The Yankees have decided to place outfielder Aaron Judge on the injured list, manager Aaron Boone announced to reporters including Erik Boland of Newsday (via Twitter). He’s dealing with a mild calf strain.
Boone made clear that this is only a precautionary move. While the injury is said to be merely a grade 1 strain, if that, the team is exercising ample caution with its star slugger.
Yankees fans will be forgiven for fostering greater concern than the skipper himself let on. Judge hasn’t topped five hundred plate appearances in a season since his mammoth 2017 rookie year, owing to a series of health issues.
It’s much the same situation with fellow middle-of-the-order centerpiece Giancarlo Stanton. He’s also sidelined with what’s hoped to be a mild leg muscle issue, but comes with the same sort of worrisome background. In their absence, former top prospect Clint Frazier could get a window to prove himself.
fair-critic
Tough blow with both power bats out (99 & 27). But if our basehitters keep awake like they were against Atlanta, we should be able to get by without rushing rehab for Judge or Stanton. The Yankees’ biggest thorn is pitching right now.
pasha2k
The NYY do not need either bat. They will mow every team with pitching n some hitting.
throwinched10
Cashman should just tell the fans when Stanton and Judge aren’t on the IL.
higgy5220
Haha very true
johnnydubz
Or when Clemens,Giambi,Sheffield,Chucky,Arod weren’t using roids
oldmansteve
If you were an athlete in the 90’s and you weren’t on gear, you were doing it wrong.
looiebelongsinthehall
BS to that Steve. They hid what they did because they knew it was wrong and against the law.
gdbyers
You’re full of it steve
Ducky Buckin Fent
Best comment I’ve ever read here, @nebraska.
Hat tip.
99 Captain Judge
@johnnydubz- nobody is using steroids on the Yankees anymore. Your boy, Mike Piazza was a big juicer also. So obviously the hall of fame is tainted with Rickey Henderson, Ivan Rodriguez and Jeff Bagwell all in. So please, just give it a rest already.
Chris 75
Out of curiosity, who was Chucky?
99 Captain Judge
@Chris- It was Chuck Knoblauch or @johnnydubz both known for their excellent defense.
wild bill tetley
I’m sure ‘roids are still around the Yanks and 29 other teams. Just a different form using different masking agents.
Halo11Fan
throwin… Very seldom do I laugh out loud at a post, I laughed at yours.
99 Captain Judge
Halo11Fan- you really need to focus on your own team & HOW bad it is. Very seldom do I laugh like I am right now at your post. So Thanks.
throwinched10
Yank4Life – oh come on, relax. He’s not personally attacking you…wait, Stanton is that you?
davidk1979
Something new poor guy
NY_Yankee
Stanton and Judge are becoming the new Ellsbury and Pavano. Always hurt
fair-critic
That’s a bit extreme to say, best be optomistic
ctyank7
Judge, for all his talent, is never going to land that nine figure contract due to his brittleness. When you can’t be counted on to remain healthy, your value erodes.
sfes
They used to say the same thing about Jose Reyes before he got his. And he wasn’t half the player Judge is.
LordShade
Jose Reyes was way more productive than Judge has been. Reyes was an elite leadoff hitter for years, while Judge has had one elite season and is hurt literally all the time.
puddles
Judges injury issues are a consideration…but his Rookie year was more productive than any season Reyes had in his career
sfes
Being a lifelong Mets fan, I watched just about every game Reyes played with the team. At the point in his career where Judge is now, he was a great player but still had the ‘always injured’ stigma he was able to shake off. If the talent is there some rich turd will overpay. .
qbass187
100% accurate
99 Captain Judge
@LordShade- seriously your really comparing Jose Reyes to Aaron Judge? smh Only a Met’s fan would do this. And when was Aaron Judge a leadoff hitter? Please do your homework.
johnrealtime
Same with Giancarlo. It isn’t that hard to get 9 figures. He could miss tons of games for years but if he Is healthy and productive during his contract year he’ll get a big payday
oldmansteve
Reyes is probably half his size, but based on total production, they were about equal through their first 3 season.
sfes
I’ll give you that. Just accrued the value in different ways.
echozulu88
Is this like a yearly NYY tradition I never knew about? Him & Stanton getting hurt together?
GB85
This guy spends more time injured than actually playing.
13Morgs13
Time for Yankees fans to talk up Frazier for the 100 time
99 Captain Judge
13Morgs13- no need for Yankee fans to talk up Frazier anymore. His bat is doing all the talking now. This kid is a star who I’m so glad we hung on to. On the Phillies, Fraz would be your 3rd or 4th player best player. He doesn’t have to do that here. So have lots of fun looking up at the Braves for the rest of the year.
Dorothy_Mantooth
Yes, it’s been what, two games so far and Frazier’s bat is talking? JBJ was batting close to .500 in week 1 this year and Christian Vasquez was leading MLB in HRs. You’ve got to wait until he has at least 100 PA’s to see if he’s really worth anything close to the hype Yankees fans constantly spew about him. I know the answer: he’s not.
Ceiling of a 30 HR hitter, .260 average, 30% K rate with below average defense. Those players are a dime a dozen in MLB now. He can definitely start for 8-10 teams in MLB right now but he’s never going to be a true star in this league. Yankees would be smart to hold onto him as Gardy should be done after this season and Hicks/Judge spend way too much time on the IL.
P.S. – They wouldn’t get much for him in a trade.
MetsFan22
Lol him and Stanton
DodgerOK
Out with a grade 1 calf strain? Wrap it and get out there! These guys get to play baseball for a living.
Orel Saxhiser
Please don’t embarrass Dodger fans with your inane comments.
99 Captain Judge
@Cey Hey- he’s not embarrassing Dodger fans with his insane comments at all. He’s just embarrassing himself like most of the nuts on here.
johnrealtime
So that it gets worse and he misses playoff games or has more injuries down the road? He’s not making the call here, the Yankees are protecting their investment
99 Captain Judge
@DodgerOk- Ok, whatever you say I wish you my very best trying to catch the Rockies. Wrap up a grade 1 calf strain? Have you ever had that injury? Probably not. So how would you know how to treat it? smh
higgy5220
Is it retroactive to Wednesday or the 10 day clock start today?
YankeesBleacherCreature
He can play on the 21st.
Begamin
thats my bday!! what a gift that would be lol
bobtillman
If 3 more Yanks go on the Il, sox can win one game this weekend
pasha2k
I doubt it!
Angels & NL West
I don’t follow the Yankees closely, but Judge seems like a stand up guy and, of course, he’s a big time talent. I wish him a speedy recovery and continued health for the remainder of 2020.
jb19
Karma injury for all the cheating
99 Captain Judge
jb19- there is no proof of the Yankees cheating. Just because the Astros & Red Sox cheated and got caught. This is fake news that you have to let go of. Especially when there is no evidence of any cheating from the Yankees. Till then…
pasha2k
JBJ made a really dumb comment.
pasha2k
Sorry typo JB
rocky7
Quite full of it ain’t cha jb19…jealousy is a curse….get over it….get a life!
frank costanza
Rays are going to win the AL East with or without Judge or Stanton.
99 Captain Judge
@frank costanza- just because you want the Rays to win the AL East doesn’t mean it’s going to happen. It doesn’t work that way. So good luck with that. lol
pinstripes17
Lol sure they will buddy, only been saying that for like ten years!
nentwigs
Sorry to learn of Aaron’s calf.
How are his cows?
mlbnyyfan
Time to take trade offers for Judge or Stanton
99 Captain Judge
@mlbnyyfan- hope your just kidding brother? Judge & Stanton are both going nowhere. And neither is Sanchez. The Yankees will still win without Judge and Stanton in the line-up no worries cuz. The Rays are a great 2nd place wild card team that is all. Put them in the AL Central or the NL East and they could be a lst place team. Their in the wrong division.
jekporkins
I don’t think there is a team in the league that will want to trade for Stanton.
brucenewton
Nobody would trade for either.
Ezpkns34
Always a question of when he ends up on the IL, not if
99 Captain Judge
Ezpkns34- Yankees aren’t going to care if they win the division and have the best record and get to a World Series & win, and get Judge and Stanton back. So who really cares?
pburns65
lmao…comparatively speaking he’s Dave Kingman. At least Kingman stayed healthy! ROFL
Old User Name
Poor comparison. Kingman never had Judge’s defense or on base skills. He really couldn’t hit for as much power as Judge TBH.
99 Captain Judge
pburns65- now who are you comparing Dave Kingman to Aaron Judge Or Giancarlo Stanton? smh. Seriously? Kingman couldn’t even hit his weight that is the difference really. So do your homework please
99 Captain Judge
Definitely, the most ridiculous comment of the day for sure, there is no doubt about it
JerryBird
Kingman didn’t have the benefit of hitting a juiced baseball, All of baseball today has tainted home runs. Legal version of steroids.
jim stem
Muscle issues, imagine that? I bet John Kruk or Boog Powell never pulled a muscle!
Seriously, though, whatever happened to stretching, running and staying limber? It boggles my mind these high caliber athletes, in incredible shape, in the prime of their careers, constantly battle muscle issues.
Perksy
They do all those things, however they are big muscle bound guys. The more you lift the more injury prone. It taxes the muscle fibers, joints, ligaments, and tendons. Puts on a strain on it. John Kruk and Boog Powell drank beer and ate steaks and chicken wings. They didn’t have any muscles to pull.
trout27
Too much time in the weight room and not enough time actually playing. I think too many players over do it working out and don’t get the proper rest. Some players are just prone to leg problems. Stanton is certainly one of those and Judge is trending that way. What a waste of three hundred million for a DH who can’t stay healthy.
Perksy
And add in Judge’s oblique that he’s pulled a few times. A common injury for players that lift a lot.
jgus828
Have to question the training staff at some point
99 Captain Judge
I have to question trollers on here that hate seeing the Yankees win. Even when their star players are injured, they still win! So when does the jealousy end? Doesn’t this show all the TRUE talent they have on the team to play and win thru injuries to star players? smh
clepto
^^this idiot is one of those moron fans of NY who are first to complain the minute a losing streak happens.
Take a break, little one….we all see your schtick. You have not a clue what you are talking about.
99 Captain Judge
@clepto maniac- stop trolling on here nobody ain’t got no time for your chatter that makes zero sense! Your a no-name probably like the no name team that you root for. I DEFINITELY got a clue about that. I never complain about my team. I’m as loyal as you can be. So go get a hobby and stop trolling.
jekporkins
@yank… look, man, people aren’t jealous – they are laughing because Stanton and Judge are always injured and they are the big bruisers in the hyped lineup. It’s pretty simple to figure out. And is your name yank4life or is that what you do?
99 Captain Judge
jekporkins- look man, don’t worry about what I do. Worry about what you say & do. This isn’t the place to be obscene. Seriously ain’t nobody got no time for that! So stop trolling, being a pervert, and get a life, ok?
rocky7
Talk about clueless…..clepto is a very accurate and descriptive adjective for you although all of us “moron NY fans” probably can think of many many more.
clepto
Look two center of the universe morons in rocky and yank, who never left cess pool new jersey or new york. Nice try, but you both are little fan boys….at least today. Wait til a losing streak hits.
99 Captain Judge
@clepto maniac- why don’t you go be a hater somewhere else. Like get a real job not be annoying for a change. Go feed the Pigeons or something useful. Nobody cares how pathetic your life is. Seriously dude
clepto
Wow, a real crusher, fan boy
pasha2k
I am a RS fan but I enjoy Judge playing, n all the rest of the great team Cashman assembled. When you are a fan of baseball you enjoy the special players from other teams, too.
Dorothy_Mantooth
I’m with you there, Pasha. Baseball is better when Judge plays; however, some of the blame does fall on Judge for how he prepares his body for baseball season. Way too much heavy weight lifting and not nearly enough lengthening and ‘long muscle’ workouts. Just look up Aaron Judge workout videos and you’ll see what I mean. Don’t get me wrong, the guy is in incredible shape but those types of workouts tear muscles so the body naturally tightens/shortens them in order to repair (and grow bigger). Judge would be better served not picking up a weight again. He should be using resistant bands for strength training and spending more time with something like Yoga or Pilates to lengthen his muscles. The older you get, the less flexible you get too, so he really needs to change things up if he wants to play well into his 30’s.
mdunkel
Wow Stanton hurt and now Judge? I guess Yankee fan shouldn’t polish that Cooperstown Plaque just yet.
Perksy
Do you mean World Series plaque?
Yankee Clipper
Reality is that Judge and Stanton are both phenomenal and any team would love to have that combination in their lineup.
Reality is also that the jokes about when they’re going on the IL each year are accurate. As a lifelong Yankee fan it sucks; but Cash and crew need to do something about this and it’s their responsibility to do so.
If AJ and GS are going to be oft-injured, Yanks need to find suitable replacements. They cannot control calf sprains and pulled ribs. However, knowing this history, they can plan for this every single year. So far, it seems they’ve done a decent job. Fans of other teams can hammer us on this because it’s true…… and I’ll humbly accept it.
99 Captain Judge
@Yankee Clipper- I truthfully wouldn’t worry about replacements for AJ & GS. We are fully offensively loaded with players like Clint Frazier & Miguel Andujar that can play everyday right now. So the offense will be there. I’m mostly thinking of acquiring a starter by the deadline like Matthew Boyd or Robbie Ray. Starting to think Mike Minor will not be available for a trade with the Rangers likely being a playoff team. J.A Happ isn’t the answer. With Sevvy out with TJ, and Domingo German out being suspended. The Yankees got to get creative before the August 31st trade deadline and get another starter for their rotation. Ray is a rental. Boyd has another year on his contract after this one.
YankeesBleacherCreature
I don’t see a reason for the team to overpay for trade assets really as we don’t even know if this weird season will finish. You’ve got Cole, Tanaka, and Paxton as top 3. I wouldn’t mind again using Greene as an opener #4. He’s been really solid in his career.
Perksy
I’m not sure how much of an upgrade Ray or Boyd are to give up assets for. Both have upside and rack up the k’s but both pitch to high ERA’s. They’ve shown flashes but are now pushing 30. I feel more comfortable with them going internal.
99 Captain Judge
Perksy- yes, expect Clarke Schmidt to take J.A Happ’s spot in the rotation shortly. Schmidt wouldn’t be in any trade for Boyd or Ray anyway. Not saying that pitchers like Michael King, Al Abreu, Luis Cessa, Jonathan Holder, or Ben Heller wouldn’t be. I feel that Clarke Schmidt, Deivi Garcia, and Johnny Lasagna all will still be Yanks after the deadline and so will Frazier or Andujar.
OilCanLloyd
“We are fully offensively loaded with players like Clint Frazier“
Come on. I’m not trolling, but you open up to criticism and bashing by making such a comment. Speedy recovery AJ.
99 Captain Judge
PTSD Jays- Have you been watching the games lately? Frazier has been on fire. All he needs is to play regularly and get at bats. And that will either be for the Yankees or someone else. I’m biased. I want it to be with the Yankees. Not some other team. So take your time AJ and come back for the playoffs. The Yankees will be waiting for you there.
Dorothy_Mantooth
Fraizer has played two games so far! Slow your roll man
99 Captain Judge
@Dorothy_Mantooth- my point is if Fraz keeps on going on this way with the bat he’ll go from trade bait to kept player. Even with Clarke Schmidt on his way up shortly and J.A Happ likely heading for the bullpen as a long man. The Yanks will likely be looking for a starter at the deadline anyway. That’s why a Boyd or a Ray fit the bill. There is no reason why a Miguel Andujar can’t net either pitcher in a trade with Fraz staying playing leftfield this season and next season especially with Gardy likely retiring after his option being declined like you were saying. I do like the slow your roll man- good stuff and funny. Thanks for the laugh. I needed it tonight. Seriously.
pasha2k
He is no trade bait.
EasternLeagueVeteran
And wait for that first fumble in the outfield that costs you a game. Sing your tune now. Trade deadline is a little over two weeks away
Dorothy_Mantooth
There is no way Andujar alone brings back a quality starter at the deadline. While he did have a great offensive rookie year, he was hurt all of last season and he played so poorly this year (including that horrible play in LF) that they demoted him to the ATS. He has all but proven that his only true position in MLB is DH and since the NL does not have a DH next year (so far anyways), that limits what you can get back for him as most AL teams are well set at DH and not to mention, Andujar really hasn’t done anything at the plate since 2018 either.
99 Captain Judge
@Dorothy_Mantooth- Are you convinced that Frazier is a star now? Or do you need to see more? All he needs is the at bats to prove how good he is. That’s all.
Yankee Clipper
All great points. I do agree with Yank4 on SP. I think that is a fairly consistent weak spot middle to bottom. They should really focus on who they want to acquire and go for them in the offseason.
99 Captain Judge
@Yankee Clipper- thnx. The problem is the D-Backs are going to want Frazier for Ray. I wouldn’t and the Yanks aren’t going to trade Fraz for a rental. As far as Boyd he hasn’t pitched well like Ray so maybe the Yanks can get him cheaper as well. Thinking, Matthew Boyd, Michael Fulmer, and Austin Romine for Miguel Andujar, Michael King or Al Abreu, Ben Heller, and Jonathan Holder. That deal seems fair. It definitely looks like Robbie Ray or Matthew Boyd at the deadline for the Yankees. I think the Braves will trade for one of them as well, using Davidson, Muller, Shuster, or Ynoa as the bait.
Yankee Clipper
Man, I have to agree with you. Ray and Boyd have both been on their radar for a while, so it seems very logical that could occur.
99 Captain Judge
@Yankee Clipper- that being said I think I would prefer Boyd instead of Ray. I would love to expand the trade with Detroit with Fulmer and Romine coming back here to NY. Austin is the perfect back-up to Sanchez. We miss him. Yanks could always expand the deal with Arizona to include Archie Bradley along with Ray. It all depends on which team would want Andujar more to get a deal done.
Yankee Clipper
Yeah, more great perspective… I agree if those guys are included in the deal with Boyd. I miss Romine as the backup.
Fg-3
It’s a testimony to the “old school” athletes that used to play with pain.. Ripken, Jeter even the Juiced guys.. Arod Bonds.. in there prime. Never landed on DL. They played through. Now a days if a hitter has a hangnail it’s 10 days! Lol. I love to watch our lineup when fully healthy. Problem is between “resting” and injury it’s few and far between
EasternLeagueVeteran
Don’t think agents aren’t without influence. On the other side of town, Cespedes who is playing for a contract, decides to opt out. He and his agent decided that it would be better for him to do a showcase fir a contract rather than try to play this season and show everyone he either isn’t healed, isn’t motivated, or just plain lost it, or any combination of the above.
99 Captain Judge
rule-5-draft-dodger- All Cespedes wants to do is hang out with beautiful Cuban women on his rancho and on his yacht. He would rather ride horses and play golf then play baseball. Last time they saw him he was hanging out with Captain Morgan when they found him later he had a little captain in him and was looking for his lost shaker of salt. Nevertheless, it wouldn’t surprise me if next season he is playing for his favorite manager, Bob Melvin in Oakland. He said that’s where he wanted to be shortly right after signing with the 3rd best team in NY. smh
99 Captain Judge
It’s funny how the Braves need starters. The Yankees got a few arms that could help them right now. In Mike King and Al Abreu that could help them win the division. The Braves need to call up Tucker Davidson today and make a trade with the Yankees for a starter. A showcase start for J.A Happ on Sunday night against Boston. If he doesn’t pitch well then Clarke Schmidt will probably get his spot in the rotation. The Yankees would definitely have a interest in Kyle Muller & William Contreras from Atlanta. Andujar, King or Abreu, Heller, and Holder probably could get that done. Yanks likely are holding on to Frazier now with the injuries to Stanton & Judge.
bayareabenny
Judge and Stanton hurt again, you don’t say, Ms. Cleo could have seen this coming.