While the Athletics’ rebuild isn’t over, it does appear that the club has moved out of purely a selling phase as the 2024-25 offseason begins (and the team’s temporary tenure in Sacramento begins). A’s general manager David Forst told The San Francisco Chronicle’s John Shea that his front office has already at least touched base with every team except the Dodgers and Yankees, and that “any trade activity we’re discussing is about improving the major league team in 2025, not about trading major league players for prospects.”
This isn’t exactly a new stance, as Forst said in July prior to the trade deadline that the A’s were somewhat putting the brakes on moving any established trade chips. While this could have been construed as some gamesmanship to get rival suitors to up their bids, the Athletics ended up keeping such notables as Brent Rooker, Mason Miller, and JJ Bleday, despite significant interest from other teams. The A’s did trade Paul Blackburn (arbitration-controlled through 2025) to the Mets and a longer-term asset in Lucas Erceg to the Royals, though Erceg’s team control through the 2029 season is somewhat undermined by the fact that he is already 29 years old.
While the Athletics had a 69-93 record in 2024, things seemingly started to click for the team’s young core as the season developed. After a brutal 37-61 record in the first half, the A’s had an even 32-32 mark after the All-Star break, and even delivered a 29-21 mark over the months of July and August. Rooker was one of the better hitters in the entire league, and Bleday, Lawrence Butler, and Shea Langeliers all showed some intriguing potential elsewhere in the lineup.
The weak links were pretty obvious, as Shea writes that the Athletics’ offseason wish list includes upgrading a porous defense, a starting pitching staff that was one of the worst in baseball, and some help at third base. A whopping 10 players suited up at the hot corner for the A’s over the course over the 2024 season, but this revolving door combined for a sub-replacement -0.6 bWAR (ranking 28th of 30 teams in third-base production).
As always, Forst will be limited in what he can spend on any new players, though how much the A’s might spend on free agents in general is still up in the air due to the uncertainty surrounding their relocation. “We have to be active in the trade market until we get a clear sense of how free agents are going to view the possibility of coming to Sacramento. That’s been the impetus for our reaching out to clubs ahead of free agency starting,” Forst said.
With this in mind, the A’s might well be one of the more aggressive teams in the early stages of free agency, with Forst and company perhaps being keen on acquiring any non-tender candidates or unwelcome contracts that other teams have on their books. The Athletics have roughly $35.5MM on the books for 2025 (according to RosterResource) though none of that money is actually guaranteed, so some trades or non-tenders of their own could reduce that number. This gives the A’s some relative flexibility in terms of payroll space, as Forst has said the club is prepared to spend beyond its $63.1MM payroll from 2024.
This one belongs to the Reds
They couldn’t go much lower, after all.
MLB Top 100 Commenter
Watch for the Sacramento A’s to make the playoffs in one of the next three years
sad tormented neglected mariners fan
I think you mean only the athletics, as they want to be called
My favorite teams are the Washington football team and the Utah hockey club
MLB Top 100 Commenter
I’ll be wearing my Sacramento A’s jersey to the games, as will many others.
letitbelowenstein
I enjoy the Washington Redskins and the Cleveland Indians.
avenger65
Nothing wrong with “Indians.”. Redskins, a bit more offensive.
sad tormented neglected mariners fan
They won’t change them back, I wish at least Indians were still around but there’s no point in arguing
zacharydmanprin
That’s because you’re a racist.
Asfan0780
Yes they can, pretty sure they won’t pay rooker in arby maybe in 2026. But they’ll waste a chunk of money on crap veteran pitchers to prove they are spending revenue sharing checks
FartPocket
I want to see Larry Buts in Atlanta, but I don’t want them to give up anything of value because I hope John Fisher never has good news for the rest of his life. Let him take over LF.
Scottnva74
Watch they will have competitive team going into their 1st Vegas season, make a 2023 Rangers like run through the playoffs to get the Vegas fans excited…then he say f— you and blow up the team!
drprofsps
What concerns me about this team is their plan to build an open stadium in Las Vegas. We Rangers had an open stadium in North Texas for years, and once we built a covered one, not only did we win the World Series, but attending games in the summer became enjoyable. When I watched the Las Vegas AAA team, the Area 52s Aliens (or something similar), I would always pay for the air-conditioned seats. However, after they moved to a fully open park, I stopped attending games when I visit Vegas. The A’s will never make the playoffs without players willing to play in 120+ degrees!!!!
JoeBrady
The A’s will never make the playoffs without players willing to play in 120+ degrees!!!!
=========================
It’s seldom 120 degrees at night.
Roguesaw2
Most Saturday and Sunday games, games before a travel day and games serving as the first leg of a double header, are played in the afternoon. So to his point, you need guys willing to play in the heat. Or you need to change your scheduling and then get guys willing to give up their weekend evenings and travel on short rest.
JoeBrady
They can play Saturday at night. That’s not unusual. Sunday and get-away games are an issue. And the average high at the end of May is still only 95. That’s pretty comfortable in LV.
And maybe this will finally result in them scheduling less April games in the cold-weather states.
kellin
No, but it can still easily be 95-100.
TheOtherMikeD
But its a dry heat.
Philly A's
It’s not an open stadium, fully enclosed.
daddyshark423
It’s supposed to be a full dome. Frankly they need to worry about getting that stadium built before they worry about anything else.
This one belongs to the Reds
Cart before horse is always a wise move.
Braveraider
No they are building a dome.
JoeBrady
Good to see them succeed. The A’s fans deserve something to root for.
Roguesaw2
Any A’s fan who survives this as an A’s fan deserves baseball Sainthood.
Or a free psychological exam…
Steinbrenner2728
JoeBrady is a Vegas resident who is a Red Sox fan, was born in the Bronx, trades stocks for a living, is very pro-Vegas/John Fisher, and roots for the Raiders… just so people are aware based on his past comments I’ve seen from him.
themustache
You keep notes on the guy? Yikes.
JoeBrady
Not a LV resident, but very pro-LV. I’m looking forward to catching some RS and Raider games out there. I’ve attended some minor league games there a long time ago, and had a great time.
Don’t care one way or the other for Fisher. But I’m not a big fan of fans that don’t attend games, but expect a lot of spending.
daddyshark423
There are no A’s fans anymore.
MLB Top 100 Commenter
The Athletics were 32-32 in their last 64 games, better than Texas and just one game behind Seattle for post all-star break. Their next three years are going to be incredible.
daddyshark423
Going .500 over a 64 game sample means the next three years are going to be incredible? Did you just start watching baseball last week?
MLB Top 100 Commenter
The next three years are going to be an incredible experience in Sacramento. Go, Sacramento A’s.
Mikenmn
If only some group of taxpayers could subsidize the improvement of the roster…
User 2770661946
Fisher did everything he could to build a new stadium and keep the team in Oakland. His dream was to bring a World Series to Oakland and Thao made sure his dream, your dream and my dream was crushed. He pursued five different Bay Area sites all at an operating loss directly to his pocket just to make sure the legacy of the A’s would remain in Oakland. Thao is the villain. Fisher is the victim.
Roguesaw2
I have trouble thinking of any of them as victims
centerfield13
Not sure if you live in/near Oakland, but anybody who does who thinks it would be wise for Thao or any other mayor to spend any city money on a stadium for a billionaire is nuts. There are so many other priorities for Oakland to improve the lives of residents than spend public money on a stadium.
Fisher is hardly a victim. He could have put up more of his own money if he truly cared about Oakland.
FartPocket
Found John Fisher’s human bidet. Troll tongue-ing owner b-holes to get a response
daddyshark423
Lol
A's lover
@User 2770661946
I don’t know if you are being tongue and cheek, or if you really mean this. One of my close friends was an attorney for the city of Oakland and Alameda County during the process, she was intimately involved. She is a calm, gentle person, but she was furious at the end of the negotiations, after John Fisher did a dog and pony show with Oakland and Alameda. He never intended to build a stadium there, and just played games with them. I trust my inside source. You are way off base.
Blackpink in the area
So they are going to trade prospects for big league talent? That doesn’t seem like a wise move to me.
MLB Top 100 Commenter
Improve the team to increase value and then sell minority stakes.
Blackpink in the area
The team isn’t a pump and dump stock.
MLB Top 100 Commenter
Fisher wants to generate excitement in Sacramento and Las Vegas without spending much.
jbigz12
The team showed signs it can compete. They can move some blocked prospects for ML upgrades. They should be looking at guys with multiple years of control back in any deal though.
Atloriolesfan
Anyone who thinks that the As can’t compete in Sacramento did not watch them in the last half. They have a talented (but small) core. They have a pristine payroll. Langeliers, Wilson, Gelof and Bleday is a pretty promising up the middle combo and Rooker and Butler combined for a 8.6 WAR. So they’re basically missing corner IFs and one corner OF. Those are available everywhere.
Pitching will require upgrades and that requires better FA choices than Stripling and Wood. Proven FA starters will shy away from signing initially, but what happens in Feb/March when some of the Lance Lynn/Kyle Gibson/Montas/Pivetta/Quintana/Lorenzen layer of FA pitchers are looking for pillow one year deals? The As can load up with $8m to $12m deals and flip them if they’re out of it.
I can easily see the As looking very competitive on opening day.
Blackpink in the area
Pristine payroll?
Look if Oakland adds 100 million to their payroll in 2025.sure they could compete. But what are the odds they actually do that? Somewhere between slim and none i think.
norcalblue
If the Dodgers traded Austin Barnes to the As, he’d be their second highest paid player.
aragon
Sadly, the Angels will be 5th in the division.
Atloriolesfan
They were last by 6 games this year. Why would anyone expect them to pass anyone in the division?
Old York
Should be a nice few years for the A’s, getting away from Jokeland. I’d prefer they move to Tokyo or Seoul but I know that won’t happen.
Lindor's Bodyguard
Guam is in play too.
Acoss1331
Mexico City is another option.
This one belongs to the Reds
If they move to Seoul, a player on the roster could say he’s a Seoul man.
cincinnatikid
Don’t know if Oakland would consider trading Brent Rooker to Cincinnati for a package with Noevi Marte, Graham Ashcraft and a minor league pitcher
larkraxm
It seems like the time to trade Rooker was last year’s trade deadline, when he was at peak value and the acquiring team got him for this year’s playoff run. Whatever the return will be at this point, it is diminished
letitbelowenstein
Sign Soto and Burnes. That will make people sit up and notice.
Dumpster Divin Theo
And then he’ll interview Nixon
Dan oleson
Of course they’re past the ‘sell ‘ stage – they’re also past the ‘sign a handful of FA’ too; as to trades, you bet that every player & their agent with any leverage will have a ‘no Sacramento’ protection in their contract. Bush league team playing in a bush league stadium.
mad1
Little league players would be an upgrade to this roster
Jiggs
Oakland GM should take advantage of the Cubs in Trades. Hoyer has much talent ML ready, all blocked by high dollar FA’s he’s signed and extensions given. Cubs are in a Position to be taken advantage of.
davemlaw
Ticket sales for the A’s have already been robust. It’s a small park so less supply and more demand. Plus, the good people of Sacramento are excited about MLB in their town, if only for 3 years.
So more revenues means more to spend. They’re going to surprise a lot of people next year. I could see the A’s and Giants making a deal or two; a guy like David Villar, who’s had a ton of success in Sacramento, could really take off there.
chiparm
Sounds like the future home of Brett Baty at 3b. Aside from Miller, any pitching with upside to offer the Mets back.
rockingryan
This is like the dollar store saying “they’re going to get new products”…yes, but they’re going to cheap dollar store products.