deal, and take whatever you can get for that in return.
C- Wong
1B – Casas
2B – Campbell
SS – Story
3B – Bregman
LF – Teoscar
CF – Rafaela
RF – Duran
DH – Devers
Bench: Hamilton, Refsnyder, the backup catcher, and ideally a corner OF/1B type – like maybe a Gavin Sheets?
SP1: Whichever FA they choose
SP2: Houck
SP3: Crochet
SP4: Crawford
SP5: Bello
CP: Whitlock
SU: Weissert
SU: Chapman
SU: Slaten
MRP: Kelly
MRP: Bernadino
MRP: Winckowski
LRP: Fitts
hyraxwithaflamethrower
Depends on the prospects, but Abreu and lower-level guys isn’t likely to be the best offer the White Sox receive.
ClevelandSteelEngines
who has a better offer and what do you think it is?
Best Screenname Ever
Bregman has Toronto written all over him. A mega-deal for a guy in steep decline. Which means they won’t be trading Guerrero before he leaves next off-season.
Sox have no need of a huge overpay like Bregman with his .315 OBP, who’ll be 31 on Opening Day. That’s Toronto material if ever I saw it.
ElitebFour3
I’m probably as die hard of an Astros fan as one can be. So here’s my take on it: I want Bregman to stay in Houston. He is always focused on improving his game, and his contributions exceed just what he does on the field. That being said, I don’t want the Astros to handicap their future just for nostalgia. If Bregman over prices himself, let him go. And then immediately pivot to resigning Tucker.
I mean if we’re all being realistic and we set aside any fan feelings or nostalgia, I don’t think there’s a single baseball mind out there that would prefer Bregman over Tucker. They can’t afford both. So any fans of the Astros should know, if Bregman signs on the dotted line, Kyle Tucker is gone. There’s no debate. The only argument about keeping Bregman over Tucker is that Tucker will fetch a nice prospect haul if they trade him. And Houston’s farm system is depleted so it’s much needed.
I wouldn’t give Bregman a $300 million contract. But I would give it to Tucker without hesitation.
mlbnyyfan
Yankees need to stay away from Walker and Bregman. Bellinger for 1B and Jazz for 3B and possibly lead off if Durbin is not ready
JGCNYYGBP
I’d like to see them sign Christian Walker for 1B, move Chisholm to 2B, trade for Nolan Arenado for 3B, trade for Cody Bellinger for CF, as Judge moves to RF, and start Dominguez in LF.
Ignorant Son-of-a-b
@EliteFab What do they should/will do with Valdez? If Bregman goes, I think the Astros should trade both Tucker and Valdez to repopulate the farm system. If Bregman stays, they should keep them for one more shot at a ring. But it’s a tough call and I’m a Mariners fan , so maybe biased lol.
Sad.Sox 3
This article sounds to me like more Boras disinformation. The Sox have LOTS of holes to fill, and, regardless of your feeling about Devers overpaying another third baseman isn’t number one on that list.
Sad.Sox 3
I’ve got a great idea, let’s take the money from this deal, give Bresliw a reasonable severance package, buy out Cora and give the rest to Dave Dombrowski
wileycoyote56
Why would Boston use him at 2nd when they could improve their defense moving Devers off of 3rd. He’s one of the worst defenders in the league
Sad.Sox 3
Devers isn’t the problem!
Devers isn’t the problem!!
Devers isn’t the problem!!!!!!!!!!
Hasn’t anyone noticed the Sox dont have a second baseman, or an adequate left fielder, or #1 SP???????
Stop obsessing over the third baseman’s defense, as if 5 less throwing errors wins us the A.L. pennant
thickiedon
Bregman makes sense for Boston but only if Devers is traded. Hear me out, a trade involving Seattle w Castillo, Garver, + for Devers, Toshida, +…
Ignorant Son-of-a-b
They aren’t going to trade Devers after just signing him to that monster contract.
wiredrunner
Bregman is only 30 years old?
The Sox are just aching to sign him to a 15 year 500k/yr deal now!
Ignorant Son-of-a-b
Bregman is not a fit for the Red Sox. Too many moving pieces and would force the trading of Casas which is not smart. Much better fit for the Yankees if the fans can handle Bregman.
MLBTR needs to hire editors
“Meanwhile” has to START the sentence. It’s not supposed to come in the middle, separated by commas. And there shouldn’t be a comma before “now” when it starts the sentence.