As a soon-to-be 36-year-old and a pending free agent, Yankees outfielder Brett Gardner’s future looks uncertain beyond this season. However, unlike 39-year-old teammate CC Sabathia, Gardner isn’t planning to retire at year’s end, Ken Davidoff of the New York Post relays. Gardner unsurprisingly wants to continue his career with the Yankees, the lone franchise he has ever known since entering the pro ranks as a third-round pick in 2005.
“At this point in the season, I expect to be playing next year. Hopefully it’s here,” Gardner told Davidoff on Wednesday .”I feel like I’m definitely still capable.”
Gardner, who debuted in 2008 and is now the longest-tenured Yankee, is indeed “still capable.” On a team with no shortage of big-name stars, Gardner’s one of many less heralded players who have helped the Yankees survive an onslaught of key injuries this year. Across 380 plate appearances, Gardner has slashed a sturdy .265/.334/.484 en route to a 112 wRC+, which ties for the second-highest mark of his career. Never known as a major power threat, Gardner has chipped in 17 home runs and what’s easily a personal-best ISO of .228. Combining Gardner’s output at the plate with his typically strong defense and base running has given him at least 2.4 fWAR for the seventh straight season and the ninth in his career.
Considering Gardner continues to function at a high level, he should overcome his age to land a decent – albeit short-term – payday prior to 2020. Gardner’s currently playing on the $7.5MM salary the Yankees handed him last offseason after declining a $12.5MM option over him. The plan then was for Gardner to serve as depth behind starting outfielders Aaron Judge, Giancarlo Stanton and Aaron Hicks, but all three of those players have missed a substantial amount of time with injuries (Stanton has barely been a factor).
No doubt, Gardner’s presence has been highly beneficial this year, and he’s one of the reasons New York boasts the American League’s leading record (75-39). However, even though Gardner’s a still-productive player and a revered Yankee, it’s up in the air whether they’ll bring him back next year. Judge, Stanton and Hicks are all in line to return in the outfield, while potential breakout player Mike Tauchman has made a case that he should get a roster spot in 2020. As a pre-arbitration player, Tauchman should earn a far cheaper salary than Gardner next season. Plus, the Yankees won’t be able to send the soon-to-be out-of-options Tauchman to the minors then, which could also influence their decision if they make a choice between him and Gardner.
Not to be forgotten, the Yankees have corner outfielder Clint Frazier hanging around in Triple-A ball. While Frazier (25 next month) at least looks like a major league-caliber hitter, he hasn’t stuck in the bigs this year despite quality offensive numbers. But the Yankees are known to be bullish on Frazier – whom they’ve been unwilling to trade to this point – and might finally choose to dedicate a spot to him next season. It remains to be seen whether that would help push out Gardner, the more well-rounded player.
twinsfan368
He ain’t gonna play much then. One thing is tho it’s seems like he’d be such a pest for a pitcher cuz he never swings at crap
dobsonel
That’s what they said this year until everyone hit the IL. Gardner turned out to be a fantastic signing and the numbers back it up.
KnicksFanCavsFan
don’t let @louiebeans hear that. he’s adamant that Gardner’s 1 year deal was crippling to the Yanks offseason payroll and the Yanks are destined to fail if he’s
KnicksFanCavsFan
… in the lineup.
srechter
Louiebeans also disavowed this yankees team six games into the season, claiming he was “done” after his 40+ years of fandom. That dude is a hoot.
sherlock_
Well, Gardner is underrated and NY will need him, even if it is going to be a while
mlb1225
The Yankees know about the durability of Judge, Hicks, and Stanton. I don’t see any reason for the Yankees to sign him as a platoon/4th outfielder on a short term deal.
robluca21
You mean you dont see any reason not to sign him right ?
mlb1225
Oops, I missed that part, lol
jbigz12
Tauchman, Frazier and his age are the reasons not to sign him. I see the reasons but 7 straight years of 2.4 fWAR is remarkable. You know what you get out of Brett Gardner every single year. I’d be inclined to bring him back and use one of the other two as a part of a package for another SP.
robluca21
His age ? They sent check your ID when you step into the batter’s box. he can be brought back on a 1 year deal .
Frazier is not an outfielder. He was so bad in left hes at the point of being unplayable
robluca21
Sorry I meant they dont check your ID
tomselleck
Frazier? Lol.
KnicksFanCavsFan
I think you’re exaggerating. I have no explanation as to why he’s had problems this year in the field but he never had those problems previously. They’re are wayyyyy worse OFs in the majors playing the field but that’s not the point. Yanks should want their best defenders out there. a lot of roster decisions to make regarding Frazier, Tauchman, Gardner, Urshela and Andujar next year.
allweatherfan
I’ve seen a fair number of comments from Yankees fans disparaging Gardner. I believe he has been referred to as Brett Garbage. What’s that about? He seems like a pretty good player to have.
robluca21
I’m a Yankees fan..I’ve noticed it’s a 50 50 split on Yankees fans loving him or hating him
Some Yankees fans are spoiled and want stars at every position…because gardner is not flashyor on social media and hes not 6 foot 6 hitting 40 Homer’s a year..some low IQ yankees fans dont see the value gardner brings to a team
TheTrotsky
Yeah a dude that has brought 40 career WAR is garbage. Spoiled indeed.
KnicksFanCavsFan
It’s been borderline ridiculous the way some have disparaged him of late. He’s a solid buy in a 1 year deal around $5-$8 mil. Tauchman might make the choice difficult next year.
srechter
Warms my heart to finally see some love for the obviously-valuable Gardner.
Roll
I have been a gardner fan for years … and that saying something for someone thats a mets fan. I was hoping the mets would sign him last year hoping NY was good enough to get in the race for him.
costergaard2
Before ‘17 started, I debated the merits of trading Gardner to the Mets for Jay Bruce. The Mets had a lot of OF but no true CF, and the Yankees had Ellsbury (remember him ?) and looked like we needed a corner OF (this was Feb and pre- 52HR Judge, or the breakout of Hicks).
JoeBrady
Some Yankees fans are spoiled and want stars at every position…
——————————————————
Same here in the RS Nation. The idea that, even on big market teams, you cannot have a superstar at every position, is lost on them. Gardner has been, and continues to be a fine player.
todd76
I believe Gardner/Sabathia/Chapman (with Cubs), are the only proven World Series Champions on this team.
Old User Name
Maybin with the Astros and, ahem, Ellsbury with the Sox.
JoeBrady
Who is this Ellsbury of whom you speak?
robluca21
Love gardy. Such a gamer and has really become a generational yankee. Sure hope hes back for another season of elite baserunning and defense and above league average offense
spooky
Yankees will low ball him and force Gardner to look elsewhere to get what his production is worth.
dust44
With the rosters expanding to 26 next year. And Stanton more then likely spending most games as a DH. Gardy has to be resigned. I think I’d try to sell on Trachman and Ursela in the offseason as a package for 2 starters if they miss out in Gerrit Cole. That’s the only free agent pitcher I’d throw money at. But maybe using one or both of those guys in a package to try to pry away Robbie Ray. I’d like to c them get 2 starters and move Happ to a long relief/spot starter. He really disappointed this year. Maybe even send him to Philly (Happ) to open up a second starter spot.
jbigz12
Tauchman and Urshela together aren’t going to bring back 2 starters you’d want in your rotation. With that being said I can’t believe the Yankees and Dbacks couldn’t agree on a deal for Ray at the deadline. It seems pretty hard for me to believe they find common ground this offseason. Don’t really think Ray is the TOR answer though. Think he’s another James Paxton. Ideally no higher than a #3 in your rotation.
Blue_Painted_Dreams_LA
Or tbh even 1 that’s preferable.
dobsonel
They are not trading Urshela
Loadinguser93
They need to he’s a career utility player having 1 good year it’s likely he will crash back to his career normal next year
Phanatic 2022
Is 1 year of Ray worth Frazier? The kid is young and a good athlete so I think his defense can come around. Also, he was playing a new position. Also, Schmit looked good the other night.
jbigz12
They offered far more than that for less than 1.5 years of Frazier and the D’backs declined.
robluca21
This isnt a video game. You’re not getting 2 starters for urshella and tauchman and even next offsrsdon happ contract will be hard to move
KnicksFanCavsFan
agreed. even with the good season a lot of ppl are not sold on some of the replacement guys. nut enough to move a TOR starter.
itsmeheyhi
Roster expansion is the best point raised so far. Its easy to then find a spot for him.
Lucky-Arm28
Move Stanton to 1B (gonna happen sooner or later, Marlins thought about it and Yankees did in 2018 ST) , package Voit, Andujar and maybe Hicks for pitching and Gardner and Tauchman man Center and Left.
Blue_Painted_Dreams_LA
You’re going to be extremely disappointed if you expect much from that package, especially when you add Hicks. A huge contract offset by age and injury accompanied with corner guys(or future 1Bs) who albeit offensively are good, but positionally have been devalued if not established elite off profiles will not lend itself to what you’re probably imagining in terms of P. Also Gardner is not an everyday CF.
iverbure
I can’t think of a single team that would need/interested in both Voit and Andujar. Maybe the marlins or the D-Backs but they aren’t going to be giving up good pitchers for those two.
robluca21
Ugh…dear jesus help me ..why do I read the comments
bluejays92
I hope that he plays as long as he can and does well. He’s been one of my favourite players to watch for a long time. He’s like sandpaper, and I love that.
its_happening
So long as the Yankees show zero faith in Frazier’s ability there is a very good chance Gardner re-signs.
Alex hamilton
There will be trades in the offseason. I don’t believe yanks will go huge for Cole, thus trading is the necessity. Depending how trades shake out will have an impact on what happens to Gardner.. my bet is he is back.
dobsonel
Yanks need to clear 10 to 12 roster spots this offseason so trades are definitely coming. Even if they are only small ones.
Fg-3
The yanks need to be the yanks of old… at least next year.. sign madbum and cole no questions asked and give Gardy a 1 year deal.. on the premise he will retire. He’s a class act. Can’t see him in another uniform. But yanks need those 2 arms time to pay and pay big
PopeMarley
Neither Bumgarner nor Cole want anything to do with NY.
KnicksFanCavsFan
Cole grew up a Yankee fan and was actually drafted in the 1st round but his wealthy parents urged him to go to UCLA. Not saying being a fan as a child is enough to him to sign (see Corbin) but i doubt he or Boras would be adverse to signing with them if the money is right.
fitsiqis65
Gardy deserves a great deal of gratitude and respect for his work in pinstripes. I take nothing away from him. However, resigning him is a huge mistake unless its a bargain and no guarantees. he’s making 10 mil this year which is insane. It’s apparently much easier for the genius to find outfield depth than it is to find SP. with cole, baum and others available (hopefully), no need to waste hal’s budget line on a 6th OF.
Thank you Brett for your service and how you represented the greatest franchise ever
jbigz12
Thanks Brett, now here’s a minor league deAl for your troubles! A true Yankee great!
KnicksFanCavsFan
why is resigning him to be a 4th OF a “huge” mistake?
fitsiqis65
on what depth chart is he 4th? the Tigers?
i think we can agree stanton, judge and hicks are ahead of him. So next year he’s a ahead to tauchman too? you’ve written off frazier, and who knows who else the genius finds on the cutting board.
Unless gardy takes an adam jones like 3 mil deal to come back its a waste of coin. of course if Hal gives the green light for an unlimited budget it doesnt matter.
I know cavs fan you simply don’t care about the rotation.
southbeachbully
@geeson
I care about the rotation but am not silly enough to try and draw a correlation between a likely 1 year deal they might offer to Gardner to be a backup vs the tens if not hundreds of million it might cost to sign a front of rotation starter. One has nothing to do with the other.
fitsiqis65
South beach is back- the one who loved the happ and cc signing? That one?
The yanks are paying cc and gardy 18 mil this year and Corbin is 23- so yeah paying a 6th outfielder 10 mil makes a difference when the team sets a budget.
You’re usually wrong and this is no exception
srechter
Actually, looking at the value of war this season, Gardner has been worth quite a bit more than his 7.5 mil plus 2 mil buyout earned this season. Nothing about that is insane whatsoever; he’s provided surplus value on that contract.
mike156
Gardner is definition of a useful player, And I’m a Yankees fan and watched him his whole career. He isn’t at all flashy, but he does a lot of things right. One day, his production is going to drop too far, and he will be without a job, But not yet. And, ask yourself, if you were a GM with perfect foresight: Would you have drafted a player with almost 41 career BWAR. I think you would have.
dt47
Package Stanton – not a Yankee
hockeyjohn
What teams are going to trade for Stanton which his contract and injury history?
rxbrgr
What about Ellsbury!
siddfinch1079
If the Yankees are so bullish on Frazier, then why did they trade for him?? I am guessing they do not like his attitude, since, for the most part, it looks like his bat plays well at the major league level…
srechter
I’m confused as to what you mean here…“Bullish” means optimistic about his chances.
Baseballfreak
Louiebeans is an idiot! Gardener has more than earned the paycheck he got this year. The one I’m pissed with is Stanton who has been a non-factor in anything Yankee affiliated this year! Trade that overpriced bum to whomever will take on that contract! Jacoby Ellsberry on roids!
southbeachbully
@geeson
I care about the rotation but am not silly enough to try and draw a correlation between a likely 1 year deal they might offer to Gardner to be a backup vs the tens if not hundreds of million it might cost to sign a front of rotation starter. One has nothing to do with the other.
Louiebeans
Maybin $550K Thinks he’s a better option over Gardner for LF. Yankees just saved almost 10 Million.
fitsiqis65
Look- you’re clearly a passionate fan. However you have no clue what you’re talking about. So I’ll keep this Sesame Street simple:
Hal and/or cash set a budget every year. That happless who you loved and I detest, cc and gardy who I both respect and thank for their good work in pinstripes are getting paid 35 million this year means the team had less money to spend elsewhere like upgrading the rotation and adding mlb depth. This is fact
Gardy is 10 mil and I assume cash has learned and will not overpay him again next year.
If you don’t comprehend budgets and expense than it’s the school system that failed you.
crazylarry
Just another monthly Gardner- Yankee update. WHO CARES?? Let’s pander to the New York crowd. Good Grief.
Louiebeans
I thank Gardner for his services but I’m going to go with what I have below and if you ask why. Each one of the options with a * are cheaper more money to spend on SP since they really blew it last off season.
* All Cheaper options then Gardner
Judge
Hicks
Stanton
Frazier*
Maybin*
Tauchman*
Last year I wanted the .330 hitting Michael Brantley over Gardner
I also believe there will be better option out there for LF is they move Stanton to 1b (dunno if they will only speculation)
Option Yasiel Puig – Anything can happen but I believe it’s long due the Yankees walk away from Brett
Thank you
Big Ol Frankiebeanshooterjohnson
TrillionaireTeamOperator
The practical me says let him walk, with Tauchman and Stanton and others as options. The sentimental me says give him the QA value on a 1-year deal to send him off financially super stable but I’ll go with the cynical me: He’s on pace to put up around 4.1 WAR or better, so re-sign him assuming you might need to use him full time 33.3% of the season and half or less the other 66.7% and split the difference in his contract and give him an amount that evens up his overall Yankee paydays like a 9 year extension: 1 year/$12.5M
That’s $85.5M over 9 years or $9.5M a season. I think he’s earned the 8-figure last year and I think we will use him close to that figure.
canadianyankee
Hicks and Stanton can’t stay healthy enough to get on a plane let alone play a game! Gardner has played his heart out and deserves another year, leadership, grit, and nobody bangs a clubhouse roof with a bat better than Gardy!