The Reds had another slow offseason, their second straight winter defined mostly by inactivity. It’s a rebuild in Cincinnati, with the upcoming season again more about evaluating the future than winning in the short term.
Major League Signings
- RF Wil Myers: One year, $7.5MM (including buyout of 2024 mutual option)
- C Curt Casali: One year, $3.25MM (including buyout of 2024 mutual option)
- RHP Luke Weaver: One year, $2MM
- C Luke Maile: One year, $1.175MM
2023 spending: $11.675MM
Total spending: $13.925MM
Option Decisions
- Team declined $13MM option on LHP Mike Minor in favor of $1MM buyout
Trades and Claims
- Acquired LF Nick Solak from Rangers for cash
- Traded SS Kyle Farmer to Twins for minor league RHP Casey Legumina
- Acquired SS Kevin Newman from Pirates for RHP Dauri Moreta
- Acquired minor league RHP Jake Wong from Giants for Rule 5 draftee C Blake Sabol
- Acquired CF Will Benson from Guardians for minor league OF Justin Boyd
- Claimed LHP Bennett Sousa off waivers from White Sox
Notable Minor League Signings
- Chase Anderson, Silvino Bracho, Alan Busenitz, Allan Cerda, Daniel Duarte, Tayron Guerrero, Kevin Herget, Derek Law, Ben Lively, Richie Martin, Nick Martini, Daniel Norris, Chad Pinder, Nick Plummer, Henry Ramos, Chuckie Robinson, Austin Romine, Jared Solomon, Hunter Strickland, Jason Vosler, Alex Young
Extensions
- None
Notable Losses
- Farmer, Minor, Donovan Solano, Mike Moustakas (released), Aristides Aquino (non-tendered), Jeff Hoffman (non-tendered), Art Warren (non-tendered), Moreta, Kyle Dowdy (non-tendered), Justin Wilson
The Reds stripped things down over the 2021-22 offseason, dismantling a team that had finished a few games off a Wild Card appearance. Payroll constraints led to a reboot of the roster, with a number of veterans shipped out for young talent either last winter or at the summer deadline. That teardown paired with brutal injury luck resulted in the second 100-loss season in franchise history.
It’s an organization now clearly amidst a rebuild. There was never much expectation for the Reds to do a whole lot this offseason, and general manager Nick Krall essentially confirmed as much before the winter got underway.
Unlike last winter, when the likes of Luis Castillo, Tyler Mahle, Jesse Winker and Sonny Gray were on the roster, Cincinnati didn’t go into this offseason with many obvious trade chips. The most apparent candidate was shortstop Kyle Farmer, who was headed into his second-to-last season of arbitration control. Farmer is a low-end regular at shortstop or high-quality utility piece who’d have modest appeal to a contender. Cincinnati indeed cashed him in for young talent.
It was a one-for-one swap with the Twins that brought back Double-A swingman Casey Legumina. The Gonzaga product had just been added to the Minnesota 40-man roster to keep him out of the Rule 5 draft. He’ll start the season in the upper minors but could factor into the MLB mix later in the year.
Hours after trading away Farmer, Cincinnati backfilled at shortstop with another stopgap veteran. The Reds and division-rival Pirates aligned on a deal that brought in Kevin Newman for middle reliever Dauri Moreta. Newman is also in his penultimate arbitration season and broadly brings a similar profile to the departed Farmer: a contact-oriented offensive approach at the bottom of a lineup and solid glovework. Newman is a little more affordable and could be a midseason trade chip.
He steps into an infield that has a handful of players vying for reps. It’s unknown if Joey Votto will be ready for Opening Day after last summer’s rotator cuff surgery; once healthy, the former MVP will be back at first base. Jonathan India is looking for a bounceback year at second base.
Newman is the presumptive starting shortstop. Jose Barrero could also get one more look to see if he can piece things together offensively. Barrero was a fairly recent top prospect based on his power and defense. He’s coming off an atrocious season in both Triple-A and the big leagues, though, and the clock could be ticking for him to carve out a role. Elly De La Cruz has now firmly emerged as the likely shortstop of the future; he’ll start the year in the upper minors but could make his MLB debut at some point in 2023.
Third base also features a few talented but unproven players trying to cement themselves. Spencer Steer, acquired from the Twins in last summer’s Mahle trade, made his debut last September. He struggled in his first 28 outings but had an excellent age-24 season in Triple-A. He’ll get the first crack at the hot corner, though there was plenty of buzz in Cincinnati camp regarding corner infield prospect Christian Encarnacion-Strand.
Also part of the Mahle trade package, Encarnacion-Strand mashed between High-A and Double-A last season. The Oklahoma State product tore the cover off the ball in Spring Training. Cincinnati reassigned him to minor league camp yesterday, taking him out of the running for an Opening Day roster spot, but he could push Steer for reps before long. That’s also true of Noelvi Marte, a power-hitting infield prospect brought back from the Mariners in the Castillo deal.
The Reds made a firm commitment to the infield youth movement when they released Mike Moustakas in early January. The three-time All-Star was headed into the final season of an ill-advised four-year, $64MM free agent deal. Moustakas had hit only .216/.300/.383 in just 654 plate appearances as a Red. His 2022 campaign was diminished by both underperformance and foot injuries. With little hope of another team taking any notable portion of the $22MM he was due this season, the Reds acknowledged the sunk cost and opened a clearer path to reps for younger players like Steer and Encarnacion-Strand.
Cincinnati should also have room on the bench for a non-roster Spring Training invitee or two. The Reds had arguably the best minor league signing of last winter with Brandon Drury, and they again leveraged their lack of certainty on the roster to bring in a swath of veterans on non-roster pacts. Chad Pinder, Henry Ramos and Jason Vosler are among the position players in camp, while Cincinnati brought in over 10 relievers with some level of MLB experience on minor league deals.
As with the left side of the infield, the outfield is up in the air for players to seize a job. Jake Fraley probably has the leg up on a corner spot after a solid second half. The Reds have maintained they’re going to give former top prospect Nick Senzel another crack in center field. He won’t be ready for Opening Day, so the likes of TJ Friedl and Stuart Fairchild could get on the roster.
The Reds rolled the dice on a pair of former top prospects to add to that mix. Their first move of the offseason was to bring in Nick Solak from the Rangers for cash. It was a no-risk flier on a player who has hit well in the upper minors but struggled to carry that over against MLB pitching. Solak doesn’t have a great positional fit — he struggled mightily at second base and is a fringy corner outfielder as well — but he’s a former second-round draftee who has a .293/.370/.510 line in parts of three Triple-A seasons.
While the Reds didn’t give up anything for Solak, they parted with last year’s second-rounder Justin Boyd to take a shot on 24-year-old Will Benson from the Guardians. A first-round pick in 2016, the 6’5″ Benson has moved extremely slowly up the minor league ranks thanks to huge strikeout totals. He’s shown as patient an approach as anyone in affiliated ball, however, and he clearly has raw power potential. While he’s taken some time to climb the ladder, he’s consistently fared better in his second crack at a level than during his first. That was particularly true last season in Triple-A, when Benson sliced his strikeout rate to a personal-best 22.7% en route to a .278/.426/.522 line.
In addition to those fliers on upside plays, the Reds added to the corner outfield in their biggest free agent move of the winter. Cincinnati guaranteed $7.5MM to Wil Myers on a one-year deal, giving him a chance to rebuild his stock in a hitter-friendly home ballpark. Myers had an up-and-down tenure in San Diego, hitting for power but struggling to make enough contact to be a middle-of-the-order caliber hitter. At age 32, he’s not a long-term core piece for Cincinnati. He’s a perfectly reasonable veteran addition to a young team, one who’d surely be in trade conversations this summer if he’s performing.
Myers is likely to see the bulk of his playing time in right field. That’s in large part because the club is planning to give young catcher Tyler Stephenson more time at designated hitter. The 26-year-old went on the injured list three times last season, all of which were related to incidents behind the plate. He was concussed in a collision with Luke Voit and both fractured his thumb and clavicle on foul tips. Those injuries were all fluky in nature, although there’s little doubt Stephenson will have a better chance of sticking in the lineup if he’s not donning the tools of ignorance as often.
Skipper David Bell told reporters at the start of Spring Training the Reds were aiming for Stephenson to play around 65 games at catcher and 80+ contests at first base/DH (link via Bobby Nightengale of the Cincinnati Enquirer). With that in mind, Cincinnati added a pair of veteran backstops to take some of the workload. Northern Kentucky native Luke Maile signed a one-year, $1.175MM pact in November. He was joined by power-hitting veteran Curt Casali, who received $3.25MM in January to return to the Reds for a second stint.
The Reds didn’t do as much to augment the pitching staff, even on lower-cost pickups of the Maile/Casali ilk. The only such addition was right-hander Luke Weaver, who signed for $2MM after being non-tendered by the Mariners. Weaver is another former top prospect who showed some early-career success but has fallen on hard times of late. Great American Ball Park isn’t an ideal venue for a pitcher to try to rebuild value. That said, the Reds are likely to afford the 29-year-old another shot to get the ball every fifth day and take a crack at developing a breaking pitch he feels comfortable using regularly.
Weaver will step into the fourth spot in the season-opening rotation. The top three will go to second-year hurlers Hunter Greene, Nick Lodolo and Graham Ashcraft. All three have a chance to be core pieces of the next competitive Cincinnati team, with Greene and Lodolo former top ten picks and consensus top prospects. The final rotation spot is up for grabs this spring. Justin Dunn is out of the immediate mix thanks to shoulder issues. The likes of Connor Overton, Luis Cessa and minor league signee Chase Anderson are battling for the job. Prospects Brandon Williamson and Levi Stoudt could join the group over the summer.
Open competition is also the story of the bullpen. Cincinnati didn’t add any MLB veterans to a relief corps that was among the league’s worst. The only acquisitions were Legumina and waiver claim Bennett Sousa, both of whom could start the year in the minors. Cincinnati should welcome back Lucas Sims from an injury-plagued season. They’d hoped for the same with Tejay Antone but he suffered a forearm strain while rehabbing from Tommy John surgery and will start the year on the injured list.
Cincinnati has breakout reliever Alexis Díaz ticketed for ninth-inning work. One of the few bright spots of the 2022 campaign, the hard-throwing righty reportedly drew some trade interest over the winter which Cincinnati rebuffed. Sims and Buck Farmer should have high-leverage work and could be trade candidates this summer. The middle relief corps is wide open, with the likes of Silvino Bracho, Daniel Norris, Derek Law, Alex Young and Hunter Strickland trying to earn jobs in Spring Training.
Broadly speaking, the 2023 campaign will be about evaluating players for the future and identifying what veterans could be shipped off in the coming months. It’s hard to envision this team finishing higher than fourth in the National League Central. The Reds are near the lowest period of the rebuild, with most of the veteran players shipped away. They’ll continue to incorporate young talent as they look ahead to next offseason, one which could see a relative spike in activity.
Cincinnati doesn’t have a single player under guaranteed contract for 2024, with option buyouts for Votto, Moustakas, Myers and Casali representing the only firm commitments. The slate is almost clean for the front office to chart a new path back to contention. In the interim, the fanbase is in for another losing season.
MLBTR is conducting team-specific chats in conjunction with the Offseason In Review series. Anthony Franco held a chat about the Reds on March 16. Click here to view the transcript.
(poll link for app users)
F as in they couldn’t F it up worse.
Why?
It’s a team in full rebuild with a couple smart investments where prospects are thinner.
If anything, this is what the Rockies should be doing.
With Greene and Lodolo maybe they shouldn’t be in full rebuild. Those are 2 fantastic foundation pieces. They only have them for so long and shouldn’t waste a single year.
Takes more than that to fill a baseball team. You don’t win in free agency. You do it by drafting and developing. The Reds actually have a lot of talent in their system now. We’ll see if they develop it but they’ve certainly cashed in on guys
Makes perfect sense to wait
Not sufficient with the other pieces on this team and the budget constraints.
i did D for Doesnt matter at all since they blew up a contending team last year.
Farm could be sneaky good
Definitly 1 sp short to start the season. Bullpen should hold it’s own if Santillan returns in May and lack of starting pitching doesn’t put too much pressure on the relief corp. As for posiion players, who knows? Too many moving parts. They did dump Moose, As long as they go young and stick to rebuild plan A, Reds will be fine in 2024.
Two SP short and a whole bullpen short outside Diaz when there were affordable options other teams smart enough to scoop up.
After the three young studs, there will be a lot of hope for rainouts.
Affordable options? RU kidding. Relief pitchers signed at a premium this year. Too high for a rebuilding team. Higher risk is to spend into “dead money” next season than underspend currently. Krall has it right.
Only team I will blindly vote F for every time because they didn’t have a ’98 Marlins-esque fire sale after 2014 like I said they should. And they should have.
I too will always vote F for the Reds because I’m a hard headed gorilla!
Harambe,
Chill bro. Come back to the party. We got unlimited beer and table games. You want to throw darts, or maybe a kid who wandered too close?
Oh maybe you hadn’t heard…
Jimmy Carter will be joining us pretty soon. Politics aside, the man was… Err.. is… a great human being. We got an arrival party to set up.
Another day, another thelegendaryharambe post where he talks about his earlier predictions as if anyone on Earth but him cares
As a reds fan, it was afun spring though..
Time for Cincy to start adding pieces. It feels like Green, Lodolo & Ashcroft are about as good a platform as you can get.
That was why the offseason irked me so much. Especially with a weak NL Central which will be more so when Milwaukee has to do this year what the Reds had to. Glad someone else gets it.
Milwaukee ain’t having a fire sale and the Cards will easily win 88-90 games. No reason for the Reds to overpay for volatile bullpen arms when they’ll lose another 100.
They (and me as well) seem to think they’re still a year maybe two away from truly adding pieces to compete. Let this season play out and add top prospects to big league as surroundings dictate, and then add missing piece(s) maybe next offseason if you’re bullish or one more season for prospects to season
Amazing so many think its ok to give a middle finger to their paying customers.
If I recall correctly, the games haven’t been played yet. Unless you all say you have a Delorean and know how it turns out.
Newman a trade chip? Pirates could not find any takers and neither will the Reds. Good Glove but weak bat.
Absolutely a trade chip. A good middle defender has value. Any injury and you would love to have him. Without injury he is still a great weak platoon. Pirates got a great arm for him and I would guess were extremely pleased with the trade.
At this point, it’s not even fun to laugh at the Reds. I understand the small market blues, but they are in hole they mostly dug themselves. If you are in a place financially, that you have to wait whole seasons for a bad contract to come off the books before you can move forward as a franchise, you should have never given that contract out in the first place.
Signing Will Myers was a waste of $7.5 million that could have been spent on a veteran starter or a couple of veteran relievers who could be traded later.
$2 million for Luke Weaver seems like an overpay, but I like the idea. Why not roll the dice on a bounce back starting pitcher?
Kevin Newman is a perfect fit. Any team wanting to develop and evaluate young pitching should prioritize defense. Errors un-nerve veterans. They can play havoc on a young pitcher trying to earn a spot. The Pirates should start thinking in these terms.
I sincerely hope the prospects the Reds have accumulated pan out. I’m tired of the NL Central being the laughing stock of the National League. I think the Brewers are establishing a sustainable approach, the Cubs seem serious about their rebuild, and even the Pirates are showing signs of life. Now the Reds need to hold up their end and help make the division more competitive.
Reds are by far the worst run team. They are doing well in development though so they have a chance. Yeah must spend $ better.
Last run for the Brewers. They have some huge pieces that need to be traded. They can develop but hard for anyone to replace those guys all at once.
Cubs have the largest payroll capacity and should dominate the division. If their develop improves look out. Can’t believe what other teams gave up for their 2 month rentals. Instantly built their farm system.
Pirates have a deep farm. They should be able to produce 80 win teams for a decade once these prospects get up. If they step up their develop we will see some 90 win teams.
Cardinals are steady as ever. Excellent development.
Division is going to improve significantly.
Agreed. I’m pleasantly surprised by the Cubs. When they started selling, they issued what sounded like empty rhetoric about a quick turn around and I was skeptical. I thought they intended to rest on their laurels and milk that World Series win for every cheap dollar it would produce. But they have positioned themselves well and it appears their turnaround could indeed come quickly. I think they’re a little short yet this season, but definitely a sleeping giant going forward.
Cubs spent alot to become a mediocre team. Which they are- and unable to rebuild anytime soon. 75 wins now and for the next couple years.
Don’t let this year’s payroll fool you. The total expenditure looks bad compared to the level of talent. But they have plenty of bad money coming off the books going forward and most of what they have committed after this season carries decent value as of today. They are the only team in the division with the willingness to take their payroll north of $200 million. Fiscally they are in good shape and will have the ability to use free agency to improve over the next couple of off-season’s. If they continue to adhere to their plan of “smart spending”, they’re going to be tough.
They’re basically heading into the season without a complete rotation and a one-man bullpen, a trainwreck.
The cupboard isn’t bare. Most clubs would love to have Greene and Lodolo in their rotation. Diaz is a solid closer. Stephenson could break out. India should bounce back. Myers is likely to hit 20+ bombs in that yard. DeLaCruz looks legit. Newman is strong defensively at SS. Fraley looks above average. Patient Reds fans should have fun watching this young club.
The Reds have one of the very best farm systems in the MLB right now. At this stage of their rebuild, it would make zero sense to make big splashes in free agency. I know fans haven’t been happy with the product for awhile now (I don’t blame them), but they should honestly be pretty excited (relatively speaking) with all the talent they have coming up (or that has already debuted).
Next offseason will likely be FAR busier for them, as they’ll have a much better idea about how all these young players are faring. *Then* they can go get bigger FA signings to fill the gaps.
Solid 50 win team
Nice to read comments about the Reds that (up here at this time) didn’t take a shot at the owner.
GM Nick Krall has done some very nice things the past few years. They have a good young group of players at the ML level and a very good farm system. The fun part about following MLB to me is watching good young teams being built. Reds have a very strong chance of being one. Let’s see how their development goes and if the manager and his coaches get these guys to play solid fundamental baseball.
How about an F the ownership and a B plus for Nick Krall the GM. He’s positioned the team just about as well as he can for the future, given the ownership’s mandate to slash payroll.
The team could have probably have tried to add another innings eater or two to the pitching staff, so as not to overtax their developing arms, but they may still get there with their non-roster invites.
Really hoping all the trades by Reds and Twins turn out as win win. Twins win a playoff series and these prospects turn into regulars for the Reds. Both clubs and their fans will be happy.
More like 70, if all goes well.