The Mets are calling top infield prospect Brett Baty up to the Major League roster, reports ESPN’s Jeff Passan (via Twitter). The 2019 No. 12 overall draft pick will need to have his contract formally selected to the 40-man roster. Mike Puma of the New York Post further reports that the move to select Baty won’t officially take place until tomorrow (Twitter link).
New York also appears set to recall righty Stephen Nogosek from Triple-A, as MLB.com’s Anthony DiComo tweets that there’s a locker in the clubhouse for him. Nogosek will likely take the roster spot of Carlos Carrasco, who’s IL-bound due to an oblique strain.
Baty, 22, has split the season between Double-A and Triple-A, posting monster numbers at each stop (albeit through just six games in Triple-A thus far). Ranked as the game’s No. 26 prospect at FanGraphs, No. 28 at Baseball America and No. 38 at The Athletic, the lefty-swinging Baty has turned in an outstanding .315/.410/.533 batting line with 19 home runs and 22 doubles in a combined 420 plate appearances. He’s walked at a hearty 11.7% clip and fanned in 24.8% of his plate appearances so far.
Rumors of a potential Baty promotion were swirling over the weekend, although Mets skipper Buck Showalter briefly put an end to those yesterday, when he specifically indicated that a Baty promotion wasn’t in the cards. Whether that statement only applied to Monday or whether the organization simply had a change of heart matters little at this point. Baty will join the Mets in Atlanta and figures to see regular playing time with Luis Guillorme out up to six weeks and veteran Eduardo Escobar currently banged up. (Teams don’t call up prospects of Baty’s caliber just to sit them on the bench or deploy them in minimal roles.)
Scouting reports on Baty suggest that he’s both begun to elevate the ball more often in 2022 — resulting in an uptick in power output — and improved defensively at the hot corner. The Mets have also tried him out in left field on occasion, but with Guillorme shelved and Escobar not at 100%, Baty seems likely to be installed at his traditional position, third base, for the time being. It’ll be a telling trial run, as Baty has all the tools necessary to be the long-term option at the hot corner in Queens — and this could well be the onset of that anointment.
The Mets are surely more focused on their production over the season’s final few weeks than on Baty’s service time, but it’s still worth quickly touching on his outlook in that regard. Baty can’t get to a full year of service in 2022, nor will he be able to accrue enough time to push the boundaries of Super Two eligibility. Even he’s up for the rest of the season, he’ll still be on track to reach arbitration eligibility following the 2025 campaign and will remain under team control all the way through 2028. Future optional assignments could further push back those critical milestones, of course.
If Baty indeed cements himself as a viable regular in the coming weeks, Escobar’s role on the club will become increasingly murky. Signed to a two-year, $20MM contract in the offseason, the 33-year-old veteran has floundered en route to a .216/.269/.384 batting line through 409 plate appearances. With Baty at third base and Jeff McNeil at second, Escobar’s role would seemingly be relegated to that of a pricey bench piece.
Robrock30
LOL Mets,
The FO had to be prodded by the Fans to make the logical move for 3B. Trotting out a Long Island Duck or a hobbled Eduardo Escobar with Luis Guillorme down in a pennant race series vs. the Braves was unacceptable. Next they need a starting catcher. Calling Alvarez
astoriacub
tell us you know nothing about the Mets and baseball without telling us you know nothing about the Mets or baseball….
Robrock30
NYM Lineup
B Nimmo (L) CF
S Marte (R) RF
F Lindor (S) SS
P Alonso (R) 1B
D Vogelbach (L) DH
J McNeil (L) 2B
T Naquin (L) LF
D Marrero (R) 3B ( Long Island Ducks)
M Perez (L) C ( Waiver pickup)
JeffreyChungus
Copying the Mets’ lineup for tonight from MLB’s website just proves his point… Not sure they’d be better off with a 20-yr old showing major contact issues in AAA is the answer either
coachdave2
I read he’s not available till tomorrow
AHH-Rox
Forget that, tell me how I can make big money working from home.
Poster formerly known as . . .
I don’t follow the Mets very closely, but if you’re talking about Baty when you mention “major contact issues,” I’m curious as to why you think that. Looking at his stats, his K% is high but not terrible, and his walk rate is healthy, as is his OBP.
JackStrawb
@Fink Ployed Makes some sense. A 25% K rate in the upper minors is a cause for concern, remediated by the terrific walk rate and .390 OBP on a BA of .289 throughout the minors.
That 25% rate on average projects to over 30% in the majors, which starts to put you in territory where you’re simply not putting the bat on the ball enough to create runs. —Particularly for someone like Baty, who’s on track to make 30+ errors in a full season at 3B and has to get by with his bat, he’ll be prone to nasty slumps in the event of even a small downturn in BABIP, which is exactly what’s happening to him now.
I’d be interested to see how often minor leaguers with Baty’s profile succeed in the majors: bat-first guys with high OBPs who K 25% of the time. I’ll guess the answer is “they don’t succeed very often.”
In Baty’s case he’s probably been told for a decade what a sweet swing he has, as if that’s enough. It probably won’t be.
Robrock30
Tail wag Dog
JeffreyChungus
I’m living in your walls, Robert. I am viewing you right now
TradeAcuna
I bet you use, “XYZ lives rent-free in your head” at least 100x per day
JeffreyChungus
David Fletcher lives rent-free in your head
TradeAcuna
Haha, my comment wasn’t directed to you. It was towards astoria guy.
Curly Was The Smart Stooge
Mets, bring these young guys up, the Braves have & it’s improved their team. Young players like Harris, Grissom & Strider make the Braves formidable. Mets, take the chance & make this a great 2022 race!
JackStrawb
@Curly Was The Smart Stooge
The problem with that is that the Mets, led by Alderson for most of a decade, are nowhere near the Braves when it comes to developing polished minor leaguers ready at 20, 21, 22 to jump from even AA to a starting gig in the majors.
The Mets have never been good at this, and won’t be until they get a real GM and PBO to completely revamp their system.
To that point, Baty’s not a 3Bman. He hasn’t improved in the minors and in a full season he’ll make 30-plus errors there without otherwise distinguishing himself. He might be able to play LF, but for now the Mets are putting him in a position to fail. The Braves don’t do that.
coachdave2
I think you’re right….
peterd
75-41
DJM7315
Agree completely, He needs to be starting at 3rd base in tomorrow nights game, no excuses. And when i saw Perez was our catcher tonight i threw up in my mouth, bad enough the production we are getting from McCann and NIdo, now we take a step down from that. I agree that if McCann or Nido are hurt it is time to promote Alvarez and let him start.
JackStrawb
Thank Eppler for that. Deadline comes, you have at least three major injury / fatigue risks in the rotation and… trade one of your better relievers away. You have real problems at catcher and… don’t get a catcher.
They dealt actual talent for platoon DHs. They dealt two very promising minor leaguers off to great starts for Naquin, a 5th OFer in steep decline when Naquin’s the kind of player teams that aren’t sleepwalking get for nothing more than salary relief. It’s unbelievable.
They could have dealt less than the talent they traded away, in a package for Willson Contreras, and the Cubs would have jumped at it.
kenphelpsformvp
i agree. escobar wasn’t even a poor mans villar. they should have stopped playing him sooner than they did. dom smith was also a 4th OF that sucked.. and the bearded one was starting to turn into a pumpkin as well. baty is the way to go right now.
and lol what buck said about baty being called up. yesterday or the day before.
dp7
Yeah!!
TradeAcuna
The Mets were definitely inspired by Strider’s moustache and called up Nogosek.
bryan c
Alright, this one is funny. Well played
rct
Well, when you’re right, you’re right. lol
chemfinancing
New York going batty for baty #WAAAAASSSSHHHH
LFGMets (Metsin7)
Finally, only took them getting blown out to realize that Escobar is too injured to hit from the right side + hes been underperforming all year. Calling up Marrero yesterday was a joke
Bill M
Yet Marrero is still on the team. And I believe he’s in the lineup tonight
DJM7315
So is perez at catcher, ugh
Chris G.
Because Baty is not officially up until tomorrow, and the corresponding move will most likely be Escobar to the IL. Marrero will stay up because there’s no backup SS or 2B and Baty is iffy at 3B.
Bill M
Exactly. Which is why calling up Marrero was NOT a joke
User 401527550
About time they brought in some youth. This should make the lineup even more dangerous.
Bright Side
And yet the Yankees refuse to call up Florial, Cabrera, Peraza while continuing to keep Hicks, Torres, and Kiner on the roster.
itsmeheyhi
Gleyber is having a good season overall. Using a 25 at bat sample size… stop yourself.
Bright Side
Gleyber is a microcosm of the Yankees. People remember his 2019 38 HR season. That came with 3 caveats: 1.000 OPS against the lowly Orioles and a .750 OPS against the rest. 2019 was a year of juiced baseballs. His OBP was a mediocre .337. I never mentioned a 25 game sample. Don’t assume. The truth is that he hasn’t hit well for 3 seasons.
itsmeheyhi
OPS+ of 107 at 2B. Which he plays just fine.
He is in a slump right now, yet still has a high avg exit velo and barrel rate. 16HR, 21 doubles and .187 ISO… ok no power lol. Yeah, his OBP is lacking but I didnt say he was perfect.
And he is having a good season by WAR as well.
Stop yourself.
Bright Side
Hey mastermind, I’m not through with you yet. Let’s examine Gleyber’s 2022 season. Currently, his OBP is .299, OPS with RISP is .541, and defensively, his OAA in at the 30th percentile. In summary, he lacks power, has to hit his way on base, is a failure at SS, sucks at 2B, 8sca bad baserunner, and strands more men on base than Gilligan. Perhaps, you have a different definition of “good”.
JackStrawb
Or perhaps you simply don’t understand the game. Torres is headed for a 3.5-win season. If every player on the roster played at his level the Yankees would be about where they are. If he didn’t have the weaknesses you note, he’d be a superstar.
What did you think your point was?
pinstripes17
Torres hasn’t been good since 2019, his numbers suck again this year.
Bright Side
Torres is lucky that Hicks is still around.
Astros2017&22Champs
Everybody wants their team to call up said top prospect and then when they fail they complain anyway. Brett baty has barely any at bats above double a. Theres just as good a chance he fails in his first cup of coffee as he is successful. You cant have a star at every position.
Bright Side
Sure you can. If I’m building a team, I’m not thinking “I want terrible player at that position”. Along those lines, I would take the approach of trying to win a WS every year.
Astros2017&22Champs
Why would anybody say that? It’s unrealistic for you to have a great player at every position. What smart teams do is have excellent depth and league average players to complement their stars. Average players are very valuable.
iverbure
Bright side doesn’t understand baseball
Prospectnvstr
Or said prospects could flourish (see Braves).
Jacksson13
Proof positive that the Mets’ Organization is BATY !!
miltpappas
I have a feeling, based on absolutely nothing, that this kid is going to do very well. Feel free to copy and paste this even if his career batting average is .197 by 2024. I can handle it.
Bk11235 2
No way in hell will his batting average be 197 in 2024. This kid along with alvarez will be 2 cheap building block while we are paying big contracts to all others
C Yards Jeff
@miltpappas & Bk11235 2: I’ve seen him play. Gifted ball player and one cool customer. My gut says he’ll be impactful from the get go. Following him all year, couldn’t understand how the prospect publications had him ranked outside of the top 10 to 15.
TheREALMetsFan22
He’ll be better than the two kids Atlanta brought up.
Holy Cow!
I don’t know about deGrom. His ERA is up 50% from last year.
Smacky
If that’s the case, then the Mets front office is wildly incompetent and the dude should’ve been up awhile ago.
bluetooth2
Buck had something to do with it he was opposed to bringing him up his input matters
SoCalBrave
Better than Grissom? maybe, there’s a good chance, no doubt.
Better than Harris? That’s gonna be a bit more difficult. Money Mike is a special player, hope Baty is just as good for the Mets.
Fred McGriff HR
@RealMetsFan22 & other usernames
Will he? Your opinion on whether he’ll be better than Harris & Grissom is just your hatred of Atlanta. Your opinion counts for zero, the statistics will be the facts.
DarkSide830
Mets fans going absolutely Baty with this move.
bravesfan
Looks like the Mets are trying to do what the Braves are doing
bluetooth2
I think they’re doing what’s necessary
bluetooth2
Yes I agree
saluelthpops
I don’t know. My guess is they’d prefer to stay in 1st place.
DarkSide830
Play decent young players? Novel!
bryan c
What? Win? Yep, the Mets are looking to try to win
rct
I think they looked across the diamond yesterday and saw Grissom and thought, ‘why don’t we do that?’
User 401527550
I think most of the league is trying to improve their roster and win.
bryan c
Huge believer in this kids bat. Loved it from day one. I believe he has the ability to become a big part of the offense quickly. He has to play nearly every day. His defense should be comparable to Escobar and he can slot into left field as well. OBP well over .400 means he has patience. This is an exciting time. I don’t know if it was needed per se but May as well get him up here and see if the bat is as ready as most think. If so, big boost to the bottom of the order immediately and potentially another table setter with power in the years ahead. Very similar offensive skill set to David Wright.
Big whiffa
Yeah I’m not a Mets fan, but this guy has legit prospect wrote all over him. Not a lot of pressure in this line up. I’m expecting a big finish to the season from baty
C Yards Jeff
@bryan c; I’ve watched him play. Yes, he does have patience. Wonderful plate discipline. And he keeps it simple. IE. he let’s the ball get deep. And then one of 2 things happens; if he likes what he sees he turns on it or if he doesn’t like it, he let’s the catcher catch it. IMHO, very Jon Olerud (sp?) like.
DJM7315
Very well said and true to point. Welcome to the Bigs Baty, now smash the Braves!
Basehitupthemiddle
If you go based on his draft day announcer comparisons. His ceiling is a little lighter hitting babe Ruth and his floor is a 3rd base version of Bryce Harper.
Smacky
LOLMets trying to copy how Atlanta goes about things. Lolz for days!!!
VonPurpleHayes
Copying the WS champions and long-time owners of the NLE is probably smart.
bryan c
So the Braves called two kids from AA this year that barely even played at the AA level while the Mets promoted a kid destroying AA only to watch him hit .364 in AAA and called him up only when their depth was depleted with two MLB regulars getting injured within days of each other. Not copying at all. Baty is legit. It appears that Grissom and Harris are as well. The Braves had ZERO major league depth and called up their last two prospects. It’s working so far. The Mets still have plenty of prospects in the cupboard.
To be clear, it was the Braves that SIGNED Cano as a chance to have some depth. The Mets paid him to go away
rct
Braves call up a kid from AA: Brilliant! They’re showing they want to win!
Mets call up a kid from (essentially) AA: OMG LOLMETS HAHAHAHA
Do you see how ridiculous it is to be a hater of any team?
SoCalBrave
yeah, I don’t get where that comment is going… are they making fun of both the Braves and Mets?
VonPurpleHayes
Get the kid some major league ABs. Even if he doesn’t succeed this go around, just his presence should add some excitement to an already exciting team. Getting this kid surrounded by all these older vets will certainly help.
Robrock30
Von Purple Hayes,
My $.02 is the Mets FO is embarrassed to admit their huge FA mistakes with signing McCann ( a career backup Catcher ) to a 4 year $ 40 MM Contract and Eduardo Escobar 3B instead of working hard to sign Realmuto and trade for 3B Arenado taking Lindor off the Guardians hands when they didn’t need a SS as they had Gimenez controlled with Rosario.
Benching Escobar for Baty might not be popular in the Mets country club. LOL
rct
Your $0.02 is wrong. A different GM signed McCann, so why would they be embarrassed to admit it was a mistake?
And the plain fact is that Alvarez is not quite ready yet. His defense needs a lot of work and he started slow in AAA at the plate.
Cosmo2
I’m pretty sure they know that, in hindsight, McCann was a mistake. Do you expect them to announce that? Where do you get these ideas?
User 401527550
Trouts first stint in the majors didn’t go that well and it set him up for the next year.
saluelthpops
“Teams don’t call up prospects of Baty’s caliber just to sit them on the bench or deploy them in minimal roles.”
I’m guessing Gabriel Moreno would disagree. Would be interesting to see what the data says about this statement.
DarkSide830
Very few players can play C, and TOR needed a C at that time. It’s not like they brought him up for a month and didn’t use him.
saluelthpops
I don’t disagree. But the quote said teams “don’t do that.” I just wonder how accurate that statement is. Not trying to knit-pick, just genuinely curious (but not enough to do the research myself)!
Bart Harley Jarvis
Exciting times in Queens! This guy could be the next Wayne Garrett!
bluetooth2
Garrett had warning track power
Bart Harley Jarvis
All kidding aside and last time I checked, Wayne Garrett has more WS rings than you, me, and Brett Baty combined.
Canosucks
I like it not matter what happens; give the kid some AB’s and exposure to a pennant race; why not?
Sid Bream Speed Demon
Pretty exciting time to be a Mets fan I would imagine. Hope this kid plays up to his potential.
VonPurpleHayes
Perfect name for a hitter.
Bill M
Too bad the Mets don’t have a 3B prospect named Fieldy.
VonPurpleHayes
Yeah. Appropriately, Baty’s glove is not great.
Poster formerly known as . . .
His initials aren’t bad for a hitter either.
SoCalBrave
Traditionally, the Mets worst enemy is the Mutz. But this type of move is not one they would have done in the past.
I still expect the Mets to implode at some point before the season ends, but they are making strides into becoming a functional MLB team.
C Yards Jeff
Unapologetic Buck fan here. Grateful to have watched him do his thing here in Baltimore. Next to Earl, my favorite Os manager. Following the Mets this year because of him. Come on boys, win that WS for Buck!
So in June, Binghamton is at Bowie for an extended series. Stoked! Got an eye full of Mets AA ball. Wanted to see Alveraz up close and personal. OMG! Came as advertised. IE Bat speed and great attitude. Well done scouting department. That said; it was Baty who stood out. One cool cat, both at the plate and in the field. Not surprised to see him up before Alvarez. All said; scouting departments miss some times. IMHO, Ronnie M ain’t got it. He’s still a Met because my gut says GMs around the league see this too. Best wishes to him, Alveraz and Baty with their careers. Oh, Butto looked like the real deal in June as well. Another Mets scouting department coup.
Fred McGriff HR
Master Baty apparently is a good pull hitter, so more than likely they will be shifting on him.
Backup Catcher to the Backup Catcher
Baty will be the second coming of David Wright. Enjoy, Met fans. Yooze guys are gonna luv him!
Back when the season started, I posted that the only thing that can stop the Mets from winning the NL East would be injuries. Now, they are coming at a most opportune time.
Guillorme and Escobar are down. Carrasco on the IL and Walker may join him. Be thankful you still have Scherzer, deGrom and Bassitt as your 1, 2 and 3 SP. Although Peterson can dial up a good one, too.
The boss isn’t getting much for his FA spending. Canha has been okay, but now looks to be on the short side of a platoon with Naquin. Escobar had one little hot streak and then fizzled. Marte has been good. I’ll give him a grade of B or B+. But what happened to the stolen bases?
Braves are only 3 1/2 behind, but no worries. Would be nice to get a first round bye in the playoffs, but as long as the aforementioned Big 3 SP remain healthy, I would be hard pressed to bet against the Mets in any playoff series.
Dallas Mets
Eppler, didn’t do enough at the trading deal line especially knowing how fragile Carrasco and Walker are prone to injuries? Also, not getting a Lefty for the bullpen, shows just how horrible a GM he is..The only trades he made that were decent was acquiring Volgy and Nyquin as they have filled in nicely. He gave way to much for a 36 old strike out king in Ruff ?? If you want to go for it all, you do whatever is possible, to win a ring, even if you have to sacrifice some prospects.. Most of the time, prospects don’t pan out, like everyone thinks..
Canosucks
Eppler also failed when he set up the bench with 1/2 DH players who can’t play the field and that’s why they had a Long Island Duck playing third base and a catcher from no where in a BIG divisional game; Eppler is horrible; being a Met fan in Angel Honk land I caught both acts.
JackStrawb
@Dallas Mets Shocking deadline from Eppler. Imagine dealing away four promising or useful players for Ruf when that would have easily brought in Contreras from the Cubs. The Giants must have been toasting in the exec suite.
And dealing away Holderman? Giving away two very interesting, very young prospects off to great starts for Tyler F. Naquin?
It’s easy to see why Eppler failed so badly w the Angels. This is excruciating, but typical of the worst GMs who haven’t quite been weeded out of the game yet. They wildly overpay to fill the most trivial needs so that it looks like they’re doing their jobs. They’re too timid to negotiate lest a deal fall through and they look bad, so they jump.
It’s not that he dealt away the next Juan Soto—it’s that he dealt away something like 10 useful or promising players to only very, very marginally upgrade the team, without filling any of the major holes or anticipating the major problems that will / have hit the rotation.
JackStrawb
If you think stolen bases are relevant, especially to a player in his mid-30s with hamstring issues, please rethink.