The Red Sox introduced new chief baseball officer Chaim Bloom yesterday, with Jason Mastrodonato of the Boston Herald and Julian McWilliams of the Boston Globe among those to cover the proceedings. With Brian O’Halloran rising to become GM, the top leadership is set. But how did the team settle on this arrangement and what does it mean for the rest of the baseball ops department?
President Sam Kennedy, chairman Tom Werner, and principal owner John Henry all addressed the matter, as did Bloom. The picture painted was of a hiring search that increasingly became a coronation.
While the Boston club started out looking at about twenty possible candidates to replace Dave Dombrowski, it recognized that many roads were leading to Bloom. It was a bit of a risk, Kennedy acknowledged, but the club focused on the key Rays executive even before sitting down with him.
There certainly was an interview process, with Bloom convincing the Red Sox of the merits of their intuitions. As Henry explains it, the team “felt he was the right candidate before we met with him” and left everyone with precisely that belief after a lengthy two-day process that involved a number of one-on-one meetings with key organization personnel.
Clearly, Bloom and upper management were on the same page — and not just on his general baseball acumen and lauded people skills. Both Kennedy and Bloom hit upon the same theme. The former says that Sox fans “want” and “deserve” a “sustainable baseball organization;” the latter cited a desire “to build as strong of an organization as possible in all aspects so that we can have sustained long-term success and compete for championships year in and year out.” While there’s no disputing the desirability of putting out a good product every year, Craig Calcaterra of NBC Sports rightly points out that the concept of sustainability is en vogue leaguewide as something of a euphemism for profit-minded salary management. The Red Sox have not been shy about stating a desire to draw down their spending levels.
Bloom wasn’t brought in to sit atop the existing leadership so much as to integrate within and lead it. Henry said that his initial inclination to pursue a heavily experienced baseball ops manager began to shift as he watched the club’s four-person interim team operate. “I don’t think anybody thought we were going to be interviewing No. 2’s, or people that had not been at least a general manager,” said Henry. “But because they were so strong, we decided that we should have somebody who can compliment them and lead the department.”
The precise stucture is still being sorted. Brian O’Halloran has been elevated to the GM seat, so he’ll be Bloom’s number two. But the exact arrangement on the next tier isn’t clear. Raquel Ferreira, Eddie Romero, and Zack Scott joined O’Halloran in filling in bridging from Dombrowski to Bloom. They’ll all remain in key roles, though at least one could still be on the move, as Chris Cotillo of MassLive.com reports. That’s not due to any known acrimony, but a hiring opportunity. Henry did not specify which person was actively under consideration elsewhere, but did make clear one of those three is interviewing for a position with another club.
hawkny11
Okay. With that said lets move on to solve the Pedroia situation and that of JD Martinez opting out.
bostonbob
Hawk, no situation with Petey. He’s DONE. Thanks for everything lets move on. JDM, its his decision. Live with his decision and move on.
hawkny11
Bob,
Pedey is still owed $25M for 2020 and 2021 together. I don’t know the rules thoroughly enough to know if this negotiable or whether he loses out because he is unable to play. Do you? Anyway, I would hope the Red Sox have insurance on Pedroia to cover any loses incurred because of his injuries. As for Martinez, it is his and his agent’s decision but where is he going to find $23M to be a DH and part time OF’er in the AL. I hope he stays and I hope the Red Sox FO rewards him somehow for his contributions to the club. Maybe a 6th year with a mutual club option?
joshua.barron1
Hi Hawkny,
Not bob but I have some answers/opinions.
Fact – The team can’t ask Pedroia to walk away from his contract, and all money is guaranteed. The Red Sox widely do not purchase insurance on their players because the insurance is exorbitant expensive and they can afford not to (smaller market teams need the cost certainty – sometimes the cost of insurance is 25% of the cost of the contract or more). Pedroia could decide to walk away on his own, or the team could buy him out in exchange for deferring some of the money with his consent. For the most part that $25MM stays though.
As for JD, the team has said they won’t add more money to his deal. I’d be sad to see him go, but I’d be surprised to see the team budge. They never had any doubt about his abilities entering the deal, rather his ability to stay healthy in years 3, 4, 5. That sentiment likely hasn’t changed, especially in light of the true cost of going over $208MM in payroll being actual salary + 50%
Have a nice night!
Josh
Phanatic 2022
Fully guaranteed contract. Only way Sox are off the hook is if he retires this forfeiting the money
ffrhb14Sox
Definitely no situation w Pedroia. What could they possibly do, trade a guy who didnt play last year? Not happening. Cut him? Sure but money still counts against lux tax so you gain nothing. It is just 2 more years for a Boston great. JD opting out is the real situation to look forward to.
NewYorkSoxFan
I can see Bloom being a lot like Cherington. Hopefully that includes the championship part.
Angry Disgruntled Sox Fan
If one championship in 4 to 5 years is what you want along with an albatross contract for Fat Panda and among others.
NewYorkSoxFan
Didn’t say I want that. However, I can see him being great at developing the farm while having trouble with free agent contracts just like Cherington did. He had minimal experience with big money deals in Tampa.
lovethatdirtyh20
Bloom has his work cut out. Fortunately one of his strengths is evaluating and developing pitching. Sox have failed miserably in both areas. They’ve wasted a lot of time and money with the draft and international free agents.
pasha2k
I wish him n Redsox nation all the best. I think new blood is good n having LaRussa nearby to consult is a good situation for him. I still feel badly for DD, his hands were tied, n I hope he finds a job.
Paul Heyman
Maybe he’ll look into the Pirates opening.
Paul Heyman
He’ll=Dombrowski
Caleb Clark
Dolphins just acquired Talib from the Rams
MafiaBass
I can’t believe Dante Hicks is our GM… is he even supposed to be here today?
MoRivera 1999
I’m told over and over that the Bloom move is a huge coup for the Sox. I’m open to believing that. I would just like someone to put forth some concrete examples of things Bloom did in Tampa Bay to suggest he was the lynchpin to their success. For someone so roundly lauded, that shouldn’t be too much to ask nor hard to do. Please. What was it?
JoeBrady
That’s why I take these things with a grain of salt. Every writer is attributing TB’s success to Bloom. I like the hire, but none of the writers have any idea of just how involved Bloom was in any decision.
wordonthestreet
Great points
slider32
Bloom is smart, hopefully the Sox will give him 3 years to build their farm system. Since only one team wins a championship, I don’t see that in the near future.
whyhayzee
No one person is the reason for success of any team. The smart effective leaders are able to work in a team environment and contribute to success. That seems to be Bloom’s skill set, not that he is some superhuman evaluator (there’s no such person).
bradthebluefish
Well said!