Jim McAndrew, a former major league pitcher for the Mets and Padres, has passed away, according to Jay Horwitz, vice president of media relations for the Mets. McAndrew was 80 years old.
While McAndrew may have been overshadowed by Hall of Fame teammates Tom Seaver and Nolan Ryan, he was a dependable back-end starting pitcher, and occasional reliever, throughout his time in Queens. Across 146 games with the Mets (105 starts), the Iowa native went 36-49 but pitched to an estimable 3.54 ERA. He was a member of the 1969 World Series champion team, and although he did not pitch in the postseason, he helped the Mets win the NL East that year, tossing 135 innings with a 3.47 ERA.
The following year, McAndrew pitched what was arguably the best season of his big league tenure. He made a career-high 27 starts, crossing the 100-strikeout threshold for the first and only time. Even more impressive, he maintained the lowest walk rate of his career. The 6-foot-2 right-hander threw nine complete games, three shutouts, and to top it all off, he earned two saves in five relief appearances. McAndrew had a difficult season in 1971 but bounced back in ’72, finishing 11th among qualified NL starters with a 2.80 ERA. He went 11-8 that year, adding another four complete games to his career tally. Unfortunately, the righty struggled again the next season, and as was the case in 1969, he did not pitch in the playoffs for the 1973 NL pennant-winning club.
After nine years in the Mets organization, six spent with the big league team, McAndrew played his final season for the Padres. He retired in 1974. Although his last MLB season was marred by injury, he still managed to throw one more complete game, bringing his career total up to an even 20.
McAndrew’s son Jamie, one of four children he shared with his wife Lyn, played two years in Major League Baseball. A right-handed pitcher like his father, the younger McAndrew pitched for the Brewers in 1995 and ’97. We at MLB Trade Rumors send our sympathies and condolences to McAndrew’s family and loved ones.
drprofsps
RIP
Flanster
From Lost Nation,Iowa. Rest In Peace,Jim!!
CrikesAlready
…an injury-marred final season… where he made *15* appearances before being released on the 1st of June.
deweybelongsinthehall
Why such a clarification comment? My dad went to the 69 WS and bought me a “scroll pennant” that had the full roster listed. Although I was a Sox fan, that pennant was on my wall next to a pic of Yaz. McAndrew was included and back in the day I was able to recite the entire team in alphabetical order as it was listed. Can’t do it today but I remember Jim. RIP and thanks for the memories.
MLB Top 100 Commenter
Three shutouts in a single season, I doubt that any National League pitcher will do that in 2024!
Eighty years old is too young, my sympathy to his family and fans.
CarryABigStick
Shutouts, let alone complete games.
This one belongs to the Reds
I recall him in the early 70s. A lot of childhood ballplayers seem to be passing. Sad state. RIP.
YankeesBleacherCreature
RIP Mr. McAndrew. Career 4.9K/9IP and a 3.53 FIP is interesting. That low K% would never work in today’s game.
rcerso75
Well I guess it’s good he wasn’t pitching in today’s game.
LordD99
He’d have a higher K rate in today’s game.
sascoach2003
Rest in peace. Another from my childhood goes to the Field of Dreams. Time is undefeated.
txman22
Same here. Fond of him as I got a single off him at Mets Dream week back in the 90’s. RIP
Non Roster Invitee
Got a sweet ’71 Topps card of him.
25 years in the coal industry, yuck.
RIP Jim.
I.M. Insane
161 games, a WS ring and a part of a truly magical team. Fine career, Jim. RIP.
377194
RIP
Followed him and the Mets as a kid. Sad.
Old York
Man, lots of Mets players passing away this and last year.
Blue Baron
@Old York: Lots of people in general. It’s an unfortunate part of life.
jorge78
RIP Jim…..
Robertowannabe1
RIP Jim…..
LordD99
Looks like he might have had an arm injury judging by how he fell off after his first five seasons. Another one of those pitchers who’d likely have a longer career if he played today due to medical advances. I remember him well from my youth. RIP. Condolences to his family and friends.
I.M. Insane
True about medicine, but they’d have him trying to throw 100-MPH to every hitter since high school. So he still wouldn’t have gained anything except maybe more strikeouts.
Niekro floater
RIP
hoof hearted
20 complete games in career. Would be in top 10% of today’s pitchers
all in the suit that you wear
RIP
royhobbs7
Coincidentally met Jim McAndrew on a NYC subway (of all places) in 1971… He was pleasantly surprised that even a fan would recognize him. What a fine gentleman. We talked for several minutes. It was so refreshing to meet a ballplayer on my favorite team (NY Mets) who was so relaxed speaking to a fan without him having any pretense..
Blue Baron
I was 10 years old when I attended this complete game win over Phil Niekro and the Braves, 8/27/70 at Shea.
ultimatemets.com/gamedetail.php?gameno=1434&t…
McAndrew didn’t get the credit he deserved because he was overshadowed on those teams by Tom Seaver, Jerry Koosman, Jon Matlack, Gary Gentry, and Nolan Ryan.
kingmanscorner
My condolences to the family and may Jim rest in eternal peace.