2:07pm: Gonzalez will opt-out, tweets Andy Martino of SNY. The club has 48 hours to either grant him his release or add him to the active roster.
Friday, 2:47pm: Gonzalez does indeed intend to trigger the clause, per MLB.com’s Mark Feinsand (Twitter link), which means the Yankees will have to decide whether to add him to their roster. That appears to be unlikely, per Feinsand, suggesting that Gonzalez will probably head back onto the open market.
Friday, 12:16pm: Veteran left-hander Gio Gonzalez has hired CAA Baseball to represent him, Mark Feinsand of MLB.com reports (via Twitter). He’d previously been a client of the Boras Corporation. The change comes just before tomorrow’s opt-out date in Gonzalez’s minor league contract with the Yankees — a provision that he is giving strong consideration to exercising, according to Jeff Passan of ESPN (Twitter link). The Yankees recently got CC Sabathia back from the injured list and have received three solid outings from righty Domingo German, so there’s no guarantee they’ll bring Gonzalez to the Majors for a look.
Gonzalez’s contract comes with a $3MM base salary, but the greater consideration for the Yankees is surely the incentives structure to which he agreed. As one might expect for a veteran of his stature, Gonzalez’s non-guaranteed deal is packed with incentives — perhaps more so than any minors deal in recent memory. He’d reportedly be paid a hefty $300K per start with the Yankees at the MLB level, on top of that base rate of pay, making it a fairly expensive proposition to even take a look at him on a short-term, trial basis.
Thus far with the Yankees’ Triple-A affiliate, Gonzalez has had mixed results. He was shelled in the season opener for Scranton (eight runs in four innings), but he’s rebounded with a pair of excellent outings, yielding a combined two runs with an 18-to-2 K/BB ratio in 11 innings.
The fact that he made 93 pitches in his most recent outing should signal to other clubs that he’s built up enough to the point that he could step directly onto a big league pitching staff if needed. Assuming he opts out, that type of opportunity would likely be the type he and his new representatives seek. Several teams that entered the year hoping to contend — Red Sox, Brewers, Cardinals, Angels, Mets, Phillies, Athletics — have seen their starters combine for an ERA of 4.50 or worse, so it stands to reason that there could be heightened interest in Gonzalez now, as compared to when he was a free agent over the winter and was unable to find a big league deal.
If Gonzalez does trigger his opt-out clause tomorrow, he won’t immediately become a free agent. The Yankees would have 48 hours to weigh whether it’s worth placing him on the big league roster or grant him his release. But with the rotation currently featuring James Paxton, Masahiro Tanaka, J.A. Happ, Sabathia and German (with other depth options on hand in the form of Chance Adams, Jonathan Loaisiga and Luis Cessa), the team may simply prefer to let him go.
Gonzalez’s change in representation has been reflected in MLBTR’s Agency Database. As always, if you see any errors or omissions within, please let us know via email: mlbtrdatabase@gmail.com.
david klein
Sign him Brodie, please
zoocreatures
I could see it, especially with the move to CAA. At this point I’d rather see anyone pitch in the 5th spot besides Vargas.
VonPurpleHayes
Famous last words. Gonzalez is not good.
padam
Neither is Vargas. Gio just happens to be better than him.
homer 2
He could be a number 1 on the Red Sox.
ChiSox_Fan
White Sox should bring him home. Never should have traded him for Swisher!
GoSoxGo
Amen! Swisher’s single year with the White Sox was forgettable.
Polish Hammer
His time in Cleveland didn’t end quick enough either.
Solar Flare
Yeah and Guillen was dumb for using him in centerfield, because Swisher was not good there, but to be fair, he would still be a defensive liability no matter where you put him.
nicktrombino
I actually think Swisher was a leave average RF, after his stay with CHI. Atleast in his Yankees years, maybe even his first year with Cleveland. I don’t remember him being a liability atleast.
spinach
$56m, right? Can’t believe teams are trying to avoid contracts like those these days.
ChiSox_Fan
Sox division easily winnable.
Sox need another solid starter.
Jose Patino jr
I think it’s possible for sox to sign him, now that Scott boras is out of picture. Teams don’t like to deal with boras.
Jose Patino jr
Sox are too cheap to pay him
Manbitesdog
Amen
Jamesjohn1988
Can we please sign him over this weekend because Jason Vargas is pathetic
whynot 2
Maybe you are pathetic, Vargas is just not a good pitcher
padam
So you agree with him, but just wanted to call him pathetic?
Thanks
“Sign him Brodie, please”
Jumping the gun much?
48 hours. Your move, Cashman.
spinach
No, not much. He could well get signed nigh-instantly after the 48 hours expires, making now the time to make the comment.
flippinbats79
Back to Oakland makes a lot of sense
Lefty Grove’s right hand
I think that ship has sailed. I don’t see his services as a need anymore. The A’s will be getting several arms back in the coming months. Cotton, Puk, and manaea (sometime after the all star break) and still have arms in the minors with Mengden, Blackburn, Holmes, Jackson.
Asfan0780
Puk will need more time in minors. Manaea and luzardo have shoulder injuries whicj can ne umpredictable. Also cotton is just a back rotation guy and when he last pitched healthy he was terrible in 2017. If anything i expect them to be cautious with theae injured pitchers.
Lefty Grove’s right hand
True, but at this point in his career, Gio is a back end guy too. A’s already have enough guys to fill the back end. What they need is a front end guy. There’s Keuchel, but he is a bit overrated of a front end guy.
Not Xabial
He’s definitely going back to Milwaukee.
jonsteele
Nooo I want the cardinals to get him so maybe we will have someone capable of getting Yelich out.
Juicemane 2019
But wait the Cards have Hudson, Ponce de Leon, Reyes, Flaherty, and Mikolas….What happened Cards fans?
LOLOLOL
postcards
Any realistic Cards fans probably realized that their “incredible” rotation depth consisted of unproven, young, and fragile arms; illusory depth, if anything.
Unfortunately, there aren’t too many level-headed Birds fans here.
rocknwell
There are a couple. We all have HOPE they will return to good form, but more doubt that will happen.
I suspected Martinez would get injured. I suspected Mikolas would regress (though he finally showed some promise recently), never was real confident in Wacha or Wainwright, and of course the rest have good stuff, but unproven. And I never really expected much from Reyes either. Miller has been a disappointment too. We all hope, but I never had confidence that the rotation was really worth much. I feel the Cards should have dealt some of that perceived value for a proven starter or two.
Cardinals17
I totally agree with you rocknwell. I hope, when Carlos Martinez completes his rehab, he comes back throwing strikes. I also hope the Cardinals trade him for at the least, Madison Bumgarner. Sure Bumgarner is not the Bumgarner of old. However, the Cardinals need a seasoned starting Lefthander. Haven’t had one since Garcia was in his prime.
dwightgoodenspinkynail
Brodie loves those CAA clients. Just saying.
bravesfan
Lot of predictions on here, I’m gonna put my money on the Mets. Wouldn’t be shocked if he ends up there as their 5th starter.
Melchez
Tigers lost Matt Moore for the season….
Solar Flare
Good point and also they won’t have Fulmer back until sometime next year.
refereemn77
Man would it be nice if the Twins picked him up…
Slogo
It makes me wonder if it really is that teams are trying to stick it to Boras, rather than not finding value in the players themselves.
Lately, it always seems to be a Boras client that gets shafted. Remember a few years back with Drew and Morales? This year it’s Kuechel and Gio,
its_happening
Option 2: demote him to AA.
Dutch Vander Linde
There can’t be an option 2 since it’s an opt out clause which means they need to put him on the roster or release him
HalosHeavenJJ
Angels need help and have plenty of CAA clients.
Then again, I could type the same about several teams.
J. C. Hahne
I think I’d Gio may be a better option than Chris Stratton.
HalosHeavenJJ
the peanut guy in my section was making better throws than Stratton last night.
Matt_Angel_Bronco_Laker
I don’t doubt that in the least
bobtillman
A 3M guarantee and 300K/start is a LOT of money to pay for the kind of “meh” Gio’s been the past few years……He’s at best a 5th starter on a competitive club, and you really can’t pay that kind of money (outside of the Big Boys) for a 5th starter. Too many AAA vagabonds available for cheap.
Koamalu
3.53 ERA, 123 ERA+ the past 2 seasons. Far above average, so by definition not “meh”. He is at best a #2 starter since #3 is average. Too many people like you that don’t realize what good is.
Yankeepride88
People think 3 million is a lot, but the cost of one WAR for a SP is ~ $4.2 mil. Gio was worth 2.2 WAR last year and 6.5 the year before.
$3 million is too much. Lol bobtillman you should maybe do more research.
dwightgoodenspinkynail
No one thinks 3 million is a lot. People think 300k a start on top of a base of 3 million is though. That deal the Yanks inked him to was a turd for the team and that’s why he won’t be a Yankee tomorrow. It’s also why he dropped Boras for CAA.
jbigz12
His 300K a start isn’t what is keeping him in AAA. It’s that they have 5 healthy and effective starters. The Yankees would pay that 300K if German wasn’t effective. But he is. If the Yankees ran Gio out there for 30 starts it would be because he was an effective starter. Why would they bump any of their 5 starters? They’re paying happ, the worst performer 16 million bucks regardless. None of those guys are getting bumped for Gio. I’m sure the Yankees would love to keep Gio around as depth but obviously he wants to be in the big leagues.
dwightgoodenspinkynail
So you think the next team to sign him will put that kind of cash on the table? I’d bet the farm they won’t. Six million including incentives will probably get it done.
jbigz12
No the next team and Gio will probably take a higher base salary guarantee. I don’t think Gio wants to take another gamble like that. BTW at this point Gio will only make a max of about 27 starts so at that incentive structure would add 8.1MM. Though I agree he won’t be receiving that kind of deal.
The Yankees don’t have room for Gio in their rotation right now and that is the biggest thing keeping him down. I’m very confident that they would’ve paid that salary had they needed Gio. That’s just not the case.
snotrocket
Nobody takes fangraphs calculation of $/WAR as gospel besides people who like to quote it on this site.
jbigz12
Fangraphs $/WAR is much higher than 4.5 that he quoted.
spudchukar
The Cards do not need Gio. Granted their starters have gotten off to a less than expected April, but with Martinez nearing return, Reyes building arm strength in Memphis, and last year’s primary 5th starter Gant pitching fabulously in long relief, and PoncedeLeon working to a near 1.00 ERA in AAA, they don’t need pitching help.
pmollan
I trust the Brewers are keeping tabs…
Cheeseman Forever
Hope so. They could use him, and the price is reasonable. Pitched well for the Crew last year.
old dodger fan
The Phillies have given 4 starts to Nick Pavetta. 18IP and 17 ER. Gio would be a big upgrade.
DarkSide830
Gio was the SP i had highest on my wishlist in the offseason, given his steadier track record than Keuchel, and better health history then Corbin. now that he has gotten some reps id like the idea once again.
Yankeedynasty
Gio is an aging, 5-6 starter at best. Keuchel could give a team like the angels or A’s an ace, and Corbin is even better, hence his six- year deal. Corbin 6/120, Gio 3/MiLB. When Keuchel signs it will be more that 3/MiLB, because he and Corbin are far, far better than Gio
Yankeedynasty
*MiLB/3
Cardinals17
Keuchel has killed his own marketing with the help of Boras for this season. At least until July. I believe I’d switch agents. How in Hades is a former Cy Young pitcher still without a job????
Yankeedynasty
Who’s Hades
Matt_Angel_Bronco_Laker
If he opts out, Eppler better give him a call.
Baseballfreak
Another bonehead move by Cashman and company. You can never have enough quality arms and to let this guy slip for money you’ve already allotted? Then take fliers on IL players to instruct your youth movement how to sign extensions then ride the pine! No better way to claim another ring than building a patchwork team with fragile framework.
DarkSide830
Yanks can easily negotiate a new deal with him after he hits FA.
jbigz12
Why would Gio want to go back to Scranton? If he opts out he’s not going back to the Yankees. He already has the best incentive based contract the Yankees could give him. If he isn’t going to be a major league starter he’s going to go elsewhere. Maybe right down the road to Mets. He’s too good to be sitting in AAA.
fieldsj2
What money have they already allowed? A month in the minors? He wants to start, which is not happening in NY. What exactly is bonehead with this move? Cashman signed him for insurance and didn’t end up needing him.
Baseballfreak
Don’t need insurance? The ace is on the IL. Then you’re going to depend on the rest of that patchwork rotation to carry you through with a few minor leaguers? Tanaka is a time bomb ticking for TJ surgery. Please do tell me why they don’t need a #3 possible #4 pitcher. Oh, that’s right, they already have a rotation full of #4 at best pitchers that are waiting their turn on the IL. Cashman will then trade half the farm at the deadline for a pitcher worse than Gio. Sonny Gray worked out great from the A’s standpoint. Cashman and his analytical team sucks over the past 10 years.
jbigz12
How do you propose they keep Gio? Pay him 10 million dollars and put him in the rotation for 25 starts? Who is he going to replace? Gio isn’t going to sit in the minors and make 10 cents and wait for an injury. I’m sorry that’s just not how it works. If you want the depth, the Yankees would have to bump German and bring up Gio. Why you would do that at this point I don’t know.
All Minnesota Sports
It seems a little counterproductive for Boras to negotiate those large per start incentives, etc. Perhaps why Gio left him?
jbigz12
If German wasn’t effective the Yankees would’ve paid that 300K every start without blinking. They are the New York Yankees. The gamble didn’t work out obviously but I don’t think it was a horrible gamble. It was terrible he got guaranteed such a small amount of cash in his contract but considering how late in the game it was I don’t think it was a bad deal for him. Now, you can blame boras for getting him to that point. Even if Gio didn’t have that high incentive structure I don’t think he’d be up in NY right now.
Chris
I honestly think it’s worth giving him some more cash to extend the opt out date.
mike156
I don’t blame Gio for opting out, because he can get guaranteed money. The contract makes the most sense for the Yankees if they are going to use him for ten to twelve starts, and some long relief. Then you get a durable reasonable quality arm for somewhere between $6-7M+ CBT. But it doesn’t make sense to trigger it (and the $3M) for a handful of starts and then you think about cutting him loose, because you’ve sunk, say, $4.5M+CBT to get five starts out of him. I actually think the structure might work against Boras. He might have been better off incentivizing the Yankees by having the per-start payments begin after a certain number of appearances.
Jamesjohn1988
Can we please sign him over this weekend because Jason Vargas is pathetic
Grizalt
I see they still only mention the former agent when a player switches agents if the former agent was Boras
Roll
I think it depends on who posts the agent change, Nick Senzel also changed from Boras to Wasserman but was not mentioned in the MLBTR post
mlbtraderumors.com/2019/02/nick-senzel-hires-wasse…
Grizalt
Anyway, it was my impression that the Yankees always intended to call him up and the deal only started as a minor league deal because Gio hadn’t had a Spring Training and they wanted him to ramp up in the minors for a few weeks first.
Philliesfan4life
Come on philly go get him
Dorothy_Mantooth
Yet another player who has been burnt by the Boras corporation. When are players going to figure out that if you are not a Top 5 player at your position, Scott Boras is going to fail more times than he succeeds in finding you a deal.
Gio Gonzalez is absolutely a MLB pitcher and it’s ridiculous that Boras could not get him a MLB contract in the off season. Yet another example where Boras overplayed his hand and most likely convinced Gio to pass on good offers that he would be thrilled to have now. Boras must be the best at selling players on themselves and over-inflating their market value in their own eyes. Then he has them turn down good offers, the market dries up and players are forced to sign a below market deal (Moose), a minor league deal (Gio) or no deal at all (Keuchel). This has happened for years now, so I hope players finally realize this about Boras and go with an agent who has a realistic view of the market and doesn’t put them in these terrible situations.
I hope Gio opts out and CAA finds him a MLB deal quickly. It won’t be for nearly as much as he was offered in the off season (thanks Boras) but hopefully he can rebuild some value and sign a reasonable deal next year.
brewsingblue82
Well, in this case, by over playing his hand he would have cost Gio offers. Because Gio said the Yankees were the only team to make him an offer.
Macho King OG
Gio belongs in the NL anyway.
its_happening
Yanks might have to re-sign Gio to play the outfield. Judge just got hurt and was pulled.
virginiascopist
Gio does have a couple of home runs to his name, but replacing Judge is a tall order (pun intended).
its_happening
Pun well done.
chicagofan1978
Milwaukee, he will be the ace. I’m being sarcastic btw but they can definitely use him
TreyMancini
Welp, another Boras flop. Honestly if Gio had agreed to a lesser deal, the yanks probably would’ve been more willing to call him up. 300k per start is insane incentives, there was no way in hell the yanks would call him up without a dire emergency. You gotta agree to non-guaranteed contracts in a range the team would actually pay, otherwise they just view you as a nice boost for the AAA squad,
fljay73
Those incentives works both ways.
Yankees rotation could get more desperate forcing their hand in promoting him (did not happen of course).
Also those incentives makes a team think long & hard when the player uses the opt out so the player is assured of getting back to the pitcher mound ASAP at the mlb level even with another team.
Gio used the Yanks to get himself in game shape so now he is ready to go.
stretch123
They’d be dumb not to call him up.
jdgoat
He’s going to the Brewers. Not even worth discussing.
darkstar61
Angels could really use him if someone can pry some more money out of Arte’s wallet
After wasting so much on Cahill, Harvey and Allen though, I’m not sure Billy will be allowed to add a few more million to the payroll
jbigz12
The angels should probably get some consideration for worst signings of any team in baseball over the last 2 summers. Bour, Allen, Harvey, Cozart, and Cahill. Doesn’t get much worse than that. I did like the Allen signing at the time. The other ones were pretty predictable.
fljay73
For around $5mil the Angels should be calling his new agents once Gio is a FA
User 4245925809
I just hope Boston doesn’t take a flyer on him when the Yankees refuse to call him up after the 2 days expire and he hits FA status again. Would rather Brian Johnson/ Hector Velazquez take turns filling the hole made with Eovaldi’s loss than Gio Gonzalez, who figure will get hammered in the smaller AL East parks which he’s no accustomed to.
Maybe later on this year either Darwinzon Hernandez, even Shawaryn can get the finishing MiLB time in and fill the hole also.
timewalk42
Back to the Brewers you heard it first
Baseballfreak
Last place for the Yankees this year! Harper, Corbin, and Machado looks real good right now!
TennVol
With Shoemaker going down today with a leg injury, the Jays may be interested in him.
OilCanLloyd
Buchholz is looking like a good insurance now. But I would take Gio too.
Yep it is
What opting out?? The “ Genius” Cashman not getting it right? Wow
OilCanLloyd
If released. Jays should get him