The Astros acquired right-handers Aaron Sanchez and Joe Biagini for outfielder Derek Fisher, according to reports from Rob Longley of the Toronto Sun, Joel Sherman of the New York Post, and Shi Davidi of Sportsnet.ca. The deal was a precursor to a trade deadline buzzer beater, as the Astros picked up Zack Greinke from the Diamondbacks as well.
Sanchez, 27, was drafted 34th overall by the Blue Jays in 2010 and was ranked among the best 35 prospects in baseball prior to his 2014 debut. The Jays had Sanchez work out of the bullpen as a rookie, and he joined the rotation the following season. He suffered a lat strain that season and returned as a reliever. Sanchez was again moved back to the rotation for the 2016 season, and he authored his finest campaign: a 3.00 ERA in 30 starts, good for a seventh place Cy Young finish. He would never reach those heights again, dealing with a blisters and finger injuries in the ensuing years. His ERA sits at 6.07 in 23 starts this year.
Biagini, 29, was Toronto’s Rule 5 Draft selection in 2015 and enjoyed a tremendous rookie campaign in 2016, pitching to a 3.06 ERA with 8.2 K/9, 2.5 BB/9, 0.40 HR/9 and a 52.2 percent ground-ball rate in 67 2/3 innings. However, the Blue Jays’ subsequent attempt to move Biagini into the rotation in 2017 proved an ill-fated mistake, and his 2018 season spent mostly back in the bullpen didn’t yield quality results, either (6.00 ERA in 72 innings).
The 2019 season has seen Biagini bounce back to the tune of a 3.75 ERA over the life of 48 innings. He’s been homer-prone — like most of the league — but is sporting a career-high 9.0 K/9 against an even 3.0 BB/9 with a 45.3 percent ground-ball rate. There’s reason to be optimistic about further improvement, too; Biagini’s 13.7 percent swinging-strike rate is easily a career-best, as is his 36.1 percent opponents’ chase rate on pitches outside the strike zone. The spin rate on his breaking ball is elite as well, ranking 21st of 399 big league pitchers to throw the pitch at least 100 times dating back to 2016. That type of profile has yielded substantial benefits for the Astros in the past, of course, and they’ll look to elevate his profile with their data-heavy approach moving forward.
Once a top 100 prospect, Fisher hasn’t established himself in the majors since debuting in 2017. He likely wouldn’t have gotten a chance to do so in Houston, either, with the team loaded in the outfield now and with high-end prospect Kyle Tucker ahead of him in the organizational pecking order. Fisher has hit just .201/.282/.367 with 10 home runs in 312 MLB plate appearances, but he has been quite productive in Triple-A ball. The 25-year-old has slashed .289/.379/.520 with 50 HRs in 1,053 PA at the minors’ highest level.
Photo courtesy of USA Today Sports Images.
PapiElf
They were right down to the wire!
Perksy
Good pickup by the blue jays. Will Fisher start for them? Over McKinney. Like to see him play everyday
notyourfriend
All deals are done
jdgoat
Not necessarily
notyourfriend
Like Verlander last year
I’m not saying Biagini is Verlander
JC507JC
Verlander was two years ago, and there’s no more waiver trade deadline. So all deals are done as of 8 minutes ago.
worldchampskc
Which is why deals are still trickling in….its not really a hard stop at 4pm. They’ll give a small window of a grace period. Teams are still talking you know.
AllRiseForTheJudge
All deals had to be submitted to the league for approval by 4pm EST. Those trades will be announced as they are approved and that will happen over the next hour or so.
goalieguy41
Correct AllRiseForTHE judge
dimitrios in la
No, I think that’s incorrect. The deadline has passed. No new deals can actually happen; but new deals can be announced.
Taejonguy
you think incorrectly
GB85
Thank god he’s gone
rodster
Happy day, the best news in decades.
southern lion
Joe be a genie and grant me a wish.
bigdaddyt
Time to give this jays fan one last awkward wave joe
astrosrock
Hopefully we only gave up one magic bean for this acquisition….
Confortoismyspiritanimal
Supposedly another name was included in the trade.
Taejonguy
Aaron Sanchez
jb19
Weak
brewcrewenthusiast
To cap off 5ye
Socrates Curveball
Look at Astros players numbers v. Biagini. Bregman 0-3 (2Ks), Springer 0-5 (2Ks), Correa 0-3, Gurriel 0-3. Yankees probably were involved here.
jb19
First of all, small sample size. Second of all, Biagini would come in after the Astros lineup destroyed whoever the Yankees trotted out there to start the game.
brewcrewenthusiast
To cap off the worst trade deadline ever Joe Biagini
astrosrock
Hahahaha, agree!!!!
notyourfriend
And Sanchez
User 2997803866
Looks like you spoke too soon …
dman07
Lol the Astros want him in their bullpen so that says something. Good luck Joe!
clrrogers 2
She Davidi just tweeted that there “are more pieces to this.”
ThePriceWasRight
Smoak?
astrosrock
Marcus Stroman?!!!! ….no wait….
ThePriceWasRight
Aaron Sanchez also going
Taejonguy
Aaron Sanchez
NoRegretzkys
Sanchez apparently
astromariner
He’s worse than everything we already have. Ugh, what are they doing.
User 2997803866
It’s called buying low.
thickiedon
Biggio?
notyourfriend
Throw in Vlad and Lourdes Gurriel while you’re at it
damhikt
Glad you were too late with that comment. You would have had them thrown in if you’d beat the 4 pm deadline
Chino
I’m not liking the comments from Jay’s fans about Biagini… his standard numbers look OK….
ThePriceWasRight
biagini is fine, just an odd duck
Dexxter
Yeah.
And Jays fans remember his experiment as a starter too which didn’t go well. As a bullpen piece he’s a great 7th or 8th inning guy.
Have fun with Sanchez though. 🙂
damhikt
Odd duck is right. Pretty solid reliever though
its_happening
Heard Sanchez is going to Houston also.
GB85
Whoa, Sanchez too…
notyourfriend
Who was 85
dman07
What are we getting back with Sanchez also going out!?
ThePriceWasRight
derek fisher
Dorothy_Mantooth
Sanchez….yuck!
governator
Derek Fisher in return
ThePriceWasRight
derek Fisher coming back
Ryan_W
Sanchez, Biagini and Osuna. Blue jays becoming Astros farm team but not sure if the jays are better than Houston’s AAA team.
Digdugler
they are not 🙁
Dorothy_Mantooth
Astros get Greinke too now…WOW!!!!
Miamisunset80
AWESOME
n13gmlb
My Yankees are sunk… Funny thing I was mentioning Yanks should just get innings Leake or Sánchez or the starter the Rays got from Marlins… Al of then got sent elsewhere hahahaha My Yankees are sunk
Steven Chinwood
Cashman screwed the pooch again…
ThePriceWasRight
Greinke also going to houston.
bigdaddyt
Why trade Sanchez. Jays mishandled him all year and without even knowing the return messed up the trade. Guy shoulda been the jays 8th inning man the last 2 months instead of the rotation.
vbcbpt
Should I be surprised the best the incompetent Jays FO could only get Derek Fisher in return. Derek who? Looking at his numbers looks like a crappy outfielder hitting at about the Mendoza line. Great.
notyourfriend
He was good recently (scored the winning run in WS Game 5 for Houston), and he has inconsistent playing time in Houston
Taejonguy
it gets worse… the Jay’s also included Prospect #25 Cal Stevenson…
jjd002
Guy has raw skills. Just needs to put it all together.
its_happening
Colby Rasmus had raw skills too.
User 2997803866
This is a short sighted comment. Fisher was considered a solid prospect, they just never had a place to play him.
mark0817
Three pitchers I hate are finally off the team, hated joe since the start, Sanchez can never keep his fingers blister free and when he does he still gets light up, jays should have put him in the pen ages ago and the hot head stroman no longer throwing tantrums in the six, overall a good trade deadline by TO
damhikt
Great trades if the goal is to please mark0817, looking pretty crappy if the jays are still hoping to play Major League Baseball. What did we get for the 3 pitchers? 2 minor league pitchers (not great) and a fourth outfielder? WTF!!
Costandreward
An OF they will just send down comes season end. This FO is trash. Sure they draft well but trading is something they suck at
Baseballfreak
Grienke will get lit up in the AL! Just sit back and watch as the Astros made these moves just to block the Yankees. In the meantime, they’re trading all their depth pieces for overpriced pitchers. Hasn’t been that long ago everybody slammed the Yankees for these same moves! Now, because Boston and Houston does it its being called great baseball business? I just don’t understand the reasoning behind these thoughts!
apuszczalowski
I don’t know what they gave up for Greinke, but they gave up a mediocre outfielder for a decent bullpen arm and a starter that will be much better as a reliever where the Astros will most likely use him
damhikt
Guess the word is out. “Shatkins” (Shapiro and Atkins) have no clue what they’re doing. You want someone from the jays..phone these two buffoons. Unbelievable!
User 2997803866
Yeah. They built the Cleveland World Series team. They really just have no clue. Why don’t you give it shot, buddy?
jjd002
Didn’t Greinke with a Cy Young in the AL?
PeeWeeGaskins
You sound mad, bruh.
goastros123
Baseballfreak, people said Gerrit Cole would get lit up in the AL. How has that worked out so far?
Ryan_W
Derek Fisher – I like the over 400 OBP and .924 OPS in AAA this year but to only get Fisher for Sanchez + is pretty weak.
Costandreward
This FO is terrible at getting a good return for their players. Stroman couldnt even get a top 100 prospect while Baeur gets a kings ransom, Sanchez and Biagini (1 former all-star and another with great potential) get a left fielder batting .200. Jays already have OF’s.
KingRyan227
Idk who they’re getting since Martin, Bukauskas, Beer are gone Now for greinke
apuszczalowski
a mediocre outfielder……
apuszczalowski
Jays also throw in their #16 prospect, a single A pitcher who they drafted recently. someone at TSN is saying the Jays are getting back more but the Astros are working on informing those players before they are announced
coldgoldenfalstaff
As long as we’re not losing Abraham Toro in this deal, I can live without any other non-Tucker/Whitley prospect.
jay6ix
lol Jays gotta be the laughing stock of MLB right now…those GM’s there have no clue what they are doing, all they are concerned about doing is trading away every Alex Anthopolous pick, or pick up..lol what idiots, good for other teams tho.
damhikt
“Shatkins” seem to have no clue what they’re doing.
User 2997803866
Yeah because making up a “nickname” makes you look more informed.
its_happening
The Houston Astros have to be the team to beat in the American League. They are showing plenty of desire to win another World Series title.
The Blue Jays are a disaster. Very few Jays fans on here have voiced concerns with front office and their (in)ability to pull off big trades. They waited too long on Smoak (wasn’t traded), waited too long on Pillar, waited too long on Donaldson. This vision from the Blue Jays is blurred. Too many Atkins/Shapiro apologists on here. History is repeating itself from the JP Ricciardi/Godfrey days; beancounters who’ve never won and do not know what it takes to win will forever lose. That’s your Blue Jays.
One Bite Hotdog
“Very few Jays fans on here have voiced concerns with front office and their (in)ability to pull off big trades. ”
I’m pretty sure the majority of Jays fans complain about the FO in every comment
its_happening
Joel you haven’t read Jays fans for months. Only a few guys have pointed out the problems. The apologists are running and hiding.
melochejohn
Basically all Jays fans are in agreement that the FO has been making horrible deals and has little to no care what the local market thinks.
Digdugler
No one is a shapiro/Atkins apologist they are awful at everything. Horrible at injury management, selling people at all time lows when they dont even need to be traded and getting bad players in return.
Digdugler
LOL the Jays had to include Cal Stevenson with Sanchez and Biagini to get Fisher!? What are they doing!
jimmertee
Jays are a laughing stock at the moment.
Cal Stevenson is also in the deal for Fisher. The Jays got rid of players they didn’t want and didn’t get much in return. This should seal Atkin’s exit from the organization.
kodion
“Jays are a laughing stock at the moment.”
Management certainly is
its_happening
You and a couple others have pointed this out for months, if not longer.
bluejays92
The Jays are also sending Cal Stevenson (an underrated outfield prospect in my opinion) to Houston. I’m pretty upset at this trade from a Jays POV. Ridiculous.
gcv
So whose supposed to pitch? Maybe the lifetime .200 hitter they got in exchange has a hidden talent.
jjd002
Fisher just needs an opportunity to play. The guy has talent, just needs to put it all together. Had no room in Houston
Catch tha Taste
Fischer is Billy McKinney 2.0, what the heck are the Blue Jays doing?!
GB85
Apparently more is coming back in the trade for the Jays, no way Shatkins is THIS incompetent (though the Stroman deal now looks worse than ever).
its_happening
Add Andrew Tinnish and Tony LaCava. The whole front office should be held accountable. Tinnish and LaCava have been around since the Ricciardi days.
dkramer
Think again.
MapleJay6ix
Ross Atkins is a 4 year old sitting at a poker table playing for milk and cookies while experienced players are taking Millions from him and he still thinks it’s fun. A 10 year old could negotiate better than this baby face moron.
Ok taking a chance on Fisher in the OF, just 25 but it concerns me that he couldn’t hit well in a fricken little league park in Houston. But once again this idiot Atkins sells low on another guy for Sanchez (who could still be good as a starter, had my doubts but I’d be willing to use as a set up man and could be elite in that role) and Biagini who is still a decent bullpen guy with experience.
How in the hell did Toronto not get another pitching prospect in this deal? Meanwhile teams are getting huge returns for Bauer and Greinke when Stroman is probably better than both.
Give this another year or two but I’m sure both Fisher like Grichuk will be gone and add more reasons for the firings of both idiot Atkins and Mark Shapiro.
Dk trucking
I totally agree!! Those 2 idiots should have been fired after the Stroman deal and today shows why!! They have no clue of what they are doing!!!!!
Franx
Wow there is no way derek who the F Fisher is the only thing to get back. I understand Sanchez has been whatever so I can understand his return. That should literally have been the only person traded for him, and now Bigi too? Come on Jays
TennVol
Cal Stevenson is vastly underrated. 300 hitter, 400obp, talented cf with a cannon arm. GM all over should think twice if Houston says “hey, we will do this deal, if you throw this guy…what’s his name…Cal Stevenson…into the trade”. That means he has some talent! Worst trade of all the Jays trades this week.
its_happening
Stevenson should have been up in New Hampshire earlier this season. Seems the Jays have been hesitant with certain position players to promote them. Forrest Wall in NH should be in Buff. Other examples too.
dkramer
The Blue Jays are now the laughinstock of MLB (move over Marlins). I thought the Stroman return was bad, but oh boy did the Astros fleece them on this deal. Jays fans should boycott this regime and revolt until Shapiro and Atikins are fired. These guys couldn’t look after a tball team let alone an MLB team. It’s almost like they’re deliberately sabotaging the franchise. If Atkins is not fired after this, then I am done being a Jays fan. Completely and utterly unacceptable.
jimmertee
Yes! The Jays have acquired Teoscar Hernandez 2.0 from the left side for a serious haul [to the Astros]. This one hurts. He can run[like brito] and has power[like Hernandez] and stikes out [like Grichuk].
How does it feel Jays fans to be the farm system for the rest of MLB?
Well at least most of us are in argreement now that the professional scouting of the BlueJays is really broken and Mgmt needs to be replaced. This trade deadline set the BlueJays back from winning at least another year.
The only way out of this pit is bumping the budget 100 M and sign, sign, sign. But Rogers won’t allow that. They even said it in their recent quarterly statement that the BlueJays salaries are low and that is why the Rogers Board are making their profitability numbers.
Blue Jays gave up more salary too at this trade deadline, even reducing the budget more. #BlueJayslaughingstock #scoutseyes
its_happening
Rogers needs to sell the team. They are the ones hiring Shapiro and Godfrey. They need to hand the team and the stadium over.
jimmertee
Will Rogers sell the BlueJays? I know it has been talked about it at the board level a lot. I wonder what the sales timeline is?
I wonder why they have caved the budget rather than choose to spend and win?
its_happening
Who knows. Rogers is the problem and continue to be a problem with their hiring at top levels. TV, Radio, Sports entities….
Taejonguy
Godfrey has not been involved for more than 10 years…
its_happening
Godfrey was hired 2000/2001 and he hired Ricciardi. Please follow along.
Oilcan
how do we start a petition to get adtkins and shapiro removed for gross incompetence?
turner9
This is beyond terrible
I put myself out there saying “just wait and see what they do at the deadline” before we judge Atkins and Shapiro too harshly.
I will not attend 1 more game or buy 1 more peice of merch until these 2 clowns are fired.
How did this morph into Biagini for Fisher then Biagini AND Sanchez for Fisher….. then we added a kid younger and better to the deal as well.
What in the $%^&
GB85
Something is very wrong here, this makes no sense and is so disappointing. What was management thinking?
Shatner
Atkins needs to lose Lunow’s number, he’s like an old girlfriend whose moved on but pops by every once in awhile stays the night then leaves the next morning and steals money out of his wallet. Oh well maybe Fisher will be OK.
jdgoat
Sanchez should’ve been a reliever since day one of this year. He hasn’t had any value since 2016, but he could’ve been dynamic out of the bullpen and rebuilt that. I am kind of surprised to see Houston acquiring these guys though.
jimmertee
Careful JD you are starting to sound like me….
DarkSide830
i dont think this is a VV situation. Sanchez lead the darn league in ERA a few years ago. injuries or not, that probably set back the “time until moving to the bullpen” counter back a good two years. I have to agree though, he should have at least been moved there some time this year and held onto. he’s going to be great in low leverage in Houston’s pen.
OilCanLloyd
Brutal. I’m surprised MLB even approved such a lopsided trade without questioning it.
jdgoat
It’s not even really lopsided. It’s just selling low for no reason.
dman07
I predict this offseason they trade Giles for nothing then the team goes up for sale. By opening day 2021 they’ll have no big salaries (expenses) and the team is sold…
It’s apparent they (Rogers) is thinking to sell the team. Grass was supposed to be installed in 2018 right? I remember hearing that awhile ago…it’ll be somebody else’s expense now. Not on Rogers books!
ericl
Apparently Ross Atkins doesn’t realize that you are supposed to get multiple pieces for your players when you are in a rebuild & not the other way around. This is an absolutely ridiculous trade on Toronto’s part. How do you give up two established major leaguers & a prospect that has hit fairly well, albeit in the low minors, so far in his young career for only an outfielder who hasn’t established himself as a big leaguer & has spent most of the season in AAA? This is one of the worst trades in franchise history & the Blue Jays have made some bad ones
dalrob
Have you watched Sanchez lately? He has been absolutely terrible for almost 3 years. He won’t go to the bullpen because his agent, Boras will have a fit. This is nothing but addition by subtraction. If Fisher comes here and fits in with the kids, that is a bonus. The Jays have given up very little. Even Stroman is highly overrated. What was his ERA in 2017 and 2018? Massive ego, horrible attitude = bye bye!
dalrob
Gross incompetence? Please……
dalrob
Okay, Stroman was good in 2019, bad in 2018, good in 2017, not so great in 2016. You get the picture.
dalrob
Grass wasn’t installed because it won’t grow indoors and the climate is too cold in the spring to open the roof. Rogers is a corporation and doesn’t throw money away frivolously. Like all Toronto fans, you have grossly overrated your talent. The only pitcher who went for highly valued prospects was Grienke and he is far superior to either Jays pitcher. It was very clear that Minnesota, the Yankees, etc were not going to move their top prospects and they didn’t. Get your head out of your Klavin.
citnetter
Can’t wait to see what the Astros pitching coach, Brent Strom, can do with Sanchez and Biagini. He’s a master at turning pitchers into machines (Cole, Morton, Musgraves, Pressley,…) Excited to see if he can turn Sanchez around. Don’t know much about Stevenson, but can’t believe they got all this for Fisher. Fisher’s a decent player, but player guys like Kemp and Straw passed him up as far as everyday MLB bench/platoon value. Plus, there was no way he was going to get any major PT w/the Astros OF any time soon.
As for the Jays, I don’t know much about your team and management, but your young core of players is pretty scary. If mgmt gets their head out of their @##, I think y’all will be really good in a couple years. BTW, can we have Biggio? 🙂 He belongs in H-Town.
its_happening
Won’t matter if they can’t pitch. Pitching is what they needed at the deadline and they did not get it. Not Kay, not the hyphenated guy or the pitcher they got for Hudson. The Jays organization just proved they are not capable of negotiating trades to better their club. Club control is only as good as the player.
maxorange33
It is obvious, for whatever reason, Shapiro/Atkins don’t have a clue when it comes to talent evaluation. Whatever system they’re using is puzzling, I’m not exactly an analytics nerd but it seems like the numbers of all their recent acquisitions don’t “pass the smell test”! The only bonafide future stars that Shatkins have drafted are Biggio and Bichette. Guerrero, Gurriel, Jansen, are from AA. Atkins is preaching “time will tell” to cover for the unique talent evaluation that no other club has, but the time for these hitters is NOW, but oops no pitching. Jays fans like me better used to a lot of 10-9 and 12-10 type of losses in the next few years.
Shatkins Sux
Aaron Sanchez just threw 6 no-hit innings in his Astros debut, and Derek Fisher camped under a routine flyball only to miss it entirely as the ball struck his face.
damhikt
Your name says it all. Can’t believe the lack of return for any of the trades shatkins has made. And it’s so discouraging to see what Sanchez and Biagini did in their first game