Justin Smoak’s time with the Blue Jays is all but certain to come to an end when Toronto plays its final game this season. The rebuilding Jays will want to get a look at Rowdy Tellez, who has already begun to cut into Smoak’s playing time, and Smoak is set to become a free agent for the first time in his career.
As far as contract seasons go, Smoak surely can’t be thrilled with his results. He’s hitting .206/.342/.398 with 21 home runs on the year. At a time where seemingly everyone in the league has morphed into a power hitter, Smoak has cleared the fences 17 fewer times than he did in his 38-homer 2017 season. Waning playing time and a brief stint on the injured list have impacted that total, but the overall results aren’t ideal with free agency looming.
Smoak’s season, though, is also among the stranger you’ll come across when sifting through this year’s class of free agents. No one likes a .206 batting average, of course, but there’s also quite a bit to like about Smoak’s 2019 campaign. His 16.1 percent walk rate is the highest of his career by a long shot and is the sixth-highest of any qualified hitter in baseball. Smoak’s strikeout rate (21.1 percent) is down more than five percent from its 2018 level and is the second-best mark of his career. Only eight qualified hitters in baseball — Mike Trout, Alex Bregman, Mookie Betts, Joey Votto, Carlos Santana, Shin-Soo Choo, Tommy Pham and Daniel Vogelbach — have chased fewer pitches outside the strike zone than Smoak and his 22.9 percent clip. He ranks in the top 30 in terms of pitches per plate appearance (4.10). He’s been extremely disciplined at the plate.
A notable portion of Smoak’s struggles could be tied up in the fact that he’s had some poor luck on balls in play (.220). When looking into particularly egregious BABIP erosion, it’s common to see some trends that would portend to fewer balls dropping for hits — an uptick in infield flies, for instance, or for a player with Smoak’s skill set, perhaps a sharp increase in ground-balls. That hasn’t been the case, though. Smoak’s seven percent infield-fly rate is the second-lowest of his career, and his 36.9 percent ground-ball rate is actually down nearly three percent from 2018. His line-drive rate, correspondingly, is up nearly three percent. His fly-ball rate is right in line with his past four seasons.
So perhaps Smoak simply isn’t making good contact anymore? Not the case. Smoak’s overall percentage of balls hit at 95+ mph is down from 41.9 percent last year to 38.9 percent in 2019, but he’s upped his average exit velocity, improved his launch angle and very slightly improved his barrel rate, per Statcast. Smoak’s expected batting average of .242 and his expected slugging percentage of .472 (also via Statcast) dwarf his actual output. Among hitters with at least 100 plate appearances, the -.041 difference between Smoak’s actual wOBA (.325) and his expected wOBA (.366) is the ninth-largest. Put another way: Statcast considers Smoak among baseball’s unluckiest hitters in 2019. Not great timing for a player who’s about to hit free agency.
Of course, a poor season can’t be entirely blamed on rotten luck. Some of the struggles in terms of batting average are tied to aggressive shifting against Smoak — particularly when he hits left-handed (where he’s vastly better than from the right side). Smoak is MLB’s fourth-most shifted player when he bats lefty, and teams are shifting him 12 percent more often than in his monster 2017 season. As such, it’s barely been worth the effort for him to leave the box when he puts the ball on the ground. (I joke for the sake of hyperbole — run out your grounders, kids!)
Smoak is hitting .139 on grounders as a lefty and a ghastly .105 from the right side. Shifts are becoming more aggressive, more universally adopted and more precise; that’s going to hurt your plodding first basemen of the world, and Smoak is no exception. He’s already top-25 among qualified hitters in terms of fly-ball rate, but it’s easy to argue that he should strive to elevate even more. It’s also worth noting that Smoak is hitting .583 on line-drives, which sounds nice but is substantially south of the league average (.686) and his career rate (.711). Shifting likely plays a role there as well — but to a lesser extent. That’s one area where he seems likely to improve moving forward.
Given the leaguewide uptick in shifts over the past few years and Smoak’s decreasing speed, he’s probably never going to hit .270 like he did in 2017 (.270/.355/.529). But Smoak is also still making good contact and is more patient at the plate than he’s ever been before. He’s only been narrowly above replacement level this year by measure of wins above replacement, but there’s good reason to expect his bat to bounce back in 2020. The free-agent market has been particularly harsh for first base/DH types in recent winters, which could lead to someone getting themselves a nice bargain on Smoak.
MuleorAstroMule
At some point you guys have to come around to the realization that extremely slow players constantly under-perform their xwOBA and not being able to beat out singles or stretch them into doubles has nothing to do with being unlucky.
He’s had ten seasons in the league. In only one of those he’s produced enough fWAR to be considered league average. Hard to see much upside there.
jdgoat
Interesting read. Someone’s gonna be getting a real nice bounce back season next year.
jimmertee
For his 10 or so years in the league, Smoak has had 2 good years. As discussed a few years ago, a bat cannot increase in speed at 30 years old without help.
Smoak admitted that 2 years ago he started seeing a sports psychologist. And Bam he has career years. I wonder how that works? Yah right, changing swing plain. Yeeesh. Not.
It’s humanly impossible for a bat to speed up like his did in 2017. I saw swings from him he wasn’t capable of over the previous 3000 AB’s.
FYI, what usually goes along with sports psychologist in MLB is a prescription with exception for Adderall.
Google Adderal tor star. You’ll see that it makes a good legal PED for MLB players. But the trouble with adderall is that is stops working after a while. – see Chris Davis career for a prime example.
This is not a strange season for Smoak. It was actaully called in these pages a few years ago.
Smoak won’t be bouncing back, unless he finds more help.
terrymesmer
JibberJabberTree, psychic detective! He sees things only he sees! A superpower without equal and without falsifiability! But…
…who will be cast in the movie version?
jdgoat
If you’re going to troll, why make a TL,DR post?
Paul Miller
More like a clown attempting to be a troll who can’t even get that right!
infractor
Because, sadly, he doesn’t realize he is…and thinks he sounds smart.
jimmertee
Movie version has to be Brad Pitt playing the #Scoutseyes role.
tycobb016
As far as Davis goes, his Adderall wore off because after his suspension his petition to re-apply for a TUE was denied. He was suspended in the first place because he or his agent failed to turn in the required paperwork but Davis continued to take it anyway.
cito's mustache
Smoak is a great clubhouse leader for the young Jays and Tellez is far from a sure thing yet himself. I think if they can bring Smoak back for 2020 they should do it.
its_happening
Hit it where they ain’t. Unless you are Smoak. Then hit the ball in the shift. Hopefully there is a team vying for his services. A team not named Toronto.