Quite a few of MLBTR’s top 50 free agents have already signed, though there are still a host of players available on the open market. We’ve seen somewhat less action on the trade market, which still features a number of stars and other useful targets.
Those links provide lots of info on the supply side. But what about demand? We’ll run through each division to identify the biggest-remaining needs of each team.
Atlanta Braves [Offseason Outlook]
As they did last time around, the Braves sprinted out of the gates to address multiple key needs. But the club’s biggest question entering the winter — what to do about the departure of star third baseman Josh Donaldson — remains unanswered. It’s a good roster as-is, but the lineup would look a whole lot better with another big bat in the middle of it. If Donaldson can’t be retained, the Braves could look to the trade market at third base or pursue one of the remaining corner outfielders and re-shuffle their internal deck accordingly. The club seems quite settled otherwise but could still explore opportunistic rotation additions.
Miami Marlins [Offseason Outlook]
The Fish have spent the winter plugging in one-year veterans and jettisoning unwanted relievers. The idea was to create a mix that will improve the results a bit in the near term while simultaneously aiding the development of and avoiding undue pressure on young players. Much of that work is already done, but the team is reportedly still looking to add a power-hitting corner outfielder who’d supplement (or supplant?) recent minor-league signee Matt Kemp. Perusing the roster, it seems there’s also room to pick up a veteran pitcher or two to join the bullpen or perhaps the rotation. That’d become a clear priority in the event of a trade involving Caleb Smith, Jose Urena, or some other pitcher. Presumably, the club will continue to explore trade opportunities involving those and other players while keeping an eye on the waiver wire.
New York Mets [Offseason Outlook]
Aided by a renegotiation of the Yoenis Cespedes contract, the Mets have placed a series of expensive (a combined $25MM+) single-season bets on high-variance veteran pitchers. Having picked up two new starting-capable hurlers, a pair of bullpen pieces, and a part-time center fielder in Jake Marisnick, the New York org has already ticked the boxes it needed to.
So … why doesn’t it feel like GM Brodie Van Wagenen is finished? With a forthcoming ownership transition underscoring the need to win now, the club’s top baseball exec can’t afford to leave any stones unturned in his sophomore offseason. Installing a top-flight center fielder — Starling Marte looks like the best bet — would be at the top of the list, but the club can also explore blockbuster scenarios at other positions. It’s possible to imagine further improvements to the bench and bullpen mix, too. The Mets will be most keen to utilize blocked first baseman Dominic Smith as a trade chip — whether to bring back prospects, shed the Jed Lowrie contract, or deliver a different MLB piece — but younger big leaguers J.D. Davis and Steven Matz could also conceivably be dangled.
Philadelphia Phillies [Offseason Outlook]
The Phils landed two of MLBTR’s top dozen free agents, and they did so for lesser commitments than were necessary to secure quite a few other top players. That’s a nice start, but hardly sufficient to stand out from the other three contending teams in this division. Improving the bullpen remains an unfulfilled priority. While the rotation no longer stands out as a problem, it’s susceptible of being bettered. And the position-player mix doesn’t feel quite finished. The Phillies could choose to utilize Adam Haseley in center field and Scott Kingery at third base. But the lineup would look better with a newly installed regular for at least one of those positions, freeing Kingery to function as a super-sub and reducing the team’s reliance upon the still-unproven Haseley. It’s a tough scene in free agency unless the club reimposes itself in the market for Josh Donaldson. Creative trade exploration seems advisable. The Phils also still must figure out what to do with Odubel Herrera, who’ll be returning from a suspension.
Washington Nationals [Offseason Outlook]
Having finally completed a summit attempt, the Nats face new challenges in a repeat bid. Not unlike the Braves and Phillies, the D.C. roster would look much better with Josh Donaldson added in at the hot corner. If they miss on Donaldson, the Nats could be forced into some difficult and high-stakes trade talks. There’s an opening at second base as well — especially if the club intends to utilize the recently re-signed Howie Kendrick at first base, which is partially dependent upon its decision with regard to Ryan Zimmerman — which creates both need and opportunity.
Youngster Carter Kieboom could be cast into a big role, but the organization probably prefers to see him force his way up rather than relying on him out of the gates. It’s possible to imagine the addition of multiple veteran infielders from a large remaining pool, with a plan to mix and match and adapt over the course of the season. Any of the team’s internally developed reserve players could be supplanted over the next few months. Ditto the holdover fifth-starter and middle-relief options. Another rotation piece (if only for camp competition) and one or more relievers (preferably including a legit setup option) also remain on the list of needs for president of baseball operations Mike Rizzo, who’s overseeing a huge amount of roster turnover while trying to recover from a (literal and figurative) championship hangover.
ForestCobraAL
Braves: “It’s a good roster as-is”
No it’s not. They were humiliated by the Dodgers in 2018 and they exited the 1st round in 2019.
Ted Turner would never accept such an embarrassing postseason performance. The Braves have plenty of room on their payroll for both Gerrit Cole and Anthony Rendon but Greg Maffei couldn’t care less about World series trophies.
bravos4evr
you don’t understand baaeball huh?
playoffs are pretty random and based on nothing a team can build. Stop with this “built to win” crap, it’s total nonsense
ForestCobraAL
There is little to nothing that is “random” about the playoffs.
I expected to see the beat down of the Twins and if they make it back this year the Yankees will do them just as badly and maybe even worse.
The difference between those two teams is huge and obvious.
SheaGoodbye
Small sample sizes are inherently chaotic, especially in baseball, so yes, random was a good, if only imperfect, choice of word.
Of course, better teams would still have a greater chance of winning, but the opportunity cost of significantly improving one’s playoff odds is pretty high by default. And more importantly, there is a soft real-world limit to how high a team’s odds of winning can go, with only a few outlier cases in which a team would have amassed an incredible amount of talent.
Tl;dr: Baseball is not basketball. There is no Golden State Warriors.
Down with OBP
You’ve described the Braves as a playoff team. That is pretty much the definition of “good enough as-is”.
ForestCobraAL
It is good enough for a loser.
jleve618
You act like it’s a coin flip each round. Yes there is quite a bit of chance involved but the braves were not good enough either year that a ball or two landing their way would net them a series win.
Sunny 2
I guess you missed Molinas 60mph bloop hit, barely over Freemans glove in game 4….
tbones3141
Yeah that play ends that series. Should never look at it that way, but you can’t ignore it either.
bravos4evr
oh and Liberty Media does not control payroll. The team runs on revenue.
CrewBrew
gotta love Braves fans taking over the comments just to cry and moan.
Go get a diary and a tissue kiddo.
RunDMC
Turner obviously didn’t care a lot about trophies. Sold them almost immediately after they won their first, as owner – his 19th year as owner, btw. Final sell to Time Warner went through in 1997, after they won in ’95. Face it, they were a business to him just like they’re a biz to Liberty. Turner was more hands-on of an owner, which, quite frankly, not sure if that works nowadays (i.e. Jerry Jones, etc.).
ForestCobraAL
Look at the payrolls adjusted. The difference is massive.
Greg Maddux is a CUBS player. The Cubs drafted Maddux. Greg Maddux won the Cy Young in his walk year for the Cubs.
Ted Turner signed Greg Maddux to the largest contract ever for a starting pitcher and then Maddux won three more CYA’s in a row for the Braves. Today Maddux is in Cooperstown as a Brave and most fans think he was drafted by the Braves.
That’s Ted Turner’s work.
steelerbravenation
Did you know that offer wasn’t even the highest Maddux got ?
Known fact Yankees offered him more but he wanted to stay in the NL so maybe Billionare Ted May have got him he obviously didn’t throw the money around because if he did Maddux woulda got more.
ForestCobraAL
Is that what they told you?
braves25
@ForestCobraAL
Maddux DID NOT go into the HOF as a Brave! He did not pick a team because of his ties to the Cubs.
bravesfan1970
That story about Maddox turning down more money from the Yankees is true.
cjb
Maddux went to the HOF without a team. Neutral bro….
ThatRogue
Turner sold his entire company to Time Warner (which includes TBS, TNT, CNN, Cartoon Network, etc.) of which the Braves were just one component. He then became the largest individual shareholder and Vice-Chairman of Time Warner. Caring about the Braves was one thing (at one point he even managed the team until MLB told him he couldn’t) but that was a media transaction that was bigger than baseball. It had nothing to do with him not caring. (And I’m not even a Braves fan nor a Ted Turner fan.)
VonPurpleHayes
They dominated a tough division and were a better team than the champs for the majority of the season. The playoffs comes down to luck and timing. The Braves are good enough to dominate a tough division again.
ForestCobraAL
NOPE.
Best NL Least team won out.
N.L. East Pythagorean W-L Standings:
Nationals 95-67, 873 Runs, 724 Runs Allowed
Braves 91-71, 855 Runs, 743 Runs Allowed
Mets 86-76, 791 Runs, 737 Runs Allowed
Phillies 79-83, 774 Runs, 794 Runs Allowed
VonPurpleHayes
Nonsense. I look at the actual records instead of fan-fiction stats.
SalaryCapMyth
Pythagorean metric is not perfect. Something that tends to throw it off is a bad bullpen because they will blow a lot of 1 and 2 run leads. The Nationals were among the top 3 worst bullpens in baseball. That’s why they carried just 3 relief pitchers into the post season.
Ejemp2006
We don’t crown a World Series winner until twenty years have past. Then we use the average career WAR of all the players on the teams to decide who actually won. AND this is the best way too. AND don’t tell me you’re still using ERA and battling average to tell you who won the World Series. #stuckinthepast
DarkSide830
oh please, invoking Ted Turner? Braves just spent a whole load to add to areas of need. they’re the division favorites once again, and the margain is even greater now.
darmstrong92
We are definitely not the consensus favorites dude. The Nationals are very good and we lost our cleanup guy.. It will be another tough year. Let’s not get too cocky.
SalaryCapMyth
The Braves weren’t division favorites in 2019 or 2018
tbones3141
It’s a fine roster and I agree with the comment below…do you, in fact, watch baseball? Or do you just make $300/hour working from home trolling this website?
ForestCobraAL
What is taking the Nats so long to lock up Josh Donaldson? Do they want to perform so poorly people think they were a fluke this year?
MountainBraves
They can’t force him to sign. He’s waiting for the Braves to give him the 4th year guarantee.
Youtube.com/@PINGTR1P
It pretty much was the definition of a miracle run. I still don’t respect them or think they did anything spectacular other than beating the Astros in the WS. Nearly every other series before that was gifted to them or taken via pure luck. Let’s be real, if Grisham fields the ball the Gnats lose the WC game.
Gumbo
“Other than being the Astros in the World Series” Ha! Like that’s not that important. They did that and had the best record in MLB for 3/4 of the season.
xmadxtiox
How can you say that? I respect that its your opinion and everyone is entitled to one. But even I, a Mets fan, knows that the Nats deserved that title. They fought hard and even came up on miraculous wins. They dominated the playoffs and even beat a cheating Astros team. I want to cut my tongue out for saying this but The Nats are by far the 2019 WS Champs.
SheaGoodbye
Because the Nats were not one of the top teams in the playoffs.
But they did play well enough to win.
That’s the definition of baseball. Get in, have a couple of elite arms you can ride and see what happens.
SalaryCapMyth
I wish I can agree with this but it’s just wrong. The Nationals took a risk by constructing their playoff roster in a way that was different from every other team because their bullpen couldn’t be trusted. The Nationals are a worthy opponent.
whosyourmomma
Maybe because they are keeping the possibility of trading for Kris Bryant open. I’d take a younger KB for 2 years at say 40 mil versus the older Donaldson who wants a 3-4 year deal. Or they might be hoping to get Donaldson for like only 2 years. They have other options I’m sure too. They will sign Adams to platoon with Kendrick at 1st or pinch hit too.
Ejemp2006
The holdout strategy wasn’t kind to Donaldson last time. Hope he doesn’t play his hand wrong again.
darmstrong92
Huh? Holdout strategy wasn’t kind to Donaldson? What are you talking about lol his only other year in FA the Braves signed him almost immediately when the playoffs ended
Ejemp2006
Still hasn’t gotten guaranteed money. The sign for the best early offer worked well for Cutch. Probably could of worked for Donaldson too.
tbones3141
When did Donaldson hold out? He was one of, if not the, first FA to sign last year. You may be thinking Keuchel…in which case, stop drinking…
DarkSide830
same reason the Phils are. they cant win without Cole AND Rendon.
Armaments216
Will be shocked if the Nats sign Donaldson. They’re just driving up his price for their division rivals, like they did with Harper last offseason.
Steven Hevenstone
Josh is waiting to see if Atlanta will go for the 4th year – They offered 3 from what I read – true or not I don’t know. The concern the team has is another situation like BJ Upton – also, it was one year he played great after being injured for 2 years. There is risk. Then again, there is risk with any player.
Dan Hunter
Marte will most assuredly be a Met in 2020,
mrdozo
I don’t see Marte as a need, he will also be expensive. Nimmo is more than serviceable as our starting CF’er.
rct
The asking price for Marte is well above what the Mets should be willing to offer. He’s aging, his defense is declining, and it’s a gamble that he’d put up better offensive numbers than a healthy Nimmo over the next few years.
Canosucks
As a Met fan I sure hope not; bad move to pick up a guy on the downside of his career; CF legs go first and age faster.
We will have to give up to much talent to get Marte, pick up Pillar for money and call it quits.
MarlinsFanBase
@Dan Hunter
I see that you’re softening your statements. Earlier this offseason, you were stating that Marte was already traded to the Mets. Now he “…most most assuredly be a Met in 2020.” If he gets traded elsewhere, I can’t wait to see your statement then…if you even show your face on this board after ward.
MountainBraves
Josh Donaldson hasn’t departed yet. AA needs to give him the 4th year and end the stand-off. It’s not worth losing him to the Nats.
ForestCobraAL
Kris Bryant is better.
The Braves have the prospects to get Bryant and the money to extend Bryant.
When is Atlanta going to address their Greg Maffei problem?
brave from the woods
When the tax breaks run out….
MountainBraves
He is absolutely NOT better. He was one of the worst defensive 3B in baseball last year while Josh was one of the best. Josh is a better hitter. Bryant would be a downgrade who cost money AND prospects …and would only be around 2 years. The Braves don’t give out 8 year 200M contracts.
Maffei isn’t a problem. The payroll is making a big jump this year. It will be at least 160M by spring training. AA just don’t believe in long term contracts for extreme amounts of money. Mid market teams can’t afford dead money contracts.
ForestCobraAL
The Braves are a BIG market.
Same as Boston.
rct
Demonstrably false. Boston’s population is larger and the Red Sox are more of a regional team (most of New England). Further, said region cares more about baseball than Atlanta.
southi
Market size isn’t dictated by just the number of people in the area. The median household income in Atlanta area is only 57k compared to about 107K in the Boston area. That income difference is a HUGE factor.
ForestCobraAL
It’s a lot cheaper to live in the Atlanta area.
Go on Zilliow and look at the difference in housing prices.
sviscusi
Cost of living when you’re making 10+ million is inconsequential. He’s not going to need to get a mortgage and he’ll just sell the house when the contracts up getting his equity back.
proof2006
That’s actually very wrong. The braves cover the largest area by drive to the stadium of any organization at 30million people. Nearly double the population covered by the red Sox.
i.imgur.com/whdlraP.jpg
basquiat
The Braves have been the team of the South since Ted Turner put them on his cable network. You see Braves caps in all the southern states.
Geebs
You keep saying this about Bryant like you know he’s available, logic alone tells you that the Cubs aren’t going to move him before the resolution to his grievance.
Of course they, or any team for that matter would be able to afford to extend him, least we forget Bryant himself would have to want to sign the extension, of which he’s so far shown no inclination to do. Also, 2 years (maybe 1) away from FA, why wouldn’t he want to test it now? All of this complicated by the fact that he’s a Boras client.
ForestCobraAL
Boras always signs his clients before free agency if that team will pay him now.
It’s flat out stupid not to and Boras and “stupid” are polar opposites.
Geebs
Lol no he doesn’t, very seldom does a boras client sign before hitting FA, specifically the superstars that will set new financial watermarks.
ForestCobraAL
“very seldom does a” team pay a player his free agent value and keep him from the free agent market.
Fixed that for you.
Geebs
my statement was accurate so stop because I don’t need a moron like you misrepresenting my words.
I’m lucky in that I have facts backing up my statement whereas you have what? a spin tingling feeling?
Boras clients generally don’t sign before hitting FA because that’s what’s in a clients best interest, specifically the superstars. This is a real easy concept, however since you’re a blithering moron I’ll make it simple. If you held an auction in an attempt to sell all the crap in your garage but only invited 1 person you could probably expect not to make much money because that 1 person has all the leverage however if you invited 29 other people to bid you then have the leverage and your items theoretically will sell much higher.
It is always better to have a group of teams bidding on your services then just 1. Is this sinking in for you or should I try posting some picture art?
steelerbravenation
Reported today the Cubs have told AA 3 outta 4 of Waters, Riley, Anderson & Wright gets Bryant whether it’s 1 year or 2.
If that is the cost I would rather just give Donaldson the 4th year.
ForestCobraAL
Give up those pitchers. The Braves have the money to sign a good starter who is better and a lot more dependable than any or all of those kids put together.
seamaholic 2
How do you know Donaldson would sign with the Braves if they offered 4 years? Maybe he’s just trying to play the Nats, Twins and Braves against each other for the highest four year deal and needs the Braves in the mix to extract more out of one of the others. In fact I would put money on it.
RBI
Reported where? Stop making up stories… Santa will not come until for another year.
steelerbravenation
cubsinsider.com/2019/12/26/cubs-trade-rumors-very-…
steelerbravenation
Trying to paste the article it’s not letting me do it
CubsInsider had it up a couple hours ago
Geebs
Did you read it because it had a lot of assumptions and very loose connections. If it’s true that that’s what the Cubs asked for (and why wouldn’t they start out asking for the moon) the Braves should defiantly pass. Anderson alone is probably more valuable then Bryant, even with 2 years of control. Donaldson offers similar production at a similar cost for nothing but cash.
fisharebiting
his argument was that Boras rarely lets guys get to free agency yet the 3 biggest guys out there this year were Boras clients, including one who tested the market and then resigned with his original team. kinda contradicts his argument in itself. I am curious to see what the picture art would have looked liked though
RunDMC
LOL – address the Greg Maffei problem?? Yes, ATL is going to march to Colorado with pitchforks and demand he sell the team. They’re going to wear paper bags over their heads at the 2020 ceremony hanging their 2nd consecutive division pennant. Cry me a river.
rct
With Donaldson, you give up money. With Bryant, you’re giving up a boatload of prospects in addition to the money you’re going to have to pay him via abitration the next few years.
ForestCobraAL
So Rendon was the correct answer.
Now Bryant is better for the Braves.
Youtube.com/@PINGTR1P
ForestCobraAL
You used to make me laugh all the time, but man you’re starting to sound a lot like the last poster “Casey’s partner” I’m pretty sure that’s you, btw. With your statements about Greg Maffei and Atlanta being the same sized market as Boston. You’re a Phillies fan, also. That pretty much gave it away.
ForestCobraAL
I’m Free_AEC
proof2006
Atlanta covers a far larger area than Boston does.
DarkSide830
Bryant isnt going anywhere. not even enough smoke yet and there’s certainly no fire.
iamhector24
Bryant is not better when you account for the fact that he’ll cost more than money. Give me Donaldson and keep the prospects.
tbones3141
JD is older and more risky on a 4 year contract. But he is in fact better than Bryant right now. To me the offense is A and A- as a grade. But the defense is A to C in favor of Josh. You cant ignore that.
ForestCobraAL
The Washington Nationals still do not have a TV contract. Look at their payroll. Look at the taxes they have paid on their payroll.
Process the meaning of that.
Look at the Braves payroll. Look at John Middleton hiding in his plane hanger while the Yankees sign Gerrit Cole and Angels take Rendon.
whyhayzee
Free agency is the process of extracting a ludicrous contract from the team you want to play for by convincing them that they’re not the team you want to play for thus enabling the team to vastly overpay for your services. Some play better than others. It’s all about the money until somebody picks the wrong team and winds up miserable. All of these teams have done “OK” but the off season’s not over. A few more billions to be committed then maybe some blockbuster trade entertainment.
Geebs
What??? You think they negotiate by telling the team they don’t want to play for them? Have you ever negotiated anything in your life? Like you’re selling a car and you tell a prospective buyer how you don’t want them to own the car so they’ll have to convince you to sell it to them? Do you try to get dates by telling a girl how much better then her you should be able to do?
whyhayzee
Oy. You make them believe that there are other teams you would be willing to play for to raise the stakes. Some just go where they want or stay put without playing that game. Others are all about maximizing the payday. That’s what I’m saying.
Also, baseball has little to do with reality.
Geebs
yes but you don’t try to make them think you don’t like them, you just want them to think other like you as much or more then they do.
whyhayzee
I think I left out the word “only” in the latter part of the first sentence of my original post. That’s what I meant.
Geebs
Fair enough
david klein
Mets don’t need a CF-Nimmo is fine there he’s just entering his prime is very valuable and Marte is exiting his prime. Nimmo has more years of control and has been the better player as recent as 2018.
SheaGoodbye
I don’t know why you’re making this seem like a one-or-the-other proposition. We could acquire Marte while keeping Nimmo. Of course, that would force JD to the bench, but a bench consisting of him, Lowrie, Marisnick and Dom looks pretty nice to me. And JD could still receive a fair amount of playing time by spelling at the corner spots and 3rd, if he can make enough improvements there to be barely passable.
I’m not saying we should necessarily make a move to get Marte, of course. Just that having more depth isn’t the worst thing in the world, particularly for this snake-bitten franchise.
Canosucks
Marte is a bad move but Van Lunchwagon may make it just to get his name out in the media.
iamhector24
Canosucks what an idiotic take.
frankt
NL teams can’t feel comfortable giving Donaldson 4 years. He’s a very good player but he has injuries in the past. Isn’t he 34 years old? An AL team such as the Twins can give him 4 years. He can split time as a DH.
MarlinsFanBase
The NL may be getting a DH in a couple of years.
beyou02215
Always thought that Dom Smith would be a great target for the Rockies.
seamaholic 2
Why exactly? I suppose it’s a fine move as long as he has an option remaining (hard to tell if he burned his last one in 2019 or not) but not sure he’d make the Rockies in 2020 except as a 26th man bench bat. They have a bunch invested in Daniel Murphy for one more year, and they have a kid in AAA who just clubbed 35 home runs and is a lefty first baseman too.
DonC.
Why can’t Kingery have his own position,why does he have to be a super sub?Get rid of lazy Segura.
ForestCobraAL
Kingery is more valuable that way. Why can’t Kingery be more valuable?
Why can’t John Middleton stop hiding in his plane hanger and pay for the players the Phillies need?
AndyMeyer
Bryce Harper ring a bell?
ForestCobraAL
Gerrit Cole and Anthony Rendon.
Those are the two bells John Middleton needed to ring this winter.
AndyMeyer
High expectations my friend. Unrealistic as well
AndyMeyer
And what franchise is going to spend $94 million on 3 players for the next 7 years?
Geebs
ForestCobraAL Are you just a troll or what? How can you complain about the Phillies not spending money? That is a team that has spent a tremendous amount of money in FA. Harper, Wheeler, Arrieta. Not to mention trading for the best catcher in baseball, remaking the infield last year and so on. You can say they haven’t spent wisely but you can’t say that Middleton hasn’t spent, whenever they are competitive they trade for the best they can and spend at the luxury line. Look at what happened the last time they were competitive, they spent.
tbones3141
He is the King of the Trolls.
DarkSide830
Segura is still a great middle infielder who is relatively young and on a great contract. and Kingery will be playing a single position – 3B – for some time next year. Phils woln’t and shouldn’t add another starting IF.
tbones3141
In no way does “great” describe Segura.
Gumbo
Nats should have signed Moose.
ForestCobraAL
Donaldson is better.
seamaholic 2
And older and way more expensive.
ForestCobraAL
Donaldson is better.
DarkSide830
older and better suggests that Moose contract wolnt age well. (likely the case) oh, and you gotta pay to play. that’s how winning with free agency works.
Tazbk
They also had to wait on Rendon.
TradeAcuna
If the Braves don’t get another starter, they are either going to lose out on the playoffs (likely) or get embarrassed again in the playoffs (guaranteed). This whole remaining offseason rides on them getting another starter.
ForestCobraAL
Kris Bryant and Freddie Freeman on the corners.
TradeAcuna
^^
Hey brother from another mother. I share the exact same sentiments as you. The argument, “the playoffs is a crapshoot” is completely invalid in respect to the Braves. How long before these delusional fans realize they lose in the playoffs (particularly after 2003) because they don’t spend, trade, and build a team that can win it all?!
They lost yet again in the first round, yet they have another excuse. The common denominator is the team is not built to win and this offseason they have regressed or remained stagnant at best. But they are true fans so they must be right.
Sid Bream
The Braves lost in the playoffs because Snitker decided to pitch Keuchel(+10era) in Busch stadium on 3 days rest and decided to pitch Foltynewicz in a game 5 decider.
The Braves lost a 5 game series 3-2 because they didn’t execute which had nothing to do with “spend or trade”. It was all to do with lack of execution. Game 1 unfortunate injury to Martin we were leading the game 3-1 bottom 7, Jackson comes in for Martin and did not execute and also left two runners on for Melancon. Furthermore, Snitker should have left Fried in the game until he got into trouble and we probably win that game. We then go and win games 2 & 3. We then lose game 4 when Snitker uses Keuchel on 3 days rest, and no need for commentary on Game 5. It was nothing to do with trades or spend, it was lack of execution, and as far as I am concerned some bad moves from Snitker.
TradeAcuna
No, it is not. The Cardinals are/were not a good baseball team, yet every game (except the last) was close. Struggling against the Cardinals only means the team is not ready to compete against the big boys. If you think otherwise, keep dreaming. We will see again next season the same exact results or worse.
tbones3141
NOBumgarnerEqualsNONLCS…please go away. Your takes are embarrassing and so blatantly ignorant. I hope you sre just trolling and dont believe what you said….
AndyMeyer
Offer up the kids and get Clevinger
TradeAcuna
He is my #1 target right now as well (.. : (( Bumgarner : ((..).
1. Indians probably have no urgency to trade him
2. Braves don’t have an urgency to win
So, unlikely. Whether it is the best available free agent pitcher or best available trade target, the Braves will not bite. They have to go cheap as they did with Hamels. No long term commitment and they get to keep their precious prospects that will probably amount to nothing.
tbones3141
$18 mil is going cheap? Again, your ignorance is outstanding.
DarkSide830
Braves have plenty of great starting options already and many more that can break out this year. they’ll be fine, and there’s also the deadline.
bravesfan
So I am a big fan of Caleb smith. Would love the Braves to get him somehow. Marlins go hog crazy with their players when the Braves are in talks with them. Demand Acuna for JT then turn around and trade JT for a bucket of balls.
I know smiths #’s aren’t amazing, but I think he’s tough. Put him on the right team and he could thrive
DarkSide830
Sixto Sanchez is a “bucket of balls”?
bravesfan
I’m exaggerating for sure. But Acuna a proven high rank young star vs a at the time young class A pitcher. There is definitely a big difference.
MarlinsFanBase
So Sixto Sanchez and their current starting catcher who has more offense than many other starting catchers and a better arm than a vast majority of them, along with another pitching prospect is a “bucket of balls”? Keep listening to what E!SPN and FOX Sports told you.
richt
This is well-written
bigbadjohnny
NL East cold be the BEST division in 2020……too bad the Marlins will suffer !…..LOL
ForestCobraAL
NOPE
Rendon is gone.
The Braves could get Bryant and maintain NL Least strength from 2019 but then folks wouldn’t call it the ” N.L. Least” would they?
How’s John Middleton’s Phillies ever going to rise if everyone else doesn’t get weaker?
MarlinsFanBase
Don’t go to sleep on the Marlins.
Phiilies2020
Not sure what kind of a salesman Klentak is but we will see if can unload Odubel Hererra. I’m in sales and I have a way of convincing people to spend their money with me. Klentak kind of needs to do the same with Odubel. “Hey Rockies GM, listen if you give us Wade Davis we’ll give you Odubel. Money evens out and you got an extra 10mil to play with now. Who’s your CF? Ian Desmond? Ouch. Oh you want a young catcher? We have Grullon and Marchan. If we give you either one of them and a couple of our MLB ready arms like Suarez, Irvin or De los Santos and one of our top prospects like Stott or Medina or Moniak would you consider letting go of Jon Gray or Kyle Feeeland? Sheet while were at it, what would it take for you to let go of Arenado?We got a billion dollars from Comcast, so we’ll pick up the tab. We’ll even take one of those awful Shaw or McGee contracts since we wont give you Howard. And we’ll give Bohm so you have your stud prospect 3B. Man he’s gonna be a beast in that ballpark. Take Segura too because I know you guys think you can compete and hes better than Ryan McMahon at 2B. Whatdaya say?”
I dont know what the Phillies are doing behind the scenes but the point of this nonsense I just wrote is- they need to do more. They are not the best team in the division and everyone in the NL seems to be taking the competitive road this year so there’s going to be a lot of good teams fighting for those two wild cards. Should be a fun season.
bravesfan1970
TLDR.
DarkSide830
no trading with Colorado, it’s too risky. Arenado is the only player i feel safe trading for from the Rox, and he’s not really on the block at the moment. (id believe at least)
Lee cohn
Think Klentak took his family on a Carnival Cruise somewhere in the Caribbean, returning February 1. Silence from Phils on all fronts. Starter and relief pitching is low rent at this point so repeat of last year is sadly inevitable. Smart front office would have cured this by now. Hate the drippings. When Spring games begin the problem will be more pronounced and trading partners will be licking their chops. Look what Kluber went for. Billion plus dollars from Comcast was a mirage or better spent on paint and a new restaurant facility at Citizens Bank Park. Plus owner smartly took the better cruise line…Viking Ocean Cruise returning to Philly in March. Fans will be checking out too.
DarkSide830
Phils should take a run at Kikuchi for the bench
Henry Limpet
The Mets don’t want Starling Marte very badly if all they are offering Pittsburgh so far is Brandon Nimmo. I would take my Starling Marte and go home if I was the Pirates GM in this circumstance.
Marte is a perfect blending of power, speed, defense and just plain ‘good hitting’. He can hit .300, or hit long home runs. If he focuses on base stealing, he can easily steal you 40 or more bases in a season. He regularly guns down runners trying to advance on him, or testing his arm to try to score.
There is just too much in the package to really give a proper write-up of his abilities. Only people who have watched Starling Marte play day in and day out know what I’m talking about. Playing in Pittsburgh, he doesn’t get the spotlight from the media like he would if he played in a big city or a media center.. But Starling Marte is far too good to just easily flip for some middling outfielder.
The Mets haven’t even come to the table if Nimmo is all they are offering. I wouldn’t trade Marte unless at least J.D. Davis was in the deal, along with some prospects to boot. personally. Otherwise I say keep him. Maybe even look into giving him an extension (I know that is sacrilege to cheapo owner Bob Nutting, but sometimes you need to put your money where your mouth is).
jkoko
Phillies need to ditch Odubel
SalaryCapMyth
It seems the Braves and Nationals have taken their regular season competitiveness into the offseason. If the Braves can resign Donaldson it would be a big win against the division rival Nationals. What should make every Braves fan a little nervous though, is the Nationals being more willing to spend money and take chances while the Braves behave like a middle market team.
There are a lot of misconceptions about what the Braves owner, Liberty Media, can actually do for them. LM certainly CAN spend money on the Braves and that was exactly what they did in 2014 when they brought on.
You can read more about the relationship the Braves and LM have and all the technocalaties here:
tomahawktake.com/2016/05/07/atlanta-braves-fans-lo…
What they can’t do is make a profit from what the Braves make. The Braves are a real estate investment. LM won’t make a penny until they sell the team.
I say all that to support the issue with the Braves spending. LM can’t just spend money like the Nationals do because LM is publicly traded, has a board of trustees and investors to think about.
So do the Braves have the money to sign Josh Donaldson? I would say yes but they have to be careful. Just because the Braves got Liberty Media to help with paying Ervan Santana back in 2014 doesnt mean they are going to go get Donaldson for them.
I hope the Braves give Donaldson his 4th year because I think trading for Bryant is a mistake. The most you will get out of him is 2 years. Boras loves getting his clients to the free market and this offseason only reinforced that habit.
tbones3141
My favorite thing I have ever read on the internet is “technocalities” just giggled my booty off. So fantastic.
JackStrawb
The section on the Mets really missed the point. They didn’t have ‘boxes to tick,’ they had opportunities BVW frittered away. It turns out the Mets had the money to add two premium players, of the kind that drive you towards the postseason, but they brainlessly followed some strange supermarket checklist: “5th starter slot–so he can’t be very good. Preferably an old scrap heap guy….”
They lost Wheeler, Frazier, Vargas, Avilan, and some odds and ends from a team that overperformed and still only won 86. That’s a team projectable to around 78 wins at most as of the end of October. To that depleted club they only added 2/3 of a Stroman season, a #6 starter on a contender in Porcello, an iffy reliever in Wacha, a backup OFer, and a reliever with one appearance last season.
Turns out they had real money to spend, but are barely able to claim they might be as good as they were on Opening Day, 2019. It’s too bad, but it’s what we should have expected from a GM who, over the last two offseasons, and in addition to the Cano fiasco, has traded away 8 useful minor leaguers for backup OFers. Imagine a good GM packaging those players for the best available young, MLB-ready CFer or starting pitcher. But the missed opportunities on top of the gross blunders have been routine for this inept FO.
The Steve Cohen era–and Van Wagenen’s firing–can’t come soon enough.
MarlinsFanBase
I’ll do the Marlins bit.
Wondering if they really would sign Yasiel Puig. Could Mattingly deal with him for a season?
Wondering why not go after Domingo Santana if they are looking for power-hitting corner OFs. He’d be worth a look, especially with the odds of us being in last place are very good again in our rebuild.
Not sure what else I would want for this year for our OF. I prefer just keep adding options to our bullpen and maybe take a flyer on Danny Salazar if he is healthy.
jim stem
In regard to the Mets, JD Davis needs to play every day. There just aren’t that many players that can hit for power AND average today. Either plug him in at 3b or left field and let the kid get 650 plate appearances. With Cespedes looking like he wants to play for a contract beyond 2020, that means LF is taken. Davis either moves to right with McNeil moving to 3b or he takes 3b himself.
I’m also ok with trading Matz if it means moving Smith, Nimmo and/or Lowrie (or Cano) in the process.
Mets still have some chips to deal with to acquire Marte or another true CF type. Love to see them go get Ketel Marte who could also slide into 2b as soon as Cano breaks down again.
A package of Matz and Smith could return a pretty nice piece, hopefully a young, productive catcher.
Lee cohn
Think Klentak took his family on a Carnival Cruise somewhere in the Caribbean, returning February 1. Silence from Phils on all fronts. Starter and relief pitching is low rent at this point so repeat of last year is sadly inevitable. Smart front office would have cured this by now. Hate the drippings. When Spring games begin the problem will be more pronounced and trading partners will be licking their chops. Look what Kluber went for. Billion plus dollars from Comcast was a mirage or better spent on paint and a new restaurant facility at Citizens Bank Park. Plus owner smartly took the better cruise line…Viking Ocean Cruise returning to Philly in March. Fans will be checking out too.