Angels right-hander Luis Garcia is drawing widespread trade interest, according to Jon Heyman of the New York Post. Heyman names the Yankees, Red Sox, and Royals as among the interested teams.
Garcia, 37, is a veteran of 12 MLB seasons and has been a steady middle relief arm for many yearss. After pitching to roughly league average results (99 ERA+) in six years with the Phillies to start his career, Garcia has bounced around the league to pitch for the Angels, Rangers, Cardinals, and Padres over the past half decade. With a better ERA+ than average in each of the last five 162-game seasons, Garcia sports a 3.94 ERA (107 ERA+) and a 4.00 FIP since the start of the 2019 campaign, though he’s only collected nine saves in that time as clubs have generally utilized him in the middle innings.
The veteran righty has put together a solid season this year in his second stint with the Angels, posting a 3.80 ERA with evens stronger peripherals (3.68 FIP, 3.44 SIERA). Garcia’s 22.3% strikeout rate and 7.8% walk rate this year, while perfectly solid, don’t exactly jump off the page, but in conjunction with his excellent 50.8% groundball rate this year they make for a quality relief arm who would improve the majority of the bullpens around the league. With so many teams in contention and a number of them facing bullpen struggles this year, it’s hardly a surprise that teams would be interested in Garcia’s services. For their part, the Angels removed any doubt regarding their willingness to deal rental players earlier today by shipping closer Carlos Estevez to Philadelphia.
As for Garcia’s potential suitors, each is known to be on the hunt for bullpen help this summer. Reporting earlier today indicated that the Yankees hope to add two relievers to their bullpen before the deadline, and while Garcia is unlikely to be the sort of shutdown closer New York is seemingly hoping to add in front of struggling righty Clay Holmes, Garcia could be an excellent secondary addition to work lower-leverage spots alongside arms such as Michael Tonkin and Tim Hill. The Red Sox, meanwhile, are also in the market for a reliever or two (as noted by MassLive’s Sean McAdam) following injuries to leverage righties Justin Slaten and Chris Martin. While Garcia’s 112 ERA+ isn’t quite on the level of Slaten’s 129 or Martin’s 128, he could certainly join the late-inning mix alongside Brennan Bernadino, Zack Kelly, and closer Kenley Jansen for a few weeks until Slaten and Martin can return to action for Boston.
The Royals may be the best fit for Garcia’s services of the three, however. MLB.com’s Anne Rogers reports that Kansas City was in on Estevez prior to him landing in Philadelphia, but were ultimately unwilling to part with their top tier of prospects in order to acquire a rental piece like Estevez. While Garcia is also a rental piece, his price tag shouldn’t approach that of Estevez, a former All-Star with a 180 ERA+ and 20 saves this year. A lower price tag doesn’t mean Garcia couldn’t still be impactful for the Royals, however, as the club’s 4.18 bullpen ERA ranks in the bottom ten in the majors this year. That leaves them likely to benefit considerably from the addition of a player of Garcia’s caliber, even after they swung a deal with the Nationals to acquire Hunter Harvey earlier this month.
Halo11Fan
What’s the point. The Angels got little for Estevez, you think they’ll get anything for Garcia?
Champ world champion Texas Rangers
Jeff seems to think angels got the moon.
Fever Pitch Guy
Champ – The Angels need a catcher and the Red Sox desperately need relief help now that Bailey Magic has worn off. McGuire for Garcia would be a win-win trade for each team.
Angelfan 4
What are you saying? Klassen is probably the Phillies 2nd or third best pitching prospect.
Champ world champion Texas Rangers
I’m saying it seems like the angels got a good return according to Jeff
Halo11Fan
From High A to college, he’s pitched poorly at every level but A ball.
And what he did at A ball he did not carry over to high A.
Great return for an All Star closer. Not.
Kevin H
I guess I missed your Top Phillies Prospects article
Halo11Fan
One is a nothing prospect, the other is a high risk prospect.
And the high risk prospect wasn’t exactly setting the world on fire at high A.
And since when are the Angels good at developing either? There is a reason they draft college player.
Johnny Bravo
So pessimistic are you really an Angels fan?
The Angels got two pitching prospects. I thought they did pretty good for a rental player.
aragon
He is not pessimistic. Angels just cannot develop pitchers especially mediocre pitching prospects.
That name is already taken
So you tell us all why the Angels should have held on to Esty so he could walk in free agency for nothing?
orange2001
They won’t get much for Garcia, Strickland, or Pillar. And as I’ve stated before, I doubt they’ll trade Anderson, Ward or Rengifo unless a team overpays (which I’m skeptical will happen).
TurksTeeth
Jeff Passan : “A quick reminder for the trade deadline: Public prospect rankings quite often are not updated during the season. If you think George Klassen and Samuel Aldegheri are not good because they were ranked in the 20s before the season, you do not know ball. They are both very good.”
Kiley McDaniel: “To Jeff’s point: like Agustin Ramirez in the Chisholm trade, George Klassen is also firmly in the top 100 mix, if not on the list; has been since May when it was clear he was much better than in college at Minnesota. He was a 2023 6th rounder with well below average command then…and to make the point with Klassen further: I had him over Mick Abel in my Phillies live/private rankings and just checked with a few more execs to make sure. They also had Klassen over Abel.”
Halo11Fan
I know that three months and 38 innings are practically meaningless.
Especially at A ball where it’s not carried over to high A.
That name is already taken
So you tell me what the Angels could have gotten for a 2 month rental?
Halo11Fan
What did the Angels give away last year for two week rentals?
aragon
2 month rental can gets rings.
rottenboyfriend
U need to find a new team! I have read many of your posts and 90% of them are negative! Ron Washington will turn this franchise around by 2026! Manasian certainly needs to get better however Joyce, Ohoppe, Neto, Schanuel, Moore, Moniak, and Detmers, we’re under his watch! Anderson and Garcia are the first free agents we have signed where they are wanted by all the contending teams so everything isn’t gloom and doom!
Guard the Vogt
Wrong Luis Garcia hyperlinked to bref
jk2me1310
Seems to happen pretty frequently
RoyalsFanAmongWolves
was coming here to say same thing
Guard the Vogt
It’s fixed now. Ty
Chris Lee
Do the Angles need a catching prospect? That’s where the Royals system seens to have depth.
Johnny Bravo
Juan Flores 20 year-old Scouting grades: Hit: 40 | Power: 45 | Run: 40 | Arm: 60 | Field: 55 | Overall: 40
Flores drew attention from scouts in Venezuela because of his advanced skills behind the plate. That’s a big reason why the Angels gave him $280,000 to sign at the start of the 2023 international signing period. He made his debut in the Dominican Summer League and showed that word of his defensive acumen was not greatly exaggerated, while he also shook off a slow offensive start to provide a little more with the bat than anticipated.
Flores’ calling card will always be his glove work. The skills are there for him to perhaps be a plus receiver in the future and he already has a plus arm, one that threw out 53.1 percent of potential basestealers in the DSL during his debut. The Angels thought so highly of his work behind the dish they thought he’d be able to handle higher-level arms and invited him to big league camp this
Alexpulido7051 2
Although both Estévez and Garcia both had rocky starts to the season. They seem to be playing their best leading up to the trade deadline. It could be win win trade if they stay consistent towards the end of the season
3 finger split
Saw enough of Garcia in San Diego…throws hard but flat with ZERO movement and he is a can of gas. Great pitcher when you’re up by eight or down by eight but in a tight spot…he takes the loss and can’t hold any lead.
Redstitch108* 2
Obvious to me that you have not been watching Garcia for the past 3 months then if you think he’s still that garbage time only hurler he once was. He’s carved out a solid role as an 8th inning bridge to the closer. I really thought he was a crap signing when the Halos got him, but I have pleasantly surprised by his ability to get big outs and induce ground balls this year. He’s figured something out that he didn’t have last time he was a Halo.
troutfishing
You guys… this site becomes much more enjoyable if you just ignore Halo11. 95% of his posts are complaints and negativity.
Looking forward to seeing on how the improvements these 2 prospects made in 2024 translate on the field for the Angels.
MLBTR needs to hire editors
Among professionals, Deeds is the most incompetent writer I’ve ever read. “Meanwhile” has to START the sentence; it can’t come in the middle between commas. Either learn this or move out of the way for a better writer to take your job, Mr. Deeds.