The Tigers made their most important front office hire of the offseason yesterday, tabbing former Giants general manager Scott Harris as president of baseball operations. At a press conference this afternoon, Harris informed reporters (including Tony Paul of the Detroit News and Evan Petzold of the Detroit Free-Press) he’ll look for a new GM who can serve as his top lieutenant in baseball ops.
“These jobs are increasingly large and complicated,” Harris said. “Every single year they get more complex. Having another bright and talented person to partner with in these jobs is critically important. I think it gives you an edge, bringing more talented people to this front office and empowering them to make decisions that ultimately can put out a better team on the field. That’s what we’re trying to do, and I think a GM is going to be a big part of that.”
Harris himself had served in that role for the last three years, working as San Francisco’s GM under president of baseball operations Farhan Zaidi. The Tigers gave him both an elevated title — a common occurrence for front office hirings, since teams often deny employees’ attempts to interview for lateral positions — and the opportunity to lead an organization for the first time. He’ll now search for a person to work in the point role he occupied for Zaidi the past few seasons in the Bay Area.
Last summer, former GM Al Avila promoted both Sam Menzin and Jay Sartori to assistant general manager. That makes both potential candidates for a bump to GM if the club stays internal. Menzin, it’s worth noting, led day-to-day baseball ops on an interim basis for the roughly five weeks between Avila’s dismissal and Harris’ hiring. While Harris didn’t mention either by name, he noted that internal executives would be under consideration if they fit the criteria he desires. Petzold speculates that Diamondbacks special assistant Jason McLeod could also garner a look, no surprise considering McLeod worked alongside Harris in the Cubs front office before the latter made the jump to San Francisco.
There’s no specific timeline for the GM hire, but Detroit’s front office heavy lifting is not finished. Harris will have final decision-making authority regardless of who is eventually tabbed. One of his key early calls will be settling upon a second-in-command.
DonOsbourne
I hear Al Avila is available.
For Love of the Game
I’m the future speaking; Al Avila is still available in my time.
sergefunction
Too soon….you’re rebooting Detroit-fan PTSD.
Highest IQ
Tigers to hire Alex Avila as next GM.
dodgersfan445
Hire me. What’s the worst that can happen that already hasn’t happened?
MotorCityJack
I would hire Sam Menzin.
He knows the players, farm system ect. He would be a valuable asset for Scott Harris to utilize.
Go Tigers!!
alproof
Draft all college hitters.
MPrck
when your talking a half a billion for someone like Judge, then it makes sense to have a President looking out for spending an profit, and others to deal with the product on the field. Then too that gives the President options if the G.M. fails. He’s building the organization for success.
The game is changing quickly now, sometimes every year. You need to have a good organization to handle it. When fans like myself see little Tampa in the playoffs so much, you wonder why we are not better. That is what this guy is looking to build here, and we have a lot easier division to play in.
Samuel
A Giant fan posted the other day that they need to sign the top 4 FA’s this offseason and they’d be fine.
Those 4 guys are expecting 2023 salaries for over $140m.
The MLB luxury tax for 2023 will, be at $233m. Using that figure as a benchmark, that leaves $93m to pay the other 24 players on their ML roster, an average of $3,875m a year. And even that figure is skewed as teams are paying many players in the minors as well that move up and down from their ML roster during the year. That’s also not considering those players getting at least $35m a year through their age 35 seasons – knowing that older players get hurt more, heal slower, and are on the IL for longer periods of time.
It’s very complicated to put together a competitive roster in today’s MLB. For all the impressive sounding buzzwords and phrases top FO people utter in press conferences and interviews, most organizations aren’t very good at it.
RoastGobot
If they signed the top 4 free agents they’d still come in 2nd to LA at best this team is historically good at playing averages
Cosmo2
Signing the top four free agents wouldn’t even have the impact fans think it would.
zeltrox
Our fan base is full of idiots who think throwing a ton of money at the wall solves everything
Samuel
“Harris graduated from the University of California, Los Angeles (UCLA) in 2009 with a bachelor’s degree in economics, and then attended Columbia Business School. He earned his Master of Business Administration from Northwestern University’s Kellogg School of Management in 2015.”
–
It’s fun to make a 2-3 sentence post about what the head of a MLB FO should do, as if he/she acts in a unilateral, dictatorial way in making all decisions based on looking at some public statistics that rotisserie league players check out.
The fact is that the quality MLB FO’s today are incredibly sophisticated. Those that succeed not only build TQM process-oriented structure involving most in the organization, but they also have to understand and develop both fundamental baseball play as well as how to make players better by understanding how to get them motivated buy into strategies.
As Mr. Harris said – it’s very complicated. The trick is to keep in mind that the players are human beings playing a competitive sport. It appears from a distance that the Giants FO may be the smartest guys in the room, but they’ve lost sight of the competitive business they play on the field. Something one has come to expect from Bay Area businesses – i.e. paralysis by analysis.
zeltrox
Zaidi and Harris worked under huge salary constraints from ownership, ever since Greg Johnson took over as controlling owner their payrolls have reduced every year. I hope in Detroit Harris will have access to those resources and not be constricted by ownership
JrodFunk5
All that said, this guy was hired because he’s young and attractive. Happening more and more often in sports.
cars
I hope for Tigers fans and the Organization that Scott Harris stays far away from the incompetent Jason McLeod. For 8 years McLeod was in charge of drafting and development of players for the Cubs. In the 8 years Jason the imbecile only had 4 1st round picks succeed to varying degrees of success. Jason also failed on a subliminal 1st round pick,, he drafted a pitcher who washed out. The only lower round pick who made it to the Cubs is David Bote a utility player who is pretty bad. No other lower round pick ever made the Cubs. McLeod in 8 years never succeed in drafting a pitcher who pitched for the Cubs, or even came close. Until Theo Epstein grew a set of balls and demoted his good friend McLeod.
joefriday1948
The key is to get Colton Welker away from the Giants. Harris signed him- outsmarting the hapless Rockies. In Detroit he will become the Al Kaline of third base.
C Yards Jeff
More important than who Harris hires is that ownership gives him 100% reign over who to hire. Hey Chris Illich (sp?), how’s your ego hanging?
It’s coming out in the press here in Baltimore that when John Angelos took over from his dad Peter in late 2018, he was changing the ownership model to “hands off” as opposed to his dad’s “hands on” MO. Putting it bluntly, it comes across as the dad had an ego issue, the son not so much. First hire by John is Elias. Elias gets free reign to hire who he wants to hire. So far so good.
Mr. IIitch (sp?). Can you stay out of the way?
GarryHarris
I don’t think Al Avila is completely to blame for the mess. Even a casual fan would not have made the blunders Avila made year after year. I believe there was heavy interference from the Tigers’ obtuse owner.
TroyVan
I don’t think it’s a total mess. There’s a lot of talent in some of the rookies, as well as in the system. Really light on position players, but there’s a decent foundation to build on.
I’m not so sure Chris Illich is a bad owner. Only time will tell. But, his one comment about (I believe) Verlander being traded was great.
“I didn’t trade him. The General Manager did”.
Haha
GarryHarris
And paid part of his salary to play elsewhere.
With all the hype around the Justin Verlander trade, he knew and his silence was approval enough.
TroyVan
Well, even I agreed with trading Justin. I hated that it needed to be done, but there was no sense in paying ~$25 million a year to a player who will win you 20 games when your objective is to lose games? Plus, why do that to a player of his stature? Let him move on and win a World Series. Too bad we couldn’t have done that for Miggy.
One thing you have to remember is that Chris isn’t a baseball guy. He hires professionals to run the team. It just so happens that the professional he hired didn’t succeed. But, he did what was needed and got someone else in there to do what Avila didn’t do.
GarryHarris
Then we will disagree. It’s ok. We’re being civil. I believe Chris Illich had to have interfered because no one who’d been around baseball their entire life the way Avila has could make such bad baseball decisions without some influence (bullying).
TroyVan
The only bad part of that decision was the return. Daz isn’t so bad. Hopefully Jake comes back even stronger. But, man. That Franklin Perez was pretty bad for the FCL. Even his last outing was bad. He never improved at all this season. He was the centerpiece of the deal.
But, keep in mind that the process of tanking involves losing a lot of games. I think the goal is a top 5 pick. Seriously. Why pay Justin $25 million to win you 20 games when you are aiming for 100 losses?
Think back as to why the rebuild was neccesary, too. Lots of bad contracts on the books. Lots and lots of holes (especially in the pitching staff). And, no farm system whatsoever. DD traded everyone away!
Can you think of any prospect that came up and had any impact in 2015-2018? I can’t. That’s how bad things were. Had to tear it down.
joefriday1948
Hopefully Harris will have the courage to deal with the archaic seating at Comerica which features more seats further away from the field than any other park.. Built when the Tigers feared fans running onto the field, finish the stadium as it was originally envisioned with new rows of seats filling the outfield and all around the stadium.
Motown is My Town
and fix the Right Center Field issue as the cut-out is ridiculous.
SportsFan0000
Harris is walking into a golden opportunity to have success and look great.
Tigers team won something like 75+ games last year.
The Tigers had the season from hell in’22 with all the injuries to their rotation
and multiple veteran players having their worst years.
Harris will have to clear out some of the deadwood.
Play your young players to see who are the keepers and who is trade bait and/or not in the future plans.
Get rid of: Schoop, Barnhardt, Candelario etc..
Fans would much rather see the young, hungry players giving 120% to establish themselves as big leaguers than veterans just collecting a paycheck.
Fix Javier Baez’s hitting, then deal him.
Some smart, aggressive trades and smart, short term free agent signings will be necessary.
With the Tigers great, young starting rotation getting healthy next year, the team will be very interesting if they can get better hitting and production from their position players.
There is nowhere to go but up for the Detroit Tigers.
With the right moves, the team could win 75+ games in ’23 and be ready to contend in ’24.
The Saber-toothed Superfife
Zac Veen, Rbt Hassell, Sal Frelick, Tx Jung…….can he talk someone into taking those 2 Avila signings? Sell our bp?
Can he overlook.his personal relationship and see Hinch as his best trade chip?
The Nationals are great at developing int. players….we have a bunch due at the same.time…25…..
Brick House Coffee Tables Inc
Hiring Jason McLeod would be a disaster. The Cubs basically promoted him into a “we will give you time to leave” role after their minor leagues didn’t produce squat to augment the 2017 and 2018 major league rosters.
warnbeeb
What will Harris do with Austin Meadows?
The Saber-toothed Superfife
“Buddy, if you’re gonna pounce, you’ve got to have some bounce”