The Phillies announced that first baseman Rhys Hoskins underwent a successful Tommy John surgery to repair a torn UCL in his left elbow last week. He’s expected to be sidelined for four to six months.
It’s an unfortunate development for the 27-year-old. Recovery from this procedure isn’t as severe for a position player as it would be for a pitcher, but both player and team were surely hoping he wouldn’t need to go under the knife.
Before going down with the forearm injury that ended his season, Hoskins had a strong year at the plate. He hit .245/.384/.503 over 185 plate appearances, a marked improvement in the on-base and power departments over his 2019 campaign. He’s also in line for a substantial raise, as he’ll go through the arbitration process for the first time this winter. As a middle-of-the-order fixture, Hoskins should remain quite a bargain from a contractual standpoint.
The four-to-six month timetable opens up the possibility Hoskins won’t be available out of the gate next season. It’d take his coming in at the early end of that recovery timetable to have an uninterrupted spring training. As far as recent precedents go, Yankees outfielder Aaron Hicks underwent the same procedure last October and would not have been ready to return until June. Notably, however, Hicks’ procedure was on his throwing arm (Hoskins’ is not) and initially called for a more significant eight-to-ten month recovery timeline.
just great. a 1B needing TJS. what our luck.
On the plus side, they won’t be tempted to toss him in the OF.
That joke is two seasons old. Try again.
I guess we’re all made of glass
Man that sucks. How is the recovery time like compared to a pitcher needing TJS?
It’s in the article
Americans don’t read beyond the headlines.
Oh my bad, my eyes skipped that part. Sorry boys
Not true! I read the first two paragraphs
The real bad luck is that it happened when colliding with a former teammate.
That 7-game series against the Marlins has to go down as one of the worst in Phillies history. Coming in with a 90% chance at a playoff birth. Losing Hoskins, Realmuto and Spencer Howard to injury. Losing 5 out of 7, despite outscoring the opponent. The bullpen blowing some late-inning leads as per usual. You went from chasing the 1st place Braves, to not even being in the playoffs. Really that 7-game series defined the Phillies entire season.
As a Yankee fan I’m not overly sympathetic in regards to other teams injuries.
I – obviously – don’t want to see them, or whatever.
But the last couple years have jaded me on that particular front.
However, that certainly *is* a lot of missing firepower and talent. Can’t deny that, man.
I don’t think the Phillies are all that far away. Just need some (maybe a lot?) of help in the pen.
I’m sure I’m not telling you guys anything earth shattering here.
Yea. I mean this year especially, everyone was dealing with brutal injuries. So no excuses here. They just couldn’t step up, and quite frankly are not ready to compete with teams like the Braves and Dodgers.
Dodgers are almost on their own tier, man. (of course I think the Yanks can beat ’em though – uh?)
But in the NL I don’t see that much separation after that.
Good bullpens can be built in an off-season. Risky business. Anyone would hate to land a “haul” like the Rockies.
It’s certainly possible, however. I’d give it the full winter to see how everyone looks. Like most here, I think we’re in for a pretty weird off-season.
Yeah, injuries this year were to be expect. Almost like they have spring training for a reason.
This year was the double-whammy of ramping up, then shutting it down and a lot of guys probably thinking it was over… and then having to ramp up again with little to no lead-in.
The NFL seems like they’re dealing with the same thing, no pre-season, no gradual build-up… just WHAMM-O and games that matter (unless you’re the Jets and Giants.)
The Jints, man.
See?
I really need the Yankees to keep playing.
Ya know, I was just thinking how on the surface it’s counterintuitive. Over 100 less games were played yet there were *more* injuries. It really bears out the whole, “marathon not a sprint” cliche & the difference of preparation between the two.
Phillies need starting pitching too. What they’ve got now isn’t nearly enough.
Four straight years without a lefty in the rotation. Roster construction has been abysmal. .
When did hitting .245 become strong?
It’s the Mets, no big whoop
How did this injury even happen in his non-throwing elbow? Was it from swinging the bat?
A throw from C J.T. Realmuto went between Hoskins and the baserunner; the baserunner collided with Hoskins’ left arm. Think of a hyper-extended elbow that tore the UCL
How on earth does a position player get TJS on his non throwing arm? He will easily be back by opening day 2021.
See BDJG68’s comment above. Collision with a baserunner.
It’s nice to know being a Phillies fan is going to suck just as much in 2021 as it has in 2020.
And 2019.
And 2018.
It’s very possible they’ll be significantly worse next year without DiDi and JT. Plus it’s very possible JT will be with one of our division rivals. Good times.
I can’t wait for JTR to have a 700 OPS in 2021, and everyone rips whatever figure head is credited with signing him to the longterm deal in Philly
I’m dying laughing at all the press screaming for the Mets to give JTR $200M. Yeah, seems like a brilliant idea to set a record for a 30+ year old catcher… I’m sure that won’t turn tragic by the middle of year two.
Yup. I love Realmuto and hope the Phillies resign him, but he has overpay all over him. Some team is going to regret that signing, but it’s not my money.
Keep Didi, sign McCann to share catching duties with Knapp, and spend the savings on getting a legitimate CF. Improved up-the-middle defense and an instantly better team. Maybe even sign Kiké Hernandez for additional flexibility and defense. He is fantastic at 2B. The Phillies will otherwise be done with their pricey obligation to Arrieta. There are ways to improve the team even if Realmuto leaves. And with the expanded playoffs destined to hang around, they will be a tough out with Nola and Wheeler atop the rotation. The trick will be getting there, but a sharp GM can get it done.
Actually, 2018 & 2019 are worse than 2021. It’s depressing to lose. It is extremely depressing to lose AND to be beaten out by a team that used your players to beat you out.
I have Philly fans saying he is better than Alonso after a 60 game season lol.
I mean he was this year. It’s not really laughable. Alonso’s sophmore struggles were very evident, but also like Hoskins did with his sophmore slump, Alonso will find himself again. I don’t think Alonso will ever be the 50 hr+ hitter of 2019 again, but I don’t think he’ll struggle as much as he did in 2020 either. Hoskins gets on base a lot more, but Alonso likely hits more homeruns. Both are bad fielders. I think they are very comparable players despite your “lol.”
Hoskins was wayyyy better this year lol
I agree. It will also be the last year you ever say that imo.
Pete Alonso will ultimately be Steve Balboni 2.0.
Bellinger will never be a mvp again
Alonso will hit 50 again. This the worst he has ever looked and will look and he was on pace to hit 40+
Hoskins isn’t in the same conversation as him just bc he did better this year.
Hoskins will never have a year like alsono had his rookie year. Think about that
Hoskins rookie year was not a full season and guess what? He was on pace for 50+ homers. Lol. Now obviously it’s not fair to compare “on pace” to someone who actually did it. But Hoskins was an absolute beast in his first season. Then he struggled mightily in his sophomore year. Sound familiar? Alonso and Hoskins are very similar players. I fully expect a bounceback year from Alonso, but I don’t see 50 homers again because pitchers don’t give him fastballs anymore. He needs to learn how to deal with the breaking balls, but he’ll be fine. He definitely isn’t leagues above Hoskins. It’s amazing how comparable the two players are actually.
Alonso is a better hitter. It’s sad that this even a discussion just bc Hoskins did good and Alonso slumped for 60 games… I’m sure Hoskins is better than bellinger altuve Bergman and yelich too
Nice strawman. Let me try….
I’m sure Alonso is better than Bellinger, Altuve, Bregman, and Yelich too.
Why do you think Alonso is better? I’m not saying he is or isn’t. But your just stating future Alonso homerun predictions and Hoskins failure predictions.
I’m not, nor have I ever said Hoskins is the better hitter. I said I think it’s not crazy to compare the two. I do think you’re overlooking Hoskins’ rookie year though. It gets overlooked because he only started in August, but he hit 18 homeruns in that short span. It was record breaking. Obviously Alonso’s 2019 was more impressive and absolutely historic, but it’s important to remember they were both crushing the ball their rookie years. Then pitchers started throwing them garbage and they struggled. Hoskins adjusted this year, having a pretty solid year before his injury. He was actually on fire, carrying the offense before his injury. It has yet to be seen if Alonso will adjust, but my money is on yes. It’s not “sad” that it’s a discussion because they are very similar players. Both had phenomenal rookie years. Both struggled in their second year. We’ll see what happens next for Alonso. Does he turn into an all-or-nothing type of hitter? 40-50 homers with a ton of strikeouts? We’ll see. I think it’s foolish to assume he’ll struggle like he did this season, but it’s equally foolish to assume he’ll be just as good as he was his rookie year. Pitchers don’t pitch around rookies. Pitchers pitch around the guys who hit 53 homers. Want a bold prediction? I actually think Dom Smith is better than both Hoskins and Alonso, and I think Smith has a monster 2021 season.
Hoskins is a really good hitter and Ik he killed us in his first year. But Alonso didn’t have a full year and you don’t know if he would really have had a sophomore slump. He was on pace for 42 homers after all. And he was doing bad but I don’t if it was the word season or not. We really don’t know how his year would have gone under normal circumstances. That’s why I brought up the other players who are clearly better than the two. And smith is the best pure hitter out of the 3 for sure. But smith doesn’t have the ceiling that Alonso has.
I wasn’t saying he was. I used the names to say you can’t go off a 60 game season. All those players are amazing and hit like Rojas from the marlins. And Rojas hit like a all star. I was just saying I better not here anyone say that Hoskins is better than Alonso at the start of next year. He just isn’t. He is a good player tho. NL east 1B goes like this
Freeman
Alonso
Hoskins
Aguillar
Thames
Yeah. I agree with everything you said in this last comment.
I have no idea what’s going on with Philadelphia and all four of their sports team just injuries galore I mean every team decimated by injuries and not just this year for the late last four years for each team it’s been unbelievable
Where have you been for the last fifty years?
Philadelphia 1970-2000
London 2001-2005
Philadelphia 2006-2016
Palo Alto 2017-present
Thanks for asking.