We have recently been taking a look back at No. 1 overall draft picks from previous decades. After focusing on 2000-09 and the 1990s, let’s go back to the ’80s. As you’ll see below, most of these top choices had respectable careers. However, one player was far better than the rest.
1980 – Darryl Strawberry, Mets (41.5 fWAR in 6,326 plate appearances):
- We don’t need to rehash Strawberry’s many off-field issues. Let’s instead focus on what the outfielder did on the diamond, where he often thrived with the Mets, Dodgers, Giants and Yankees from 1983-99. Strawberry was an NL Rookie of the Year winner who made eight All-Star teams, took home four World Series titles and batted .259/.357/.505 with 335 homers and 221 steals during his time as a major leaguer. In other words, he lived up to his draft selection.
1981 – Mike Moore, Mariners (34.7 fWAR in 2,831 2/3 innings pitched):
- Moore was seldom spectacular, but he did carve out a nice career for himself among the M’s, A’s and Tigers from 1982-95, during which he made 440 starts and logged a 4.39 ERA/4.27 FIP. He was also a key playoff contributor for the A’s World Series-winning team in 1989 – the same season he made his lone All-Star team.
1982 – Shawon Dunston, Cubs (7.4 fWAR in 6,276 plate appeaances):
- Four picks before the Mets selected Dwight Gooden, the Cubs went with Dunston, a shortstop/outfielder who had a long career but wasn’t a high-impact player. Dunston appeared in the majors in each year from 1985-2002, and though he totaled 150 HRs and 212 steals, he was just a .269/.296/.416 hitter who never reached the 2.0-fWAR mark in a single season.
1983 – Tim Belcher, Twins (30.3 fWAR in 2,442 2/3 innings pitched):
- While Belcher enjoyed a nice major league career with a slew of teams, the righty wouldn’t sign with the Twins. The Yankees then selected Belcher in the 1984 supplemental draft, but they lost him to the A’s in the compensation pool. That reportedly left then-Yankees owner George Steinbrenner fuming. Belcher, meanwhile, went on to post a 4.16 ERA/4.27 FIP from 1987-2000.
1984 – Shawn Abner, Mets (minus-1.2 fWAR in 902 plate appearances):
- Abner, an outfielder, was a .227/.269/.323 MLB hitter who never even played for the Mets. They sent him and Kevin Mitchell to the Padres in a trade for outfielder Kevin McReynolds, who had a few productive seasons in New York. But Abner was a disappointment, concluding his time in the majors with just 11 homers. Mark McGwire, who went nine picks after him, finished with 583.
1985 – B.J. Surhoff, Brewers (31.4 fWAR in 9,106 plate appearances):
- Surhoff went one pick before Will Clark and five ahead of Barry Bonds, who turned out to be far better players. But that’s not to say Surhoff was a failure. He started his career as a catcher, later became a corner infielder/outfielder, and wound up a .282/.332/.413 hitter with 188 HRs, 141 steals, and an All-Star appearance between 1987-2005 with the Brewers, Orioles and Braves.
1986 – Jeff King, Pirates (17.0 fWAR in 4,812 plate appearances):
- King lasted from 1989-99 between the Pirates and Royals, with whom the infielder combined to hit .256/.324/.425 with 154 homers and 75 steals. No shame in those numbers, but fellow high picks Greg Swindell (No. 2), Matt Williams (No. 3), Kevin Brown (No. 4) and Gary Sheffield (No. 6) proved to be better players.
1987 – Ken Griffey Jr., Mariners (77.7 fWAR in 11,304 plate appearances):
- Here’s the best No. 1 pick of the ’80s – now a Hall of Famer and a sports icon. The sweet-swinging Griffey hit 630 home runs – the seventh-highest total ever – and made 13 All-Star teams in a career divided among the M’s, Reds and White Sox from 1989-2010.
1988 – Andy Benes, Padres (36.2 fWAR in 2,505 1/3 innings pitched):
- Benes was a capable righty and a onetime All-Star who combined for a 3.97 ERA/4.08 FIP with the Padres and three other organizations from 1989-2002. The workhorse threw at least 220 innings in a season five times. He also led the NL in strikeouts (189) in 1994.
1989 – Ben McDonald, Orioles (20.5 fWAR in 1,291 1/3 innings pitched):
- Neither McDonald nor picks 2-6 in this draft earned a single All-Star nod. Those six teams overlooked Frank Thomas, who went seventh. Oops. To McDonald’s credit, though, he had a decent career, as he thrice exceeded the 220-inning mark in a season and hung it up with a quality 3.91 ERA/4.08 FIP between Baltimore and Milwaukee after pitching in the bigs from 1989-97.
Ontopofla
Umm. Junior.
jeterleader
yeah duhhh
WorthlessDropInTheMonty
-insert irrelevant movie quote combined with really dumb dumb hot take- I need attention!!! I am Xabial lol lol lol LOLZ!!!
burrow_is_a_bust
Xabial doesn’t have the mental capacity to store so many movie quotes
jekporkins
Xabial… whoa…. blast from the past. is he still around?
oldmansteve
It’s clearly BJ.
Ketch
No love for Shawn Abner?
phillies012tg
His son is arguably more famous then some players on this list lol
bigbadjohnny
Strawberry……and Gooden……both had HOF paths…..and they destroyed it.
dynamite drop in monty
Dunston still boasts the strongest shortstop arm I’ve ever seen.
WorthlessDropInTheMonty
Thanks for that riveting comment. What else ya got Tons of Fun?
Tim_Buck-Two
Uhhhh Beavis this guy is acting like Rodger Clemens after Mike Piazza broke his bat on a pitch and the bat flew at him
jekporkins
Just a hunch but from their usernames I believe it’s a lover’s quarrel.
Black&Orange&Silver
I don’t think it’s even close. Griffey Jr is one of the greatest baseball players of his generation, if not All Time great. He towers above everyone.
everlastingdave
I grew up under the impression King, Surhoff, and Dunston were far better players than they actually were. Strawberry wasted his talent and still put up that stat line. What could have been.
The Human Rain Delay
Very observant, I thought the same exact thing, especially with Bj-
Think the errors probably kept Dunstons War down quite a bit, he collected them in bushels
But per plate appearance Bj certainly doesn’t seem to be the player I thought he was
LouisianaAstros
Dunston was a legit baseball player.
Guy had a cannon.
Surhoff was suppose to be a catcher. Moved around. Played multiple positions and was a decent professional.
Would have had a lot more value strictly as a C
Regarding King..
Don’t particularly remember him.
I am surprise Swindell didn’t go #1
Swindell is often called the Greatest College Baseball Ever.
The Human Rain Delay
Yea I thought Dunston was legit as well but his numbers above suggest otherwise-
I think it was just that cannon that was so amazing…kinda like Ozzie Smith doesnt make the Hall without the backflip kinda deal here
dandan
Definitely not Jr., Jeff King has better numbers across the board. Woo Pig, baby.
/s
hOsEbEeLiOn
I don’t think people understand how impressive Ken Griffey Jr hitting 630 home runs is.
In an era of rampant steroid use not once was Griffey never implicated or thought to have taken steroids.
He had a pretty natural start to finish in terms of batting in his career such that as he got older his hitting diminished gradually.
Nuke LaLoosh
Griffey was an awesome baseball player.
ayrbhoy
His 4 yr stretch from the 96’ season to the end of the 1999 season was just ridiculous. That 1997 season? Whoa! He had 93 XBH that year, 147 RBI, 15 SB w a line of .304/.382/.646 an OPS of 1.028, OPS+ 165, SeCA .485, ISO .342. The year before he had a bWAR of 9.7 then followed that up with a bWAR 9.1 in 1997.
Can you imagine having him on your fantasy team from 96-99?
If only he and ARod stayed in Seattle! Those 95-2001 teams had some great lineups- Buhner, Edgar, Olerud, Ichiro, Tino Martinez, J Cora at SS, McMlemore, M Cameron, Bret Boone’s 2001 (8.8bWAR*) steroid season!! Halcyon days…..
WorthlessDropInTheMonty
I don’t think you understand how little anyone cares about your comments. Do better!
hOsEbEeLiOn
Well, you took the time to comment. Clearly you cared enough to do that.
People who usually don’t care go on about their day. They don’t stop and comment.
Cool story though bro.
chieflove42
we sports fans are getting really bored
The Human Rain Delay
Belcher really fit into that 88 Dodger team like a glove
A non athletic, mediocre player, who along with many others that year in LA had a career year all at the same time
Even as a Dodger fan, I hate to say, that was one of the least intimidating Championship teams you will ever see in sports
The Mets and Oakland were just complete powerhouses that year
jagonza
As a dodger fan I agree that team showed that you don’t need stars to win. I think they had three starters that didn’t bat their weight
The Human Rain Delay
HAHA …Im guessing they were Franklin Stubbs, Alfredo Griffin and um……Sciosca ? (Just bc he weighed a pretty penny?)
LouisianaAstros
First team to win a World Series without a future Hall of Famer
Crazy thing is their starting catcher managed the second with the Angels in 2002.
His staff included Mickey Hatcher and Alfredo Griffin
ChangedName
Wow, great decade for #1 overall picks.
LouisianaAstros
It was hard for Ben to live up to the hype.
Haven’t seen too many pitchers enter pro baseball with his hype.
ESPN was trying to hype the sport and caught magic with the 1989 Regional when LSU went into College Station and knocked off what some claimed to be the Greatest Team of All Time.
Too bad his pro career didn’t work out but I don’t think Baltimore would have picked someone else if given a second chance.
hyraxwithaflamethrower
I think they absolutely would have picked Frank Thomas if they could do it over. Thomas had almost as much career WAR as Griffey, despite having far less speed and worse defense, meaning he was just that good at the plate.
In 2009, the Nationals took Strasburg #1. Very solid pick, nothing wrong with it, worked out pretty well for them. But given another chance, you can bet they’d have gone with a young OF by the name of Trout instead. You go with the best player.
martevious
Griffey has one of the sweetest swings of all time. I was privileged to see him hit home run #1, at the home opener in the Kingdome, 1989.
jekporkins
Well, I believe I saw him get his first hit ever off. It was his first at-bat. Dave Stewart was on the mound in Oakland. I believe it was a double.
ayrbhoy
Martevious- a privilege indeed. I attended the game where he tied the record with his 8th HR in 8 consecutive games. What a thrill. We lost 5-1 to the Twins that game but we didn’t care. It was pandemonium at the Dome that night! The Kid got the longest standing ovation after that HR, it felt like it went on for 10 mins!
Marc (Phillies Phan)
Jeff King for sure. No argument.
Kidding – Junior for sure. Better question for me is who was the second best pick.
Rsox
Darryl Strawberry.
Thru 1990, his last season with the Mets, Strawberry was halfway to 500 HR’s which would have guaranteed induction to the Hall of Fame. If the wheels didn’t come off in L.A. who knows how great the Straw could have been.
Bullsfan?
To be fair, if you discuss Dunston’s career you probably should note he missed 2 seasons, age 29 and 30, following back surgery. Fangraphs and Baseball Ref both have Dunston accruing most of his WAR prior to the surgery. After the surgery he only played 100 games in 3 seasons.
hyraxwithaflamethrower
Ok, but he still wasn’t nearly as good as Griffey.
louwhitakerisahofer
I’m still sitting on a stack of Ben MacDonald rookie cards. Any buyers out there? LOL
hyraxwithaflamethrower
There’s an argument to be made that Gooden could have been every bit as good a pitcher as Griffey was an OF, but Griffey kept clean and Gooden didn’t. Sad that he threw away such a wealth of talent.
Rsox
’84-’86 teams must have had some terrible scouting departments.
I remember seeing Shawn Abner play fairly regularly for the Angels in ’91 because of injuries to Junior Felix. Its hard to believe he was a number 1 pick in anything.
Surhoff and King were solid players but looking back its hard to believe teams choose them over the likes of Will Clark, Matt Williams, Barry Bonds, etc.
Phiilies2020
Would have thought Dunston’s career WAR would have been higher. He must have been a terrible fielder and baserunner. From what little I remember he was.
Thomas Bliss
Six players drafted before Frank Thomas. 2 never played in the majors. Also Mo Vaughn and Chuck Knoblauch were drafted in the 20s in that draft.
BSpar
IIRC Jeff King really didn’t have the passion for playing baseball and he retired 1 day after he was eligible for his full pension.
Maybe I’m wrong but, that’s what I think I remember reading/hearing. Please correct or confirm thanks.
Ontopofla
You remember correctly. King was decent (not great), but couldn’t wait to get out of Dodge…
inkstainedscribe
I saw BJ play all three years at UNC. Best all-around college player I’ve seen. He played CF, SS, and C and excelled at all three. He was such a good SS he pushed Walt Weiss to 3B. I think he hit .400 or close to it his freshman year. He had a nice MLB career often playing for mediocre teams.