Brewers starting pitcher Brandon Woodruff has a right shoulder injury, which will keep him from playing in the upcoming NL Wild Card Series, manager Craig Counsell told reporters (including Curt Hogg of the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel). Whether or not he can pitch later in the postseason, should the Brewers advance, remains to be seen.
The All-Star right-hander spent four months of the 2023 campaign on the injured list with a subscapular strain in his right shoulder. However, he returned in early August and looked healthy down the stretch, pitching to a 2.59 ERA in nine starts while averaging more than six innings per game. His shoulder bothered him during his final outing of the regular season, but initially, he responded well to treatment. Thus, the severity of his injury came as a surprise for the Brewers; the team was counting on him to start game two of the Wild Card series against the Diamondbacks.
Woodruff plans to get a second opinion on his shoulder, but the team isn’t expecting an update until the end of the week. While they will hope for the best, Counsell and his staff will have to prepare for the worst-case scenario, in which their number two starter is out for the rest of the playoffs.
The Brewers have not yet announced who will start on Wednesday in Woodruff’s place, although Freddy Peralta seems to be the most likely candidate. The 27-year-old pitched his first qualifying season this year, making 30 starts with a 3.86 ERA. It’s harder to guess who will start for Milwaukee in a potential game three. Wade Miley and Adrian Houser are presumably the leading candidates; each had a solid year in 2023, and each is coming off a strong September. Miley pitched to a 3.04 ERA in his final five games, while Houser put up a 2.14 ERA in four September starts. The elder Miley probably has the edge, thanks to his veteran experience and his lefty arm, but Counsell will surely take his time thinking about individual matchups before he makes a decision.
While the Brewers have rotation depth to call upon, this still comes as a huge blow to their postseason hopes. At full strength, Woodruff is one of the better starting pitchers in the National League, and this team was counting on a powerful one-two punch of Corbin Burnes and Woodruff to lead them over the Diamondbacks. No one was more upset about the news than Woodruff himself, who choked up as he told reporters, “We’ve got a good clubhouse. And I want to be a part of that. Sitting here now, I may not.”
BaseballBrewTown
Oh… Boy…
BucksPackersBrewersWow!
What in Teddy Higuera is going on here!
tangerinepony
Teddy Higuera Version 2
bravesnation nc
Terrible!
Edp007
That’s a big blow excuse the obviousness
Manfred’s playing with the balls
The Brewers need to keep the young speedy dbacks off the bases and losing Woodruff doesn’t help. Looks like the only NL central rep might get bounced early.
This one belongs to the Reds
That sucks for you guys…
WiscoBaseballGuy08
Why do the baseball gods hate the Brewers…
Jbeck29
Seriously. Wtf. I always say WI can’t have nice things.
Angry Disgruntled Sox Fan
Hasn’t hated them yet. Yeah it’s bad, but play the games first
Blue Baron
Probably because Bud Selig stole the team from Seattle in 1970 and orchestrated the 1994 strike, cancellation of the World Series, and attempt to bust the MLBPA and institute a salary cap.
BlueSkies_LA
Now I’m certainly no Bud Selig fan, but I’m still wondering how he orchestrated this heist.
Frank_Stallone1
Stole the team from Seattle? The owners declared bankruptcy and sold them. Strange reconstruction of history.
Blue Baron
Whatever did or didn’t happen pales in comparison to what Selig, Jerry Reinsdorf, Ewing Kauffman, and their cabal of small-market owners pulled in 1994-95, cancelling the World Series, failing to bargain in good faith, and illegally trying to field replacement teams in their attempt to bust the MLBPA and force a salary cap down the players’ throats.
Frank_Stallone1
The only two people to respond, did so to the stealing of the Brewers portion, of which you did not back up.
Blue Baron
Sue me.
What he did around the 1994 strike was more damaging to the game and my main point.
Blue Baron
What he did around the strike was more damaging to the game and was my main point.
Selig was a pretty sleazy guy.
Frank_Stallone1
Great, so stick to the things that make him sleazy and don’t make other stuff up, makes you look stupid.
Of course he was sleazy, dude was literally a used car salesman.
Blue Baron
My main point.
If you think I look stupid, good for you. I would have to care for it to matter to me. This isn’t a high school cafeteria.
Frank_Stallone1
Doesn’t matter if you care or not. I care to correct you when you are simply making things up. What a ridiculous life to have to feel the need to do that, then when someone calls you out, you just shift away and don’t say you’re wrong. It’s OK to be wrong in life.
Blue Baron
I know it is, and that’s why I don’t care what you think.
If I was wrong about the Seattle thing, fine. It’s hardly a matter of life and death, it doesn’t matter 53 years later, and it certainly did you no harm.
Try to lighten up and let things go.
Frank_Stallone1
Says the guy still bitter about Bud Selig.
Blue Baron
I’m not bitter about him as I don’t live in Seattle or Milwaukee, and the strike was 29 years ago.
And however I may feel, what’s it to you, anyway?
Try to lighten up and let things go.
Frank_Stallone1
Not sure if you noticed, but you’re posting to a website talking about sports. If you don’t want people to respond to you, you can just say these things to yourself.
I’m not holding on to anything.
Blue Baron
Says the guy who keeps responding to that which doesn’t concern him.
You too can just say these things to yourself.
Frank_Stallone1
Huh? I’m not the guy telling the other guy to let things go. You seem to have trouble with your own advice. Doesn’t surprise me as you tend to say things even you don’t believe.
Milwaukee-2208
2019 Yelich
2021 Williams (self inflicted moron)
2023 woodruff
amk1920
Another hypothetical deep playoff run by the Brewers
Milwaukee-2208
Beating Arizona without woodruff isn’t the issue. Facing LA without your full arms is a death sentence
Neon Cop
Brewers would still win; they’re due some good fortune.
Angels & NL West
Dbacks need to get their bats going. Not seeing Woodruff will help. Missing Burnes and Peralta would come in handy, as well.
Vanilla Good
Hoping they get hurt too or?
Milwaukee-2208
Dbacks would still lose lol
sfes
Ahh to have the benefit of hindsight
SupremeZeus
If you’ve been watching the snakes lately you know it doesn’t matter who is pitching. Snakes are currently swinging wet newspapers and recently are a threat to get no hit every night.
brewsingblue82
I mean, it’s basically a given they’re seeing Burnes and Peralta.
Louholtz22
Fuuuuuuudge!!! Damn it
ib6ub9
Must be playoff time.
KingZeke8
I’m starting to get what Mets fans felt like when they had Harvey, deGrom, Syndergaard and so many of those young, promising pitchers. The Brewers have a 3 headed monster in Burnes, Woodruff and Peralta yet due to injuries, they’ve never all 3 been able to put it together in a single season without injury. The closest was 2021 where they each made at least 27 starts. ERA? 2.43, 2.56 and 2.81 respectively
fred-3
the days of winning with dominant starting pitching in the playoffs are over. starters rarely make it to Oct healthy and it’s very tough going through a line-up 3-4 times nowadays with so much data
kripes-brewers
Maybe, but these guys, when healthy, can do it. I’ll still take Miley or Houser in game 3. Next dude up. Counsell has trotted out McGill as the opener before. It really wouldn’t shock me if he did that in game 3, bringing Miley in after. Vary the speed and approach, keep the batters guessing.
Woody wants to be in there, we know that. He’ll be good if we can get to the Dodgers, but they’ll focus on the D-Backs right now.
Angry Disgruntled Sox Fan
Not true, pitching still wins but Brewers just couldn’t get runs before
UWPSUPERFAN77
To King Good Comment!
CubsWin108
wow
Paleobros
You can say that again!
CardsFan57
That’s a tough blow.
BlueSkies_LA
That’s a helluva tough break, but to be totally real, the Brewers aren’t the only team having to go into the playoffs down a starter or three.
avenger65
Blue Skies: I believe TB have four starters out, yet they still won 90 games. Incredible.
BlueSkies_LA
The Dodgers had only one of their opening day starters make it to the end of the season, and that was Kershaw with all of 131 innings. Nearly a third of their starts were made by rookies. And yet they won 100. Baseball can be one crazy game.
Missippi_has_3Ks
Sweet! Everything’s going good for the Dodgers! Fried, Morton now Woodruff. Ruff break for the Brewers ^_^
MarlinsFanBase
Here come the Marlins – D-Backs NLCS!
avenger65
I would LOVE that! Burger for the Marlins and Zevala for Arizona. Two ex-White Sox who deserved better than playing for the Titanic that is the south siders.
BlueSkies_LA
Gloating is bad form. The Dodgers took their starting pitching hits all season long and I sure didn’t want to hear any booyahs about that.
Jerry Hairston Jr's Toupee
Dodgers have their own pitching issues as well.
Missippi_has_3Ks
It can go really well for the Dodgers as their rookies are relatively new and unpredictable or horribly wrong, considering the rookies and might get shaky in tough spots. I don’t mind Julio Urias being out, he did horrible against the Braves this year.
avenger65
Missippi: Bad walk year for Urias. The thing about teams like the Dodgers, Braves and Phillies that were so dominate during the regular season is that it really doesn’t matter in the PO. Last year all three teams that won 100+ games didn’t go far in the PO, so you never know.
Jerry Hairston Jr's Toupee
Urias goes from getting a nine-figure contract to pitching in Asia. Talk about a bad walk year….
UWPSUPERFAN77
Ruff long gone!
MarlinsFanBase
Well, I’m glad that I didn’t submit my Playoff Brackets picks yet.
Too bad for all of you who already did and had the Brewers going far. That just took a hit. I think a couple of them on MLB TV that showed their picks earlier had the Brewers making a run.
acoss13
I think the Brewers can still defeat the Diamondbacks, but then after that, with Woodruff out, it’ll be an uphill battle for them.
avenger65
acoss: The DBacks have Gallen and Kelly in the first two games. They might not need more than that although it should be a good matchup between Gallen and Burnes.
Missippi_has_3Ks
D-Backs fans might need a Gallen of beer by the end of the week.
BrewCrewFan'
Gallen and Kelly aren’t Until games 2 and 3
acoss13
Avenger:
Oh that’s some good matchups then. I still take the Brewers, but Diamondbacks aren’t going down easy.
BrewCrewFan'
Acoss, The Dbacks dont have Gallen till game 2 and Kelly till game 3, In game 1 it will be Brandon Pfaadt. (3-9, 5.72 Era)
acoss13
BrewCrewFan,
Brewers win this series easy. I’m rooting for the Brewers, I want the NL Central to win big this year even if I am a Chicago teams fan.
Unclemike1526
Counsell has his Brewer farewell playoff tour cut short right off the bat. News at 11.
Old York
Thoughts and prayers for a speedy recovery.
Slider_withcheese
Soft. Seems like he already knows they’re not going anywhere anyway. If he were on a serious contender, he pitches through it and joins the great stories and the legends of October.
Ignorant Son-of-a-b
Milwaukee can still make it to the NLDS. Two incredibly strong starts from Burnes & Peralta and a QS from Miley & it’s not an impossible thread to weave.
_Soulrocker_
There goes the ONLY advantage the Brewers had going into the postseason. It will undoubtedly and unfortunately be a short run with these developments.
Crew2011
Just need to squeak by DBacks. Then we bring back Dodger killer Eric Lauer lol. Yes. Lauer was 7-1 with a 2.37 ERA in 11 career starts against the Dodgers, prior to giving up 3 runs in 3.1 innings in May of this year. His .875 winning percentage is the best among active pitchers vs. Los Angeles with at least eight decisions.
UWPSUPERFAN77
my biggest fan,Mrs Superfan, told me about this an hour ago. Feel terrible. Not over but!!!!
scottaz
As a diehard Dbacks fan who grew up in Wisconsin (Milwaukee Braves fan), I’ll enjoy this series. With Woodruff’s injury the DbCks have a good chance to start a Cinderella team run.
Dbacks went 1-1 against Burnes, but that was way back in April and June. Dbacks won both series against the Brewers, so Dbacks have a 4-2 advantage this year.
Dbacks are a very young team with no Playoff experience, though there was a playoff atmosphere in the last month of the season. However, this young team hasn’t cleared that hurdle to be a great team that wins tight games in the clutch (see the first 2 games of the final series against the Astros). The 2 starters after Gallen and Kelly are rookies (Pfaadt and Nelson), who could be brilliant or totally implode.
If the offense starts clicking again, the Dbacks could go on a major run, The defense and running game are elite. If the bullpen stays on their month long run of excellence and the rookie starters shine watch out.
You probably noticed all the “Ifs”. That’s my way of saying I’d love to see this happen, but I’m not sure the Dbacks are good enough yet to go on a deep run.
brucenewton
Dbacks in 3.
slowcurve
Some ruff news. They wood be lucky to have him back for the NLDS.
Dumpster Divin Theo
Miley came in like a wrecking ball but straightened things out. Her dad would be proud
ayeah
“Whether or not he can pitch later in the postseason…” No worries now. He’ll have all offseason to recover. Along with the rest of the team.