Free agent left-hander Rich Hill is going to be throwing for interested clubs on Friday, reports Robert Murray of FanSided. It’s not known which clubs will attend the throwing session but Hill has already reportedly received interest from the Yankees and Dodgers.
Hill is attempting a fairly unique mercenary mission this year, something that he’s had in mind for a while. Back in August of 2022, he told Rob Bradford of WEEI that he wanted to skip the first half of 2023 but then participate in the second half. The idea would allow him to both spend more time with his family, choose a team in playoff contention and also theoretically give him more firepower as he wouldn’t need to pace himself for the grind of a full season.
Though the idea was in his head over a year ago, he didn’t follow through on it in 2023. He signed with the Pirates on a one-year, $8MM deal, making 22 starts with a 4.76 earned run average. He got flipped to the Padres at the deadline but then both he and the club faltered. He got bumped to the bullpen and was even put on waivers at one point but went unclaimed. He ultimately recorded an 8.23 ERA in his ten outings with the Friars.
He has been more committed to the plan this year. In October of last year, he mentioned it to Kevin Acee of the San Diego Union-Tribune and hasn’t diverted since. In May of this year, he told Ian Browne of MLB.com that he had turned down offers from three clubs in the offseason but was still throwing to keep his midseason plan afloat. Last month, Pete Abraham of the Boston Globe reported that Hill was throwing from a mound and had interest from the Yankees and Dodgers.
It’s an intriguing experiment and the timing is also perhaps not a coincidence. With the trade deadline now in the rear-view mirror, teams are fairly hamstrung in how they can go about upgrading their rosters. There are still a few ways, as MLBTR’s Steve Adams recently laid out, but most of them involve making moves around the margins.
The recent trade deadline was often characterized by observers as having a lack of clear sellers, which seemingly led to high asking prices on the few players that were available. For clubs that balked at those prices, they may be intrigued by the opportunity to acquire Hill for nothing more than cash.
A source tells Murray that Hill isn’t even doing this for the money but more a desire to win. Hill has already banked over $75MM in earnings, per his Baseball Reference page, but doesn’t have a ring. He pitched in the postseason for the 2007 Cubs and then the Dodgers from 2016 to 2019, but he was with the Twins in 2020 when the Dodgers won the World Series.
Hill could potentially be an impact addition if the self-shortened season allows him to get back to his old self. He’s already had one of the more unique trajectories, as he debuted way back in 2005 and had one of his best seasons in 2007, tossing 195 innings for the Cubs with a 3.92 ERA.
But his results tapered off from there and he struggled to get a lengthy opportunity for almost a decade. From 2008 to 2015, he didn’t hit 60 innings pitched in any of those major league seasons due to a combination of injuries and underperformance. He came roaring back with the Dodgers in 2016, his age-36 season, and kicked off a remarkable second act. From that year and through 2020, he had a 3.01 ERA, 28.3% strikeout rate and 8.2% walk rate in 476 innings.
In 2021, his age-41 season, his ERA climbed to 3.86. Then it was 4.27 in 2022 and 5.41 between the Pirates and Padres last year. Perhaps Hill’s ERA would have continued climbing if he tried to pitch another full season but he’s hoping that acting as a late-season hired gun will help him deliver better results with less volume.
How that plays out will be an interesting situation to monitor. There are only about seven weeks remaining in the regular season schedule at this point. Though Hill is throwing on his own, he will probably require a few weeks of ramp-up once he signs, a sort of belated Spring Training. In a best-case scenario, he can bolster a club’s rotation down the stretch and then factor into their postseason rotation as one of the freshest October arms around, despite now being 44 years old. Per Murray, Friday’s throwing session takes place at 10am Eastern time at Champion Physical Therapy and Performance in Waltham, Massachusetts.
mlb fan
Urban legend has it that Rich Hill once struck out Jesus on a curveball in the dirt.
MLB Top 100 Commenter
Dick Mountain has not had a FIP below 3.90 since 2017.
heartsofiron
what defines a club as interesting?
jdgoat
The Mariners would probably be interested putting him somewhere in their batting order. He might be an improvement there.
sad tormented neglected mariners fan
Hill or madbum would probably do better at DH then the other guys we’ve put there
gbs42
“than”
NoShoW 2
Imagine thinking a 44 year old who had a 5 ERA last year and hasn’t pitched in a game in almost a year will somehow help you. How would this be any better than just calling up some AAA guy and paying him league minimum to also have a 5 ERA.
GASoxFan
AAA guys (or AA, or whatever for that matter) have already participated in their whole minor league calendar.
Most minor league pitchers aren’t particularly stretched out to high innings limits. So, you could call up a 25 year old making minimum… but he’s also probably already near an innings limit which can do too much if you blow past it to hurt further development or make an injury happen.
Hill won’t have much of an innings limit on his season, just a question of ramping up against live batters, possibly starting as a low leverage reliever or mop up guy a couple times.
Then there’s the veteran presence and postseason experience intangibles
pev4
He doesn’t understand how numbers work.
outinleftfield
For most teams the AAA season ends Sept 22nd this year.
HiredGun23
It’s all coming from Hill himself. I don’t see him as an upgrade but would love for Dem Bums to to a flier on him…
scottaz
I’m hoping the desperate Dodgers sign him. He would fit in nicely with their mix of has-been, continually-injured and flash-in-the-pan rotation options.
Time for a Poll Question:
Who will be the first to catch the Dodgers in the NLW standings this year?
1). Diamondbacks
2). Padres
3). Both at the same time
4). First one, then the other
5). Neither one.
NOTE: Both the Padres and Dbacks are only 3 games behind the Dodgers in the NLW. When I first posted this Poll, the Dodgers were 7 games ahead…that was 1 week ago.
Also NOTE: With the Dbacks now with their original starting rotation (Gallen, Kelly, Rodriguez, Pfaadt and Montgomery) almost healthy, both the Dbacks and Padres have much more solid team than the Dodgers.
Gwynning
I’ll stick with my previous vote for 4, but it might be 3.
MLB Top 100 Commenter
The return of Mookie Betts will make a big difference. If Yamamoto returns healthy, that will be critical to their post-season. I think the Dodgers will win their division. I do like the Padres as a wild card team that could go deep in the post-season. Right now I see Atlanta and Arizona as wild cards rather than the Mets and Cards, but the only teams that I feel certain will make the NL playoffs are Philly, Milwaukee, LA and SD. A healthy Christian Walker is important, although Josh Bell has been amazing.
User 401527550
There is nothing in the rule book guaranteeing the Dodgers a playoff spot. When the Padres and Dodgers blow past them they could get blown by the Braves in the wild card if they heat up. The Dodgers schedule isn’t exactly easy the rest of the way.
whyhayzee
The Dodgers are going to blow past the Dodgers?
User 401527550
The way they are blowing games they are but the Diamondbacks sailing by them will be much funnier.
whyhayzee
The Mets just inched ahead of the Braves!!!
3768902
D. FALVEY PERKS UP
outinleftfield
Reports are that he has been throwing 86-88 in workouts near his home in the Boston area. I don’t think many teams are going to take a chance on that so close to the playoffs unless they are desperate to fill innings and he signs for pro-rated MLB minimum.
dirtyjog
I know a team in the Boston area that’s pretty desperate to fill innings
Gwynning
The AARP Headquarters softball team?
Old York
I’ll also be trying out for interested teams on Friday.
This one belongs to the Reds
My knees are shot, so I can only DH. But I’ll take the minimum to do that.
thickiedon
Rather liberal usage of the term “mercenary”, don’t ya think?!
vincent k. mcmahon
Rich Hill you are…. a Cardinal.
Gwynning
Hopefully he enlists Maury Povich to make the dramatic announcement!
Rsox
At this point it might be “Rich Hill, you are the grandfather. “…
Rishi
I think we have seen this year with players signing late that they are rusty and injury prone. Seeing as he’s 44 I wouldn’t count on anything. But he’s a unique guy. Cool career. He did, at least, have the advantage that he planned this out from the beginning, unlike Montgomery simply going unsigned, for instance.
Poolhalljunkies
Itd have been a much cooler career had he not spent more time on the dl than the field
Rsox
The time on the DL is why he’s still hanging around. With no long injury stints the mileage on his arm would be two or three times what it is now
Rishi
Considering how many times he’s hurt his elbow I don’t really agree. We are talking about a guy who had to change his arm angle because of injury and had a tommy John after that too, if I recall. He pitched at age 43 and was awful. Morton is 40. Presumably he could pitch til 43 and potentially be awful. He is not a guy whose been constantly injured I don’t think (if I recall). Bartolo threw a lot of innings. The age thing is just a general thing. Some people could pitch longer and some aren’t gonna make it past age 30. Just my opinion.
Just Rob
Mike Elias has G-Rod’s film in one hand and a phone with Hill’s agent on it in the other.
Poolhalljunkies
Or craig breslow took a short drive to his house after watching kutter crawford give it up again last night lol
Rsox
Crawford needs to be at Worcester, Criswell needs to be starting and Booser needs to be in the Sox bullpen
whyhayzee
Crawford’s wearing down. I like Criswell. And Booser is the stuff of legends. Let’s see what they have in the new pick ups and coming off injuries. Seems like a lot of bullpen pieces. They could use another starter.
Rsox
If rosters still expanded to 40 i think more people could be on board with this but since you only get 2 additional spots i would think if you were a contending team this would be the last usage of a roster spot you could think of
Multi Position Eligibility
Did he develop a knuckleballl?
MacGromit
AARP could help Baltimore. Just make it happen, they’re might be some more magic in that man. Insurance policies don’t have to pay out on order to serve some good.
gbs42
Where’s Brandon Belt?
Brew88
It’s baffling
birdland410
The orioles have to be one of the teams looking at him right? They just have to be
spooky
Break them off Dick Mountain. The deuce is loose
MafiaBass
One of my faves! Doesn’t he live in MA? One of Joe Castiglione’s all-time favorites as well.
whyhayzee
Rich Hill, the poor man’s Jamie Moyer.
Love them both.
Let’s go!
joeflaccosunibrow
At this point, Baltimore is desperate enough. Get 6-8 starts of 4.5 ERA ball and hope the offense can wake up. Freddy Rodriguez was scratched warming up and the AAA hands are pitching batting practice when here.
NoSaint
This could become a trend. I’m pretty sure I saw Dave Kingman pick up a bat!
darthdragula
Hill could set up a throwing session that included free hookers, an open bar and the world’s biggest barbecue and nobody would show up to watch him pitch.
just_breathe
Add twins to list of desperate teams