The Royals announced Thursday that they will select the contract of outfielder Bubba Starling prior to tomorrow’s game. A corresponding 40-man roster move will be announced tomorrow.
Starling, 27 next month, was the fifth overall draft pick by the Royals back in 2011. The Kansas native instantly became one of baseball’s top overall prospects, landing within the top 50 on the rankings of Baseball America, MLB.com and Baseball Prospectus in both 2012 and 2013. Starling’s prospect status dwindled as the former high school superstar struggled to perform up to expectations even in the lower minors.
At one point, Starling nearly walked away from the game entirely, as the Kansas City Star’s Sam Mellinger chronicled back in an excellent 2017 column. Starling, however, persevered through his lowest points in the game and will now be rewarded with his first call to the big leagues. After spending parts of three seasons scuffling in Triple-A, Starling has put together a much more palatable .310/.358/.448 slash with seven homers, 11 doubles, two triples and nine steals (in 12 attempts) through 285 plate appearances so far in 2019.
For the rebuilding Royals, there’s little reason not to take a look at Starling as they take a long-term approach to building out their roster. Kansas City has given significant roles to Hunter Dozier, Adalberto Mondesi and Nicky Lopez, with varying levels of success, as they seek to determine who can realistically be a part of the team’s next core of contending players. Both Dozier and Mondesi have resoundingly indicated that they can be part of the solution, and Starling will look to follow Dozier and Whit Merrifield in cementing himself as a late-blooming big league regular.
It shouldn’t be all that hard to find at-bats for Starling in a questionable outfield mix that has thus far received minimal contribution from offseason signee Billy Hamilton and the returning Terrance Gore. Alex Gordon has appeared resurgent in left field, while Merrifield has handled the outfield well after moving there to accommodate the now-struggling Lopez at second base. Hamilton, who had turned in a miserable .217/.284/.271 line and is a free agent at season’s end, seems to be in the most danger of losing significant playing time with Starling now in the fold. Carrying both him and Gore in reserve roles hardly seems an optimal roster construction, though Kansas City has also received negative production from veteran first baseman Lucas Duda, who has hit at an awful .157/.245/.292 pace through 102 plate appearances.
The Royals already jettisoned one underperforming veteran pickup when they released Chris Owings earlier in the year, and it wouldn’t be a surprise to see the team continue to create room for more intriguing minor leaguers as the second half of the season progresses. Beyond Hamilton and Duda, the Royals have received 90 marginal innings from Homer Bailey, who could be flipped to another team for a nominal return. Lefty Jake Diekman’s bottom-line results have slipped of late, but a lefty reliever averaging 13.1 K/9 and nearly 96 mph on his heater will hold appeal to other teams on the trade market, even if the return won’t be particularly strong.
ripaceventura30
I like that they made him prove he deserves to be up and wouldn’t get hurt for an extended period after many disappointing years. I also like that he never gave up and just quietly figured it out this year. A bit old for a debut and a pretty low ceiling, but there’s a lineup full of guys with chips on their shoulders now and I hope this means Duda’s gone.
RoyalsFanAmongWolves
Unfortunately I don’t think Dayton is going to get rid of Duda anytime soon
davengmusic
Bubba Starling…what a great name!
scarfish
Its very Kenny powerful
davepond88
Well-deserved. Love to see it pay off for guys who have persevered (like Bubba and Kyle Zimmer). Now hopefully he gets a real chance to run with an OF job. Hopefully, Duda is DFA’d to make room unless there is a Hamilton dump trade coming. No reason to keep him around anymore in a rebuild. Seems like a good dude, so maybe offer him a coaching spot.
RoyalsFanAmongWolves
Hamilton isn’t even 30 And you say offer him a coaching job? Or Is it Duda would offer a coaching job?
jonnyzuck
I remember him being a big time prospect a while ago and it never worked out but it’s good to see him finally make it
jpeezy43
Bye bye Billy Hamilton
Asfan0780
Rendon, lindor, Baez, Springer noteable hitters taken after Starling pick
Ruben_Tomorrow 2
I really hate when these facts are brought up. You can say that about every draft virtually. How do those 24 picks prior to Trout look in comparison?
dandan
They don’t look as bad as Grant Green in an Oakland A’s uniform… who the A’s picked instead of taking Trout in 2009.
clepto
Any human looks bad in an A’s uniform. Awful.
…near or worst uniform in baseball, near or worst stadium in baseball. And, yet they produce decent teams on a low, low budget.
Ruben_Tomorrow 2
I’ve always considered the A’s to be one of the tops in baseball uniforms. Every uniform they wore has been a winner with the exception of the black tops. Those were unnecessary and hideous. The Reggie Jackson, Vida Blue, Catfish Hunter days of A’s uniforms will always be my favorite. Colors were vibrant and uniforms were unconventional, but never thought they were over-the-top or trying too hard to stand out. Still managed to look clean.
billbucs
Great hindsight! You have a great future. Or will it be a past in hindsight
johnrealtime
Using these facts to say a team is stupid to have made the pick is silly imo, but I enjoy it and feel they are fun facts on their own. I enjoy looking back at old drafts for this reason.
Add Story to the list, he was taken a few rounds later
TLB2001
Trout wasn’t even the Angels first pick in that draft. That draft has the three pitchers at the top and then some space and they went 1-2-3. Starling was a local kid and if we hadn’t taken him wouldve been picked soon. Perfectly legit pick that just didn’t pan out with the benefit of hindsight.
compassrose
AsFan during the draft he would have been taken higher maybe even one. The problem was would he sign or go play FB. KC was the only team that had a chance to sign him so they drafted him. It is odd how things happen to some of these high draft picks. Is it pressure and they aren’t ready for it because they have never had that much pressure before? Hard to say but their is only one first overall pick in the HOF. With all the “greats” taken at one only one of them makes the HOF.
DarkSide830
i cant believe both him and Zimmer made it
jpeezy43
Bye bye Billy Hamilton
Maybe Lucas Duda
jfedex
Gore
dray16
Someone will take Gore for a pinch runner in September, he will get dealt.
justin33broja
Gore or Hamilton could be taken just for pinch running and defensive sub. Duda is practically done for now his bat is gone.
TLB2001
We traded Gore to the Cubs for $ last year. Not going to get a prospect.
arc89
About time. 27 Y O its make or retire time. Might as well give him a chance that is what playing out the season means.
Matt Galvin
Soler been traded?
swany
If they have an off season flag football team he might stick as he was a 4 star dual threat QB coming out of high school.
Indiansjoe
Maybe they are getting ready to trade Jorge Soler. I would love to see him in the 4 hole in Cleveland. I wonder what kind of prospects he would cost?
jfedex
Gore is gone
its_happening
Assuming he’s replacing Duda.
Aside from the middle infield and Gordon, every player should be up for a trade, including Merrifield.
30moreyearsofdarkness
Aside from Gordon? He hasn’t had any value for 3 years so if anyone wants to give us something for him pull the trigger on that.
dlevin11
Royals should listen to all offers. They are still in rebuild mode. Gordon should bring back some decent prospects.
30moreyearsofdarkness
35 year old who has been one of the worst hitters in baseball 3 out of the last 4 years and costs you 4 million to release next year is gonna get you fringe prospects at best. No one is gonna give up anything big
TLB2001
Gordon has veto rights and has made it clear he will exercise them.
RoyalsFanAmongWolves
He deserves to retire like joe mauer – after his entire career with one team.
its_happening
30 I agree with you. Royals GM already came out and said he’s not trading Gordon. Going by his words, Gordon is not to be touched. That is why I mentioned Gordon. I thought this was common knowledge.
royalsfun
Gordon’s a 10/5 guy and says he wants to finish out in KC so I have a feeling they won’t even bother trying to trade him
jfedex
looking like Gore is gone again..
DaddyDimmu
Nice to see him succeeding now. Will be fun to see his debut!
mattblaze13
Finally lol
parkdav
Congrats Bubba. Long road.
johnnyg83
Good for you, Bubba. Merrifield didn’t get his first look until 27 maybe you can catch his lightning. I’m surprised it didn’t happen earlier in the season. Terrance Gore and Billy Hamilton?
One theory I’d heard about the Royals taking Bubba was that they were embarrassed about missing on local guy Albert Pujols (Fort Osage HS, Maple Woods CC) and they didn’t want it to happen again. Don’t know if it’s true …
TLB2001
Pujols was a 13th round pick, not really a “miss”
RoyalsFanAmongWolves
I think they wanted to make sure he was going to be healthy. Why take a chance with someone who’s never played a completely full season in the minors previously … adding him to your roster and then have him get injured ? He was on the 40 man for three years before they removed him last fall . He never was healthy enough for a September call up . Until 2017 we still had Cain in Centerfield.
sherlock_
Cool I have a baseball card of him back when he was a top prospect
baseballwarshipper
He would have been up last year if he wouldn’t have broken his finger getting out of bed, hopefully he can avoid doing that again.
blueoctober
Steve,
Is it really fair to say they’ve received “minimal contribution from … the returning Terrance Gore”
He has a 360 OBP.
He’s top 10 in the MLB in stolen bases with a fraction of the at bats of everyone above him.
He has a 3.0 defensive WAR in only 130 defensive innings.
He has the #1 UZR/150 of any outfielder in the MLB with at least 100 innings and it’s not even close.
Yes he plays little, but when he has played this season he gets on base, he’s the best or one of the best defenders in the game, and he’s been the best base stealer in the game. Give the man some credit.
TLB2001
I like Gore, but he makes zero sense for a team in our position. Also, he’s played the equivalent of 11 games in the field, let’s pump the breaks on “best defenders in the game.” Defensive metrics are notoriously unreliable in small sample sizes. Terrance has improved substantially defensively but by the eye test I would call him playable. Also, he’s been good for -1 runs on the bases this season because he keeps getting picked off (5 CS for one of the fastest players in the game is just stupid)
mopaniac
I think they could use a guy like Dustin Ackley ,while he didn’t live up to his #2 overall pick he still is a.991 fielding % player in 5pos. All OF and 1b 2B. And a 240 car. Avg hitter. They could get him for under 1 mil. He last hit last yr AAA 286/378/398 after coming off an extended injury he suffered while a Yankee.