The Rangers cleared a bit of payroll yesterday that could further their campaign to host Anthony Rendon’s Texas homecoming. But that pursuit is hardly certain to be a successful one. The organization needs to consider backup plans at the hot corner while also chasing down other desired upgrades.
While Rendon’s Lone Star roots surely don’t hurt, the Rangers can’t count on a local discount. Agent Scott Boras indicated to reporters yesterday that geography isn’t going to be an “overriding consideration” for his client, as MLB.com’s TR Sullivan was among those to cover (Twitter link). That hardly takes the club out of contention — state tax advantages are still a factor and the ties may still matter on the margins — but it serves to highlight that the Rangers won’t necessarily come away with their top target.
If Rendon decides not to help christen Globe Life Field and the Rangers can’t circle back to land their other top potential match in Josh Donaldson, the possibilities look quite a bit less appealing. But the Texas organization would at least have plenty of powder dry to spend elsewhere. And it could put its third base opening to use to pursue upside.
Should the Rangers turn to the rest of the market, Maikel Franco could be a fall back option, per MLB Network’s Jon Morosi. Franco did manage a serviceable 105 wRC+ as recently as 2018. In the absence of a more thrilling alternative, Franco would at least deliver a chance of liberating unrealized potential for a team with a chance of achieving “upstart” status in 2020. Still, Franco appears even less likely to make the leap than Nomar Mazara, the Rangers’ own underdeveloped star, shipped to Chicago yesterday.
Franco would certainly come cheaper than Rendon, for good cause, as Rendon’s superstar turn emerged in the national spotlight upon winning a World Series title – while Franco produced a career worst -0.8 bWAR before an inelegant end to his Philadelphia tenure via non-tender. Nick Solak is the nominal incumbent, but he can move around the diamond depending on who GM Jon Daniels adds to their collection of quasi-ill-fitting position players.
Not much further down Daniels’ checklist? Finding an offensively capable option behind the plate, per Jeff Wilson of the Fort Worth Star Telegram. The Rangers have some interest in a reunion with Robinson Chirinos and have also been connected to fellow top-remaining free agent Jason Castro. But the club still faces competition for these and other backstops.
It’s tough to imagine the club will fail to come away with a new option to supplement the existing group of backstops. Jose Trevino ended the year on a high note and should compete for a roster spot. Jeff Mathis returns as well, the definition of a glove-first player in its extreme after a truly woeful .158/.209/.224 across his 248 player appearances in 2019. Depending on Trevino’s development and their ability to add to third wheel, the Rangers are open to using the new 26th roster spot to hold a third catcher. Trevino has an option remaining, however, so that’s not a necessity, and at 37 in March, Mathis’ playing days are likely nearing an end. Of course, they also have Isiah Kiner-Falefa on the roster serving as a third catcher/utility option, and they added former Tampa Bay Ray Nick Ciuffo to the Triple-A ranks. Ciuffo, in the mold of Mathis, is a strong receiver who has yet to hit his stride at the plate. 25 in March, Ciuffo is the youngest of the three primary catchers by a few years, while Kiner-Falefa turns 25 just a few weeks after Ciuffo.
The Rangers have other irons in the fire, too. As Wilson reports, the club is working on lining up some minor-league pacts of note. Daniels indicates that the club believes it’ll be able to bring back a few pitchers — lefty Jeffrey Springs and righties Matt Bush and Edinson Volquez — on non-roster contracts.
nailz#4life
Rangers get no top FA. They hope that the “ghost” of those players they designed their ballpark after show up in spirit and be the behind the scenes reason they win ballgames.
realgone2
Huh?
macstruts
Cole signing with New York was a big loss for the Rangers. The Angels are in on Donnaldson and Rendon and the Dodgers are in on Rendon.
Regarding their pitching, the Angels were left without a chair at the big dance. The Rangers now may be without a chair at the big dance regarding 3rd.
madmanTX
Not really. The Rangers aren’t going to overpay for Cole the way the Yankees did
yanksknicks
I think you missed the point.
Vin Scully
Franco is awful. He should be playing in Korea and not MLB.
VonPurpleHayes
Franco is underrated and Kapler didn’t give him a chance in 2019. Philly didn’t work out, but Franco will excel elsewhere. Of course he’s a huge downgrade from Rendon and Donaldson, but he’s not a bad option.
Rangers29
I see marlins getting him, and sticking brian anderson in right field. The marlins seem like they are getting underrated players with upside right now for flipping at the deadline.
DarkSide830
Franco had his chances. he started off strong and then cratered. he had plenty of chances this year with no clear 3B starter and failed each one.
VonPurpleHayes
He had his chances, just not in 2019. He was platooned and benched at the first sign of a slump. Eventually he was sent down. Other players struggled offensively all year and kept playing. I think a better manager can bring out the best in Franco.
coach him
He would be fine in Texas. Hit .265 and give you close to 25 homeruns. Gets in his own head at the plate and Philly screwed with him in 2019 with Kapler antics. Change of scenery and regular play will do him well. Very underrated glove and arm.
Georgiajeff
Everything Kapler touched turns to crap
Rangers29
Please bring Robbie back, I want him to be on our next contending team… with Rendon.
Bledcam
Rangers trying to depress me now. Rendon needs to be the guy. If not, move to Donaldson or see if you can’t acquire Bryant.
seamaholic 2
Do Rangers have prospects to get Bryant or Arenado?
Bledcam
Without knowing what Chicago wants, its hard to say. If they truly need to cut salary, I think a package built around Taveras, Apostel and Ornelas could be a solid return. But I’m more than sure someone will respond to this saying its a critical undersell and they may very well be right.
RunDMC
Bryant, yes. You need a hostage included to get Arenado even if willing to take on that deal.
sippycups
Rendon definitely needs to be the guy to go all in on right now.
oz10
I know how you can’t get Bryant..just don’t ask. Guaranteed to not acquire anyone that way.
RunDMC
powder dry?
CrewBrew
Theres a strong possibility they strike out on all of these guys
Bledcam
Please stop. We can’t handle another bust FA.
CrewBrew
I think they have a good shot at Rendon, but as far as the other big third basemen, i dont see them happening.
HalosHeavenJJ
As far as tax advantages, CA has a 13.3% top rate, the highest in the nation. Texas has none.
So if Texas offers within 10% of the Angels, it’s about even take home pay.
That’s a significant advantage when you’re talking $200 million.
KremeCheez
Players still pay state taxes in each state in which they play and in their state of residency. So, while your point is valid, the numbers are off and the impact is overstated.
oz10
So it is almost half the rate since half the games are played at home. Still not insignificant.
HalosHeavenJJ
81 in Anaheim, 3 in LA, 9 in Oakland guaranteed each year if he’s an Angel. I’ve done the actual math and it’s about a 7% guaranteed difference.
But since this is a baseball thread I threw out “about 10%” to keep things simple.
No Soup For Yu!
Signing with the Rangers also guarantees several games against the Astros and Mariners. People forget this but the state of Washington has no state income tax either, so signing with either of the two Texas teams or the Mariners guarantees at le as at 100 games with no state income tax.
AA_Cardinals
Matt Carpenter would be a great addition to the Rangers squad. Send the Texas man home and let him play ball with Lance Lynn again. The Cardinals would be willing to clear some room to send him to the AL. Arlington needs a man like Carp at third base.
CrewBrew
Carp is terrible. After last season, his trade value and his contract make him almost unmovable.
dgarn
I was thinking that previously but never said it out loud. Not sure what else we would have to send with him to get a deal done though.
Lee Schafer
Rangers have too many holes on their roster to pay Rendon or Donaldson. Texas has deficiencies at catcher, CF, 1B, the bullpen, and still need a solid top or the rotation starter.
Chirinos for 2 yrs would bridge the gap to Huff and Trevino. CF is tougher, but I would take a chance on Kevin Pillar,for 2yrs, he is better than DeShields. Texas needs at least 3 solid relievers, how about Harris, Cishek, and Doolittle. Then for the biggy, lets give Bumgarner $130M for 5 years.. Instead of spending $250M+ for one guy lets go and get 6-7 quality players that can fill more needed holes. Sign Todd Frazier for a year, if you just have to have a veteran at 3B.
monymgr
I don’t disagree with your plan, thoughts or wishes for the Rangers but I have to tell you ….You are in LaLa Land !!
Jrmomo1000
Willie Calhun is a guy the cards Could use Carpenter Oniell and money for him.
charles stevens
I would let Rendon go to LA. If you want to be more competitive then use your money on two big bats for less total guarantee. Sign Donaldson for 3rd and Castellanos to play 1st. Castellanos could dh when you want to sit Choo against a lefty.
padnastikador
Agreed. I don’t like the Rangers handing out contracts over 5 years. I’d rather them target guys like Donaldson, Castellanos, and Bumgarner.
Shoeless Joe's Diploma
I think that is SOLID advise.
You could even get/afford Chirinos for a couple of years.
That fills 3 needed holes with money enough to get a #3 arm. or better.
davemlaw
Evan Longoria is going to start looking really good to whichever team doesn’t get a premier 3rd baseman. And he’s still serviceable, putting up a 2.4 WAR even after a brief stint on the DL. Kyle Seager for that matter too.
Point is once Rendon and Donaldson are off the board the pickings get slim fast and teams who are in win mode now will be looking for the next best alternatives. Maikel Franco is way down the list!
slugger82685
The Rangers will get outbid on Rendon, it’s inevitable. They always have a benchmark for what value they view players and refuse to go over it, so a Yankees or a Dodgers will come in and simply outbid them since the Rangers won’t get into a bidding war. But for top guys in FA teams HAVE to overbid otherwise those teams will strikeout. The Market always sets a players value higher than the Rangers ever will.
Logjammer D"Baggagecling
Nope. It was reported by espn
Logjammer D"Baggagecling
Rendon to the Rangers 10/300
acmeants
Rangers need to focus on building a pitching staff to contend. They can do that if they spend big bucks on a free agent who will have to carry the load by hi,self.
acmeants
By himself.
Robert16
As for a catcher, it would seem Romine would be a good fit for the Rangers (or Angels). He’s come into his own the past couple years or so and has better stats than several current starters. Pitchers love him and he’s a good clubhouse guy.