The Twins don’t plan on using a dedicated first baseman in 2023, manager Rocco Baldelli told reporters this week (link via Dan Hayes of The Athletic). Minnesota will utilize a rotation of players through the position, giving looks to Alex Kirilloff, Jose Miranda, utilityman Nick Gordon and offseason signees Joey Gallo and Donovan Solano at the position. The Twins cycled through various DH options last season after three years with Nelson Cruz as the mainstay in that spot of the lineup, and it seems as though they’ll now go with a that rotational approach at both DH and first base.
Kirilloff told Hayes that he’s feeling “optimistic” about his twice-surgically repaired wrist, which is improving by the week. A healthy Kirilloff would be the favorite for work at first base. The former No. 15 overall draft pick climbed as high as the ninth-ranked prospect in all of baseball on MLB.com’s top-100 list prior to the 2019 season (and No. 15 at Baseball America), and the Twins thought highly enough of him to give him his MLB debut during the 2020 postseason.
Injuries have derailed both his 2021 and 2022 seasons, however, and after a hot start in 2021, his production began to slide. He currently has just a .251/.298/.398 batting line in 387 Major League plate appearances, but Kirilloff is also a .323/.378/.518 hitter in the minor leagues and comes with substantial upside at the plate. He could be an option in the outfield as well — he’s played all three spots in his career — but the Twins are deep in the outfield and clearly have more playing time for him at first base.
Of the options to split time at first base, the newly signed Solano could be a frequent one. Twins president of baseball ops Derek Falvey told reporters this week Solano will get a “good amount” of time at the position (link via Betsy Helfand of the St. Paul Pioneer Press). Helfand writes that the Twins first reached out to Solano back in early January, though a deal obviously took quite a bit longer to formally come together. Solano adds that other clubs made him offers, but it seems some might’ve come from rebuilding teams, as he cited the Twins’ desire to compete in 2023 as a reason for signing in Minnesota.
Elsewhere in camp, pitching prospect Ronny Henriquez, who recently underwent an MRI after experiencing posterior elbow soreness, per Do-Hyoung Park of MLB.com (Twitter link). The right-hander received an injection and will be reevaluated in a week’s time.
The 22-year-old Henriquez, acquired alongside Isiah Kiner-Falefa in the trade that sent catcher Mitch Garver to the Rangers, made his big league debut in 2022 and tossed 11 2/3 innings of 2.31 ERA ball. He struggled to a 5.66 ERA in 95 1/3 Triple-A frames, thanks largely to an inflated 1.79 HR/9 mark, but his 25.7% strikeout rate and 8% walk rate were more encouraging. He currently ranks 23rd among Twins farmhands at Baseball America. A strong performance in camp and/or in Triple-A to begin the season could put him in the mix for a bullpen spot during the upcoming campaign.
Henriquez has been primarily a starter in the minors, but with a rotation consisting of Sonny Gray, Pablo Lopez, Joe Ryan, Tyler Mahle and Kenta Maeda — plus Bailey Ober looming as a solid sixth option — it’d be an uphill battle to get into the starting mix. It’s a deep collection of starters for the Twins — one that Baldelli will likely treat differently than in 2022, when pitchers like Chris Archer and Dylan Bundy were deployed in short starts by design. Via Phil Miller of the Minneapolis Star Tribune, Baldelli said this week that he expects Twins starters to work deep into games this year.
“I expect more out of our starters this year,” Baldelli said. “…We have several guys that, what they probably take most pride in, is giving you a good, deep effort into a ballgame. Guys that are not satisfied giving you five good innings. They want more than that out of themselves.”
The now-26-year-old Ryan led all Twins pitchers with just 147 innings pitched in 2022. Part of that was due to rampant injuries up and down the roster, but part of it was also an ostensibly conscious effort to shield starters from facing a lineup three times in an outing. Twins starting pitchers averaged just 4.83 innings per outing in 2022. The group ranked as a middle-of-the-pack unit in terms of results, landing 20th in MLB with a 4.11 ERA. Archer, in particular, averaged just 4.11 innings per start. Lopez, acquired from the Marlins last month, averaged 5.63 innings per start and pitched at least six frames in 16 of his 32 starts.
schwender
As an outsider, the Twins appear to be the “bb what is u doin” of roster construction
pohle
i dont know though, the more i look at it the more i think their roster has seriously sneaky upside. their defense and pitching have done nothing but get better, and some non-flaky hitters are returning to the lineup, and even guys like solano and farmer raise their floor as well
Rsox
Gallo is probably the best (or at least second best) defensive Outfielder on the team and his value is mitigated playing 1B. First Base is also a waste of Gordon’s speed and athletic ability. Let Kiriloff and Solano platoon at 1B/DH
mlb1225
Gallo and Gordon are probably behind Miranda, Kiriloff, and Solano for time at first base. Like you said, Gallo is a great defensive OF, and the Twins know that. Gordon is extremely versatile though, so letting him see a game here and there at first base makes sense. Just because they might see some time at the position doesn’t mean they’ll be there semi-regularly.
ZeusMacalester
Rocco has also already been saying that Gordon is going to get time at 1B. I imagine that Gallo spends little time at 1B if that is the case.
mlb1225
I never said that Gordon won’t ever see time at first base, but I doubt he gets more playing time there than Miranda or Kiriloff, or possibly even Solano.
Devil's advocate
Hey can you help me understand why Gallo (excellent glove and arm btw) is “probably the best defensive outfielder on the team” when he’ll be playing next to a platinum glove winner?
elmedius
Because Buxton is always hurt would be my guess.
Devil's advocate
Whether he’s an inquiry risk or not shouldn’t factor into whether his skills are better than any other player
cowdisciple
Gallo is a very good corner defender, but Buxton and Michael Taylor are two of the very best CFs in baseball, so he’s third at best (in what is definitely the best defensive outfield in baseball if Buxton, Taylor, and either Gallo or Kepler are out there)
outinleftfield
Always a good idea to change the player your infielders are throwing to every day. No use in getting a familiar target at 1B.
nitnontu
Hi Outinleftfield. I was thinking the same thing about using so many different players at first base. It can’t be easy for the other players when having so many different targets to throw to.
ZeusMacalester
It’s certainly an interesting idea. I can talk myself both ways. It’s not a super demanding defensive position and I didn’t hear anyone talking about issues for Twins infielders switching a lot last year – Sano, Arraez, Miranda etc. Continuity is real but I don’t know how real.
It would be interesting to see a statistical comparison of fielding % for teams with one 1B and those that use a committee.
outinleftfield
You have never played 1B have you? Other than pitcher and catcher, no player touches the ball more than the 1B. If they are not exceptional at catching the ball, all of your infield defense sucks.
Its not a coincidence that the 3 best teams in baseball at infield defense had a consistent 1B who is among the best in the game on defense.
Yankees – Rizzo
Dodgers – Freeman
Cardinals – Goldschmidt
cowdisciple
Would you rather throw to 5’10” Luis Arraez, who played one game at 1B in rookie ball before last year, or 6’5 Gallo?
cowdisciple
This isn’t a knock on Arraez, because for someone who had never played 1b professionally he did a pretty incredible job. He’s just not really a first baseman.
outinleftfield
Arraez isn’t a Twin anymore. Kirilloff and Miranda are 6’2″.
Moneyballer
Whatever….you could put a scarecrow at first and Correa will still make the play. A “familiar target” does not matter to big league infielders.
outinleftfield
Talk to a major league infielder. If you can find one that tells you that, then I would might believe it. When you can’t find one that says that, you will understand the reality that they want to be throwing to the same guy day in and day out.
HubertHumphrey
I may need to refer to a calendar. I am currently under the impression that it is 2023. I wonder if I am right, or wrong. Regardless, I am curious enough to check.
kripes-brewers
Maybe they’ll use a dedicated first baseman in 2023? Couldn’t resist…
Steve Adams
If I could insert the Andre Dawson “what year is it?” GIF, I would. Ha. Thanks.
em650r
Still do not understand trading Luis Arraez?
Guy hits 300. Average and a slick glove.
nicolletista
He does not have anything like a slick glove at second–he never did–and he has bad knees at 25, so the Twins moved him to first. The Marlins think they can use him as an everyday second baseman, and that’s why they’re the Marlins.
He was a pretty good first baseman, but if he maintains the .795 OPS he had last year (his best since 2019), that’s nothing special for the position (that was 11th in 2022) and calling him the batting champ doesn’t change his having little power.
TLDR: if he can play second (which he couldn’t in 2022 for the Twins), he’s really good. If he has to play first, not so good. That’s why they traded him.
This one belongs to the Reds
Power is not everything. Many solid first basemen over the years never hit a ton of homers.
They’ll miss Arraez.
nicolletista
Who said power was everything?
It’s not nothing though.
bombo
So did you like Joe Mauer at 1st? All we ever heard was can’t hit for power. But his obp and fielding made him a nice option (besides the contract paid like he was still a catcher).
I’m totally stoked on trading Luis bad knees no power and check his stats second half last year. And besides Lopez is very good and so many 2b 1b and 3b types coming soon.
bombo
So did you like Joe Mauer at 1st? All we ever heard was can’t hit for power. But his obp and fielding made him a nice option (besides the contract paid like he was still a catcher).
I’m totally stoked on trading Luis bad knees no power and check his stats second half last year. And besides Lopez is very good and so many 2b 1b and 3b types coming soon.
ZeusMacalester
I love Joe Mauer more than anyone. But without power, he was a league average 1B at best. Even if you raise his BA that much, he’s not elite.
outinleftfield
Arraez has been a plus defender at 2B for the last 3 seasons. He was only bad in his rookie season.
He rated slightly above average in terms of range at 2B last season, and in 2021 and 2020 for that matter, but he was supposedly moved to 1B because of bad knees according to you.
Arraez was a VERY good 1B in limited time at the position. 4 DRS. 11 scoops in 529 innings played.
A 131 wRC+ and 130 OPS+ say he was very good with the bat. That ranks 8th among all 1B. If you take just the time he was at 1B defensively he had an .810 OPS. Again, 8th best for 1B.
toomanyblacksinbaseball
Didn’t someone once say, “Who’s on first?”
Twins will swap out 1B in the fire drill that is two times through the order. They’ve opened the door to production and consistency doesn’t matter.
rocky7
So Baldelli’s admission that he doesn’t intend to have 1 first baseman is pretty much an admission that they pretty much all suck the same…..he’ll have to pick the one that plays that day as the one who sucks he least…..
Finlander
Or it may be to take pressure off Kirilloff so he doesn’t rush his recovery from wrist surgery. If/when he’s finally healthy, he’s the guy at 1st. If he can’t recover, Miranda will move to make room for Lee/Lewis at 3rd.
ZeusMacalester
Real negative read there Rocky. It also can mean “Hey, we’re a deep team and we have a bunch of guys who can play 1B and other positions. So we’re going to rotate some guys through 1B.”
C Yards Jeff
Big league infielders throw to a spot. It happens quickly, very reactionary with a good dose of instinctive intuition. The physical make up of the various 1st basemen “employed” by the Twins (or any team for that matter) is not an issue. Rocco and staff know this, of course.
cowdisciple
Being tall still helps, though.
ZeusMacalester
It does help on high ones. I imagine being shorter helps on the low ones?
C Yards Jeff
Killebrew and Garvey were fun to watch back in the day. IMO, craftsman as 1st basemen. Both under 6’0″
Steve(shs22)
So let me get this straight:
twins have a top 2 defensive LF ‘ er in Gallo
2 of the top 5 defensive CF ‘ ers in Bux and Taylor
A top 3 defensive SS in Correa
And A still above average prob top 10 or so defender in Right Field , Kepler
As long as 3B and 1B are not black holes the Twins are vastly improved defensively alone …