Memorial Day is behind us, which is typically the time of year that teams at least begin to shift their focus to the summer trade market. With this year’s draft pushed back to July, it’s possible some clubs will look to be active a bit earlier than usual. Even if things don’t really pick up until next month, as is typically the case, we at least have some semblance of an idea as to how things will play out.
As in past years, this list aims to rank players on a combination of likelihood of being moved and overall value as a trade chip. It’s all subjective, of course, but “value” in this instance is a reference to a player’s on-field production, salary, remaining club control, etc.
Club control and salary dovetail nicely with a player’s likelihood of being moved. Rebuilding clubs and clear sellers are obviously more likely to move impending free agents — particularly those who aren’t candidates to receive a qualifying offer. Players with one extra year of control are also frequently moved at the deadline, but once you start getting into players with two, three and four years of affordable control remaining, the likelihood diminishes. The composition of a club’s farm system comes into play, too. Does a veteran with a year and a half of club control remaining have a top prospect breathing down his neck? Is the team’s farm so bleak that it needs to consider moving players with several years of control remaining? There are many factors to consider.
As the deadline draws nearer, the names on the list will change. Teams will fall out of contention, and some who look far from the top of their division will make a surge. Injuries or poor performance will sap some players’ value, while a return to health or a turnaround on the field could boost the performance of others. Again, it’s subjective and highly debatable, which is part of what makes the whole thing a fun exercise.
On to the list!
1. Jon Gray, RHP, Rockies: The Rockies turned over their front office earlier this year after yet another lackluster start, and Gray stands out as the likeliest trade candidate on the roster. The former No. 3 overall pick and top prospect is in the midst of a solid rebound campaign, but he’ll be a free agent at season’s end. The Rockies probably wouldn’t issue a qualifying offer without a huge finish to the year, and starting pitching is always in demand at the deadline.
2. Trevor Story, SS, Rockies: While Gray may be something of a borderline QO candidate, Story seems like a lock to receive a qualifying offer if he isn’t traded. That’s the key difference between him and Gray in terms of trade likelihood; the Rox need to feel that whatever they receive in return is more valuable than that 2022 draft pick. It should be noted that outside of a brief hot streak from mid-April to early May, Story hasn’t really hit much in 2021. He’s also on the IL with what the team has termed minor elbow inflammation, and the hope is his stint will last only 10 days. Story is also striking out at a career-low 22.4 percent clip without sacrificing anything in the walk department, and his track record is so strong that if he shows his health in the next few weeks, interest should be robust.
3. Mitch Haniger, OF, Mariners: It was great to see Haniger take the field at all after his 2019-20 seasons were derailed by a bizarre series of escalating injuries, but the fact that he’s returned as one of the American League’s most productive hitters only makes his story better. They’re enjoying the comeback in Seattle for now, but Haniger only has a year of control remaining beyond the 2021 season. With a deep crop of young outfielders on which to rely — 2020 Rookie of the Year Kyle Lewis, plus top prospects Jarred Kelenic, Julio Rodriguez and Taylor Trammell — the Mariners seem likely to explore the market for Haniger this summer. He’s earning $3.01MM in 2021.
4. Matthew Boyd, LHP, Tigers: The Tigers held onto Boyd when he was one of the most oft-mentioned trade candidates in the game in 2019, but their club control on him is beginning to dwindle. Boyd is eligible for free agency after the 2022 season, and he’s enjoying a nice year thanks largely to a new-look changeup that has helped him neutralize opposing right-handers. So long as Boyd stays healthy and reasonably effective, this summer will be his trade value’s apex. It’s hard to see him sticking around into August.
5. Tyler Anderson, LHP, Pirates: Anderson’s signing couldn’t have worked out much better for the Bucs so far. He’s pitching his best baseball since his rookie year in 2016 and sporting career-best marks in swinging-strike rate and opponents’ chase rate. Durability is a major question mark for Anderson, who has only twice started 25 games in a season. But he’s been healthy since Opening Day 2020, and his $2.5MM base salary is a bargain for clubs in need of some reinforcements at the back of the rotation.
6. Adam Frazier, 2B/OF, Pirates: Frazier has put last year’s awful season in the rear-view mirror and is in the midst of the best start of his six-year career. The 29-year-old has ample experience at second base and in the outfield, and he could fill in as a starter or versatile bench option for any contending club. His $4.3MM salary is, incredibly, the second-largest on the Pirates behind Gregory Polanco, but that’s an eminently affordable price for Frazier even if he reverts back to his typical, roughly league-average level of offensive output.
7. Richard Rodriguez, RHP, Pirates: One of the most anonymous high-end relievers in the game, the 31-year-old Rodriguez boasts a 2.84 ERA, a 27.4 percent strikeout rate and a 6.7 percent walk rate dating back to 2018 with the Pirates. He’s not flashy, sitting 93.2 mph with his heater, but Rodriguez gets the job done and is controllable all the way through 2023. Any team seeking a high-leverage reliever could acquire two and a half years of his services this summer, and given his $1.7MM salary in 2021, his subsequent arbitration raises won’t break the bank.
8. Kyle Gibson, RHP, Rangers: Gibson’s 2020 season was a nightmare, and the 2021 campaign looked to be more of the same after he couldn’t escape the first inning of his first start. Since that awful 2021 debut? All Gibson has done is pitch 54 innings of 1.50 ERA ball with a 53.7 percent grounder rate and the lowest walk rate of his career. His strikeout rate is below-average, he’s not going to sustain the .214 BABIP he’s logged over those eight starts, and his 81.7 percent strand rate is due for a correction as well. But even with some regression baked in, Gibson looks like the latest veteran to outperform a modestly-priced three-year deal in Texas. He’s on the IL with a groin injury at the moment but is reportedly looking at a fairly minimal stint.
9. Ian Kennedy, RHP, Rangers: Kennedy has had more success than arguably any pitcher who inked a minor league deal this winter, rejuvenating his career with a dominant showing as the Rangers’ closer. He’s among baseball’s leaders in saves and is doing so with a revitalized heater, a strikeout rate north of 31 percent and the lowest walk rate of his career. That minor league pact came with a $2.15MM base salary, which makes Kennedy affordable for any team in need of bullpen help. He’s a free agent at season’s end, but he looks like one of the better bullpen rentals out there.
10. Kendall Graveman, RHP, Mariners: Another reliever rental in the AL West, Graveman has gone from a solid fourth starter to someone who looks like a potentially overpowering bullpen piece. His sinker velocity has soared since he moved to short stints after an IL stint in 2020, and he’s emerged as the Mariners’ closer on the back of a 26 2/3-inning run during which he’s posted a 1.35 ERA with a 22-to-6 K/BB ratio and a 50 percent ground-ball rate. He’s currently on the Covid-related IL, but Graveman hasn’t surrendered a run in 16 2/3 frames this season. He’s on a one-year, $1.25MM deal with incentives that can max it out at $3.75MM. This is the type of reliever every buyer will want.
11. Yimi Garcia, RHP, Marlins: The Dodgers’ decision to non-tender Garcia in 2019 has proven regrettable. Since joining the Fish on a $1.1MM deal that winter, Garcia has turned in 36 2/3 innings of 1.23 ERA ball, striking out 29.2 percent of opponents and walking just 6.8 percent of them along the way. He’s on a small $1.9MM salary in 2021 and will be a free agent at season’s end, making him an appealing rental option for teams in need of relief help (which ought to be nearly every contender).
12. David Peralta, OF, Diamondbacks: Peralta, 34 this summer, hasn’t recaptured his 30-homer pace from the 2018 season but has been an above-average bat and solid corner defender throughout his career. When the deadline rolls around, he’ll be halfway through a three-year, $22MM extension on a D-backs club that has been among the worst in the game. He generally struggles against lefties, but Peralta mashes right-handed pitching and would be a boost to any club looking for some left-handed pop — particularly if said club has a solid right-handed pairing for him. He’s earning $7.5MM in 2021 and has the same salary in 2022.
13. Michael Fulmer, RHP, Tigers: Like Boyd, Fulmer has a year of control beyond the 2021 campaign and was an oft-mentioned trade candidate earlier in his career. It’s a little easier to see why Fulmer wasn’t moved, as trading a former AL Rookie of the Year when he had four or even five years of club control remaining would’ve required a massive haul. By the time he was in a more conventional window to be moved, injuries had wrecked multiple seasons for the righty. Those look to be in the past now, however, as Fulmer has seamlessly moved from the rotation to the ’pen, stepping up as Detroit’s closer in 2021. His fastball velocity is as good as ever now that he’s working in short stints, and Fulmer boasts career-best marks in swinging-strike rate and opponents’ chase rate. He’s owed a raise on his $3.1MM salary in arbitration this winter, but that looks plenty reasonable for this version of the right-hander.
14. C.J. Cron, 1B, Rockies: Cron’s minor league pact with the Rox could scarcely have gone better thus far. He’s proven that his surgically repaired knee is healthy, which was about the only question mark surrounding him given that Cron has hit pretty much since the day he made his MLB debut. He’s not an elite defensive first baseman and doesn’t really offer any versatility, but he’s a solid everyday option at first or DH. Cron is a bit above average against righties and absolutely punishes lefties. His deal came with just a $1MM base salary at the MLB level, so he’s not going to break the bank. Teams have generally devalued first base/DH-only sluggers in recent years, but Cron will draw interest and fetch the Rockies a prospect or two.
15. Michael Pineda, RHP, Twins: Minnesota is probably baseball’s most disappointing team, and at 22-31, things are looking bleak. Pineda stands as the most logical rental candidate they could market, though the Twins’ offseason consisted entirely of one-year free-agent signings, so they surely have others. Pineda should have the broadest market, however, as most contenders will be looking for solid rotation pieces, and he certainly fits the bill. Pineda is playing out the second season of a two-year, $20MM deal and will be a free agent this winter. Barring a major winning streak in Minnesota, he figures to be available.
16-17. Dylan Bundy (RHP) & Andrew Heaney (LHP), Angels: Bundy has been rocked in his past three starts, which has sent his ERA spiking to 6.50. His velocity is up this season over its 2020 levels, however, and he’s sporting similar marks in K-BB%, SIERA and other secondary indicators that he carried during his excellent 2020 season. If Bundy continues to struggle with the long ball, which has been an issue for him in the past, then his stock will obviously dip. If he looks like he did in 2020 or through his first six starts of this season, however, he’ll be one of the market’s more in-demand rentals. It’s a somewhat similar tale for Heaney, who has had a roller-coaster season beginning with a miserable season debut. He’s sporting a 5.24 ERA but with demonstrably better K-BB numbers and fielding-independent marks. With the Angels six games under .500, Mike Trout absent for another six to seven weeks and a new front office regime installed, the Angels could sell off some short-term pieces.
18. Jose Urena, RHP, Tigers: A hard-throwing 29-year-old, Urena doesn’t miss many bats but is inducing grounders at a 54.3 percent clip and has been a generally solid fifth starter for a rebuilding Tigers club that is all but certain to flip him if a decent offer presents itself. Urena has a 4.14 ERA in 54 1/3 frames, albeit with a poor 15 percent strikeout rate and a pedestrian 9.4 percent walk rate. He’s unlikely to factor into a club’s playoff rotation unless injuries necessitate it, but for a postseason hopeful looking for some stability at the back of the rotation for the season’s final few months, Urena is a decent, low-cost option. He signed a one-year, $3.3MM deal with Detrot this winter.
19. Raisel Iglesias, RHP, Angels: The 31-year-old has run into some uncharacteristic homer troubles since being traded to the Halos, but he’s also sporting the best K-BB% of his career thanks to a career-best 35.1 percent strikeout rate and a career-low 3.9 percent walk rate. His ERA is just shy of 5.00, but most teams will expect that number to trend downward in the months to come. Iglesias is second among 184 qualified relievers with a 21.1 percent swinging-strike rate, and his 37.9 percent chase rate is tied for 19th.
20. Joey Gallo, OF, Rangers: Gallo is drawing walks at a career-high clip, and his strikeout rate is “down” to a career-low 34 percent. His power numbers have trended downward since Opening Day 2020, however, and if Gallo isn’t hitting like a 30- or 40-home run threat by this summer, the offers probably won’t be enough for Texas to consider a move. Playing on a $6.2MM salary for the current season, Gallo is controllable through the 2022 campaign.
21. Nelson Cruz, DH, Twins: Cruz is in his third season with Minnesota and has become an invaluable leader and integral part of the clubhouse. Trading him would be a difficult move, and his market will likely be limited to AL suitors. The Twins are likely hoping a big June showing for their team can get them back into the postseason hunt, but it’s increasingly tough to ignore a 22-31 record and a 10.5-game deficit in the division. If they’re still nowhere near contending as July 30 approaches, Cruz could be the most impactful bat moved at this year’s deadline.
22-23. Eduardo Escobar & Asdrubal Cabrera, INF, Diamondbacks: The D-backs hold one of the game’s worst records. Escobar and Cabrera are reasonably productive veterans who are impending free agents. It’s a pretty textbook formula for a trade. Escobar slumped to a .269 OBP since 2020, but he’s also been dogged by a .241 average on balls in play during that time — well down from his career .290 mark. He’s never drawn many walks, so the BABIP dip has been particularly harmful to his batting line. That said, his power is back in 2021 after a brief disappearance in 2020. The 32-year-old is solid at second or third, can handle left field or shortstop in a pinch, and is playing on a reasonable $7.5MM salary. The switch-hitting Cabrera, meanwhile, just keeps on producing, even at 35 years of age. He’s no longer a shortstop, but Cabrera can handle either infield corner and second base. He’s been an average or better hitter every season since 2015, and this year has been perhaps the best start of his generally underrated career. Playing on just a $1.75MM salary this season, he’d be a boost to any contending club’s infield mix, although he’s currently on the injured list with a right hamstring strain.
24. Michael A. Taylor, OF, Royals: The longtime Nats outfielder inked a one-year deal with the Royals after getting non-tendered and is out to a .256/.308/.397 start in 169 plate appearances. Taylor isn’t a great hitter, but he’s a plus defender with some home run power who can swipe a handful of bases in a given year. Considering the number of clubs dealing with outfield injuries — in center field in particular — Taylor represents a fine stopgap who can later shift to a bench role. He’s playing on a cheap $1.75MM base salary, which makes him affordable for just about any team.
25. Merrill Kelly, RHP, Diamondbacks: I profiled Kelly as one of the game’s more appealing under-the-radar trade chips last summer. He promptly went on the injured list thereafter, and within weeks was headed for thoracic outlet surgery. Sorry, Merrill. He’s back healthy in 2021, and while the results haven’t been as good this year, Kelly is sporting solid K-BB numbers and has really been plagued by a poor strand rate. Looking past his smallish-sample ERA, his skill set appears pretty similar to that of the 2019-20 version of Kelly who was a solid No. 4 starter. It’s not necessarily an exciting package, but Kelly has just a $4.25MM salary in 2021 and a $5.25MM option for 2022, so he’s a nice add for a pitching-hungry team with budgetary constraints.
26. Robbie Grossman, OF, Tigers: Grossman’s two-year, $10MM deal with Detroit this winter has already paid off in spades. His perennially high walk rate is at a career-best 15.9 percent, and he’s posted a .256/.382/.423 slash with five homers and a 7-for-8 showing in stolen base attempts. Grossman isn’t a great defender, but he’s playable in either corner and is a proven source of OBP whose power has ticked up in the past couple seasons. A contender with OBP struggles and/or outfield deficiencies could probably jump the market, since Grossman ought to be available well in advance of the July 30 deadline.
27. Freddy Galvis, SS, Orioles: Hitting for the most power of his career with his second-best walk rate and a strikeout rate a good bit south of league average, Galvis has exceeded expectations in Baltimore. Both Defensive Runs Saved and Outs Above Average feel he’s playing the worst defense of his career, but a contender might look to Galvis as more of a utility option to bounce between shortstop, third base and second base anyhow. His cheap $1.5MM salary isn’t going to stand in the way of anyone acquiring him. Galvis obviously won’t get a qualifying offer, and the Orioles aren’t going to contend this year, so the impending free agent seems all but guaranteed to be traded as long as he’s healthy.
28-29. Starling Marte & Corey Dickerson, OF, Marlins: The Marlins are hanging around in an unexpectedly mediocre NL East, but the salaries of both Marte and Dickerson, paired with some young outfield talent on the rise, could prompt the club to move either veteran. Dickerson, in particular, feels likely to be on the market given that the Fish have more depth at the outfield corners than in center. But Miami might not want to risk a qualifying offer for Marte, and the Marlins certainly don’t want to lose him for nothing when he reaches free agency at season’s end.
30. Kole Calhoun, OF, Diamondbacks: Calhoun is still on the shelf after undergoing hamstring surgery earlier this year, but he should be back a month or more before the deadline, giving him some time to prove his health to other teams. He was out to a nice start in ’21, hitting .292/.333/.479 in 51 plate appearances. Calhoun has an established track record as an above-average bat and quality defender in right field, though certainly a hamstring operation could impact both facets of his game. He’s earning $8MM this year, and his contract has a $9MM club option for the 2022 season. Given that option’s $2MM buyout, it’s effectively a net $7MM decision for the D-backs or an acquiring team.
31. Jacob Stallings, C, Pirates: Stallings isn’t as commonly cited as a trade candidate as some of his more well-known teammates, but he’ll be among the better catchers available on rebuilding clubs. He’s a roughly average bat wh0 gets there more through OBP than power, but a league-average bat at catcher is valuable when the average catcher is hitting .216/.298/.367 so far in 2021. Stallings is a .256/.331/.384 career hitter who’s out to a .240/.343/.421 start in 2021. He’s earning just $1.3MM in 2021, is controllable via arbitration through 2024, and is a premium defensive option. He’s also already 31 years old, so despite being controllable, the Pirates should have no problem moving him if a catcher-needy contender comes calling.
32. German Marquez, RHP, Rockies: While Gray and Story look like near-locks to be moved, Marquez is in a different situation. The 26-year-old is signed affordably through 2024, earning $7.5MM in 2021, $11MM in 2022 and $15MM in 2023 before the Rockies (or another club) can decide between a $16MM club option or a $2.5MM buyout. He was absolutely blown up by the Giants last month, serving up eight runs and getting knocked out in the first inning, but he’s been excellent outside that one fluke appearance. Marquez has a 4.47 ERA overall but a 3.28 mark if you’re willing to overlook that career-worst day. Marquez whiffs hitters at an average or better rate, typically has a better-than-average walk rate (albeit not so far in 2021) and induces grounders north of 50 percent. He’s posted a combined 4.18 ERA since 2018 while calling Coors Field home. Most clubs would view him as a mid-rotation starter with the upside for more, and his affordable contract adds to the value.
33. Spencer Turnbull, RHP, Tigers: Similar to Marquez, Turnbull is a controllable starter on a rebuilding team who doesn’t “have” to be moved this deadline. His recent no-hitter garnered him some national attention — deservedly so — but Turnbull has been a solid starter since the 2019 season. Over his past 245 1/3 innings, he has a 4.22 ERA and 3.68 FIP. He’s enjoying the best walk and ground-ball rates of his career so far and allowing less hard contact than he ever has. Turnbull won’t even be arbitration-eligible until this winter and is controlled through 2024, so the Tigers could certainly hold onto him. Then again, they got burned by doing just that with Boyd and Fulmer, so perhaps they’ll be more proactive this time around.
34-36. John Means (LHP), Anthony Santander (OF) & Trey Mancini (1B/OF), Orioles: Baltimore has some tougher decisions to face regarding the three players that figure to hold the most appeal to other teams. Means has been one of the game’s best pitchers in 2021 and is controlled through 2024, which indicates he could at least be part of the next competitive Orioles club. But he’s also already 28, and the Orioles know they won’t be competing just yet in 2022. Holding Means would be gambling that he’ll remain this effective into his age-30 and age-31 seasons — completely plausible but also inherently risky, as is the case with any pitcher. Mancini would be a natural trade candidate were he not the Orioles’ feel-good story of the season — the heart-and-soul of the clubhouse who triumphed over a frightening diagnosis of Stage 3 colon cancer. The optics of trading him wouldn’t be great, and the move would be felt immensely in the clubhouse. Santander drew plenty of offseason interest after a nice 2020 showing, and he’s another player who is controllable through 2024. He has power but clear OBP issues. Of the three, he’d probably be the easiest to part with should another club show interest.
37. Sonny Gray, RHP, Reds: I’m not convinced the Reds will be all-out sellers at this point — more on that below — but that was true in the offseason and they still at least listened to offers on Gray as they looked to cut payroll. Gray would require a pretty notable return given that he’s signed affordably through 2023 (the final year being a club option) and is once again delivering quality results. He’s missed some time but now has a 3.40 ERA with a well above-average strikeout rate and a slightly improved (but still below-average) walk rate. If it becomes clearer that the Reds will shop Gray and his contract, he’ll vault up this list in a hurry as one of the best arms who could conceivably be moved in July. That’s also true of the next entrant on the list.
38. Nick Castellanos, OF, Reds: Castellanos hit .305/.347/.611 in March and somehow got much better in May, hitting .409/.476/.667. At this point, the 29-year-old is hitting so well that it seems likely he’ll exercise the opt-out clause in his contract. If the Reds are out of the race, they’ll have to look at Castellanos as a rental they’ll likely lose. Considering the Reds’ efforts to shed payroll this winter, dropping the remainder of Castellanos’ $14MM salary while also adding some prospects in return might be a palatable gambit.
39. Danny Duffy, LHP, Royals: Kansas City’s recent tailspin has caused them to plummet in the AL Central standings. They’re in a tough spot with Duffy, as he’s a free agent at season’s end who was enjoying a dominant start to the season before hitting the injured list. Duffy is a homegrown product who’s already signed an extension once and has somewhat famously declared, “Bury me a Royal” in response to past trade rumors surrounding him. The Royals are trying to move toward a more competitive cycle and surely want him to be a part of that. Kansas City, perhaps more than any other club, is loyal to its core players and resistant toward trading veterans for prospects. At the same time, interest in Duffy will be strong if he’s healthy. They could conceivably trade him in July then try to re-sign him in November, but this sort of move isn’t really GM Dayton Moore’s style. Duffy will be in demand, but I could just as easily see the Royals signing him to an extension.
40. Madison Bumgarner, LHP, Diamondbacks: It won’t be easy to unload Bumgarner’s contract after his poor showing in 2020, but he’s shown some signs of rebounding in a bizarre 2021 season. Bumgarner has been rocked for five or six earned runs in five of his 11 starts — his first three outings and his two most recent ones. The interim six starts? Bumgarner looked like the 2014 version of himself, hurling 34 innings of 1.32 ERA ball with a 39-to-6 K/BB ratio. His average fastball velocity is up three miles per hour after last year’s dip to 88.3 mph, which has to be encouraging for the D-backs and others. Still, Bumgarner is owed the balance of this year’s $19MM salary (about $12.5MM) plus salaries of $23MM, $23MM and $14MM from 2022-24. The D-backs would need to eat some cash or take back a contract to make things work, and the financial component of any such trade only further muddies the actual return in terms of young talent.
Others to Watch (* = Currently on injured list)
Angels: Jose Iglesias, Steve Cishek, Tony Watson, Alex Cobb, Jose Quintana*, Junior Guerra, Kurt Suzuki
Cubs: Zach Davies, Kris Bryant, Javier Baez, Anthony Rizzo, Willson Contreras
D-backs: Joakim Soria, Tyler Clippard*, Josh Reddick
Mariners: Yusei Kikuchi, Chris Flexen, Drew Steckenrider*, Keynan Middleton, Rafael Montero
Marlins: Adam Duvall, Anthony Bass
Nationals: Max Scherzer, Kyle Schwarber, Josh Harrison, Jon Lester, Starlin Castro
Orioles: Matt Harvey, Paul Fry, Maikel Franco, Pedro Severino, Shawn Armstrong, Tanner Scott
Pirates: Colin Moran*, Trevor Cahill*, Mitch Keller, Chris Stratton, Chad Kuhl, Steven Brault*
Rangers: Joely Rodriguez, Mike Foltynewicz, Brock Holt, Charlie Culberson, Khris Davis
Reds: Luis Castillo, Tyler Naquin
Rockies: Daniel Bard, Jhoulys Chacin, Mychal Givens
Royals: Jorge Soler, Brad Keller, Greg Holland, Carlos Santana, Mike Minor, Jarrod Dyson, Ervin Santana
Tigers: Wilson Ramos, JaCoby Jones, Niko Goodrum, Jose Cisnero, Jonathan Schoop, Jeimer Candelario
Twins: Andrelton Simmons, J.A. Happ, Alex Colome, Hansel Robles, Matt Shoemaker, Taylor Rogers
General Notes
–As the deadline looms closer, the viability of sell-offs from disappointing, expected contenders improves. It’s tempting to jam the list full of Twins after two disastrous months, but it’s hard to see them selling controllable players when most of their core is intact into 2022 (and well beyond, in many cases). It’s similarly hard to see them climbing back into the race, but still I wouldn’t expect much beyond the impending free agents, and perhaps an increasingly expensive reliever like Taylor Rogers.
–The same holds true for the Nationals. While there was plenty of speculation on Max Scherzer earlier this month, it’s not clear he’ll be made available. Teams would certainly be interested in a pitcher of his caliber if the Nationals were to sell. But the Nats, of all teams, are familiar with how a team’s record through Memorial Day isn’t reflective of where they’ll be at season’s end. The Nats are a woeful seven games under .500, but they’re still only six games out of first in a surprisingly feeble NL East. Washington generally hasn’t been keen on aggressively shopping their core players in recent years, so it’s not a given they’d look to move Scherzer if they remain on the periphery of contention.
–There’s been plenty of speculation on the Cubs, particularly surrounding Kris Bryant, but at eight games over .500, they’re unlikely to trade any of their core players even on the brink of free agency. A prolonged losing streak would likely bring up rumors surrounding all of the above-mentioned veterans, with Bryant the likeliest to change hands based both on his massive start to the season and his monster rebound effort at the plate.
–Few picked the Royals to contend in 2021, but that was their aim, and general manager Dayton Moore has made clear that he wants to shift his focus to winning in the here and now. They didn’t sign Carlos Santana and Mike Minor to multi-year deals simply to flip them. Either veteran could draw interest — Santana, in particular, has raked — but the Royals likely view their window to contend as just starting to open. Prospects like Daniel Lynch, Jackson Kowar, Kris Bubic and the ballyhooed Bobby Witt Jr. could all be on the big league roster in early 2022. It’s hard to see them trading many pieces, and even Duffy was a borderline inclusion on this list. It wouldn’t at all be a surprise were Moore to come out and flatly say he won’t trade the left-hander.
–The Reds are closer to the cellar than first place in the NL Central as of this writing. The club walked a fine line this past winter, dumping salary without really adding any win-now pieces in hopes that a strong offense and a quality core of bats would help them contend in 2021. That hasn’t been the case just yet, due in part to the struggles of Luis Castillo. The Reds never said it, but it’s hard to imagine owner Bob Castellini didn’t push the front office to shed payroll based on their offseason. If they’re a ways back this summer, any of their veterans on notable salaries could surface as legitimate trade candidates.
DarkSide830
i cant fathom Mitch Keller being a trade candidate with his control and struggles as or recently.
Robertowannabe
As a fan of the Pirates, I hope that the Bucs Don’t trade him. The last guy that they gave up on that had control struggles is now a Cy Young candidate in Tampa, if he stay healthy…… Not saying Keller will be as good as Glasnow, but he has looked very good at times on the mound. Other times, not so much. I think that if he ever gets consistent, he could be a very effective pitcher.
pittsburghbob69
Ya, he can’t be traded. Young pitchers need acouple years sometimes. IE Glasnow, Gioltti, T.Bauer, K.Gausman, J.Gray.
They traded Glasnow and Meadows because they had(thought they had) a play-off window for acouple years. And went after C.Archer. Which I hated the trade from the beginning. Even worse when I saw S.Baez was the PTBNL.
He’s been good and he misses bats. He’s stuff is filthy. He’s just not consistent.
Look at his game log. One good outing, the.man one bad.
He needs to string acouple good outings together, that’s all.
ABCD
Gray to the Cards for any combo of minor leaguers except Liberatore, Gorman, and Herrera.
Joel Peterson
Scherzer and Rutledge for Gorman and more.
Putmeincoach12
Are you joking? Trade the # 2 Cardinal prospect for a half a year of Mad Max? I don’t think so.
Joel Peterson
You get Rutledge too dude. Read again.
SalaryCapMyth
Mookie Betts and Manny Machado cost two top 100 prospects when they were traded during the last year of their contracts. It’s more likely that you are the one not being realistic.
jimthegoat
Nats basically have to trade Scherzer. Otherwise they lose him for nothing. They can’t even QO him like the Red Sox and Orioles could have with Betts and Machado. So basically, he’s worth what the highest bidder says he’s worth.
vtadave
Machado cost one borderline top-100 guy in Diaz and filler.
kingbum
This was supposed to be a rebuilding project for the Red Sox, might still be given you have Tampa, New York, and Toronto all with strong squads. Come the deadline if they are still raking and keeping up with the other three I think they would make a play for Scherzer. I think you are right and the Nats can’t afford to have the season play out and not get anything for him. That would be a bad move…
believeitornot
Well, the big boy has gotten hit hard in High A.
believeitornot
He has been great for them but the Nationals need a first baseman, second baseman and third baseman and that is just in the infield. Keep in mind they also have the worst minor league system. Even though it is a weak East division, it is just not going well for them. Corbin has generally been bad and Strasburg is hurt again. I would trade Scherzer, Hudson and Hand. That should give them some prospects who can play in D.C. in the next two years.
baseballpun
Gray, Story and $75 million to the Cards for Paul DeJong and the assistant video coordinator.
DocBB
You missed a big one in Jesse Winker of the Reds.
Armaments216
Winker is controlled through 2023 so the Reds won’t be offering him at the deadline no matter how far back they are in the standings.
As for Castellanos, he’d be eligible for a QO if he opts out of his contract, so like with Trevor Story he’d need to bring back a better return than that compensatory draft pick.
Cosmo2
The Reds should trade Winker precisely because he has that extra year or two of control. They’ll get more. Why wait and get less? They’re not contending anytime soon.
bot
Reds are not smart enough to trade winker. He’s got a ton of value and if reds traded him – they’d most likely get taken in the process. They need to stick to simple deals.
I thought castellanos was offered a QO once. That’s good news !
ABCD
He didn’t get a QO because he was traded to the Cubs in his walk year.
twinsfan555555
twins won’t be selling. their front office isn’t looking to. they expect a winning team still. injuries are killing them.
baseballpun
They can sell and still plan to win in 2022.
seamaholic 2
Injuries are killing everyone, including lots of teams playing a whole lot better than the Twinkies.
PutPeteinthehall
You’re dreaming. Boat has sailed. Chicago in the lead and Indians in second. Two horse race. White Sox have injuries to entire outfield / two out for entire season and third hasn’t played a game yet. Still winning. Donaldson and Cruz can’t do it alone. Twinkies are below 500 for this season at end of September.
phantomofdb
Cant think of much douchier than calling them “Twinkies”
sfes
I’ve been hearing broadcasters call them that during games and on ESPN for over 20 years
phantomofdb
Twins should definitely be selling. Injuries happen. They are trying to climb out of the cellar and just lost a series to a team that had lost 13 straight.
bot
If twins win 65% of the rest of their games they’ll be over 90 wins. That doesn’t seem impossible.
Cleveland is an excellent ran franchise but hard to think they’ll be in it to the end. Just not enough talent in that lineup.
JoeBrady
That doesn’t seem impossible.
====================================
But that’s not a good reason for sitting still. Someone with a little more caffeine can probably calculate the percentage, but if their chances of making the playoffs are only 10%, then they are probably better off trying to improve their chances in 2022 and forward.
1984wasntamanual
Impossible, no. But what you’re saying is that the twins need to play better than any team has so far this year.
Cosmo2
Unreasonable to expect the Twins to play out more than half a season at a 100 win pace.
LordD99
I’d bet against a team winning 65% of their games over 2/3rds of a season. That’s a 105-win pace over a full season. No team has played even remotely close to that so far. The Twins path to the postseason means they either have to hope for a collapse by the White Sox, while also passing Cleveland, to take first in their division, or make up nine games in the Wild Card race, passing multiple teams including the Astros, Yankees, Jays, etc.
They still have the core of a good team, so no need to tear down, but a key trade or two with an eye toward additional moves in the offseason should have them back in the hunt in 2022.
Rangers29
Woah this was a great article.
As for the guy I’m most familiar with on this list – Gibson – he’s gonna be better than people think for a while. His newly added cutter is pairing well with his reinvigorated slider causing a major increase in weak contact and lots of balls avoiding the barrel of bats.
He’s had a quality start every single start since his opening day blow-up, and he even pitched his last start with groin irritation. He’ll be back on Thursday, and I have no doubt in my mind that he’ll continue what he’s doing.
Braves Butt-Head
If the Braves dont start to contend you can expect Freeman on this list as well
sufferforsnakes
Your name fits.
Braves Butt-Head
I don’t know why you’re mad but the Braves lost again it doesn’t look like they are going to sign Freeman long term during the season and if they are out of it why not sell and stock up on prospects and try to sign Freeman in the off-season.
FredMcGriff for the HOF
@BB-H. Only the Yankees can pull of a heist like that Chapman/Gleyber. Freddie has 10-5 rights.
justinept
Heist? LOL. Chapman still only has one World Series ring. Torres has been good – when he plays Baltimore. Not so much otherwise.
JoeBrady
I agree. You can love Freeman, but he might be difficult to sign with over-committing. And keeping him thru the year-end, without knowing (or not caring) if you re-sign him, would be a mistake.
Curly Was The Smart Stooge
The turd in the punch bowl for the Braves is Ozuna. None can predict where this will go, but it won’t be a happy ending. No one seems to survive the domestic violence taboo. If he is cleared & returns he’ll be booed everywhere he goes. He’ll be a stain on the Braves org. Hopefully some of that $64 mil can be deferred or cancelled & applied to holding on to Freeman. A most unfortunate situation.
thecoffinnail
That Gleyber deal hasn’t been nearly as lopsided as it looked at the time. Torres has so far been an underachiever not coming close to his promise as a #1 prospect. He was excellent in 2019 but pitchers have figured him out and his SS defense is worse than Jeter at his age. When the trade happened I sulked a bit when it was reported Cashman was given a choice between Torres and Jimenez and he took Torres. I was a big Didi fan and I knew they would use Torres as the reason not to resign him. The Miller trade from Cleveland has turned out much better. In the end they got Frazier who if he stays healthy will be an easy transition from Gardy. Plus Sheffield has turned into a decent pitcher for Seattle. Down this year but he will make adjustments like he did in the minors. Cashman was able to flip Sheffield for Paxton who would have been a nice pickup without the injuries. I would have to say the Quintana trade was way more of a fleecing for the Cubs than the Chapman trade. Maddon rode Chapman hard to the championship and it took him almost 2 years to recover. He was definitely the missing piece for them that year and the rest of that trade didn’t amount to anything. Crawford is having a good year in the Indy leagues and the Cubs can easily pick him back up. He seems to have finally found some power. Never made it past AA for the Yanks.
MasterShake
That’s bad bad optics on the Braves’ side that won’t happen.
brandons-3
The Braves know at this point what Freddie is worth to them. His value to the Braves will always be worth more than his value to any other team. They ought to know by now whether or not they intend to make a competitive offer.
Bad optics is letting Freeman walk in free agency because they wanted to pretend they’d try to resign him for two months vs. trading him if they’re out of the race and know they aren’t resigning him.
Here’s a question that I’ve been unable to answer: Has there ever been a true franchise-caliber player who entered free agency at their prime and returned to their club? I can’t think of too many. The majority of franchise players are either taken care of before entering free agency, traded, or end up walking. Can’t think of an example where they test the market and return.
ABCD
Rick Sutcliffe 1984.
RunDMC
Not sure what your question has to do with Freeman. He’ll be 32 Opening Day 2022 — despite winning MVP in 60-game season — he’s not in his prime, though he should have few more good years @ 1B.
Strasburg went to free agency in 2019 and re-signed with WSH when they flipped over the couch cushions. (Maybe should have trusted their gut).
thecoffinnail
Cliff Lee was traded mid-season awhile back and chose to resign in Philly even after he was offered more money elsewhere. Top tier free agents that have Boras as an agent rarely sign extensions. He usually pushes them to free agency. A-Rod opted out, tested FA and resigned with NY. Céspedes did as well with the Mets a few years ago. It’s not often but it does happen. Although I can’t think of a time it happened with a small market team since the QO. No wait. I think the Royals gave Alex Gordon a QO 5-6 years ago. He tested FA and resigned with the Royals. There have been a few when the QO first started that turned it down and didn’t get contracts in FA. Remember Stephen Drew? He sucked after he turned down a QO and didn’t sign until May/June. Never the same after that debacle.
Johnny NewYork
Could easily see my Yanks trading for 10-12 of these guys. We have the highest money in the league so it’d be easy for us to do with no problems. Back at the mountain, babyay
For Love of the Game
Swept by the Tigers and left at the base of the hill crying like a baby!
pittsburghbob69
I would like the Yankees to get Colin Moran. I’m a Pirates fan but also a big Yankees fan too(my dad was a Yankees fan and I grew up one).
I think he fits nicely as a LH bat platoon with Voit at 1B, can also play 3B when Ursela needs a rest. And be a good LH DH.
Last full season in ‘19 batted .277 with 80RBI. Has a .272 lifetime BA.
He’s still just 28 years old, signed cheap for the 3 more seasons after this year too.
I wouldn’t mind the Pirates getting Clint Frazier or Gary Sanchez. And give them another shot with a change of scenery and out of NY.
Just not Andujar. Pirates defense is bad enough and he’s definitely not a 3B, and doenst play a good LF either. He’s not worth the offense potential for the hole on defense he would create for a NL team.
Robertowannabe
If Cherington trades Moran, it will not be for an OF hitting under .200 with a past history of defensive issues or a catcher hitting .200. He already has those on the roster. It will take some young high upside guys. This is not Neal Huntington making trades any more. Cherington is all about building quality depth and is gaining that from AA down. He is still going to make the same kind of deals that he has made since he got here. The Bucs are making deals with the idea that they will be competing in 2023 and beyond. Frazier and Sanchez are of no value in that plan.
PutPeteinthehall
You’re almost at the cap. Kluber not looking like he is going to make 12 starts this year. You want to add salary yet they are on record as wanting to reset the luxury tax. There is probably room to add one player at the deadline and maybe another thru trade if someone wants to swap salaries. That’s it. You have what you have this year. The offseason business dealings will be interesting and can’t say Yankees are a favorite for the pennant so far this year.
PutPeteinthehall
If anyone thinks the Pirates are taking on additional salaries this year I’ve got a bridge for sale. Lol.
Brownsfan83
2nd
Brownsfan83
Freeman
Ducky Buckin Fent
Not a whole lot that is going to help the Yanks on this list.
We may be one of the few (only?) contenders (perhaps using the term a bit loosely) that actually doesn’t need help in the pen.
& in the rotation I can write Cashman’s line now: “we felt the return of Sevi & Kluber were better additions than anything on the market etc, etc.” That actually may not be overly far fetched this season.
Obviously, (further) injuries could change this, but as crazy as it sounds our pitching *should* be ok.
So.
The offense/lineup.
Could definitely use an upgrade in CF.
I guess that leaves…Taylor? Certainly not all that exciting. But he brings defense & speed. I believe we have a grand total of 3(!) hitters with an OPS above .700.
Meaning he would actually be a welcome addition.
Perhaps we can trade for all the leftover baseballs from 2019 as that seems to be the missing element, instead.
StudWinfield
T. Anderson, Peralta and Taylor are all good depth options if Yanks going stay on budget.
tedtheodorelogan
Either Matt Boyd or someone in the Tigers front office has some dirt on Tim Dierks, because that dude has been mediocre at best his whole career but I’ve been hearing about how much trade value he has for years. If my team was looking to upgrade their rotation in hopes of making a playoff push and the best they could do is Matt Boyd, I’d be irate.
For Love of the Game
Boyd can shore up the back end of a rotation, but your team is already in trouble if you think he’s going to personally turn your team into a contender!
JoeBrady
He has his moments. His ERA+ has been > 100 in 3 of the last 4 seasons. And the one thing you can count on, in every sport, is that there is always a GM that thinks he is smarter than the rest of the world.
The issue could be getting Avila to admit he was wrong to not trade him earlier.
stymeedone
Can’t say whether or not trading trading Boyd earlier was wrong as no one knows what was offered. We only know what Avila was asking for was not met. Boyd is a reliable MLB pitcher who shows potential with his spin rates. That should require more than a lottery ticket, and that may be all that was offered.
Deleted_User
LOL
jjd002
I can only imagine at least 2 of the relievers end up in Houston?
13Morgs13
How are the Phillies not in this listen anywhere
positively_broad_st
NL East – too soon to give up. At this point they’re either standing pat or trying to add to the roster…
When it was a game.
Think the entire NL east are going to hold off. Its really still anyone’s division.
Dexxter
The Mets are in front by a bit… but they are dealing with a lot on injuries and have 28 games in the next 28 days. 15 of those games are against divisional opponents…. and 11 of the other 13 games are against the Padres and Cubs.
No one on the AL East will decide to sell until this stretch is over.
RunDMC
Not to mention having the most postponements of anyone via Covid (opening series vs. WSH) & rainouts, playing the fewest games of anyone.
VonPurpleHayes
Everyone in the NL East is injured and underperforming, but 1 series sweep and they’re contending for first. I don’t think the Phillies will compete at the end of the season, but unless some team goes on a significant run, I don’t see them selling just yet.
Cosmo2
If I were the Phillies I’d sell with an eye towards dominating next year. Yes, dominating. That division is up for grabs the next few years to any team willing to be smart and have a good plan.
mlb1225
I know the Pirates are selling, but I don’t see a plasuable scenario where the Pirates give up on Mitch Keller already. He’s been inconsistent as all heck this year, but he’s at the very least shown some life.
jimthegoat
Yeah, few if any teams can more easily afford to be patient with Keller than the Pirates.
mlb1225
They can give him the whole year, and likely part of next year. They might show some improvement over the next year or two, but their true window of opportunity doesn’t open until 2023.
mlb1225
Other than that, the Pirates need to move Frazier right now. He’s way out performing what his bottom line suggests. He only has a .335 xwOBA compared to a .382 actual mark, .394 xSLG compared to a .481 actual mark, 116 DRC+, compared to a 144 OPS+/wRC+.
Dexxter
Other teams look at the advanced stats too.
With an awful year last year and advanced stats that don’t support his current numbers the return is likely going to underwhelm.
Having said that they should still trade him. He’s not going to help their next competitive team.
JoeBrady
Thank you for this. My mantra is always ‘is xxx going to help you on your next contending team?’ If not, they should probably be traded at some point.
Rick Pernell
I see a couple of posts here about the Yankees, Speed and Center field.
How do you propose to use speed hitting behind LeMahieu, Stanton and Judge?
…… Sanchez is just king on the base paths.
Ducky Buckin Fent
That would be me.
Batting him 9th would be one way.
But then we’d be burying his .705 OPS. Which would be 4th on our squad.
Man.
Who saw that coming?
So.
Tough call, @Pernell.
Not like we run anyway. But the concept of speed on the base paths is fun.
positively_broad_st
Phillies should get Galvis back to play SS, play Segura and Didi at 2nd & 3rd. Send Bohm to AAA to learn LF. Have Odubel play left in the short term. Trade McCutchen to Milwaukee for either Cain or Bradley. Add another bullpen arm and a 4th starter by trading away from guys like Velasquez, Alvardo, Hasley, Kingery, Moniak, and/or guys from outside their top five prospects. Phils just need quicker, more accurate defense and move on from their high-walk pitchers. The sooner the better. The season is not lost…yet.
DarkSide830
Kingery has very little, if any, trade value
VonPurpleHayes
To add to your point, I don’t see many teams really wanting Cutch either. Unless he turns it around soon.
JoeBrady
Cutch turned it around a month ago, with a .872 OPS over his last 28 games. I actually like the idea because Cain and JBJ occupy the same space, and Mil might be better off with one CF and one LF.
And while all three are under-performing their salaries, I’d much prefer 4 months of Cutch v 1Y 4Ms of Cain or JBJ. I think the trade would favor Mil, but Philly might like the certainty of having a real CF for a couple of years.
samlumalo
Story to A’s for 3 prospects. 1 AA or AAA major ready infielder. 2 AA or A pitchers. My guess.
seamaholic 2
Story’s salary is $20m, so mid-season you’re looking at $10m still owed. A’s aren’t getting anyone like that is my guess, although if you ignore dollars yeah, he’s a great fit and would be aces on that team in the middle of that lineup.
PutPeteinthehall
Think Story on DL and two things would have to happen. 1) he’s healthy 2) they would want an almost ready player of higher caliber. Price would be high. Probably better off waiting until mid August to make a move.
bot
A’s have plenty money to spend on trade deadline players like story. All teams do – including rays.
That being said- since the controlling team already budgeted paying the player all year – they typically cover most of salary in situations like this get to max prospect return.
jvent
The Mets should make a big trade with Baltimore and get Means,Santander and Fry since the Mets will probably lose. a SP and OR Conforto If they lose any of them to free agency than In 2022 Means= Stroman or Syndergaard. Santander = Conforto. Fry = Familia(Bentances). And those new players are a lot cheaper than the Mets free agents.
Maybe send Baltimore: Lee,Szapucki,Mauricio (since they wont need a SS for a longtime) lol, JD Davis and another minor leaguer.
rct
Not 100% sure if I’m understanding this, but given Syndergaard’s injury setback, I could see him back on a QO. And Conforto’s struggles/injury might keep his price from skyrocketing. So I think it’s possible they’re both back next year, at least more possible than it was two months ago.
Stroman, however, could be pitching himself into a big pay day. He’s been very effective for the Mets. He’s only 30. I could see a 5/$125 million deal. Roughly what Wheeler got (Wheeler was 29 when he got that deal), but Wheeler had a more extensive injury history and did not have Stroman’s track record. So maybe Stroman gets more than that? I don’t know.
jvent
Conforto’s agent is Scott Boras he takes nothing less for any of his players, I can see Syndergaard taking a QO but this year that was $18. Mil besides the Mets getting Cano’s contract coming back on plus raises to players, that’s why I don’t think they’re going to sign all 3 of Stroman,Conforto and Syndergaard and don’t forget this year Lindors salary is $20 something, so starting next year Lindor is getting $34 mil per.
phillyballers
Vince Velasquez
keysox
Not much there for contenders.
seamaholic 2
i was gonna say the exact opposite. There’s a TON of talent on that list. Maybe no superstars, but there’s typically 0-1 of those each year mid-season.
jakec77
With all the injuries this year we may see more trading than usual- even below average players will have appeal to teams that are playing their 3rd and 4th string options.
riffraff
How is Kimbrel not on the “others to watch” for the cubs? He has been lights out and has a track record much better than Kennedy or Graveman
oldmansteve
Google the NL Central standings. First place teams don’t sell their closers mid season.
riffraff
@steve – read the article it says “others to watch” and lists several cubs. I would imagine none of them will be traded since the cubs are in first place mid season. I would make the argument that Kimbrel would be more likely than Bryant to be traded as I doubt they will offer a QO to Kimbrel and thus could lose him for nothing. But hey – thanks for the condescending reply nice to know I can google things.
mike127
Riff—-as I scrolled through the list the most glaring omission (probably oversight) without a doubt is Kimbrel. As much as Google is a challenge so is reading comprehension, obviously. Bryant, Rizzo, Baez, Contreras are all on that same first place team as Kimbrel.
ABCD
Cubs have a team option at the same salary next year. It’s not out of the question that they pick it up. They only have about $55 million on the books for next year (Hendricks, Heyward, Bote, Contreras, Happ).
And Kimbrel already was tagged with a QO. He can’t get another one.
That’s how he ended up on the Cubs in mid-summer. Zobrist went on the restricted list after Julianna did him wrong. Theo spent the money saved from that on Kimbrel before it burned a hole in his pocket. Well, at least it is working out well now.
PutPeteinthehall
Think the last month has made Cubs go to stand pat mode for now. Absolutely the best bullpen in baseball. Wick possibly coming back to reinforce. Cards were rated as favorites with Goldy and Nolan but seem to not have the depth required to win the division. When your team sweeps both the Dodgers and Padres ( yes I know the Dodgers were struggling and will be the team to beat in October) you wait until
mid August and see where you are then. My guess is if pulling away in the division everyone stays. They seem to like Bryant and since books will be cleared maybe he’s gets a career contract in Chicago. Kris might have learned from Jake to take the money when he can. Having the core guys as free agents has kept the pressure on and the reinforcements from outside the organization have been a welcome surprise that have risen the team. After seeing what the Padres have it will be interesting to see the Giants. Starting to believe only Dodgers are better this year in the NL.
ayrbhoy
RiffRaff- I would imagine the Cubs who had the best record in the NL for the month of May could have something to do with it! They will be buyers not sellers.
pittsburghbob69
I think C.Moran is a great option for an American League team. Better than A.Cabrera in my opinion.
He has a .272 lifetime average and his last full season in ‘19 he batted .277 and had 80RBI. A cheap, left-handed bat, still just 28 years old, and signed for 3 more years after this season. 1B/3B and would be a very good AL DH.
Moran should be a top trade option for AL teams needing a LH bat.
jim stem
Not sure what the Mets have left other than money, but Peterson could probably be flipped after another horrible start today for a proven, dependable innings eater SP. Khalil Lee, Mark Vientos, maybe…but they have to do something at this point. Can’t let this this 3 game lead slip away waiting for regulars to return.
Cosmo2
Jim Stem: I don’t wanna trade away the future in order to tweak what is already a first place team.
stymeedone
I could see Boyd getting moved but Turnbull would take an offer that makes Avila drool. Urena hopefully will bring back something, right as Tehran decides to finally pitch an inning or two. Grossman has meant too much this year for the team to move him. Plus they have no OF ready yet. Creating holes you can’t fill is not what you do 4 years into a rebuild. It might be nice to see the Kitties sign a player or two to an extension.
Deleted_User
LOL
BasedBall
Not a lot of high end talent on the pitching side.
Tons of solid depth arms.
If the Nats do sell Scherzer, they would be the only team with a HoF pitcher available.
I hope they do it.
Rhyde1990
I understand the reasoning for leaving Scherzer off this list, but I simply don’t agree with it based solely off the fact that the Nats were in this position in 2019. That team in 2019 was simply better than the 2021 team.
HubcapDiamondStarHalo
Doesn’t Scherzer also have full no-trade rights? I wonder if that was a factor in leaving him off the list.
The Saber-toothed Superfife
Like musicians don’t want to play at Carnegie Hall..
Stevil
With Kyle Lewis likely headed for surgery to repair his torn meniscus, Seattle might want to hang on to Haniger. Addressing their infield is going to be challenging enough. Subtracting Lewis and Haniger from the lineup isn’t going to make contention in 2022 any easier, especially given the slow start to Kelenic’s career.
compassrose
I agree with the Haniger thought. If Trammel keeps hitting like he did in Tacoma that might change a bit. I also find it funny how some are saying there is little in high quality players. I would think Haniger would be considered a HQ player. Goes on IL 2 years ago comes back like he missed a week from his All Star year.
Like I said on another post. We could trade Haniger for a 5 star 2nd bm ready to come up but blocked. The interesting thing in a few years we will have White at first ? at second Crawford at SS and French at 3rd. What happens when Marte comes up? If he is what they say would they put him at SS Crawford/France 2nd and 3rd? I know someone said why would you move a GG from his position? The answer is simple if the rookie is better and it improves the team.
Dipoto is awful as our friendly Angel friends keep telling us. How many positions do you have in this quandary? I know Dipoto screwed you so you have no young talent. We were there before Dipoto got here. He made some great trades and now we have positions we have an abundance of. I wonder how much of your problems are caused by Arte?
In closing I think Haniger is tied to Trammels success. We can mix and match in the OF until Lewis is back then next year or two down the road Rodriguez will be up. Can Lewis stay healthy that nobody knows. Sure hope so..
hoof hearted
Extend Haniger-see if he’ll buy in to what’s gonna happen.
If kikucki can get 15m, why not Haniger? 4-5 for 15+M./yr.
Middle of the order hitters don’t just pop up. Keep Mitch.
ayrbhoy
Compass- I’ve recently mentioned I’m a proponent of extending Haniger so I apologize if I’m repeating myself on some of these points. I believe the M’s will not trade Haniger because Dipoto and Servais’s contracts are tied to the teams success. The M’s are just a couple games back in the WC despite having the most (16) injuries in the AL. Trading Haniger for future talent postpones the competitive window for at least another yr and sends a message to the clubhouse that they’re giving up on this season. That’s not exactly a positive message to the fan base either. Re: improving the INF or Pitching by sending Haniger away is just ‘robbing Peter to pay Paul.’ You don’t improve the team in the near term with that philosophy.
All signs point to Kyle Lewis not returning this year. You can’t expect an OF of Trammell, Kelenic and Fraley to have any kind of production this season. In fact, if it weren’t for injuries at this rate one or more of that OF should realistically be going back down to AAA. At the minute Kelenic is looking like the first of those 3 to pack his bags for T-Town. What happens if one of those 3 are injured again? Julio Rodriguez could have a 1.400 OPS in the Minors this yr, he still won’t be promoted until mid-late April 2022 at the earliest due to Service Time. That doesn’t leave us with any insurance in the OF.
The M’s will nosedive if Haniger and Lewis are out of the lineup for the rest of the year- Would Dipoto really choose to further the rebuild one more year by trading Haniger? While he’s at it why not trade Ty France? Or Marco? K Graveman? We could become the CIN Reds or the BAL – in a perpetual state of rebuilding for a decade. There’s a chance that none of our OF prospects will ever reach the production we’re seeing out of Haniger. It’s time to win now. Keep Haniger and utilize your budget to extend him next yr as well as add more pieces in FA. In other words STICK to the plan.
ayrbhoy
One more thing Compass- re: Noelvi Marte. He’s 19 yrs old with 24 games/99 AB’s of pro baseball in the US. He’s so far off the radar. Besides those crowded position situations always seem to work themselves out. Injuries, slumps what have you. Besides, we saw Fraley then Trammell now Kelenic badly struggle to make the jump up from the Minors. Because of that, I don’t see this FO in a rush to promote him.
pittsburghbob69
Adam Frazier and Rich Rodriguez to Oakland for Tyler Soderstrom.
Tyler Anderson and G.Polonco to the RedSox for M.Chavis and Connor Wong.
Colin Moran and Erik Gonzalez to the Yankees for Clint Frazier and Albert Abreu.
J.Stallings, C.Kuhl(or S.Brault) and Chris Stratton to TB Rays for F.Mejia and Alejandro Pie.
StudWinfield
No need for Moran or Gonzalez. OF and SP. Anderson is best fit as depth.
pittsburghbob69
Yankees need a left handed bat in their line-up..Bad.
Moran is a really good LH bat to platoon with Voit at 1st base.
His last full season he batted .277 with 80RBIs.
Has a .272 lifetime BA. Still only 28 years old.
Plays 1b and 3B well. And would be a good LH DH in the AL too.
Yankees also need a good utility infielder. Bad.
Erik Gonzalez plays SS/3B/2B; all very well. He’s 6,3, 210 pound SS.
Plays great defense and can hit for average and power. Much better than Tyler Wade will ever be. And he’s only 29 years old and signed cheap.
100% Yankees need a good utility infielder like Erik Gonzalez if they plan on winning. Like Boston has with Kiki Hernandez. But Erik Gonzalez is a much better fielder and still more potential there hitting.
Again, he’s a big SS, 6’3-210. And Right now, I bet the Yankees would trade Clint Frazier for a bucket of balls.
StudWinfield
Ahhh, no. Platoon Voit? Lol
Robertowannabe
Your last sentence is why Cherington will never take Frazier nor most of the other guys you list for the Pirates. The Bucs are doing a total rebuild from the ground up. The Pirates might have considered Pie if not for all of the quality MI they just drafted and acquired. Good chance the draft one of the top SS in the draft this year. The Bucs are looking for deals that will help form a club and depth for that club starting in 2023. Most of these guys do not fit the mold.
gcc
sox dont need polonco or anderson. they need relievers. Sale will be back and they have duran who could come up if they need an outfielder. could see a Chavis for Rodriguez deal even though i dont want to trade Chavis
DarkSide830
that’s a stupidly light return in the last package.
YourDreamGM
Gonzalez lol. Teams will just get him on a minor league offer after he is non tendered.
justacubsfan
Just a suggestion,
But maybe the rankings could also include their likelihood, value, and factors with their corresponding scores. For instance, if gray is #1 for likelihood, #2 for value, #1 overall. Idk how much it would take, but it would be interesting to see where you have certain players ranked.
Great job, MLBTR staff.
MarlinsFanBase
As a Marlins fan, these are my thoughts:
Anthony Bass being traded would be satisfying. If someone is dumb enough to give us something, I’m for it.
Dickerson is very likely moved whether the Marlins are out of contention or not. We’re deep organization-wide in the corner OFs. If we’re contending, I could see him moved for bullpen help.
As for Marte, Yimi, and Duvall, that all depends on what we’re doing in the standings. If we’re out, they’re all very likely moved. If we’re contending, not likely unless involving moves that compliment or build up unforeseen trades. If the Marlins are out of contention, I could also see them moving Aguilar, Cooper and perhaps Rojas.
Dorothy_Mantooth
I’m just happy to not see the Red Sox on the sell list after that 2020 disaster. While I don’t see them being big buyers at the deadline outside of a relief pitcher or two, I can’t wait to see who they draft with the #4 overall pick this year. I’m hoping that no one selects Jaden Hill in the first round after his TJS, and he falls all the way to Boston in Round 2 (after the supplemental round). It’s amazing to say, but Boston is both rebuilding and competing at the same time! The Giants are doing it too (and better than Boston) but there’s a lot to look forward to in the upcoming seasons in Boston.
Ducky Buckin Fent
I’m pretty surprised by how well Boston is playing. But I think they are here to stay. Can’t say you & certainly @Joe Brady didn’t warn me.
JoeBrady
Here’s the thing that a lot of fans don’t see, and certainly very few of the RS writers see. The RS never lacked for talent. All 5 SPs are average or better, and that’s powerful. Their offense figured to top-3. And a combo of maybe a #6/7 pitching staff and a #3 offense, figures to be a 90+ win team.
Their issue was always depth. As you can see from Chavis, Cordero, Santana, etc., when someone goes down, we have a hard time replacing them.
So the surprise is not so much our number of wins, it is the fact that we haven’t lost a single inning from our pitching staff.
Cap & Crunch
Pivetta Eovaldi Perez GA have been terrific –
I was always a fan of Nicky P despite the crooked numbers
Alex Verdugo is very very good as well, probably a multi time ALL Star when all said and done –
Kiki will be a fav fan by July, if not already, guy brings a great winning energy
What further has to set alarm bells ringing for AL East counterparts is Boston’s payroll allows room for growth next year (while every bodies still locked in) and then completely go nuts for 23′ with a lotta cheap talent still locked in.
Taking ledger and pockets into account Boston’s outlook looks the brightest outta all 5 teams moving forward . If they somehow find a way to keep this pitching wizardry going from year to year in free agency/trades they will be tough to beat from anyone
jdodson1822
Raisel Iglesias has not given up a run in a save situation. All his runs have come when Maddon tires to get him “work”.
Matt_Angel_Bronco_Laker
Please allow me to begin with an apology for a long post, but I am passionate about it, so please bear with me or do not read it. Cool either way.
It has been a tough last 5-6 years as an Angels fan. We know that the Angels cannot win without Mike Trout. Sadly, we also know that they cannot win WITH Trout, either. Since 2016, Mike Trout’s last fully healthy season, the Angels are 357-406 (includes this season so far) for a .468 winning percentage. The Halos are playing under .500 ball with or without him, and he is now accounting for just over 20% of the payroll this season. Fortunately, the Halos are estimated to have a guaranteed payroll of roughly $109M in 2022, in which he would account for approximately 34% of that estimated $109M. However, if you excluded Trout’s $37M, it brings it down to $72M.
Sadly, it is time to face reality. It is time to burn it down and grant Mike the opportunity to partake in October baseball. It is time for baseball fans, not just Angel fans, to witness the greatness that is Mike Trout.
This type of bold and questionable brainstorming requires a buy-in by the same superstar in Trout to waive his no-trade clause. My hope is that he would want to stay “in the area.” I also thought Arte Moreno would not want to trade the greatest player of our generation to the unrealistically categorized nemesis, the Dodgers. What better way to get back at the Dodgers than to deal Trout to the San Diego Padres for him to, 1) Stay in the area. 2) Play meaningful baseball in October. 3) Be surrounded by an uber-talented roster. 4) For Arte to get back at the Dodgers by giving the Padres another piece that could potentially eliminate the Dodgers come post-season time.
The Angels trade Mike Trout and Andrew Heaney to the Padres for their three top prospects; LHP MacKenzie Gore, SS CJ Abrams, C Luis Campusano, and 1st basemen Eric Hosmer. No money exchanges. Just what is listed.
The Angels should make several other trades, but I will not exhaust that list other than to tell you what they should not trade and only one trade to make. Do NOT trade from the 40-man roster; Shohei Ohtani, Griffin Canning, Chris Rodriguez, David Fletcher, Anthony Rendon, Jared Walsh, Jo Adell, and Brandon Marsh. Though not on the 40-man roster, I will include Reid Detmers, the Angels 2020 10th overall pick, to not be traded. Everyone else is a free game to see what you can get for them. Justin Upton is not going anywhere with his trade clause and monies owed next year. Trade anyone not listed above to the Milwaukee Brewers for Josh Hader. As little or as much as they want. Just get that deal done.
2021-2022 Free Agency:
1. Sign Max Scherzer: 3yrs/$90M.
2. Sign Noah Syndergaard: 2yrs/$40M (2023 Player Option)
3. Sign CJ Cron: 3yrs/$9M.
4. Sign Andrew Chafin 4yrs/$32M
5. Sign Brad Hand 2yrs/$5M (2023 Mutual Option)
6. Sign Hector Neris 3yrs/21M
7. Sign Adam Ottavino 2yrs/14M (2023 Player Option)
8. Re-sign Max Stassi 3yrs/4.5M
Why give Eric Hosmer a platoon?
Eric Hosmer career OPS Vs. Lefties: .669
Eric Hosmer career OP Vs. Righties: .818
CJ Cron career OPS Vs. Lefties: .827
CJ Cron career OPS Vs. Righties: .758
Bring up all the kids and see what you have.
The 2022 Angels:
C. Luis Campusano
1st. Eric Hosmer
2nd. David Fletcher
SS. CJ Abrams
3rd. Anthony Rendon
LF. Jared Walsh
CF. Brandon Marsh
RF. Jo Adell
DH. Shohei Ohtani
Bench 1. Justin Upton, LF/DH
Bench 2. CJ Cron, 1st/DH
Bench 3. Max Stassi, C
Bench 4. Taylor Ward, OF/3rd
Bench 5. Luis Rengifo, 2nd/SS
SP1. Max Scherzer
SP2. Noah Syndergaard
SP3. Griffin Canning
SP4. MacKenzie Gore
SP5. Reid Detmers
SP6. Shohei Ohtani (Swing Starter)
Bullpen 1. Jamie Barria, Patrick Sandoval, or Jose Suarez (Competition in the Spring)
Bullpen 2. Chris Rodriguez
Bullpen 3. Brad Hand
Bullpen 4. Hector Neris
Bullpen 5. Andrew Chafin
Set-up. Adam Ottavino
Closer. Josh Hader
With these subtractions and additions, the 2022 payroll could on or around $172M for 2022. It is a solid blend of veterans, youth, and some right in the middle of their careers. The starting rotation and bullpens are revamped and ready to support the offense.
Versus Righties:
1. CJ Abrams
2. Luis Campusano
3. Shohei Ohtani
4. Anthony Rendon
5. Jared Walsh
6. Eric Hosmer
7. Jo Adell
8. Brandon Marsh
9. David Fletcher
Versus Lefties:
1. CJ Abrams
2. David Fletcher
3. Anthony Rendon
4. CJ Cron
5. Jarred Walsh
6. Justin Upton
7. Jo Adell
8. Luis Campusano
9. Brandon Marsh
And before anyone asks… Yes… I have a job. And no… I do not have a life.
ABCD
Just talking through it helps, I’m sure.
WeeWoo
Matt_Angel – it’s gotta be tough being a Halo’s fan, seeing the greatest player since The Kid wasted on such a middling team that is still spending money.
compassrose
I have to know did you do that from memory? If so hats off if not you have to be getting a couple good subscriptions. With my dumb comments you can tell I don’t prescribe to any. I was wondering if you take Trout over Jr? Depending on age you should have seen both enough. It is hard for me but will tip to Jr because he was an M. Anyway nice read. Man what is the world coming too I am complementing an Angels fan. Lol
BasedBall
I think that return is a little light for Mike Trout.
Wouldn’t the Dodgers be willing to offer more?
Gavin Lux, Keibert Ruiz, and Josiah Gray would seem like a better deal for the angels
phantomofdb
Sending off trout without any salary relief wouldn’t net what trout would otherwise be worth. He’s still producing like a madman, but baseball has an extensive history of the backend of these deals being terrible. He’s still owed 10 years @36 per. I think expectations of a massive return would need to be held in check.
BasedBall
A team like the Dodgers is willing to overspend for top end production.
The length might give Friedman pause but he gave a massive deal to Mookie because of his production and personality.
Andy would have no problem giving up top talent but he probably asks for money to offset.
These things aren’t so cut and dry, the way fans want to understand them as.
Everyone has a price and their price is constantly moving.
Tatsumaki
Dodgers would have to include bellinger in any deal imo. Dodgers won’t saddle themselves with 3 35 plus million contracts for short term gain. Trout and betts would something to see for sure.
Dodgers receive
Trout
Fletcher potential replacement for seager
Angels receive
Bellinger
Lux
Gray
Ruiz
@dan55 your also not getting trout and not giving up Abrams. Trout is likely worth 10 times Abrams even if he pans out.
dan55
I wouldn’t trade Abrams at all. He has superstar potential and Mike Trout is getting older(though he’s still amazing).
My trade for Trout would be Gore, Marcano, Campusano, and Hosmer for Trout. Maybe a couple extra throw ins on both sides, but those would be the main parts moving places. The Angels would probably decline this trade, but that is all I would offer.
The big problem with the Padres taking on Trout is that his contract is paying him about $36 million for the next decade, and the Padres have two long-term deals on the books with Machado and Tatis.
jjd002
There is literally no prospect off the table for Mike Trout
stymeedone
There are many teams, due to their payroll, or their rebuilding status, that have no interest in taking on Trout’s contract. So… Their are literally many prospects off the table when discussing a $300MM contract. Detroit, Kansas City, Baltimore and Pittsburgh are not stripping their farm for that privilege.
jimthegoat
There’s not a team in baseball that wouldn’t take Trout’s contract. You aren’t getting that kind of production for cheaper elsewhere.
Cosmo2
Very few teams would or even could take on that contract. But the Yanks might bite.
stymeedone
They might take his contract, but they won’t empty the farm for the privilege. Not every team runs a $200 MM payroll. Just try talking Tampa Bay into adding that salary. Angels are running close to $200mm, and can’t win with him. Dodgers are winning because of the home grown talent, which is cheap. That’s what allowed them to add Betts. Dodgers don’t win with Betts alone.
jimthegoat
The Rays would absolutely add Trout’s contract. The idea is that having Trout on their team would allow them to spend less money elsewhere and still win more games. At least in theory. If that isn’t true then that means Trout would actually have negative trade value.
But I do agree that a rebuilding team isn’t going to give up prospects to take that contract. If they’re going to lose anyway, they might as well lose for cheap.
Cosmo2
The point is the theory is flawed. The Rays wouldn’t take on Trouts contract precisely because that is the type of theory that fans believe in, but it doesn’t hold up in the real world. In the real world no one player, not even Trout has that type of impact in this game. Trout doesnt allow them to spend less elsewhere, he’s just one piece of a big puzzle. (Plus I think the Rays would get more value from that money by spreading it around anyway).
jimthegoat
@Cosmo2 then you are, by definition, arguing that Mike Trout has negative trade value. And no, not just to the Rays. To every team.
Cosmo2
I mean, in terms of value vs cost, yes, unless you’re a bottomless payroll like the Yanks or Dodgers, that is exactly what I am saying. His contract could cripple many teams. Of course a team like the Twins who seem to win without commitments could maybe make it work. But those big contracts are usually more hindrance than the players value.
Deleted_User
Hate to break it to you pal but Trout is going to cost you your “untouchable” prospects. All of them.
jjd002
And they will still finish third
JoeBrady
The Angels should’ve put Trout on the block at the same time as Betts was traded. If Betts was worth Verdugo, Downs and Wong, I have no idea what Trout would’ve been worth.
But now? Going by what phantomofdb said, Trout’s long-term value is a little more questionable. He’s still really good, but less than healthy, and his 1.090 OPS is highly dependent on a .456 BABIP (.348 career) and HR/FB of 30.8% (21.6 career), and his W/K has declined from .71 to .66, and GB/FB is 1.23 against a career .89.
He is falling off from a 1st ballot, maybe unanimous HOF level, to a merely AS level, but with $37M/year until age 38, he is no longer the best value in baseball.
Fly over fan
Personally I doubt Syndergaard only signs for 2 years plus option. I’d think a 7 year deal would the ask.
bot
Angels are reds/Rockies just with money to spend. Doesn’t matter how talented your team is – when it’s broken at the top – there’s no chance for success. Not even when trout and ohtani fall in your lap
Hudson6
The fan who made this trade proposal is very obviously an Angels fan. It seems he prefers Gore, Abrams and Campusano to Lux, Ruiz and Gray.
ayrbhoy
Hudson- You mean the trade proposal by Matt_Angel_Bronco_Laker? What gave it away?
Cosmo2
bot: the Angels have no money to spend because they are paying so much at the top for guys like Trout, Ohtani, Rendon… No one fell in their lap, they paid out the nose for them and now their payroll is maxed out. They’re too top heavy and that’s why these mega deals are rarely worth it.
bot
Ohtani is making 3 million this year. He signed after mlb changed their international prospect rules that got Luis Robert 26 million. If those rules where still in place – teams would have spent 50+ million to acquire his services as he was more highly regarded than Robert- which would not have been angels. Then he picked angels due to geographic reasons. And 20 teams passed on trout.
Angels best 2 players fell in their lap.
And they aren’t out of money – they just wasted all their cap Bc they have no clue what they are doing. Which puts them in same boat as reds and Rockies. Arguably worst ran franchise in baseball and professional sports as a whole
Cap & Crunch
Nice post, you have put great thought into this –
I think You’d be able to get more for Trout,
Gores stock is way way down right now and Hos (altho getting cheaper) is still underwater but I hear ya w the principle of trading Trout as the bigger story –
Shoulda coulda woulda but damn Ryu Wheeler>Rendon …wish I had more for ya
Arte is very perplexing, tough fandom path you follow, stay strong and GL
joew
adam frazier is almost a lock to be traded sooner than later. up there with the league leaders in hits and even being at the top off and on and hes a gold glove candidate the past couple years.
He has hit well at every level and could very well lead the league in avg… his problem is that he slumps hard. Couple times the pirates had to send him down a week or two and he would come back doing well again.
With his control he should bring in a pretty good package. he is an everyday second basemen… well … unless you got a darn fine one already.. then he can pretty much play any other position should the need arise.
I really did think the mets would be the place he would go last week.. just made sense.
again as with many of the pirates traded in recent years… i hate to see him go i’ve been rooting for him since he made the jump to AAA
tigersgm
Appears tigers will be busy, hopefully Avila didn’t continue to blow it..
2012orioles
Galvis has a $250k bonus on his contract of traded. Rooting for him to get his money and he probably will
Johnnymarty95
I can see the Astros trading for Matthew Boyd and Yimi Garcia. I could also see the Mariners trading away Haniger and probably Seager as well for prospects.
joew
Stallings has a rather large trade value. he’s an 100 OPS+ type of guy who tends to hit when its needed. Plus defense with control through 2024. by 2024 though he might be on a down trend but still should be a quality cheap backup at that point.
The ONLY way you can let him go though is if somewhere along the line you pick up a good quality catching prospect through any number of trades done.
Brault coming off a high in 2020 got injured and hasn’t played. he’d bring in some decent stuff but not expecting much in return. If the value isn’t there well then just keep him because you need some arms to get you through the rebuild and its fairly cheap. In the last off season i figured he’d be gone given his better performance in 2020.
Khul really has no trade value, kinda like with brault.. you’re going to need arms might as well keep him cheap.
Cahill not much different but on his short deal take whatever someone will toss at you.
Anderson.. won’t bring back a lot either but hes doing okay for what could be a backend type guy could bring back something interesting.
Keller is an interesting mention though. He will go some where else to learn how to properly put glue on his fingers increase his rpms and become a cy-young candidate. (pretty sure that is /s). Keller is crazy inconsistent from batter to batter. but… it does look like he is making progress on that. His value is low and anyone going after him is looking for another pirates lopsided trade. thankfully its not Huntington making the calls now.
IMO: keep brault Kuhl and Keller. the trade value isnt there and they need arms to fill the rotation that is cheap.. and they check all the boxes…. maybe they’ll be bundled in or someone will give more than Milb depth…
just this armchair gm’s opinion.
madmanTX
If the Rangers do trade any of these guys, there better be no doubt that they won any trade. In other words, “hand over your top five prospects”.
BasedBall
For Kyle Gibson?
No thank you
seamaholic 2
Hah. There’s literally no one associated with the Texas Rangers organization for whom you could make that demand or anything close to it. Was watching them play the Rockies last night and they’re way worse than Colorado, which is saying something.
beckmt
I think you are totally wrong to ignore the two elephants in the room, Buxton and Berrios. Twins will get very little return for two good players if they are not moved this midseason. They both are FA after 2022. I would try and resign, but if they tell me they are going to FA it is time to move them now.
bot
Twins need to keep those pieces. They can work their way back into contention or atleast regroup over next two seasons. Once u deal those two – it’s full rebuild mode though and you are still paying Donaldson
seamaholic 2
Twins have (as usual) nothing on their long-term books. There’s no reason they wouldn’t extend Berrios, given how young and good he is. And Buxton is in the same boat. Besides, they’re having an awful year but they have a great farm system and next year could be completely different. They’re not selling.
1984wasntamanual
I can think of a reason not to extend Buxton. As talented as he is, the injuries would scare me away. That issue rarely gets better as guys age and Buxton depends on his legs for a non-inconsequential portion of his value.
beckmt
If you want to meet their full market value or slightly more price. Don’t think the Twins are there. You are talking $20 – $25 million a year for Berrios and somewhere in the neighborhood of $25 million a year for Buxton. That assumes they are even open to resigning with the Twins. We have a month to get those questions answered.
Cosmo2
I’d trade Buxton if there’s a taker who thinks he’s for real right now. Sell high. Berrios try and extend.
bykoric
Rumor from Chicago media: Ricketts is going to order Hoyer to unload Kimbrel in June in an effort to “destabilize” the team and force a sell-off later.
Me, if I’m the Cubs, I keep everyone and break the bank for Scherzer and Means (or equivalent)… load them into the rotation and be like: one last ride! I may have just doomed the team to a 7-year rebuild because they’ll get zilch for the impending FA’s, but another ring is too nice to pass up.
Dunk Dunkington
Just stop!! Lol
Ricketts are not go tell Hoyer to trade Kimbrel to destabilize the team, that is total nonsense.
bot
As is everything else that comes from media
RoyalsFanAmongWolves
you do know another ring is not a guarantee?
butch779988
If the Red Sox slide, JD Martinez could be a huge piece to move.
Bits_of_Real_Panther
I thought it was weird that there was no mention of JD or any other Red Sox – they have a few good candidates, especially arms
seamaholic 2
Not that huge. DH’s who can hit and make a lot of money aren’t that valuable.
Bits_of_Real_Panther
He only has two years left and he can really hit
drew ford
Scherzer to the Blue Jays makes a lot of sense if the Nats sell.
jimmertee
Robbie Ray and Marcus Semien should be on this list. Jays are out of playoffs for sure.
seamaholic 2
Jays aren’t selling.
jimmertee
The BlueJays are currently last in MLB in starter innings/start at 4.1. No team can is doing that over 162 games because it requires the innings to come from the bullpen and there are not enough quality and healthy relievers on any club to do that over 162 games.
The Jays cannot win a playoff spot over a 162 game season with this strategy.
They need to be sellers and position to win next year.
We always need to remember that good pitching beats good hitting head to head.
We always need to remember that while hitting sells tickets, good pitching and defense wins championships.
bamck
Haniger would be a great fit on the Red Sox. They desperately need another reliable outfielder. Danny Santana is not it.
denistaylor
Off topic but I’m curious. Why does Panik get credit for a sacrifice fly yesterday at the end of the game when the outfielder dropped the ball?
seamaholic 2
Why wouldn’t he? What else are you going to call it? Can’t call it an error because it doesn’t matter whether he caught it or not.
denistaylor
Looks like it was ruled both an error and a sac fly, according to the box score. Here’s the actual rule: (If the ball is dropped for an error but it is determined that the runner would have scored with a catch, then the batter is still credited with a sacrifice fly.) Error was still called on the play.
seamaholic 2
Lots of potential sellers and good players possibly available, but where are the buyers, especially for high priced talent? I don’t see a lot of them, to be honest. The big boys will be bargain hunting (Yankees because of their stupid insistence on staying below the lux tax, Dodgers because they don’t need anything besides relievers), and most “competitive” teams aren’t even sure they’ll get in a wild card game. Absence of dominant teams (hell the Dodgers and Padres aren’t even in first place at the moment) is gonna kill the market.
jesseglaubitz
One thing that I’ve noticed before, that this list makes clear: there is no lefty relief help available.
Logjammer D"Baggagecling
If the cubs can keep winning I don’t see why they would trade any of KB,Rizzo or Baez. They need a starter so maybe Michael Pineda.or Michael Boyd. As long as they don’t trade Amaya or Marquez.
tonyinsingapore
Seemingly a lesser researched/written story…
kevincwilson
Nationals????? Stras and Max?? Why aren’t they on this list
Tatsumaki
What would it cost angels to get Marquez and gray in a package?
I’d definitely include adell, Chris Rodriguez/Reid detmers and jack kochanawicz. Maybe a bit more if they threw in story.
jimthegoat
Makes no sense for the Angels to trade for either of Gray or Story the way things are going. Better to just throw money at them next winter.
A Marquez-for-Adell framework could definitely work tho.
86mets
So where’s Bryan Reynolds if Pittsburgh? Switch hitting CF who can play all 3 OF spots, can hit, is still fairly young and cost controlled on a team going nowhere.
Cap & Crunch
Probably a good time to offload Castellanos….The package won’t be great but it will help rebuild 4.0 this century nonetheless
Urena could be useful to 12~15 teams right now, Welcome to 2021
Cubs making my blow it up dreams a far cry from reality, good for them
Why isnt Jon Gray in a Braves uniform yet?
Ive been calling/begging for Haniger to the Dodgers for years ! Lets pull Trader Jerry outta retirement this 4th of July after a couple brews ..
RoyalsFanAmongWolves
Not sure why you have the Royals possibly trading Danny Duffy ? you know Danny “bury me a Royal” Duffy? Now I could see them possibly trading Michael A Taylor since he’s just a one year deal…But it would take a LOT to trade Danny.
The Saber-toothed Superfife
Will BigAl Avila step away from the buffet long enough to make a deal?
How about trading Hinch? He is doing a good job. Does he have trade rights?
Hinch for Madden + a top 15 prospect for the difference in salaries.
Then trade Madden to the Yanks,+ take on the Sanchez contract, get a good couple of top prospects.
Then trade Boone…ect…..
Trade anyone and everyone for Alex Reyes, preferably with. Gorman and Liberties…..Turnbull, Fulmer,Boyd, Candelario Soto and whatever it takes….
If St Louis won’t play ball,the East has plenty of wanna be’s…let Beck know and advertise it to put pressure on and raise the price
…
If only we could get BigAl to just, ‘ step away from the buffet, sir’!
The Saber-toothed Superfife
Or not…..