The Braves and Giants have struck an intriguing pact that’ll send veteran reliever Mark Melancon to Atlanta, according to Jeff Passan and Buster Olney of ESPN.com (via Twitter). Righties Tristan Beck and Dan Winkler are going to the Giants in the deal, Robert Murray of The Athletic tweets. Melancon has full no-trade rights, but consented to the swap.
Melancon is owed a hefty $14MM this year and next. Rather surprisingly, the Braves are taking on all the remaining salary owed Melancon, according to Henry Schulman of the San Francisco Chronicle (Twitter link).
Melancon originally joined the San Francisco organization on a four-year, $62MM pact in advance of the 2017 campaign. That contract really hasn’t worked out for the Giants, as Melancon has dealt with injuries and hasn’t been nearly as effective as he was heading into free agency.
That said, he has been a solid pen piece over the past two years. Through 85 1/3 innings since the start of 2018, he carries a 3.38 ERA with 7.9 K/9 and 3.2 BB/9. Importantly, Melancon has held opposing hitters to just five home runs in that span; whether that suppression can be maintained will tell on his future. He owns a monster 61.4% groundball rate this year.
With Melancon and Shane Greene joining the Atlanta relief unit, the club is obviously betting on worm-burners over strikeouts. Both have ample experience closing out games, but neither really profiles as a high-end game finisher for a prime contender. Just how the late innings will be handled remains to be seen.
In Beck, the Giants get a young hurler who has shown a bit of swing-and-miss potential. It’s still early in the developmental process, but the 23-year-old has reached the High-A level already. In eight starts there this year, he carries a 5.65 ERA with 9.6 K/9 and 3.4 BB/9.
Meanwhile, the San Francisco club will see if it can help Winkler rediscovery the form he showed over the prior two seasons, when he emerged as a quality reliever after battling through a litany of injuries. The 29-year-old has stumbled to a 4.98 ERA and allowed five long balls in 21 2/3 frames this year, enduring drops in his strikeout and walk rates (9.1 and 4.6 per nine, respectively) but boosting his swinging-strike rate to 14.8%. Winkler struggled all the more at Triple-A, walking 18 to go with twenty punch-outs in 16 2/3 innings.
Photo courtesy of USA Today Sports Images.
PapiElf
Yummy
Francys01
The Braves are active in this trade deadline, please Cardinals wake up.
notyourfriend
No
worldchampskc
Braves are on fire!!
TradeAcuna
At least the Braves secure their chance to win a AA or AAA title this year.
nmendoza7
You’re annoying and unfunny, please be miserable elsewhere
slowcurve
Gotta stop feeding the trolls. The pathetic, sad little trolls who know nothing about humor or baseball.
jorge78
Well he does feel abandoned!
skip tracey
I’m not sure who is included in said abandoning…. Drop Dead Fred, maybe. DDF doesn’t handle rejection well at all. And by multiple Gods. This does not bode well.
MasterShake
Couldn’t have said it better myself, he’s been like this since ST started as far as I can remember.
realgone2
You’re a useless waste of sperm
jorge78
Ouch!
braves fan 138
Your honestly the most annoying person on mlbtr, like dude get a life
realgone2
They used to ban morons like him
TradeAcuna
Thanks, but at least I’m glad Tom Verducci is on my side.
sufferforsnakes
Well, Gwinnett will have to go through Columbus first…..and that spells doom for them.
casey
He has looked real good lately.
ABCD
Jeffery is intrigued again!
Kolukonu
Braves grabbing all closers/former closers
Jean Matrac
Except for Sam Dyson, and Hunter Strickland.
krillin89
Aye! I’ll take it
Confortoismyspiritanimal
Love RP with 1.4 WHIP and 3+ BB/9.
bhambrave
Better than the average Brave reliever lately.
Breezy
Braves are wheelin n dealin
Ketch
The NL contenders are dominating the deadline. In the AL, only Cleveland (Puig, Reyes, Allen), Oakland (Roark), and Boston (Cashner) have done anything…
Confortoismyspiritanimal
Cashner wasn’t even deadline – it was 2 weeks ago.
notyourfriend
But 4/5 of the NL are contenders
giants4evr27
Ummm Astros?? Only made the biggest trade this year.
chippahawk
One of the most fun days of the year every year, Christmas in July.
So that’s 3 guys that gotta go off the roster now..
BobSacamano
The day trash talk never gets resolved! Lol
trollie fingers
I’m thinking Jackson, Walker, Minter
1738hotlinebling
NLCS here we come!
notyourfriend
Or not
notyourfriend
The Giants get Felipe Vasquez lol
notyourfriend
Why did I post that
losbravos 2
Luiz gohara would be great to dump off here in this trade
steelerbravenation
Rather let Gohora try and build some value back unless San Fran eats the whole contract
losbravos 2
Yah 14 mill is alot for next year. Maybe they pay 5 mill of it
PaulX
I was in San Francisco the last 2 weeks and Melancon looked very good. I like this move.
notyourfriend
Tony Kemp looked good for the 1 play I watched him play defense and he got DFA’d
FullMontilla
I’m not sure you were at a Giants game. Melancon has been adequate but these days he walks a fine line between getting out of an inning or getting knocked around. He’s far from the dominant force he once was
pustule bosey
he has been good lately, not good enough to justify his contract, but good enough to not cringe in rhe late innings when he comes in
gilgunderson
Hmm, how much of his salary are the Giants going to eat on this? He’s been pitching better lately, but not sad to see him go. Excess to requirements, really.
snotrocket
Hopefully the Giants are paying all his salary and actually get a decent return.
22Leo
Even the people reporting on deals are getting bored with this trade deadline. Some of them have resorted to using the term “pact” just to mix things up a bit.
notyourfriend
???
RadioPirate
Yeah, if this were the NBA, there woulda been 75 deadline deals by now and the Association would be pimping each and every one of them like they were Magic-for-Bird and the sports media would be eating it up. When it comes to shameless self-promotion, MLB is “PBS Newshour”, the NBA is “Real Housewives”.
steelerbravenation
If they are eating some of that contract and the return is minimal I am ok with it
Better than we have now
Colorado_d
so you want him for free basically, even though hes better than what you have now. LOL
notyourfriend
I would
sherlock_
He’s actually doing better than I thought
losbravos 2
Ik snit said newk stays in pen but maybe these r moves to transition him back as a starter
notyourfriend
Can you translate for a non-Braves fan?
losbravos 2
Sean newcomb is a young a great pitcher. Was really good lat year until the last month or so. He struggled early this season and sent him to AAA. He came up and was placed in our struggling pen has been really good in the pen (except for today) for the most part. He tops out at 97. So instead of spending big money for a top SP, they could try to see if newcomb can go back to a pretty good 3 starter
losbravos 2
Cause our head coach said he modt likely will stay in the pen (cause our pen is awful) but with these trades we might not need him in the pen as much
notyourfriend
Thanks
Mancuso
Peace out Luke Jackson
SplashHittaz
I love it, Farhan, trading a bad contract. Hhahahhaha. I can’t believe it, braves want that contract.
Colorado_d
hopefully they took the contract
notyourfriend
Not all of it certainly
Colorado_d
Too all of it. Wow.
notyourfriend
I take that back
notyourfriend
They want the player. The Giants might take on most of the contract, who knows.
bravesfan
After the allard trade, us braves fans holding our breath hoping to not give up a ton for guys that are solid, but nothing special.
That said, potential 3 bullpen arms that should be huge upgrades, good for them for at least addressing the correct area of need.
Frisco500
Melancon has pitched well lately. Great timing as he had zero value a couple months ago. Great move Zaidi. I say that based on salary, not knowing the return.
SplashHittaz
As a Giants fan, I will tell you Braves fans. Melancon is trash, hahahahah. He was absolute trash for the last two seasons. Thanks for taking up that contract.
notyourfriend
Sam Dyson was trash last year and look at him now
Colorado_d
False
Gobbysteiner
No he wasn’t. Dyson was good last year. Melancon has been trash ever since he signed the contract.
notyourfriend
Thanks for fact check
chound
Good news for you, Winkler is cheaper trash!
Youtube.com/@PINGTR1P
Beck and Winkler is the return, nothing fancy there. Melancon might find something with a change of scenery
Gobbysteiner
The real return is getting 14 million off the books
KirkRueter
Good riddance lol!
milkman
Bye bye mark. Have fun Braves. He’s been very inconsistent and underwhelming for two seasons
SF1034
>”Melancon is owed a hefty $14MM this year and next. Needless to say, it’s hard to imagine the Atlanta organization taking on all of that. ”
Why are you phrasing this like the Giants haven’t already paid him nearly $10MM this year?
chound
He isn’t “owed” $14m this season… Just saying
notyourfriend
“And next
SoCalBrave
Beck is a very high upside pitcher. Braves might regret this in a few years.
66TheNumberOfTheBest
The Giants must be eating most of that deal to get anything back for him.
A-A
He has a negative value contract, so yeah
Gobbysteiner
Welp. No money exchanged.
66TheNumberOfTheBest
Lunacy.
It should have been two prospects going from the Giants to the Braves to eat that contract.
steelerbravenation
Melancon’s biggest problem has been is injuries
He seems healthy now & gettin ground balls
With our infield defense he could be good
Better than what we got but very underwhelming trade deadline
Dorothy_Mantooth
Nice job by the Braves on their bullpen. They should have grabbed Corey Dickerson as well
bravesfan
Good deal. Beck and Winkler… yea I’m a fan of beck and think he’ll be good and I love Winkler also… but Winkler isn’t getting it done this year and we need the upgrade. Beck is struggling also, but he’ll be fine. Especially heading back to an environment he’s possibly comfortable with
SplashHittaz
I’m just glad the bum isn’t on the roster anymore. The return is irrelevant at this point to me. They should have packaged Evan Longoria with him 😀 heheheheh
notyourfriend
Anyone who bothers to type hahahahahah or heheheheh generally has a bad opinion
CobiEven
The “:D” did him no favors as well.
SplashHittaz
😀 Hhahahha. Don’t be mad bro, braves going nowhere. Heheheheh. Chuckle, Chuckle, Chuckle. Thanks again for taking him off our hands rofl Hhahahah 😀
jbigz12
Jesus he got hosed here. They’re taking all the salary? That’s incredible that they gave up anything to take on his entire salary.
bravesfan
Taking all that salary and giving up a top 30 prospect is a joke. Some cash albeit not a lot should have been automatic
Gobbysteiner
No money and a top 30 prospect? Farhan is a god.
snotrocket
Farhan is a level 10 wizard
wiggysf
And to think half the fanbase wanted him gone after not signing Harper.
mays2425
How did Zaidi get them to take on that whole contract?!
Youtube.com/@PINGTR1P
He’s buddies with AA. He probably secretly told him he’d buy him a new car if he did it.
jdgoat
Winkler > Melancon, especially at that money.
jbigz12
If you’re solely focused on the money. Melancon is miles better than Dan winkler.
62% GB% is great. Melancon is a nice add. Taking on all the money is surprising especially for the publicly traded Braves. Hopefully that doesn’t take a significant acquisition out of play next year. Considering that their given a more strict budget.
jbigz12
They’re**
braves fan 138
Winkler is absolutely terrible
krillin89
Dude, taking on all the salary? The small hope I had of a Donaldson extension just went out the window
chound
That’s silly. If they want to extend them, they’ll be in among several teams for his services.
krillin89
Not with Penny Pinching Liberty Media
jbigz12
The Braves added 24-25 million dollars of payroll next season with the addition of Melancon and Greene. While it’s good news now; it may not feel that way if that’s their excuse for not spending anymore next offseason.
chippahawk
They have the money just in savings from Acunas’ and Albies’ team friendly extensions. Not worried about that especially the winning position they’ve put themselves in for the next decade. Revenue is and will continue to be a absolutely solid..
JayRyder
If the Braves take all the Salary, This is A Win. !!!
Melancon was a depth piece. Pitching better lately. With a couple of 2 inning games.
He was not a higher leverage situational pitcher.
Great Move. For next season and beyond.
It will take more than a few years to build back up. Hopefully with the kids in A Ball end of Next Season…
DTD
While that is very surprising, O’Day’s contract is up at the end of the season so it’s really only about a 5 mil addition to next yrs payroll.
jbigz12
And another 11 to retain Shane Greene. That’s 25 million added to next year’s payroll for two relievers. A bit more than Donaldson’s salary.
A-A
11? Isn’t he making 4 now? Arb raises don’t work like that
If it’s 4 now you are looking at 6-8
jbigz12
Woops. Sorry that was from Colome’s salary. Not Greene’s. That’s my mistake. You’re correct it will probably be 7.5 for Greene.
DTD
Where are you getting 11 mil from?
coach him
Win now worry about later…later. That’s a team that’s all in for the now.
Colorado_d
Giants shed about 35 million dollars in salary. Arguably are better today than yesterday with a couple of 2nd base options, and now will get a 1st round pick after they make offer to Bumgarner witch undoubtedly will be turned down.
Only major loss that stings is Dyson, due to his contract. I would of rather moved him to closer and traded Will Smith as Dyson is controllable longer.
Not a disastrous day.
Gmen777
Maybe I’m optimistic but I think the Giants end up extending Bumgarner right before free agency exactly like the Dodgers did with Kershaw last year. He loves it in SF and honestly there are rare times sentimentality tops business and he’d bring fans to the games for years to come.
Colorado_d
Only problem is Bumgarner has never been paid his worth. He had the biggest bargain contract in Baseball. Never made more than 14 million a year while pitchers half his worth have been raking in over 20 million. Hell Melancon made more money than him.
He is going to want to cash in as this will be his last major contract.
Gobbysteiner
I doubt bum cares too much about money, if anything he might give them another discount
Gmen777
Agreed but I honestly think the Giants will pay him his due because they have more of a reason to overpay him than other clubs (value in the clubhouse, marketing etc). I do wonder what happens with Smith though. I’m not a huge fan of signing relievers to big deals and I could see him accepting a QO
rivera42
AA is like Dombrowski. Once he takes over an organization, say good-bye to the farm system. Atlanta’s still has a number of legit prospects left, but that’s only because it was ridiculously deep to begin with.
MasterShake
The only questionable one was Allard and he’s had his issues of late. They kept the big 3 that most people see as untouchable. Maybe you just have a negative outlook on most things?
missjill2u
Schulman confirmed: Braves taking on remainder of Melancon’s contract! $18M! Sending Zaidi flowers, candy, teddy bears and perhaps a back up girl of his dreams. Brilliant!!!
Questionable_Source
3 bullpen upgrades and all they really gave up was Wentz. Not bad. Folty and Newcomb can help the rotation if needed. Swanson should be back soon, getting Camargo off the field. Things are looking up.
TradeAcuna
“getting Camargo off the field”
sometimes you forget how valuable someone once they [Swanson] leave or get hurt.
I feel like Swanson could have saved the Braves a few runs if he played.
fabulous61
Apparently you haven’t watched the last few games that Camargo has played very well in.
russ5tide
So all the braces have given up today is tristen beck and dan winkler for MM, and Joey Wentz and Travis Demeritte for Shane Greene. And Allard for Chris Martin.
All prospects other than Tristen Beck and Travis Demeritte were really at the point that they need to move on to a new club as they weren’t going to beat out the stash of pitchers the Braves still have.
I think AA and company did a great job today and didn’t give away anyone were gonna truly miss (including Allard). The only surprise would be accepting all the money left on Mark Melancon
The Braves improves a lot the last 2 days
davemlaw
Christmas in July? YES!
So glad to be rid of that guy. He blew his first save opportunity for the Giants and I knew he would be a disappointment.
Alex Anthopolus, thank you!
washington_bonercats
Happy that awful contract made its way out of town. Dudes a cancer
Pete'sView
One of the two best deals the Giants made all day. Melancon will help the Braves. His injuries now seem to have passed and he’s pitch quite well the past two years. PLUS the Giants shed his contract—a disappointment because of those injuries. Melancon is NOT a “Cancer;” there is no evidence of that, despite the comment above.
JoeBrady
That’s a whole lot of salary for a small market team for a guy that’s not even going to be their closer.
UGA_Steve
It’s really funny reading media articles from both teams on this. The Giants media is all aglow because Melancon has just been terrible for the money. The Braves media, while a little skeptical is seeing this as a huge get.
It just shows you how tired everyone is in Atlanta of watching RP’s come in and walk every other hitter. I mean, the budget-conscious Braves were willing to take on a big contract for what is probably an average bullpen guy at this stage. Well, at least it’s not the Mets taking on Cano’s contract and trading away multiple prospects just to get Diaz bad.
Atlbravesmania
how do you compare braves with mets those mets would have signed babe ruth so they don’t win anything
ElMagoN9ne
I remember mark Melancons first game as a giant. He blew a save. I bet he does the same in Atlanta
Atlbravesmania
this got hot tremendous change they finally did something good