The San Francisco Giants have hired Scott Harris to serve as the team’s general manager, according to a report from Jeff Passan of ESPN. Harris had previously worked as the Cubs’ assistant GM since 2018 after five years as Chicago’s director of baseball operations.
Harris, 32, will join the Giants as Farhan Zaidi’s second-in-command after the team went more than a year without a general manager. A bay area native, Harris graduated from UCLA and earned his MBA from Northwestern, breaking into the baseball industry as an intern with the Nationals and Reds, positions that he turned into a full-time gig in the MLB commissioner’s office. In his time with the Cubs, he had a hand in the club’s ascension to World Series champions in 2015, emerging as the right-hand man for top baseball ops officers Theo Epstein and Jed Hoyer.
Even with a general manager in place, the Giants’ baseball decisions will still run through Zaidi, who with a year under his belt now has the opportunity to populate the Giants’ leadership ranks with his own hires. Zaidi was brought aboard to be the top dog and foremost decision-maker, and that won’t change. However, that’s not to downplay the importance of Harris’s addition; the general manager, in Zaidi’s own words, will “share the load in managing the overall operation,” an endeavor in which Harris should be of considerable utility: in a statement from the Giants, Harris is credited with overseeing the Cubs’ research and development department, the arbitration process, and the baseball ops department’s financial strategy and planning.
And Harris will have to get started right away. With the GM meetings underway this week, Harris will enter his new post during one of the busiest and most critical times of the year for baseball executives. With the Giants still searching for their next manager, it’s not clear how much sway Harris will have in the final hire, though it’s no doubt a priority that Harris, Zaidi, and the new skipper are all on the same page. Still, Harris could still provide some valuable input: Joe Espada, one of the finalists for the Giants’ job, also interviewed for the Cubs position, a process in which Harris almost certainly would have participated.
The addition of Harris represents the continuation of the Giants’ organizational overhaul of the baseball operations department, which began last year with the ouster of GM Bobby Evans. The organization sought a more modern front office, with a president of baseball operations working in concert with a general manager. In Zaidi, the club found their president last year. And now, the GM is in place. After Bruce Bochy’s retirement, there’s of course another important hire that must be made, and it seems that a decision could be coming soon: the Giants have reportedly narrowed the field down to three finalists: Joe Espada, Gabe Kapler, and Matt Quatraro.
On the field, Zaidi has already begun his transformation of the team, showing an aptitude for acquiring marginal talent improvements in low-risk moves. The acquisitions of players like Mike Yastrzemski, Alex Dickerson, Kevin Pillar, and Donovan Solano—all of which came at a minimal cost to the Giants—played a part in the Giants’ surprising midseason run that kept them on the brink of playoff position despite low expectations.
This, along with a burgeoning farm system and the undeniable purchasing power of the Giants, makes the Giants an attractive rebuilding project for an executive like Harris—more so, at least, than when Zaidi took over after 2018, inheriting a group consisting largely of dynastic leftovers and pricey, past-their-prime mercenaries. The outlook for 2021 and beyond, though, is a promising one. With prospects like Joey Bart, Heliot Ramos, Marco Luciano, and Hunter Bishop anchoring the farm system, there’s some foundation to work with. And when hefty contracts start to come off the books, the Giants can expect to flex their financial muscles and become a real player in negotiations with top free agents.
For Giants fans hoping to learn more about the newest addition to the San Francisco front office, The Athletic’s Sahadev Sharma profiled Harris in March of 2018, painting him as a hard-working rising star in baseball’s front office landscape. Harris drew rave reviews from superstar execs Theo Epstein and Jed Hoyer, under whom he worked in Chicago.
Francys01
Okay.
Xavier Blaine
Thanks for the insightful response, francys08.
Francys01
You’re welcome. I am glad to help you.
dynamite drop in monty
I tried making an omelette today and It was tragic
ioh2710
Same thing happened to me dynamite
dynamite drop in monty
Together we will get thru this
live42day
Dynamite I actually and honestly made a great omelette today.
dynamite drop in monty
I’m really proud of you. Seriously.
Baseball 1600
Very interesting hire. I think Farhan will still be making most of the moves, though. Similarly to how Bobby Evans was Sabeans puppet.
Ejemp2006
32 year old GM? Really?
You are spot on, Farhan will be making the moves because this kid couldn’t possibly be expected to know what to do. Nor could this kid have the relationships with other GMs necessary to make deals.
burrdeuces
You should read The Athletic article on him. This statement couldn’t be further from the truth.
Ejemp2006
Many great baseball careers culminate with a GM opportunity. You think career guys, who paid their dues, will look at him as a peer or want to entertain his ideas?
He headed R&D, and in that role you want a young guy representing novel ideas. In the GM role, you want a mature guy who represents stable sustainable growth.
But I guess it’s good to see that not everyone can be the Cardinals.
JayRyder
Seems. Like a good hire. Coming from the Cubs..
Then they can discuss who they like as a Manager together.
andrewgauldin
Albert Almora to the giants?
spinach
Why would they give up anything for him?
dynamite drop in monty
Who is bond compared to Kronsteen?
Phiilies2020
First order of business is to try to get rid of Longoria’s contract, if that’s even possible. I wouldnt be surprised to see the Giants pull the plug and go all out rebuild. The Rockies should too
Baseball 1600
There’s nothing to sell. You could say that they should be rebuilding, but what is there to sell off? The only players they had of value were Smith and Bumgarner in which they negligently decided not to trade at the deadline. Now it’s Farhans turn to continue to make wonders out of his dumpster diving technique, hopefully he finds another Yastrzemski or two.
Phiilies2020
Buster Posey has to have some value still, especially with so many teams needing catching help. Hes a proven winner, WS champion and has a chance to rebound offensively. .280 15-20 dingers maybe. Samardzija’s not a bad #3 or #4. He made 32 starts last year. I agree they waited too long but there’s no way they can compete with the Dodgers so I don’t get why they’re even trying
Baseball 1600
There’s no reason for them to trade Posey. He’s their franchise guy, and with his contract and his terrible health status these past few years, may not even warrant a legit prospect that would speed up a rebuild. The guys they can trade are Pillar (if they tender him a contract), Gott, Watson, and Samardzija (who’s coming off an extremely underrated season). Not much else to sell off.
ghostrobot
There has to be some balance between ‘burn it down’ and competitive. Nobody wants to watch garbage for 3 years but it doesn’t mean they should dump posey for salary relief and prospects.
Dingerz
Could move him to first to make room for Joey Bart
steelerbravenation
Stop with the can’t trade Posey nonsense
Anybody can be dealt
His position still holds value
I bet his childhood team would give up something of value for him where he could hit 7th and his offense wouldn’t be so scrutinized.
His leadership over a young staff would be valuable and the more money the Giants eat the better the prospect haul going back.
Plus they can play hero’s and say they decided to move Buster to his childhood team to give him the opportunity to compete for another championship or 2 instead of being mired in a rebuild with the Giants top prospect breathing down his throat
steelerbravenation
His offensive number do not play at 1B especially at that price
His value is in his catching
Cam
Posey has very little value to anyone other than the Giants. He’s got a lot of mileage on his legs, and his bat doesn’t play anywhere on the diamond.
spinach
There’s no reason they cannot be competitive. They are like $90m under the tax line. Their veterans players don’t stink, they just have not been having great years lately. Add 3-4 good-to-really-good players and they can certainly be a playoff team. (Agreed the Dodgers are juggernautish but that’s not a reason not to compete and get into the playoffs.)
Cam
Their veteran players do stink – what Giants have you been watching?
Dingerz
That’s a lot though lmao. And we’re 70 million under the tax.
rightyspecialist
Is this poster under psychiatric care? Meds?
The San Francisco Giants are 3 years away from being relevant. 5 years away from being a playoff team.
They need to try and log a season above .500 before thinking about October baseball . Lol
Dingerz
^
Dingerz
Posey’s body typically won’t be able to play catcher anymore in 2 to 3 years. He’ll retire or move to first base.
semut
splnach – Gotta admit I laughed at “Their veterans players don’t stink, they just have not been having great years lately.”
amk3510
Yazstrzemski is 30. They will be lucky if he isn’t another Dereck Rodriguez
Bobby Czyz
Posey would be one of the worst hitting 1st basemen in baseball.
Bobby Czyz
Yaz is 29. Why exaggerate?
Dingerz
He’s already one of the worst hitting catchers. And because of his broken leg and the hip surgery he’s not gonna be able to play catcher much anymore. He’ll move to first like Mauer did. Especially because we have Bart coming up.
Balk
What do you think they were going to get for Bum or Smith? A couple of low level prospects? Cmon, they didn’t lose anything, I’d be pretty safe to say I’m sure Zaidi knows a heck of a lot more then you do! Get out of here with your assumptions!
Dingerz
Rosenthal said Bum would get back a top 100 lmao
Balk
Exactly, and you can get that by just letting him go in to free agency with the qualifier attached.
Dingerz
Yeah, a second-round sandwich pick is better than a top 100 prospect.
MoRivera 1999
One positive thing you can say about the Longoria transaction: it wasn’t as bad as the Sox’s deal for the Panda. 🙂
Dixon Miaz
That Longoria trade wasn’t bad at all. Christian Arroyo did not pan out and got traded to the Indians for a player that did not crack the Indians top 30 prospect. The giants gave up nothing
sacball
Lucius Fox might pan out still…big on might
ghostrobot
That transaction was puzzling to me. Wasn’t it for chompers
Dixon Miaz
Lucious fox was for Matt Moore, not Longoria. Fox’s value has been degrading. His hitting tool isn’t looking too good. He’s now rated as a 45 instead of 50.
Dingerz
That contract though
spinach
And the contract was paid down a bit. Agreed, fine trade.
MoRivera 1999
It’s the $80MM!!! contract for Longoria. THAT was a disaster by any measure.
Evan Longoria Trade Turning into $80M Disaster for Giants
bleacherreport.com/articles/2783951-evan-longoria-…
Matt_Angel_Bronco_Laker
There’s only about $44M left on the remaining 4 years (The last of which is a team option with a $5M buyout). The Rays are eating $9M have been every year that Longoria has been with the Giants.
That AAV for what he brings to the table… pshh, definitely worth it.
MoRivera 1999
125 GP, .694 OPS in 2018.
129 GP, .762 OPS in 2019.
Yeah, he really brings a lot to the table.
rightyspecialist
The Longoria deal is one of the worst deals I’ve ever seen. How much money did they take on ? 80 million
MoRivera 1999
Tampa Bay paid $2MM of Longoria’s $10.2MM contract in 2019.
Tampa Bay will pay $2MM of Longoria’s $11.2MM contract in 2020.
Longoria is basically league average OPS+.
Longoria is 15 of 18 among qualifying 3B in fielding %.
antibelt
Get rid of Longoria? His contract is not nearly as dreary as the Brandon’s. We need another starter amd middle infielder than we do ditching Longo. I don’t like Harris from Chicago either. They have been making a lot of poor signings, and emptied the cupboard with trades.
leprechaun
What a terrible move why would you hire anyone from the Cubs organization it’s a joke from Theo on down
anthonyd4412
Yeah right? 4 consecutive years in the playoffs, 3 in NLCS and a championship. Terrible
Dingerz
Harris is 32. He’ll be here a while. So when the Giants are contenders again we might be able to get a 4th ring in
theoepsteinhof
Why hire from the Cubs? Probably because Farhan has more smarts in his little finger than some short green fantasy cartoon figure who comments here.
Mario93
It’s not Theo Epstein, so who cares.
Mech986TRtt
Zaidi is doing the right thing, hiring smart, young talent with proven experience and openness to modern analytics. He’s in it for the long haul because it will take a few years to get SFG in a better position in the division and with their team.
bigbadjohnny
For the last two seasons, the Giants and Cubs talked about a Jason Heyward trade. Anyone think it might happen now, and who would the Cubs get in return ?
andrewgauldin
If it happens, Cubs would be attaching prospects to the contract. I wouldn’t expect much going back to the Cubs. I don’t see it happening. I think Almora is more likely if the cubs are willing to sell low.
talking baseball
Big bad Johnny, we need a POWER HITTING OUTFIELDER and Heyward is not it, besides that he’s not a youngster anymore. Let’s see what the young guys can do. I’m tired of the old retreads.
spinach
Heyward was in his 20s three months ago.
Ejemp2006
Heyward got hit in the face and has never really been the same since. He has been dancing around in the box for years.
its_happening
What is the gameplan for the Giants?
Sadler
Shuffle around players from waiver claims, trades, minors, etc. until they find a reasonable core worth building around. They’re not going to be seriously competitive for at least a few years.
hopper15
Draft and develop. Sign International talent. Wait until the hefty contract are off the books in 2 years.
jekporkins
I concur. The Giants are looking at 2022 to jump back into things.
They will have another hit-or-miss season in 2020 and by the middle of 2021 they will start seeing some of these hot guys come up (Bart, Ramos, etc). They will also be seeing the end of some contracts after 2021. Posey, Crawford, Belt, Samardzija will all be gone by 2022, and their payroll will be under $60 million.
So by 2022 with a full season from Bart and Ramos, maybe Webb, Bishop too. Fill in with a couple free agents and you’re young, dumb and ready to compete.
The kid they will be watching like a hawk is Marco Luciano. He is barely 18 and looks like he could be the next A-Rod, or at the very least Nomar Garciaparra. He even plays shortstop. Google him and read for yourself. The beauty is if they can push him he’ll be ready to rock in 2022 as well.
sacball
Bart and Ramos have been aggressively promoted, I’m guessing they’re going to be with the big club by September, if both of them can find a way to stop being hit by pitches…
Dingerz
Trying to contend apparently. Hopefully Harris and Farhan don’t make any stupid moves like trading Bart or other top prospects
hopper15
Why would they trade top prospects during a rebuild? They aren’t going to do something that foolish.
Dingerz
They’re not rebuilding, sadly
hopper15
They didn’t publicly say it out of respect to Bochy and his final season. But it’s absolutely a rebuild.
Rallyshirt
I think they’ll lose Bumgarner, keep Smith and sign Gerrit Cole.
letsplaytwo
The Cubs won the World Series in 2016, not 2015.
AndyWarpath
So sick of the rebuild talks. Giants were 54-51 after May, have a perfectly decent farm system, and 60 something million available in salary. No, they’re not the Dodgers, but they’ll be competitive in 2020.
Fans clamoring for teams to burn it all down and stink for 3 years so that maybe, just maybe they’ll be good in the future is the worst sounding broken record I’ve ever heard.
Dingerz
So we should trade our best prospects?
wordonthestreet
So what is the better plan Andy?
AndyWarpath
Compete. Add a couple outfielders and a couple pitchers. They’re not far off; and they have the money to resign their free agents and go after someone like Castellanos. A 54-51 record across an entire season is an 84 win club. It’s not a far stretch to see them win 90 games and be in discussion for a wildcard spot with a couple decent signings.
Sadler
Except they were not an 84 win club, they were a 75 win club.
At one point in 2018, they were 68-68. They finished 73-89.
A season is played for 162 games, not 105, nor 136. They need to compete at a high level for an entire season and this isn’t a roster capable of doing that.
rightyspecialist
Not far off? They’re 4 years away . Have you seen the teams that play in the postseason?
You have no hitters. AND you have no hitters. Lol
You don’t Buy a competitive team in 2020 ….you grow one. You build a core of position players and young arms. Then you add FA’s to fill it out
Giants fans are like 5 -6 years behind current baseball philosophies. Lol
steelerbravenation
Can you imagine Castellanos playing the OF everyday in that ballpark lol
gravel
Someone like Castellanos is someone who cannot play defense. Oracle would eat him alive.
The Giants can be compelling as they further develop their farm system and churn the waiver wire for player who may stick for a season or two. Let’s not fool ourselves, this team isn’t one or two additions away from the wild card.
Sadler
The Giants gave up 95 more runs than they scored.
They won 30 fewer games than the team they’re chasing, the Dodgers.
Their #1 starter is a free agent that’ll likely leave.
Their #2 starter pitched in 4 games last year.
Their #3 starter is Jeff Samardjiza
Every one of their young starters, Beede, Rodriguez, Anderson, Webb, and Suarez had ERAs over 5.
They had 2 everyday players with an OPS+ over 100. One of them was a rookie, the other was Evan Longoria.
The Giants will not be competitive next year.
MoRivera 1999
I have it on good authority that Longoria brings a lot to the table.
Backup Catcher to the Backup Catcher
Only if he’s catering the post-game spread!
rightyspecialist
The farm system is mediocre. The 40 man roster is garbage
They just booked their 3rd consecutive below .500 season.
Zaidi is gonna burn it to the ground and start over
There is no other way
AndyWarpath
Again, over .500 for most of the year with 60m to spend in free agency. They have the cash to resign Bumgarner, Smith, and bring in 5-10 war in talent. Not to mention the gm’s proclivity of finding talent for next to nothing (see yastremski, solano, Dickerson, gott)
MoRivera 1999
With the exception of Yaz the sample size on those guys (Solano, A. Dickerson, Gott) is kinda small to start making strong claims to anything.
hopper15
The Farm system actually isn’t mediocre in it’s current state.
Rickey O'Sunnyvale
You mean it’s worse?
Frisco500
Giants farm system is looking more solid than it’s been in years. 4 guys who can be the core in a few years, and Seth C. who took huge strides last season, and was not only one of the top lefties, but one of the top over all starters in the minors last season. They’ll be leapfrogging lots of teams in no time. In the mean time, 3 WS rings since 2010 still give the real fans enough to keep us warm in the winter.
rightyspecialist
Yes it is. ‘Mediocre’ means moderate or average
The Giants farm system highest ranking in September was 16th out of 30 teams . It’s mediocre
rightyspecialist
You don’t get it. This team rode a 70+ DIFF all last season. Finished w a 90+ DIFF
Negative run differential clubs don’t play in the playoffs.
They are not ‘ a few pieces away’ they are organizationally flawed. Which means they don’t have the prospects to build with yet let alone provide depth at the big league level . Not to mention they have no pitching . Oh , and no hitters either . Lol
Bobby Czyz
But it’s on the upswing. What was it’s ranking at this time last year?
gravel
Mediocre is an improvement. The farm system was a tire fire.
PeeWeeGaskins
Rebuild.
xxbooradley
2015?
Tiger_diesel92
Hey the cubs won it in 2016, 2015 was the Kansas City royals.
Backup Catcher to the Backup Catcher
SFG gonna be last in the AL West this year. Maybe a 70 win team with a little luck. Even the Marlins might be more exciting this summer than the SFG.
I think SF is gonna like Dubron, the kid 2B they got from Milwaukee.
If there is one aged player they can trade, it’s probably Brandon Crawford. On a contender, his defense plays. If he batted eighth he’d still be better than most guys who hit that low in the order.