Veteran catcher Jonathan Lucroy is set to officially announce his retirement Saturday as part of a ceremony at American Family Field, reports Todd Rosiak of the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel. A third-round pick by the Brewers out of Louisiana-Lafayette in 2007, the backstop, who spent the first half of his twelve-year career in Milwaukee, will be inducted into the club’s Wall of Honor alongside former teammate Ryan Braun.
Arguably the most accomplished catcher of the 2010s not named Buster Posey or Yadier Molina, Lucroy’s best years — including a fourth-place MVP finish (and 8.2 fWAR) in 2014 — came with the Brewers, but he remained a serviceable option behind the plate for several years to come following a deadline trade to the Rangers in 2016. His production did dip considerably thereafter, however, and he became something of a journeyman in his 30s, playing for the Rockies, A’s, Angels, Cubs, Red Sox, Nationals, and Braves. He sported a robust .284/.343/.442 batting line across his first seven seasons — all but the last two months of 2016 in Milwaukee — but a comparatively paltry .248/.315/.350 thereafter. His once-elite defensive acumen also declined precipitously in the latter half of his career; after accruing 95 defensive runs saved between 2010 and 2016, he cost his teams 42 runs thereafter per the Fielding Bible metric.
For his career, Lucroy logged a more-than-respectable .274/.335/.416 triple-slash, a particularly strong output given the comparatively anemic production at his position across the majors. While he’s unlikely to receive any serious Hall of Fame consideration, the long-time Brewer can hang his hat on an excellent career that included two All-Star selections (in 2014 and 2016), 37 career fWAR, and four playoff appearances, including a 2011 NLCS run with the Brewers.
Yanks2
Respectable career
Holy Cow!
Honor for Lucroy. Braun doesn’t deserve it.
Yanks2
Yeah, Braun’s stats mean nothing essentially but he still had the audacity to accept the MVP award even though he took steroids. Tried to then shift the blame away from himself. What a guy!
Milwaukee-2208
@yanks how about A-rod? True saint right there huh?
Yanks2
Yep. I never liked A Rod, he’s another fraud as well. Same as Robbie Cano however I always liked Cano until I found out he got busted for PEDs…twice.
skip 2
Hummmm who was the guy that just got into the Hall of Fame that tested positive? All a joke!
skip 2
Hummm who was the guy that just got into the Hall of Fame and tested positive? All a joke!
Yanks2
I’ve heard conflicting stories on whether or not Ortiz actually took PEDs. Is there actually proof?
phillies012tg
Steroids don’t make you a good ball player
ArchRivals
No, they make good players great. And in the case of guys like Bonds and Clemens, great players into all-timers.
They can’t help you hit a baseball but they sure can help you recover faster, strengthen easier, stay healthier, push you past your previous limits, or fend off father time for a little longer.
RoastGobot
Dude cost Aaron Rodgers a year of his salary
RonDarlingShouldntBeInTheHallOfFame
@Yanks2 Think he was one of those who tested positive in ‘03 when they did the sample tests before they started cracking down.
jimbobsjorts
Really? Damn, we should do a fundraiser for the poor guy.
Fever Pitch Guy
I agree, and I’d like to thank Lucroy for his contributions in a Red Sox uniform. He had a memorable tenure in Boston.
Dorothy_Mantooth
The Ortiz PED issue is a joke. He was part of the volunteer group who all submitted samples when they were thinking about adding the PED penalties to the CBA. He and 150 others showed up on a list of failing that volunteer sample process. They never told any of them what they tested positive for; it could have easily been an over the counter GNC supplement. Ortiz pushed back hard but they would never tell him what he tested positive for. The biggest thing to remember is that once PED penalties were in place, Papi never failed one test even though he was tested 100’s of times. I don’t consider him a cheat or a PED user as he had a clean career from that point on (when he did most of his damage). If he took PEDs, he wouldn’t have missed all the time he did with nagging injuries and his body would have looked a lot different too.
myaccount2
Congrats on a great career. One of my favorite catchers to watch during his years.
Wilmer the Thrillmer
To go out with a World Series ring in 2021 is a pretty good plan.
Outstanding catchers don’t grow on trees. For 5 seasons he was outstanding.
CKinSTL
Wait. Did he actually get a ring?…
censorshipsuxblowme
almost certainly, yes.
at this point, if you’re on the roster for even a few days, they issue you a ring.
back in the day, not always the case (mets didn’t issue one for 4 players on the 86 team, for example, though terry leach ended up getting his because randy myers not only went to bat for him, but called the mets bluff when they said they’d do it, but only if randy, who was making rookie minimum at the time, would pay for half of it, as in $5000.).
neo
I hope the Mets as an organization righted that wrong and repaid Myers at some point. If not they should send him the money with 20% annual interest on the debt. I get they were stingy, but someone should show both guys some respect after that, however long after that.
Rsox
In 2004 after the Red Sox won the World Series they had a player vote to determine if Nomar Garciaparra should get a ring, the players voted “yes” so even though Nomar quit the team which subsequently led to his being traded the player looked beyond that to what he did for the organization Over the course of his time there.
MannyPineappleExpress9
Waited til the deadline passed just in case the Brewers wanted a 4th catcher, not realizing they were only adding bullpen arms.
Next stop: minor league hitting instructor for a franchise that actually tries teaching something besides launch angle and exit velocity.
Translation: NOT Milwaukee.
myaccount2
That’s the vast majority of clubs these days.
realbaseball
Sadly all clubs do that. Hitting is no longer taught.
realbaseball
6 years he was great. Every year after he was terrible. Have no idea what happened that he went from all-star to journeyman backup over night.
Cosmo2
He aged into his early thirties and quickly declined. Incredibly common. Not sure why fans are always surprised and baffled by this.
mathblaster
Cleveland legend
mlbgeek
I was going to bring that up! Forever hated in CLE. Hammy was talking about that last night how Ray Fosse said the best thing that ever happened to CLE was him rejecting the trade.
Tacoshells
Trying to steal the show from the trade deadline. It almost worked too if it wasn’t for the soto trade
juzsaydat
Not wildly good numbers but I guess for a catcher ok???
iverbure
What? If you don’t think that’s great for a catcher you must not look at average slash lines of catchers as a whole the past say 10 seasons.
kscheer
Congratulations. Still sad he was a bust in Texas.
landt143
Red Sox sign Lucroy for $100,000 in 2020 for 1 ab worst sogning signing ever
landt143
Red Sox sign Lucroy for 100,000 in 2020 for 1 ab worst signing ever
MLB-1971
Landt143 – Not even close…Jed Lowrie with the Mets – 2 years – $20,000,000 – 7 at bats – 0 hits – 1 walk.
Drew Waters Bat
I thought he did that before?
thunderroad19
Congrats to Lucroy on a great career.
The list of “most accomplished catchers of the 2010s” would have to include Salvador Perez.
partyatnapolis
remember when he turned down the indians and they went to the WS.
bluejays92
Nice career for sure. Funny coincidence that he’s announcing his retirement just weeks after the player (Steven Souza Jr.) drafted one spot ahead of him too.
Cody1981
Salvador Perez ws mvp 5 gold gloves like 8 all star games pretty sure he’s up there
bluejays92
Throw in Russell Martin and Brian McCann while you’re at it.
thunderroad19
Yeah…certainly Buster and Yadi are the guys but Salvy would be 3rd on that list.
avidjogger
Statistically, Perez isn’t even close lmao.
He had exactly 10.0 fWAR from 2011-2019, which puts him at 26th among catchers in the decade (2010-2019). David Ross put up more than that in 2500 less PA from 2010-2016 lol.
Cody1981
Nobody cares about some slanted saber metric ..how many catchers were World Series mvps and had the accomplishments salvy had during the decade ..none
cadagan
Slanted stat ? What does that even mean? / = slanted? Or biased?
RoastGobot
Don’t retire so fast giants always adding catchers
Camden453
Did he get his pension or not? He was a guy that needed 10 more at bats or something like that
YankeesBleacherCreature
I’m sure the Brewers would’ve found a way if he was not fully vested.
UWPSUPERFAN77
Thank You JL from a true blue Brewer Fan! Also, coregulations for finishing your degree in Education!
Kruk's Beer League
I remember he turned down a 3 year/$21 million deal from the Rockies in 2018 and then his career essentially fell off a cliff after that. Cost himself about $11 million with that blunder.
Holy Cow!
He cost himself more than that when he took the extension with the Brewers. Still made at least $25 million though.
madmanTX
Bad trade for the Rangers
gw9999
He seemed to fall apart just as the extension negotiations with him did. I would say they dodged a bullet there but they just chose different bullets there after.
angt222
Congrats on a successful career, enjoy retirement.
allenteller
This is about as 2022 as it gets. Are the Brewers hurting this bad for attendance?
UWPSUPERFAN77
Attendance not the best. However, it is Alumni weekend! All kinds of things happen. The biggest is the Robin Yount Replica give away jersey on Sunday. I have one from the last time 15 years ago!
ArianaGrandSlam
He did look like an owl though.
badguyswon86
Next to announce retirement?
My guess is Sergio Romo. And Jed Lowrie is still playing, but will retire soon or after the season.
brownisback
How much money did he make?
bigstein09
Was always curious to me how he was so consistently good for a few years and then every facet of his game just fell apart. Still a pretty darn good career to hang your hat on though.