Injury uncertainty has again struck the Yankees, who’ve gone without a few top starters and bats this spring. While the club isn’t going to panic, it’ll obviously have to make some unexpected decisions to finalize its roster.
GM Brian Cashman said recently that the Yanks haven’t put in calls to inquirer about potential trades to boost a rotation that has lost major pieces for all (Luis Severino) or part (James Paxton) of the coming campaign. That may well be — and it makes sense, given the time of year — but that doesn’t mean the organization is just sitting on its hands.
The Yankees have sent scouts to examine potential starting pitching targets, according to Bob Nightengale of USA Today (Twitter link). Just what level of hurler they’ll be trying to identify isn’t clear. The Yanks could certainly stand to add an established MLB arm, though that’s generally quite difficult to swing just before the start of a season.
More likely, perhaps, the New York org will be looking to acquire some depth. There are quite a few pitchers in camp on minor-league deals. Even those that show reasonably well in the spring may not end up earning 40-man roster spots with their present organization.
It isn’t as if the Yankees’ present options are without merit. As things line up at present, Jordan Montgomery and Jonathan Loaisiga would likely found out the rotation. There’s uncertainty, but both have shown real talent in the past. Veterans Chad Bettis, David Hale, and Nick Tropeano are already in camp for depth.
The Yanks could certainly enter the season with that mix, plus another addition or two, and then plan to adapt as the season goes along. The hope, of course, remains that Paxton will return before too long. And there’s always the summer trade period.
The situation is something of the opposite on the position-player side, where the need isn’t really yet known but the solutions are pretty obvious. Slugger Aaron Judge remains sidelined with a mysterious ailment in his shoulder/chest. There’s still no clarity as to just what the underlying issue is, MLB.com’s Bryan Hoch reports on Twitter.
While it’s impossible to know at present just when Judge will be able to suit up — he says he’s still not ruling himself out for Opening Day, though that seems unlikely — the backup plan isn’t much in doubt. Mike Tauchman, Clint Frazier, and Miguel Andujar are first in line for expanded roles to account for the absences of Judge and Giancarlo Stanton.
Russianblue35
Let’s start the year over
mlb1225
I’m saying it’s the Yankees divison to lose. They might be projected to win the AL East, but I wouldn’t put it past the Rays to overtake them.
Ancient Pistol
The only way the Rays overtake them is if injuries knock out too many key players, though the Rays couldn’t do it last year when half the of the Yankees were AAA players. The problem with the Rays is their lineup is no where near good enough. There’s really no one in that lineup that would overly scare a pitcher. Without the Ray’s pitching, which is quite good, they are not that good of a team.
mlb1225
It’s going to depend on how some of their new acquisitions play, and if their other players can stay healthy. Hunter Renfroe had a .900+ OPS in the first half of the season before falling to a .562 OPS. Hw will Yoshitomo Tsutsugo transition from Japan to the US? Brandon Lowe barley played in the second half of 2019.
Ancient Pistol
Come on! You’re taking about a guy with a .235 lifetime batting average. Of course, Japanese imports are always an unknown so on him the hurry is out. I think the best way to objectify this is to run a mock draft. How many teams would take a Ray position player as their first choice? Probably no one (Meadows may be an exception and I think he has a decent ceiling). Yes, the Yanks can’t expect the same output from their replacements of last year but you also can’t expect .235 hitters to jump 100 points.
Ancient Pistol
^jury is out
mlb1225
Because BA is the best way to observe a player? I don’t expect him to hit .325, but I expect him to hit .250 with a .900+ OPS.
Sonny42
U talk about a 235 avg buT lots of yankee fans love that poor excuse of a player yall call a catcher.
oldmansteve
Keep in mind every single replacement player the Yankees put out there over-preformed, so I don’t think it would be reasonable to expect Urshela, Tauchman, Gardner, and even LeMahieu to play at the level they did last year. But then again, when have Yankees fans ever been reasonable?
TheTrotsky
Well bro sorry to point out the obvious but Gardner and LeMahieu aren’t replacement players.
robluca21
I was with you the whole way Nebraska until you had to make a turn into jerk town. Totally classless and uncalled for. You had a solid point. Shame.
mlb1225
They were hovering around replacement level in terms of offensive value. LeMahieu averaged a .815 OPS and 103 OPS+ in the three seasons prior to signing with the Yankees. Gardner has had the same OPS+ since 2017. Ovbisusly, they’re defense is top notch.
Begamin
I dont understand why you just assume Tauchman has over-performed. He hit well all through the minors and in his first decently lengthed showing in the majors he hit well again. There is not really a baseline to judge Tauchman on considering there isnt much to compare last season’s performance to. Urshela, I believe overperformed but he is having a good spring currently. Gardner essentially batted as he normally does. DJ had a career year, sure, but I dont think he is going to have a serious drop off in production.
So what exactly are you on about?
brucenewton
They do have a lot of regression candidates. Volatile rotation. Tampa improved an already great defense, added power and have excellent pitching, including last year’s number 1 ranked bullpen in ERA. NY has over 300% more in payroll but the division is definitely up for grabs regardless.
jim stem
The parts are not always bigger than the whole. Some teams just play better than others as a unit. I think the key here is pitching. How does the Rays starting staff compare to the revamped Yankees staff? I also feel you would have total up the production for each position. How do the Yankee 1b starters compare to the Rays 1b starters? Do the 3 or 4 Rays stack up favorably versus the Yankee platoon? Sure, individual players, when looking at just stats, favor the Yankees, but how about the 162 total starts when you combine those numbers? I don’t know, but I think it’s a valid comparison.
ajm1121
“No one in that lineup that would scare a pitcher”
Ever hear of Austin Meadows?
MetsFan22
They Yankees overachieved last year. The rays could definitely pass them. I’m not saying it will happen. But it wouldn’t surprise me. A healthy Yankees team I would say Yankees all the way but rn the rays could beat them.
Coal tender
Judge needs to get some chest X-Rays. You never know if it is something more serious.
Dorothy_Mantooth
This is why baseball players should not bench press at all during the season. They have no time to rest and allow their muscles to heal. In the NBA, the vast majority of players only lift when they have a day off the next day. There are very few days off in MLB and to go from bench pressing 300lbs to a swing and a miss is a recipe for disaster, no matter what shape the player is in.
Vladguerrerojr20
I bet it’s bursitis or capsulitis, it’s common with weight lifters.
BobbyLox69
Trade for Archer. Frazier would be more than enough.
KingTiger
Frazier is worth a bag of dirty jocks – and nothing more.
BobbyLox69
Sounds like enough to get Archer to me. Coming off a bad year and a one year rental.
bobtillman
I think the Rays are going to trade Glassnow, Meadows and Baz for Archer.
Rudy Zolteck
What a steal for the Rays, Glasnow is a failed prospect who can’t even throw strikes!
brewsingblue82
Archer is actually under contract for 2 more seasons. Which is why I doubt the Pirates would be willing to sell so low on him.
BobbyLox69
Why would the Pirates pick up an $11 million club-option for a below-average starter when they’re rebuilding?
bobtillman
And that Meadows kid is never going to hit major league pitching.
Rudy Zolteck
Yeah and Baz is definitely not top prospect material. Rays should totally pull the trigger on that deal
robluca21
Are you high? The pirates gave up glasnow and meadows for archer…why would they then flip archer for Clint Frazier?
robluca21
Lol…archer last year was still around league average . And he at a point in his career was a top 20 pitcher ..hes also relatively young. So 11 million yeah u pick up the option
Begamin
+robluca21
a 5.19 ERA and an ERA+ of 82 is not league average. Thats safely below average. The year before that his ERA+ was 94, which is still below average. He hasnt been safely above average since 2015, when he posted an ERA+ of 121
Archer is not good.
brucenewton
If Archer still stinks this year I can’t see the Pirates picking up the option. I believe the buy out is only 250K. It wasn’t Cherington’s trade. It already cost the former GM his job. Sunk cost, move on.
Rudy Zolteck
Clocking in with the “Frazier for [insert literally any player]” early today, nice
WillisBaezzo
at least they’re setting their sights on the chris archer’s of the world instead of the mookie betts’ of the world. even if it’s still not realistic, they’re starting to figure it out.
MoRivera 1999
Frazier for Mookie Betts said no one…ever.
MTForester
Lol…
Begamin
Would rather keep Frazier’s bat with all the OF injuries than trade for him for a pitcher that performs as well as anyone in AAA would.
Coal tender
Funny as it might seem, the oft ridiculed Texas Ranger pitching staff looks a whole lot more formidable than the Yankees pitching about now.
MoRivera 1999
I’ll take Cole and Tanaka over Minor and Lynn. (I just don’t think Lynn repeats.) After that, you got me until Paxton and German show up.
WillisBaezzo
barring TJS and coming back from that, lynn has been very consistent throughout his career. it’s more likely lynn does what he’s been doing his entire career rather than falling off the map because a yankees fan said so.
MoRivera 1999
Last year for Lynn was exceptional, unlike 2018 and 2019. Expect regression to norm.
fred-3
Rangers rotation wouldn’t look so hot w/o their #2 and 3
DockEllisDee
name me a staff that would
robluca21
Fred that’s literally every team in baseball….
brucenewton
Most starting staffs look better than the yankees rotation. Fortunately for the yanks most of them are in the NL.
Pete'sView
The Yankees and Giants should pull a Clint Frazier for Jeff Samardzija deal. There might have to be a few other pieces but this would be a win-win for both clubs.
toomuchpie
lol
WillisBaezzo
“a few other pieces”
yeah like the centerpiece of the deal going to SF…. usually negotiations start with the big get, not the throw-in.
Pete'sView
You are over-valuing Frazier. Shark is not a “throw-in.” But if you think you can go with the rotation you’ve got (now that it’s been decimated), I say have at it—and watch the Rays catch you.
toomuchpie
lol
Begamin
Jeff Samardzija is a 35 year old $18MM rental who doesnt perform well consistently. He had his first decent year since 2016. He has a pattern of doing good every other year. He did good last year, so this year his era is 4.50? Would rather just keep Frazier.
Btw, the first half of the season is riddled with lots of days off. The Yankees can have their rotation limp out on the field for the first half until mid season reinforcements arrive (Paxton, German) and win the majority of their regular season games on their offense and bullpen (like they have done for two straight years where the Rays couldnt catch them).
Dorothy_Mantooth
All you need to know about Clint Frazier is that the Yankees decided to go with Mike freakin’ Tauchman over Clint Frazier when they had OF injuries last season. The Yankees don’t even value Clint Frazier highly; why would any other team do so? Not to mention, Frazier’s defense is admittedly poor, so why would a NL team want him? He is at best an average AL DH. Yankees are stuck with him.
robluca21
Mike freaking tauchman also put up a WAR of close to 4 last year in about 80 games..also was top ten in outfielder DRS and had an ops plus of around 130
Begamin
Why would an NL team want Castellanos i mean Frazier… Theres no room for poor defending big hitters in the NL, youre right!
Dorothy_Mantooth
Frazier can’t hold Castellanos’ jock strap. Once again, overvaluing a AAAA prospect here.
Begamin
Castellanos generally has an OPS+ in the 120’s. had an OPS+ of 121 last year. also worth noting, an OPS+ of 112 in 2017. Frazier had an OPS+ of 111 last year. Really not too far off for a 24 year old player with irregular playing time. He has shown he can hit just fine at the big league level.
Once again, blindly hating a Yankees prospect simply because its the cool thing to do here
MoRivera 1999
Until he got injured last year, Frazier had a .975 OPS. He was absolutely raking. If he’s injury free this year I expect he’s got a chance to return to form. We’ll see. As for trading him, I don’t see that happening with injuries to Stanton, Hicks and Judge. Maybe at the deadline if he does well.
brucenewton
Samardzija’s a fly ball pitcher. Not suited for yankee stadium at all. Cole has also turned into a fly ball pitcher since his pirates days. He too might have some issues with the tiny right field. Especially vs lefty heavy teams like Boston.
CaptainThurman
All but a small handful of teams out there would be happy with Jordan Montgomery as the 4th starter. And as little used as a 5th starter is in April and May, I would think that any combination of Loisiaga, or even Chad Green as an opener will get it done until Paxton and German are ready. And what team out there wouldn’t want Paxton and German to join their staff in June?
Nick
The Yankees schedule doesn’t really let them skip their 5th starter often in April/May this year. They have the built in days off for the O’s home opener and their own (March 27 and April 3) then they have 2 days off between April 3 and May 4
brucenewton
East coast teams get a lot of rainouts in April and May as well. Yanks generally play a few less games than most everyone else in the first half. From rainouts that get usually get rescheduled to the second. Makes the second half schedule tight, probably one reason why the bullpen burns out late in the year.
whyhayzee
Some teams would rather not have someone of questionable character like german.
Begamin
What is your favorite team, bet there is a questionable character on it (there always is, and there always will be questionable characters on every team)
MoRivera 1999
Pretty much only for PR reasons. Dude is paying his dues. He’s serving an 80 game suspension. He’s essentially paying a multi-million dollar fine in lost income. He’s getting counseling/treatment. He slapped his wife in public. That’s a horrible thing but he didn’t stab, rape or shoot her. You don’t drive people like that from society unless you want millions more hardened criminals out there. None of the baseball offenders have repeated. None. Be glad for that.
MoRivera 1999
Pretty much only for PR reasons then; any team would want a reformed 18 game winner. Dude is paying his dues. He’s serving an 80 game suspension. He’s essentially paying a multi-million dollar fine in lost income. He’s getting counseling/treatment. He’s probably on some extended probation. He slapped his wife in public. That’s a horrible thing but he didn’t beat, stab or shoot her. You don’t drive people like that from society unless you want millions more hardened criminals out there hiding in the shadows. None of the baseball offenders have repeated. None. Be glad for that.
WillisBaezzo
happy with him as a 4th starter? those teams are called rebuilding teams.
montgomery is a depth/BP piece on a contender, maybe a 5th starter on a team lacking experienced depth like the cubs, but not without competition.
also, counting on paxton to be healthy at any point is a fool’s errand. you cross your fingers and hope he will be, but preparing to not have him is the prudent move. the only downside is you have too much pitching, which means there is no downside.
Begamin
So far, Montgomery has a career ERA+ of 115. In his first full season with the Yankees, in 2017, he had an ERA+ of 116. Why wouldnt teams be happy with him as a 4th starter. That kind of performance makes him a 3rd starter on a lot of teams. He’d be the Tigers ace haha (Boyd had an ERA+ of 105 in his career year last year).
The real concern with Monty is how he is going to bounce back from TJ. He never was a high velo guy but the time away from pitching can mess with some guys.
brucenewton
He’s probably on a strict innings limit.
metsie1
Bartolo Colon is available. Just sayin.
steelerbravenation
To bad Cole Hamels is injures maybe Folty coulda been made available with the spring Wright & Felix are having.
whyhayzee
How can the Red Sox know exactly what’s wrong with Chris Sale while the yankees don’t have an iota of a smidge of a crumb of a teeny tiny little wittle clue about what’s wrong with errant judge? Yet another suspicious non-news item.
MoRivera 1999
We JUST finally learned what was wrong with Sale TODAY. It’s not unusual for injuries to be elusive, especially when it comes to soft tissues. And it sure is not “suspicious” like Big PEDi’s PED use.
whyhayzee
The yankees never accurately say what’s wrong with their players. They are trying to game the system so they can fleece some dopey team in a trade.
Always suspicious.
toomuchpie
1/10 troll effort.
MoRivera 1999
Suspicious like David Ortiz you mean?
MoRivera 1999
“The yankees never accurately say what’s wrong with their players. They are trying to game the system so they can fleece some dopey team in a trade.”
– Wayhazy
Yes the Yankees have a long and glorious history trading injured players, and they’re gearing up to do the same with Judge. You actually read the crap you write you moron?
whyhayzee
I said try. That’s not the same as do. Teams are wise to their tomfoolery.
WillisBaezzo
a yankees fan calling out PED use by a player on another team? LOL that lacks so much self-awareness it’s adorable.
MoRivera 1999
Yankees PED use was over a decade ago. Oritz used up through his miraculous age 40 ascending to heaven season in 2016. Dude managed to lead all the young bucks of baseball in doubles while fat, 40 and running on the worst feet in baseball. Sorry, that doesn’t happen. Not if you’re intellectually. And how does a fat 40 year old with bad feet lead the league in RBI’s, slugging and OPS.
whyhayzee
How does a 46 year old out run everyone who weighs over 190 pounds running a marathon? By running races up to 15 miles under 8:00 pace and by running 6 twenty milers. In other words, hard work. It’s amazing what a body can do when you push it. But I’m sure Papi just sat back and took something so he could play well at age 40. How did Carlton Fisk and Nolan Ryan do it? Hard work. I met Pudge wearing one of my marathon shirts and he said I was crazier than him. I’m not small but he was a big dude. Maybe it’s genes like Nolan says but it still takes hard work to stay fit for a sport.
MoRivera 1999
Sorry hard work will not enable a fat, 40 year old with horrendous feet that cause him great pain everyday to outrun Mike Trout all season long. Can’t happen. If you had an ounce of intellectual honesty you would not even bother to argue the point. Because it can’t be argued. Not honestly. But I am not surprised that YOU will try, because you are hopelessly dishonest in just about every post.
stubby66
I think the Brewers should trade Trey Supak or Zack Brown straight up for Clint Frazier
WillisBaezzo
several problems with that… 1) the brewers have no use for frazier and 2) teams don’t value frazier nearly as high as the yankees or their fans do.
Mikel Grady
Jose Quintana for ?
David Herrick
Jose Quintana for Luis Gil, Luis Medina, and Mike King. As a Cubs fan, I’d go for it.
Dorothy_Mantooth
How about Nate Pearson for Clint Frazier!
Ashleyr
Sarcasm. I thought the Yankees would trade Frazier and Florial to the Mets for DeGrom, Syndergaart, and Matz. lol.
bighiggy
Carlos martinez, brett cecil and Rangel ravelo for frazier.
mlbnyyfan
What about Judge and Andujar for Hader?
or Judge and Andujar for Luis Castillo
rocky7
How about Judge and Andujar and throw in Santa Claus also for either pitcher…we don’t care…..
.You’re suggestion is just too preposturous to even comment on!
You just can’t make this crap up!
brucenewton
Hader and Castillo are stud pitchers. Judge is breaking down and can’t stay on the field. Andujar isn’t suited for the NL.
OilCanLloyd
Every Yankee Fan: Frazier straight up for Hader.
Begamin
how can you say that without seeing any Yankee fans saying that?
Every Yankees hater: durr yAnkEe fAn sAy FraZiER foR beSt PlAyEr 1for1 dUrr
MoRivera 1999
“Frazier straight up for Hader” said no Yankee fan ever. So all we’re left with is your lie.
DarkSide830
who who they dig up this year?
mlbnyyfan
Yankees don’t need Santa claus however I’m sure he’s more available to play more than Judge lately who over the last few years so unreliable.
humphrey x boegarts
I don’t know, Santa only works 1 day a year so they’re both pretty even
Iknowmorebaseball
Add Puig for for 5 million/1yr and with incentives.
Begamin
Eh i personally want to see Puig back on the Reds so he can fight the Pirates some more
mlbnyyfan
The Easter Bunny works one day a year too but I bet the combination of Santa and Bunny better than Judge and Stanton.
brucenewton
Dudes softer than a fast food poo.
kjwalt1
Judge AKA as the Slug.
Begamin
AKA as
Also known as as the Slug
also how is he a slug lmao what
Chris Koch
Brewers have Brett Anderson for 1yr that they probably dont need. We can take Andujar for him since DL stints are expected with both. Brewers can option Andujar while they work their 3b platoon magic.
whyhayzee
“Just know that the year we won the World Series in 2003, the bench players, their entire role every game of the World Series, they had one job to do,” Samson told my students. “That was to steal the signs of the New York Yankees.”
Whoops.