7:05pm: The Athletic’s Ken Rosenthal tweets that the Braves and Keuchel are in “serious talks.” There’s “some thought” that the Braves are willing to offer multiple years to Keuchel, tweets MLB Network’s Jon Heyman. Earlier this morning, the New York Post’s George A. King III reported that Keuchel did indeed have teams willing to push their offer to the multi-year deal range, whereas the Yankees were still set on limiting any offer to one year.
2:18pm: The Braves have emerged as the “frontrunners” to sign free-agent lefty Dallas Keuchel, reports Mark Feinsand of MLB.com (via Twitter). The Yankees have been prominently connected to the southpaw since the draft-pick compensation tied to him expired on Monday, but Atlanta has long been mentioned as a potential landing spot as well. Feinsand notes that the Yankees are still in the mix, but Atlanta has recently stepped up its efforts.
Earlier today, SNY’s Andy Martino reported that the Yankees were also facing some degree of competition from the Cardinals. He, too, listed the Braves as a potential factor in the Keuchel market, along with the Twins, though Minnesota’s interest has yet to be characterized as particularly serious.
For the Braves, Keuchel would help to stabilize a rotation that is enjoying strong performances from high-upside young pitchers who are likely to eventually face some type of workload restrictions (e.g. Mike Soroka, Max Fried). Beyond that excellent pairing, the starting pitching hasn’t panned out as hoped in Atlanta so far this season. Mike Foltynewicz missed the first month of the season and hasn’t performed well since returning (today’s quality outing notwithstanding). Lefty Sean Newcomb was demoted to Triple-A early in the season due to significant control issues, and he’s come back as a reliever. Righty Kevin Gausman has an ERA north of 6.00 through a dozen starts. Of the Braves’ starters, Julio Teheran has been the most effective holdover, but there’s certainly room to add another veteran to the mix to help smooth things over.
Unlike fellow free agent Craig Kimbrel, Keuchel has been reported to be more amenable to the concept of a one-year contract. The New York Post’s Joel Sherman wrote earlier this week that agent Scott Boras has discussed some multi-year scenarios that would contain an opt-out after the current season, but a straight one-year pact would be less complicated and more palatable for a signing team. Braves leadership has previously spoken about payroll flexibility, though the exact level of financial resources Liberty Media is willing to provide to general manager Alex Anthopoulos is, of course, anyone’s guess.
Any one-year deal signed by Keuchel would come with a prorated salary; inking him for the same rate as the $17.9MM qualifying offer he rejected back in November, then, would cost a team just north of $11MM from today through season’s end. Atlanta has a payroll of about $121MM at present, and their previous franchise-record Opening Day payroll total was $122MM. Signing Keuchel would push the Braves into uncharted territory, financially speaking — particularly when considering the fact that they’ll likely still make some additions on the trade market in an effort to bolster the bullpen.
That said, the National League East is among the game’s more tightly contested divisions. The Braves are currently 1.5 games behind the division-leading Phillies, 3.5 games ahead of the Mets and five games ahead of the suddenly surging Nationals. Given the competitive nature of the division, it’s understandable that they’re perhaps willing to push beyond previous comfort zones as they vie for a second consecutive playoff berth. Atlanta is currently in possession of the second National League Wild Card spot, but the difference between a guaranteed ticket to the NLDS and a winner-take-all, one-game coinflip is significant for any club.
BamaZack
But they don’t need relief pitching? Are you seeing what Webb is doing today? I know we need starters but our relief pitching is terrible and we don’t even try for Craig!! Weren’t even runner ups!!
Goku the Knowledgable One
Glass half empty much?
Pretty awesome you posted this at exact time I mocked the assumed response.
BravesCanada
Move Folty to the pen maybe? There were talks before last year about him in the closer role. He has the stuff.
RunDMC
He doesn’t have the makeup. He’s so easily frazzled it’s almost predictable. His stuff is definitely there, but he has terrible mound presence.
BravesCanada
Ya good point. He had turned a corner last year but with his lack of success this year, I’m finding he’s easily frustrated out there
Oxford Karma
Hi me guy will throw 125-130 innings the rest of the way. The other might throw 40. If it’s about the same money, I don’t see what there is to complain about. They are both on the decline, but since keuschel isn’t a power guy, his might not be as detrimental. I don’t want the Yankees to get him, but I can see why teams would like him, especially if it’s only one year.
Goku the Knowledgable One
But they need bullpen help!!!
-Whiney Braves fans
jdgoat
Well it’s true….
Goku the Knowledgable One
So if they need SP and RP, you’re really going to complain that they addressed one?
Hoping front runners turns into Yankees swooping in.
bencole
He expects both. As he should.
SalaryCapMyth
Hoping front runner turns into Yankees swooping in
-said idiot Yankees fan
bravos14
They NEED relief pitching more. Needed it last season, needed it during the off-season, have needed it all this season and I expect they’ll still need it when their season comes to an end. I usually add imo at this point but not today.
stymeedone
Adding a starter will move a current starter to the bullpen. You add one–you help both.
ChipperChop
Nice prediction Nostradamus. Every team in baseball NEEDS relief pitching now and will NEED it next season. All 4 teams predicted to be contenders in the NL East need it now and a couple of those “addressed” it in the offseason. How’d that work out? You guys kill me getting so butt hurt that AA didn’t offer Kimbrel 3+ years. A guy that the Sox were literally scared to bring out the pen when it mattered most in the playoffs.
InPolesWeTrust
By adding DK, you are making another move out of the rotation; making a SP either a RP or a MiL’er. Make the right choice and you won’t have to waste prospects at the deadline and overpay. This could be a win win for the Braves.
bencole
Uh… bro… they do need both. He expects his team to win, and to spend money to do it when they need to. What’s wrong with that?
stymeedone
Is he buying more tickets to help pay for what he wants?
spinach
Is Rob Refsnyder a future HOFer?
BowserCubs
Well, there you go Braves fans.
You couldn’t get Craig, but at least will gett Dallas.
Probably will look for bullpen help at the deadline?
solaris602
Brad Hand will be available, so there you go.
BowserCubs
Hand, Will Smith, Colomé, Holland…..there is a bunch of options.
I think Cubs will bring a left hander reliever, but plenty of options for everyone (including Atlanta) at the deadline.
jkurk_22
The problem is most of us Braves fans were so keen on Kimbrel because he wouldn’t cost any prospects
weaselpuppy
Shane Greene…lots of cheap arms to be had for a top 100-150 prospect
madmanTX
Gonna take less money to save his beard smh
Goku the Knowledgable One
Sadly that’s likely valid
DTD
The SMH should be directed at NY for being a bunch of nonsensical dbags
Shiggasurus Rex
I’m oddly ok with that. Even though he did say he would shave it…..
ronnyalton
@madmanTX dont you dare. Dont you dare disrespect my doods beard
VonPurpleHayes
As a Phils fan, I hate to see Keuchel going to a division rival. As a beard fan, I’m glad he isn’t going to the Yankees.
azbraves20
I had been a Kimbrel fist guy for a while.
Over the last 2 weeks, I have quickly changed my opinion. (Granted today I don’t have an option).
If we can get Keuchel to throw every 5th day and give us 6 or 7 innings, we can skip a few starts for Soroka and Fried. We can get 25 -30 quality starts from each of them, vs them tapering off with a month to go.
Also getting into the 7th every 5th night, vs Gausman getting blown up in 2 or 3 innings is going to save the bullpen.
They have been throwing a ton of innings, and when you need 3+ every night from your bullpen you are going to get exposed.
Jackson can close for us, and as much as I want Newk in the rotation this year, he has looked solid in the pen.
Go spend some money
thegreatcerealfamine
In the end it’ll be the Cardinals or Twins.
bravos14
I agree with much of your statement, I think a 6 man rotation may work out in Atl this season, they definitely need to protect the young guns and the vets but a true Closer is needed and needed badly, imo.
spinach
“I had been a Kimbrel fist guy for a while.”
Grossest thing I have ever read on this site.
InPolesWeTrust
I went back and reread it and I chuckled. I appreciate the honor and respect you serve with as a member of the Grammar Police!!
Philliesfan4life
What in the world is matt klentak doing, he can’t be standing pat on this. They need to make a move for bumgarner • greinke • robbie ray • marcus stroman • aaron sanchez • mike minor. One of these starters and a bullpen arm.
Shiggasurus Rex
The Marcus Stroman or MadDog move would be clluuttcchhh
BravesCanada
Stroman is a headcase
jakethesnizake
You would be too if you were in that situation in Toronto. They’ve gotten worse and worse every year he’s been there. Doesn’t want to be part of a rebuild and I can’t blame him.
BravesCanada
He’s been a headcase his whole career though. Even when they were winning he was a whiner. Not exactly a good presence to have around so many up and coming youngsters
DarkSide830
and they will. at the deadline.
MC77
Robby Ray and Aaron Sanchez don’t move the needle. They need a legit front end starter that gives them a chance to match up in the playoffs. They have enough #3 and #4 starters. The Phils should have been in on Kimbrel. The bench needs a serious make over as well.
Psychguy
Hoping against hope.
braveshomer
ok I’ll be holding my breathe until the Braves sign Kuechell….wish me luck
mj-2
#NoAir2019
DarkSide830
hahaha
braveshomer
*passes out…sue’s Liberty Media for causing self inflicted pain
skip tracey
like sands through the hourglass…
ATLbravos
not getting my hopes up on keuchel!! but with a division plagued by injuries, any of our rivals could get hot. we need 2 starting and 2 relief pitchers especially with fried/soroka being limited on innings down the stretch.hoping they wont end up like the nats did that year and shut strasburg down right before play offs. 2 relief pitchers could easily be traded for. i know kimbrel got alot of braves fans heart strings but AA still has over a month to make things happen. For once im going to be optimistic and give the guy a chance even though my gut is telling me no!! dont let me down AA remember shopping down any aisle doesnt just mean the dollar general.
splitfinger42
At least I can stop typing “craig kimbrel” in the search bar every day now…. now, if I could only spell Kuechel correctly…Kkeichel, Kloodle, Klachel
ATLbravos
yea instead of looking it up usually i just put dallas lol but i misspell it all the time
azbraves20
Search for Dallas
Mind blown
bravesiowafan
Just so MLBTR is aware AA has stated there will be no pitch or inning limit for fried and soroka. Ajc has reported this many times
splitfinger42
We just need a two man rotation
Bunselpower
Old Hoss Radbourn and Charlie Sweeney!
RiseAgainst3598
Thanks Foolish Baseball
RiseAgainst3598
Thanks Foolish Baseball!
HubcapDiamondStarHalo
Spahn and Sain and then, dear God, two days of rain…
DarkSide830
hard to believe in the latter’s case. obviously they want soroka available for the playoffs, but occasional starts off would make complete sense.
bravesiowafan
Agreed just doesn’t mean they have a hard schedule for limiting anything other then extra rest even aces get a start off now and again
ATLbravos
might be off on this but braves salarys is sitting at $114.9 million and spent $136 million last year. wondering where the $122 million comes in and how $12 million after proration puts braves in uncharted territory? (numerous cites put braves as 114-116 million)
inkstainedscribe
Teams account for salaries in different ways. Deferred payments, writeoffs of guys they’ve released, etc. I’m not even sure how the beat writers or MLBTR come up with accurate estimates.
petfoodfella
RR has Atlanta at $120,900,000.
bravesiowafan
The other issue when talking about last year “record payroll” that never gets mentioned is about 90million $ went to the team the rest was dead money no the money spent this season is only wasted with o day. Still agree on the estimate of 112-116$ million at our current payroll mark bowman and ajc has said we aren’t over 115$ even with 12 million prorated that doesn’t top last years 136$ million, no uncharted territories here.
oldleftylong
Shane Greene … soon!
Ejemp2006
Greene is a pitcher, not a thrower, so many overlook him as good closer. All want 97 plus flames. Tigers smartness knows to ask for two high up side single A studs and a low upside AAA dud when people call and ask about Shane.
stymeedone
Nah. He’s a rental. A solid prospect, and a flyer will do the trick.
weaselpuppy
That will do nicely. Now to find takers for Boyd and Castellanos…
KF
Yikes. Just when I think the editing around here has gotten better I see: “He, too, listed the Braves” and “…offer he rejected back in November, then, would cost a team…”
“Then” is absolutely redundant in that sentence, and looks amateur. I rarely—if ever—find a sentence where such usage of “then” is not wholly unnecessary. It’s just filler. You might as well add a few instances of “like” if we’re trying to write like colloquial speech. If you MUST use it, at least be grammatical and put it after “would.”
Absolute rule, one that cannot be challenged (try): if “too” stands alone in a sentence, between two commas, it is ALWAYS better to say also. From there, one can add more commas to the sentence without risk of running-on.
Can’t wait to see the white knights around here tell me I’m being a troll for expecting a higher standard of writing from a site that never used to have such problems. I just assume such persons struggled in English class.
petfoodfella
You’re not being a troll, you have a valid statement, it’s just so annoying to 95% of the readers.
Honestly, most of us don’t really give a crap. This site isn’t up for the Nobel Prize.
stymeedone
Wow. Just…Wow. Do you have any Baseball related observations? I think I’ll go to a grammar chat room and see what they think of the Kimbral signing.
braveshomer
bwahaha well played sir
InPolesWeTrust
I stopped reading after ‘editing’….cmon guy, relax.
petfoodfella
If it were me…
I’d sign Keuchel, trade for Smith from San Fran to setup Folty as closer. I’d drop Blevins and Winkler to make room for the 2 new additions.
Closer: Folty
Setup: Jackson & Smith,
Bullpen: Newcomb (SP in 2020), Swarzak, Tomlin, Touki, Webb
Starting: Fried, Soroka, Teheran, Gauzman & sign Keuchel.
bravesiowafan
Gausman has been horrible and way worse then folty
petfoodfella
Gausman doesn’t have the MPH to close. Folty is fine 1 time through the order. You could make the case to replace Guasman w/ Bumgardner or another trade candidate, but I think he’ll right the ship and be fine.
petfoodfella
2020 you’ll have JD’s $23m coming off the books, with Riley making league minimum. That’s a conservative, $21m to throw at the bullpen for 2020.
There are some good names available in 2020 that can replace Webb, Tomlin & fill in for Newcomb coming back to the SP (in place of JT)
Plus, a run at Gerrit Cole should be made.
doxiedevil
Watch Riley stay in LF when Donaldson is resigned
Ejemp2006
Cole is product of awesome Houston analytics, coaching, and medical staff. Leave and regress.
Braves_Hammer
He had big numbers in Pittsburgh.
stymeedone
So, if it’s you, what are you trading for Smith? Because you have to out offer the competition.
Phanatic 2022
Does that mean they are willing to go to the GQ price? Is any team?
Yep it is
Hope Atlanta gets him. He will flop like a NBA player. For him to come back after such a lay-off and don’t give me the “ he has been working out line”.
petfoodfella
He’s been working out. A few weeks to get game ready. As long as he hasn’t taken the time off from throwing (reports say he hasn’t), he’ll be fine.
doxiedevil
What are the Vegas odds ? I don’t believe a thing the Brave front office ever would say.
Kevin28786
You nailed it on the Braves’ front office. They should be in Congress……….that’s how much stock I put in anything they say.
CrewBrew
Man do Braves fans complain alot on this page lol. Enough about Kimbrel. Ya struck out. Get over it. The girl (Kimbrel) did not want to date you so move on
Shiggasurus Rex
Dude, you’re really funny. Not to mention super clever.
InPolesWeTrust
But your name is both clever and funny!!!!
TradeAcuna
The Braves need to rebuild at this point. Their entire pitching staff is bad other than Soroka. The only good hitters they have are Freeman and at this point, maybe Riley.
bravesbkf
Lol. One of the dumber things I’ve read today. Sounds like a cool troll account name tho. Well done.
mike156
Multiyear with an opt-out after the 1st year is a great ask by Boras, and a foolish give by any team.
Fed Up
Okay people we are talking about the Braves and Liberty here. They don’t like to spend money, so you can forget signing any big name free agents like Keuchel. They have lied to us so many times about improvingving the team with free agents that it is so funny to think they will sign Keuchel.
stymeedone
The only thing making Keuchel a big name is he has no competition on the FA market.
purplesteve6
Weren’t the Braves the favorites to land Kimbrel? Realmuto? Brantley? Grandal? Pollock? Marwin Gonzalez?
Not holding my breath.
rocky7
Yes, it does seem as if the Braves and Phils are the frontrunners for each and every free agent and mentioned as the prominent suitor in every trade….and they seem to never do anything!
Braves2019
Just fu**ing do it! I don’t even care if he pans out at this point. Just do it to show the fans you’re willing to do SOMETHING. And for god sakes can we please move Donaldson out of the 4 spot and put Reilly there? This isn’t rocket science. Our offense instantly gets better if Snitker does that. Freeman see’s better pitches, Riley gets to keep doing his thing but rack up even more rbi’s with the hitters he has in-front of him and we get a .250 hitter that has only 1 home run in his last 15 games, in the 6 spot where he belongs. How long are we going to continue to cater to Donaldson’s feelings not getting hurt? He’s gone after this year anyway.
bravesiowafan
Donaldson has advanced stats showing his numbers don’t match his output. He has one of the highest hard contact rates and line drive rates in the league. 23 million $ investment you can’t give up on him two 1/3 of the way through the season.
Braves2019
I don’t think we should give up on him, I’m just a realist who wants to see him in the 6 spot until he finally heats up.
Braves_Hammer
Since Riley got called up he’s had 23 AB’s with runners in scoring position compared to JD 12. Why would you want to move him?
Braves2019
Jeez dude, talk about using small sample sizes. You’re out of your mind if you think Riley will see more AB’s with RISP behind donaldon and markakis (which are both batting around .250) compared to if he was behind Acuna, Swanson and Freeman, which are 3 all star level players (Swanson this year).
bravesbkf
I’m ok with not getting Kimbrel. Would have been a great reunion but that’s a lot of money to tie up when we have so many arms coming up. The guys down in AA look good. Just a little more growing and they’ll be ready. Keuchel would be nice to have. I’ve not given up on Folty but Gausman just looks bad. Try for Keuchel and hope he’s near game ready. Get a bullpen piece or two at the trade deadline. Quit making it sound like the ship is sinking.
bravesbkf
We’re 4 games above .500 with the 21st highest salary. I’m not complaining at this point.
frontdeskmike
Wow. An actual rumor on this site! We’re going to party like it’s 2009!
bravesiowafan
Lots of misinformation in this article too
Rumncoke
Max 3 years
HtownBuckeye
They should sign him.
Gausman has been downright atrocious and Folty can’t stop giving up homers.
Kizlay
Braves just signed keuchel. They just broke the news