The Cardinals added a second veteran lefty just prior to the trade deadline, agreeing to acquire longtime division rival Jon Lester from the Nationals in exchange for outfielder Lane Thomas. Both teams announced the swap.
Lester joins fellow graybeard J.A. Happ as a new addition to a Cardinals rotation that has been decimated by injury. The Cards are currently without ace Jack Flaherty (oblique strain), while Carlos Martinez is done for the year after undergoing thumb surgery. Miles Mikolas has pitched just four innings this year owing to another forearm strain. The Cards knew Dakota Hudson wouldn’t pitch in 2021 after he had Tommy John surgery last September. They’ve also seen absences for Kwang-hyun Kim and Daniel Ponce de Leon at times; the latter is on the shelf with a shoulder issue at the moment, in fact.
With so many injuries on the staff, the Cards had already turned to veteran lefty Wade LeBlanc to soak up some innings, and their acquisitions of Happ and Lester come with similar goals. Neither Happ nor Lester has pitched all that well in 2021, though Lester has the far better results of the two. He’s worked to a 5.02 ERA in 76 innings for the Nats and generated respectable ground-ball (42%) and walk (8.5%) rates. His 14.9 percent strikeout rate, however, is about nine percent worse than the league-average.
Lester, at this point, is primarily a five-inning pitcher. He’s recorded an out in the sixth inning or later in just five of his 16 trips to the mound this season and has been rocked at a .333/.386/.627 clip on the rare occasions he’s been asked to turn a lineup over for a third time. He’s not the innings eater that he once was, but if the Cardinals don’t try to push him into the sixth and seventh innings on the regular, he ought to be able to keep them in games and help bridge the gap until Flaherty and Mikolas are hopefully able to return. Lester is on a one-year, $5MM contract and will be a free agent at season’s end.
As for the Nationals’ return, the 26-year-old Thomas has yet to produce in the big leagues outside a quick cup of coffee late in the 2019 season, although it’s still rather surprising to see the Cardinals part with a big-league-ready outfielder who can be optioned both this year and next. Thomas is hitting just .104/.259/.125 this year, though it’s just a sample of 58 plate appearances. He’s an overall .172/.289/.336 hitter in a similarly small sample of 142 plate appearances.
Thomas ranked as the Cardinals No. 14 prospect at FanGraphs as recently as last summer, drawing praise for his defensive prowess in center field and the potential to pair that with some improved power and plate coverage. His lack of production in the big leagues notwithstanding, Thomas is a .269/.342/.468 hitter in parts of three Triple-A seasons, including a .265/.339/.451 showing in Triple-A Memphis this season.
The move to the Nationals seems like a good opportunity for Thomas, who’d been squeezed out of the outfield picture in St. Louis in favor of Tyler O’Neill, Harrison Bader and Dylan Carlson. With the Nationals, who traded Kyle Schwarber and have a struggling Victor Robles in center field, opportunities for Thomas ought to be more plentiful. He might be a long shot to break out as an everyday option in D.C., but Thomas should at least get that chance. For two months of a struggling veteran starter, it’s a pretty nice roll of the dice for the Nats to inherit.
Jesse Rogers of ESPN broke the news (via Twitter) that Lester was going to St. Louis. Jesse Dougherty of the Washington Post reported that the Nats were getting Thomas in return.
allweatherfan
Why why why Cards??????
Francys01
Welcome to the Cardinals. He was a terrific pitcher for many years. Hopefully, the Cards can help him to get better.
templetonpeck
That’s just asinine…pitchers don’t get better at age 37. 25 yr old outfielders under control until 2026 however…ask Arozarena and Adolis Garcia how they’re doing
Angry Disgruntled Sox Fan
There is clear decline, but there is also a thing called pure talent. Lester is still a talented pitcher. Let’s just see if he has enough left in the tank.
jd2223711
Look at waino he sure found success with age. Plus Lester is a soft tossing lefty who hits spots good move for what it is an arm to get us to end of year or
Geoff28
Adolis Garcia had shown nothing like what he is doing in Texas, plus he was on the older than most prospects. Arozarena hurts but he needs to keep it going for longer than a seasons worth of time to prove it was really a lost deal (not to mention Liberatore hasn’t even made his debut yet so that deal cannot be fairly judged until then)
RJY707499
We have a crowded outfield and a need for a rental pitcher. Thomas wasn’t going to get a 2nd chance with STL
CujoMarlin
You do realize that both Bader and O’Neill have higher OPS this season than Arozarena and Garcia, don’t you?
dmarcus15
Cards fans act like Arozarena is Tatis.
Timbo314
Fire Mozeliak already.. Tatis jr wanted to be a Cardinal! But our moron Bowtie GM decided to pass
Timbo314
Hopefully he retires before throwing a pitch
Curly Was The Smart Stooge
Looked bad against the Braves tonight., & was constantly disagreeing with the ump.
StlSwifty
This is plain stupid… this is obviously a lost season, why not give some innings to your up and coming youngsters like woodford or Oviedo to get them some seasoning. Instead you give the opportunity to a guy who hasn’t been good in years and is about to retire soon. This is a big head scratcher.
Geoff28
Because Oviedo has looked overmatched more often than not. Woodford I agree on but it doesn’t hurt to have some veterans come in to potentially eat innings and bridge the gap until they get Flaherty and Mikolas back.
Dogbone
The Cards can’t do that, most pitchers in their system have sore arms.
RJY707499
Let’s see….10 1/2 games behind with 31 games left in 2011. You should know what happened. Have some faith and see what happens.
Brian Roeh
Not really it’s Mozeliak on dope
Goku the Knowledgable One
Maybe it’ll help sell tickets, but both are headscratching additions financially
Took on several million for 2 guys who are lucky to make it thru the 5th.
bucsfan0004
I hate typos in article titles. Who are the “Caridnals”?
abenoitj
Bro there are multiple trades going on in a very short amount of time cut them some slack
BustyPoser 2
You couldn’t get Cardinals outta that? Wow. I guess that’s why they don’t do word jumbles in newspapers no more.
2012orioles
Hahaha
EndinStealth
He’s a Bucs fan he has nothing else.
waterdog311
I hate people that use 0004 and could simply use 4.
awf111969
Birds on a caravan?
AZPat
They play in St. Luis.
Daryl Pauley
Distant relatives of Cardinals.
EliMorganFanClub
I wonder how he feels about that
nats3256
Man Mike Rizzo certainly knows how to do a full on fire sale.
jury_rigger
Happ and now lackLester? Lol cards are garbage
mac1brad
Hot garbage!
jdgoat
I’m convinced the Cardinals computers are stuck in 2015 after acquiring both Lester and Happ for their postseason push.
psarg
Eh, he’ll eat a few innings until Flare and Mikolas are back…?
slasher016
What in the hell are the Cards doing? They have practically zero shot at the playoffs and they give up players for two aging, over the hill arms??
frontdeskmike
Thomas and Gant are not in their long term plans. I’m fine with what they gave up. They might catch lightning in a bottle.
templetonpeck
You’re Mo, or part of his family, because that’s the only way someone could defend these trades. The only other possibility is having the IQ of a brick
camdog23
Why? What the hell have Lane Thomas and Jon Gant ever done
templetonpeck
Provide a net WAR this year that VASTLY exceeds the net WAR of Happ and Lester
Joel Peterson
Have they? Look it up….
templetonpeck
.8 for Gant, -.8 for Thomas > -1.9 for Happ and -.9 for Lester. Is math hard for you?
frontdeskmike
WTF is your problem? Would you be happy if Lane Thomas was in your 2022 outfield plans or if Gant was in your 2022 rotation? No way! But I also wouldn’t be happy with Happ or Lester in the 2022 rotation but both lefties have a higher ceiling for this year.
RJY707499
What kind of playing time would Thomas get? He’s a 4th maybe even a 5th outfielder.
bball32
Well you made a dumb statement. You can’t be upset when people respond accordingly. Giving up 3 young controllable players for a guy that has an ERA of almost 7 and a guy whose ERA has been above 5 for the last 2 seasons are horrible trades. STL clearly isn’t a serious WS contender this year. Trading away young controllable talent for half a season from two of the worst pitchers in baseball this year is just stupid. Not to mention that gant has better numbers than both Lester and Happ by a lot. The fact that they included another decent player in the trade to get Happ is insane. Gant easily could’ve been a nice bullpen piece or at the very least used to get someone to help them going forward. Same with Thomas and the prospect. Instead they got wasted on two of the worst pitchers in baseball this year to eat some innings for no reason.
Oldschoolandthemets1980
Thomas is a 4th outfielder in the Kbo,st Louis took a chance on A veteran and borderline HoF in Lester who has the talent and experience to get it done. Its ine if them trades we all might be praising come October,put down your dinner and get out of Moms basement people and turn the TV on like all the rest and watch, anything can happen in baseball.
Dad
Gant publicly complained about how they were using him,in Stl if you complain your gone unless your really good!If your Mediocre shut up!
Timbo314
What!! I dont care if the cardinals traded willie mcgee for Lester or Happ!! Lester is old as dirt and has shown he should just retire.
TERRIBLE
Trading for J Happ is the most pathetic trade. Jon Gant has a better War 1.09, era 4.50
Happ has a negative war and 6.50 era
Fire Mozeliak for making our team worse
EndinStealth
I agree I don’t mind what they gave up, but they have zero chance.
Goku the Knowledgable One
*HAD zero chance
… adding Lester and Happ changes everything in the NL
Timbo314
Yea it takes the cardinals from 3rd place to 4th place. Fire MR BOWTIE
Daryl Pauley
It will be a flash of quick lightning in a bottle. Those two guys are older than dirt in baseball years.
Brian Roeh
It’s the mo blo sho
solaris602
Wow! Nats and Cubs selling everything to the walls the past few days. Meanwhile COL has done exactly nothing.
Big Al Secord
LOL… thank you cardinals for taking on old Cubs garbage.
I guess crap really does flow downstream on the Mississippi River.
Binnington50
You do realize that Chicago is nowhere near the Mississippi River, right?
jdgoat
Lol
Dotnet22
In his defense, the Illinois River flows in to the Mississippi.
waterdog311
Big Al’s geography class ladies and gentlemen…the crackhead edition.
frontdeskmike
Big Al’s is just a few hundred yards off of the Illinois River in Peoria.
SlippinJimmy89
I live about 2 blocks from Big Al’s. Thanks for the shout out.
cruiser2948
Waino probably HAPPy they brought in Lester. now the 3 can hang out at the local retirement home together.
Timbo314
Yea it takes the cardinals from 3rd place to 4th place. Fire MR BOWTIE
ldoggnation
Situational relief.
Jgwi2az
As a brewers fan, this makes me happy
17dizzy
The Brewers not only have a GM dedicated to win and the knowledge of —- when you trade for impact players—— your team gets impact results!!!
Case in point ——- John Mozeliak wasted his traded players (most who have become All-Stars) to the Marlins for an Injured, classless Ozuna. The Brewers were patient— and obtained an MVP YELICH after Ozuna was gone. Your GM Knows baseball talent when he sees it!!!! Mozeliak was an Accountant & NEVER played baseball. Plus— He can’t see past the dollar bill!!!
The Cardinals president of Baseball operations is a master of picking up ‘Low Hanging Fruit” type players in hopes of getting a good game or 2 out of them.
Thus-John Mozeliak- being a “Low hanging Fruit” master——— Has turned the Cardinals franchise into a “Low Hanging Fruit” Organization!!!
steve2345 2
actually, Mozeliak tried to trade for Yelich but the Marlins said no, so he went after Ozuna. once Ozuna and Stanton were gone, Yelich demanded a trade. so in essence, the Brewers can thank Mozeliak for Yelich.
Timbo314
MO should od been fired years ago
cards81
@17dizzy…Mo was in charge of the draft in the Cardinals most successful drafts…including Pujols and Molina…so…I guess you should check yourself
Devlsh
At least Thomas can now follow in the footsteps of Arozarena, Adolis Garcia, Patrick Wisdom, Luke Voit, etc.
LeftyNate111
Wow, not a guy I expected them to acquire. Said “wow” once the site finally loaded up again. I’m sure MLBTR hates their service provider/servers right now lol
raef715
cubs, or ex cubs, it doesnt matter, they are all getting traded this week.
alwaysgo4two
Damn….last Nat to go please lock the door behind you.
HubcapDiamondStarHalo
Yeah, I guess once they decide to be sellers, they do it in style…
panj341
Cards plan on making a run?
btharveyku08
not with these moves
Timbo314
Exactly them trades make the Cardinals worse!
brockswipessecond
Subtraction by addition? It would have been better if Mo had napped through the trade deadline.
Texas Outlaw
Subtraction by addition
Monkey’s Uncle
Cards would be winning if this was an AARP league.
thatswhtshesd
Word
tombenton
Great! We have a lot of games with The Pirates and Cubs, we will play there AAA teams
Rumy's Ghost
And then the Cardinals show up hoping the Brewers will crash and burn and the Reds will be the Reds.
bryce1344
Opening up 40 man slots for next year while hoping for magic this year
mitchladd
Another promising young outfielder traded away by the Cards before ever really being given a chance. How long until he turns into an all-star, too?
619bird
This is John Mozeliak’s v
ersion of throwing s**t at a wall and seeing if anything sticks.
Thomas didn’t show anything in almost any opportunity given. Guess we’ll wait for the financials to come out. Lester wasn’t making much iirc.
EasternLeagueVeteran
Nice trade. This will give the Cards the Righty-Lefty One-Two punch they were looking for with the AARP twins Wainwright and Lester.
Timbo314
Please tell me this comment is a joke
yankeemanuno23
Rizzo need to be fired period!
A 2019 WS champ decimated b/c he couldn’t keep it together -POOR longer term vision- started when they let Rendon go – just never put pitchers around Max and mediocre position players Merry Go Round! As a Nats fan in Sears since they arrived – I’m gone
Joel Peterson
I couldn’t care less about Thomas. But this is still pretty lame. Lester????
SupremeZeus
Very savvy move. Mo is putting the finishing touches on a roster that has a legit shot at the 2014 world Series.
Daryl Pauley
IMO this is a waste of time. I hope we don’t sign him for next year.
themed
Love the trade to get Lester. And love getting rid of Gantcand watching him walk the house. Thomas not going to be missed either. Nice to get pitchers that know how to pitch and don’t give games away walking people. I’ve seen the Cardinals win divisions and pennants being a lot farther out than they are now. Might be another miracle comeback. It’s definitely going to be a lot more fun than being a cub fan.
themed
Check out how the Cards won back in 1964. I was just a young guy but it was one of the most exciting seasons in history.
Timbo314
Instead of trading for Lester and JJ Happs 6.33 E.r.a they should of talked Randy Johnson out of retirement.. Fire MOZELIAK ASAP
RJY707499
Placing my bet with Vegas that Cardinals win it all in 2021. Baseball world would crap themselves.
Joel Peterson
Hey ya never know……
FullMontilla
Isn’t Thomas only 23? seems too early in his career to give up on him for a washed up starting pitcher
Brian Roeh
FMO
Dad
If you haven’t noticed , the Cardinals keep getting guy’s that can pitch without the sticky!
barkinghumans77
As a Cards fan, I obviously would have liked more. I’m not trashing the moves as much as others. Lester hopefully can give us something until Flaherty and Mikolas get back. Not expecting anything from Happ. Prices were high on in demand players. I’d rather keep the farm right now. They’ve stayed on the edge and are close to getting their ace back. We shall see
Timbo314
More? We got less
DonOsbourne
These trades only bother me because I feel like my intelligence is being insulted. Gant and Thomas were no loss, but Lester and Happ are no gain. So why make the trade? So Mo can say he tried. This is, as usual, a PR move not a baseball move. The problem is, I’m not dumb enough to swallow the company line. They didn’t try. They never intended to try. They have been pleased with the attendance numbers so far this season. They foresee Covid restrictions limiting attendance the rest of the year no matter how the team plays and next season has always been a question mark because of the unsettled labor situation along with ongoing pandemic related problems. The team brass saw no reason to increase their investment or trade away marketable names. So they punted and tried to apply some cheap paint. Very typical. Very disappointing.
Timbo314
Fire Mozeliak already
Peart of the game
I would’ve rather signed Porcello months ago instead of trading for Lester.
rocknwell
I have seen “Fire Mozeliak” more times than I have seen the sun rise over the last few years. I am genuinely curious…how long does it take for the owner to fire a POBO/GM based on fan hatred? Or is that not even a thing? I assume when it starts taking from the bottom line? Cards fans are too loyal. Maybe they should start boycotting in order to see “regime change”.
Del Griffith
If the criticism is that you wanted Mo to get better players, that’s fair. Thomas for Lester is fine. Thomas had regressed and is not and should not be in the plans. Lester is a decent 4 or 5. Gant for Happ makes no sense at all even if Gant is not in the plans. I have a hard time counting on Mikolas coming back and staying healthy.
30 Parks
Lester throwing to Yadi. Yes.
Daryl Pauley
I was a little high on Gant helping us in the future. He’s accomplished what’s been asked of him in the past few years. He was not the best but always took the ball.
The next announcement from Cardinals FO will be the signing of both pitchers on 2-year contracts. We will be set for a 2022/23 World Series run.
That sounds ludicrous but within the realm of possibility.
Sat, “it isn’t so.”
Daryl Pauley
Should have traded Andrew Miller instead of Gant.
Painful itch
Happ Wainwright Lester 2016 would be a tough 3 for sure.
FullMontilla
I’ll give you ‘3’, but ‘tough’? Only if you consider an ERA average of 4.50 tough
templetonpeck
Allowed the first 7 hitters to reach, 27 pitches before recording an out, and 5 runs allowed in the 1st inning. And the pen still had to cover 4 innings because Lester allows something like a .360 avg if you let him go more than 5. What a quality addition.