The Rockies have removed the “interim” tag from Bill Schmidt, as Schmidt will officially take over the team’s front office as the new general manager. Schmidt has been serving as the interim GM since May 3, a week after former general manager Jeff Bridich resigned.
The club also announced promotions of two other in-house executives. Danny Montgomery goes from special assistant to the GM to being a newly-minted vice president and assistant GM of scouting, while assistant GM Zack Rosenthal had the vice president title added to his current duties.
“After five months as our interim general manager, it became increasingly clear that Bill was the right person to lead this franchise forward,” Rockies president/COO Greg Feasel said in the press release. “We already knew Bill as a trusted and respected baseball professional within the game. He came into a challenging situation and quickly impacted the play on and off the field. Bill’s promotion also gives the organization an opportunity to promote two experienced individuals, Danny and Zack, to leadership roles that will be key in getting us to the next level.”
At the time of Bridich’s departure, the Rockies announced that a wider search for a new GM/president of baseball operations would take place after the season, though the club has now decided to stick with a familiar face. Schmidt has been working in Colorado since October 1999 in various scouting capacities, and has been running the team’s drafts since 2000. Schmidt was promoted to VP of scouting in 2007, a title he held until becoming interim GM. Before joining the Rox, Schmidt also worked as a scout and minor league coach with the Reds and Yankees, a minor league coach with the Brewers, and as a national crosschecker for the Indians.
Schmidt’s hiring is something of an old-school move, as teams have generally trended towards younger and more analytically-inclined front office executives in recent years, rather than older, more established baseball lifers. Schmidt is known to be widely respected around the sport, and his hiring will surely be applauded by peers pleased to see him finally getting a shot to run a big league organization.
It is fair to wonder if Rockies fans are as enthusiastic, however. Bridich was also a longtime front office employee before he was hired as GM in 2014, and the hiring of Schmidt (and even the promotions of Montgomery and Rosenthal) reflect more continuity within an organization that many fans and pundits believe is in need of a shakeup. Owner Dick Monfort is known to be very loyal to his employees — perhaps to a fault, as the team’s insularity has been seen as a chief reason for the Rockies have had only five winning seasons since the Monfort brothers become majority owners in 2005.
Thanks to a brutal 19-34 start, the Rockies will finish under the .500 mark yet again this season, despite a respectable 55-51 mark since May 30. That performance over the last four months quite possibly inspired the team’s decision to mostly stand pat at the trade deadline, moving only Mychal Givens despite the number of impending free agents (most notably Trevor Story and Jon Gray) on the roster. The Rockies have designs on re-signing Gray, while Story is as good as gone but the team didn’t find any acceptable trade offers, so the decision was made to keep Story and at least recoup a draft pick via the qualifying offer.
Schmidt now faces a tall order in getting the Rockies on track, considering the potential free agent losses, a farm system seen as being lacking in impact talent, and the ever-difficult NL West. It will be interesting to see how Schmidt’s approach differs from Bridich, who relied mostly on free agency to make his moves and didn’t swing many major trades (apart from moving longtime stars Nolan Arenado and Troy Tulowitzki) in his tenure as GM.
outinleftfield
Did anyone expect anything other than this outcome from the Rockies? Their owner is loyal to his FO staff to a fault and that is why they continue to be mediocre to bad.
Noel1982
This team does nothing but promote from within like it’s a Fortune 500 company or something lol
86mets
Ha! They’re not even among the top 500 teams in MLB! Which is saying something in a 30 team league.
atmospherechanger
No thanks. I don’t need anything. I’m just here waiting for the mockers to show up. I won’t be waiting long.
Monkey’s Uncle
This team can’t get out of its own way. They actually played pretty well after a rotten start to the year. You might think that candidates from other teams might have been at least interested in the position. But everyone knew that they weren’t even going to bother to find out.
Arnold Ziffel
The definition of insanity: Doing the same thing over and over and expecting a different result.
This organization needs someo e with a new perspective so bad, yet keep doing the sos.
jdgoat
Keeping the guy who didn’t trade the rentals on his bad team. Genius Rockies. I hope I’m wrong but they look like they are in a lot of trouble moving forward.
Monkey’s Uncle
While you’re correct, I would bet that Schmidt was at least influenced, if not outright directed, to not trade those rentals. Does that make sense to anyone except the Monforts? Of course not.
86mets
Not trading Gray was a huge blunder. Could’ve gotten a nice return for him then tried te re-sign him this winter. Would’ve helped the farm system and still brought him back. Now I guess they’ll just give him a boat load of money to re-sign him.
Geebs
That’s kinda a fan pipe dream though, I mean really how often can you think of that happening? Since 2000 I can think of maybe 5 times a player has resigned with the team that traded him, never top of the market players either.
hiflew
Aroldis Chapman. He was definitely top of the market for closers
Deleted_User
@abgb123 The reason it isn’t super common is because usually the team either isn’t interested in bringing the player back or they get outbid. Not because the player is punishing the team for trading him. I’ll bet you can’t name even one player who didn’t sign with a team specifically BECAUSE they traded him.
And I don’t see how the player being or not being a “top of the market player” would make a difference as long as the team is willing to pay him.
Geebs
@RemovePitcherWinsFromTheRecordBooks lol wth are you talking about? who said anything about the player being upset? I didn’t provide a reason the player doesn’t resign I just said its uncommon.
When a player is at the top of the market and they’re free agents they generally go to the highest bidder, when a team that has a player trades said player they generally don’t resign becasue that team usually traded the player (in part) because they already made the decision not to resign the player because they don’t want to pay for that player at top of the market prices, or the player has made it clear he doesn’t want to resign..
Really, you couldn’t figure this out from infrence and transaction history?
@hiflew yeah he was, I even thought of him but for some reason I didn’t think of him at the top of the market but he definently was at the time
Deleted_User
@abgb123…
“I didn’t provide a reason the player doesn’t resign I just said its uncommon.”
By saying that a player signing with a team that traded him is uncommon, you are implying that those players didn’t sign with the original team BECAUSE they were traded. In reality that is patently false. The reason they don’t sign with the original team is because usually the original team isn’t interested in bringing them back or because someone else offers more money. This means they would have left even if they had not been traded.
“When a player is at the top of the market and they’re free agents they generally go to the highest bidder…”
Obviously
“… when a team that has a player trades said player they generally don’t resign becasue that team usually traded the player (in part) because they already made the decision not to resign the player because they don’t want to pay for that player at top of the market prices, or the player has made it clear he doesn’t want to resign..”
That isn’t the case with the Rockies and Jon Gray though. The Rockies have expressed an interest in signing him and Gray has expressed an interest in returning. As long as they make a competitive offer there is no reason to believe that trading him would put them at some kind of disadvantage.
“Really, you couldn’t figure this out from infrence and transaction history?”
No, I couldn’t. I looked at several transactions and I didn’t find a single instance of any player (top-of-market, bottom-of-market or anywhere in between) being traded during a contract year and then signing elsewhere in free agency for less money than what their original team offered them. Nor did I find a single instance of a player saying that he didn’t sign with his original team specifically BECAUSE he was traded. A player simply not going back to his original team isn’t enough to prove your point. You need actual evidence that he WOULD have stayed with his original team HAD he not been traded, all other things equal.
Special Agent
The return would have pee in a can. Plus, at the deadline Gray was saying he’d like to return.
Deleted_User
@Special Agent If he wants to return so much they definitely should have traded him. Then they could bring him back as a FA and then they would have Gray AND prospects.
And absolutely they could have gotten something good for Gray. Quality starting pitching ALWAYS has value at the deadline.
Faith in the Padres
Gray and Story get Q0s. Both probably sign elsewhere. Rockies probably net 2 picks after 1st round. Idk what the $$ threshold is with the new rules.
Rockies had to weigh the offers and apparently decided the extra picks and bonus draft money had more value than the offers they were getting.
Time will tell. And we dont know what was offered.
hiflew
Gray will be back, Story won’t. Gray has said he does not want to leave several times. Unless he gets a crazy big offer from someone, he will be a Rockie in 2022 at least. He might even accept the QO.
Deleted_User
@hiflew If Gray wants to be a Rockie so much (which is frankly ridiculous, but hey) then they definitely should have traded him. Then brought him back like the Yankees did with Aroldis Chapman.
AHH-Rox
Gray isn’t consistent enough to deserve the QO price (so the Rockies will probably give him one). On a good team, he’s a #4 starter.
Deleted Userrr
@Faith in the Padres Gray accepts the QO in less than a second if they extend it. He has been 50 shades of suck since the deadline.
Deleted Userrr
An absolute circus
okieman
Great move for the club. Billy is a leader who has shown a strong ability to galvanize the various departments. Right man at the right time.
mrgreenjeans
100% agree
coloredpaper
The Rockies just being the Rockies.
They definitely have to be the worst run organization in baseball, let alone one of the worst in all major sports. Yes, worse than the Pirates. You know that old adage, “if it ain’t broke, don’t fix it?” Looks like the owner doesn’t think it’s broken, even though they’ve only had 2 seasons above .500 in the past 10 years, and only 4 post season appearances in the past 20 years. Pipeline looks pretty bad, and they failed to get any good value on their recent trade assets, including Trevor Story. Looks like it’ll be another long decade for Rockies fans.
Baseball 1600
Weird team. Their pitching has done better at home than on the road this year, which has to at least be a step in the right direction, and Zac Veen looks like he has the potential to be really, really good. Even with these silver linings they still don’t seem to have a direction and the Giants and Dodgers are two of the best ran teams in baseball, right in their division.
bobtillman
Weird situation. They still pack the joint, and TV ratings are better than average. I know Schmidt is supposed to be some kind of talent guru, but the drafts and internationals have been “blah”, and the return on trades have been “meh”. Dan O’Dowd loves the guy, (and DOD deserves some respect), but I just don’t see it. With those revenues, that ballpark, and a darn good manager, you’d think one of the young guns buried behind, say, Neander in TB or Sterns in Milw. would love the job.
extreme113
The farm system seems to be lacking impact talent so they hire the guy as a GM who responsibility was to stock the farm system through his drafts- hmm.
WarkMohlers
“After five months as our interim general manager, it became increasingly clear that Bill was the right person to lead this franchise forward,” Rockies President and COO Greg Feasel.
What has he done to show that? Nothing that’s public-facing shows that. Can someone tell me what he’s done? He’s been with the org for decades (with some stops along the way) and I get they appreciate his scouting ability, but they really aren’t bringing in “fresh blood”? Don’t let your “talent guru” get bogged down with operations, unless there is another one to replace the loss of expertise.
LordD99
Promoting from within is great, but only if you’ve built a top-notch front office. Just the opposite here.
Deleted_User
What did he do to deserve this? Not get something for Jon Gray and CJ Cron when the alternative was to lose them for nothing?
jay13
That man must make a great cup of coffee.
kscheer
Eyeroll
tominco
The folks in Colorado don’t care about baseball. They’ll come to the games, drink beer, have fun, and spend money. The game on the field doesn’t matter to them. So this is a fine promotion. Besides the fans Colorado who do care about baseball are fans of the Giants, Cubs, Dodgers, Cardinals, Red Sox, etc.
Now if this were about the Broncos, it’s a whole different story.
James LaGrow
I think Bill Schmidt proved himself to be a viable GM. Time will tell if he was the right choice.
This is the man whose Scouted, Crosschecked, Drafted, and Developed EVERY SINGLE player since 1999. If ANYONE is capable of analyzing the qualities, skills, and makeup of the postseason teams the organization its Schmidt, afterall he’s been the guy on the front-lines of the four postseason rosters since 1999.
In regards to Deadline Trades, ultimately, he was open and honest with Trevor Story. He told Trevor there is a good chance you’re not going to be moved.
His interest was not in quantity, like every other team wanted him to be in, but on the quality of what was being offered.
Arenado and Tulo were bith dealt by a GM who couldn’t recognize talent, value-timing, and quality. Schmidt understands quality; that’s what he’s built through the draft.
And… Keep in mind, the Rockies have three (3) players in the Top 100 at the moment, Veen, Montgomery, and Rollison.
With the offseason lining perfect for Peter Lambert to prepare appropriately, his recovery us the equivelant to adding another.
And before long, we will see other rise as they all shake the rust of a lost year and a half off.
Rsox
I can’t imagine the Rockies GM job being a desirable one around the league so it seems like the Rockies took the path to least resistance and just kept the guy who was already doing it…
Yep it is
Rockies being the Rockies