After a 1-6 start to the Cubs’ season, Chicago fans are already pointing fingers in many directions, including criticism of ownership for not greenlighting more offseason spending, or of the team’s desultory pitching performance. President of baseball operations Theo Epstein, however, told ESPN.com’s Jesse Rogers and other reporters that the blame falls with him. “There is always a search for scapegoats when you get off to a tough start. [Pitching coach] Tommy Hottovy is not the problem. He’s a big part of the solution,” Epstein said. “[Owner] Tom Ricketts is not the problem. It’s not a resource issue. I know he’s another one that’s been taking a lot of heat. It’s not a resource problem. If people have a problem with the allocation of resources, then that’s on me. And it has been ever since I got here, with a lot of good and some bad.”
While it’s obviously still early in the season, the Cubs are already facing a big deficit in the NL Central due to the Brewers’ 7-1 start, as Rogers notes. The Cubs can make up some of that ground in their ongoing series with Milwaukee, plus there’s also really nowhere to go but up after this opening week. “It’s been real close to, if not, a worst-case scenario for us, defensively and in terms of our pitching….We’re sorry we’re putting our fans through this,” Epstein said.
Some more from around the National League…
- Phillies reliever Tommy Hunter has been shut down from throwing after receiving a PRP injection in his right arm. (MLB.com’s Todd Zolecki was among those to report the news.) Hunter won’t resume throwing for three weeks, so factoring in those days plus the time Hunter would require to get into game readiness after missing much of Spring Training, the veteran righty might not be back in the Philadelphia bullpen until late May or perhaps early June. A flexor strain sidelined Hunter during the spring, and while the injury wasn’t thought to be overly serious at the time, it will result in a lengthy absence for the 32-year-old. Hunter was a solid contributor for the Phils last season, posting a 3.80 ERA, 3.40 K/BB rate, and 7.2 K/9 over 64 relief innings in the first year of a two-year, $18MM contract.
- The Rangers and Blue Jays were two of the teams that had interest in Dan Straily before the right-hander signed with the Orioles last week, MLB Network’s Jon Heyman reports (Twitter link). Both Texas and Toronto are dealing with rotation injuries, though the Rangers had a more immediate need for starting help now that Edinson Volquez has been sidelined with a UCL injury.
- Japan used to be seen as something of a last resort for players that couldn’t crack the Major Leagues, though as The Athletic’s Peter Gammons writes (subscription required), more and more players are returning from stints in Nippon Professional Baseball capable of thriving at the MLB level. Colby Lewis, Ryan Vogelsong, Miles Mikolas, and Ryan Brasier are some of the pitchers who revived or kickstarted their careers while playing in Japan, which some players and executives feel is a more conducive environment than Triple-A. NPB not only offers a higher level of competition, but just competition in general — players are playing to win in pressurized games in front of large crowds, rather than the more developmental nature of the minor leagues. Plus, players can earn much more in guaranteed NPB deals than in playing for meager minor league salaries or even minimum-level Major League contracts, and the extra security allows more focus on performance. “I’m not looking over my shoulder after every outing,” said Frank Herrmann, who is in his third season as a star reliever for Rakuten Golden Eagles after tossing 135 1/3 innings for the Indians and Phillies between 2010-16. “When you are that ’4A guy,’ a bad outing or even an extra-inning game in which you did your job could potentially be a demotion to the minors. That’s a grind mentality.”
ChiSox_Fan
Cubs won today!
The pitching shakeup must have worked.
chitown311
Cubs bullpen today-3 innings pitched, 6 earned runs. Bullpen’s good to go.
ChiSox_Fan
Well, Ryan and Webster (new guys) will need to improve on their 27.0 ERAs.
PopeMarley
You two are just really sad. The White Sox are off to their typical fast start 3-4, but hey let’s bury the lead.
twentyforty
Get them out of those ridiculous band boxes in Texas and Milwaukee and numbers will revert to the norm. MLB needs to do something about Miller Park when it’s closed tight…worse than Colorado.
rondon
Gotta love those White Sox ankle biters.
ABCD
Just typical hater Sox fans with nothing better going on.
batty
Do what exactly. Force them to install industrial fans to blow the ball back to the field of play? There have always been ballparks that are considered bandboxes. Each team play with the same dimensions on a field at any one time.
chitown311
Hey Schwarber hows that whole dynasty thing going?
thegreatcerealfamine
Going better than your White Sox!
ABCD
Still a chance for a Yankees – Cubs World Series.
thegreatcerealfamine
I’ve still got the Cubs in the NL, but I’m going with Astros in the AL.
2id
This has to be the dumbest comment ever posted in the history of the entire free world. Do what exactly? Push the fences back, have fans that keep the ball in? The park is 18 years old and now you are suggesting they change things just because your Cubs are getting spanked to start the year? Stop commenting, you’re making Cubs fans look real dumb.
bush1
Most of the blame for the Cubs I see is planted squarely on Theo. It sounds like he’s trying to act like a hero by telling everyone what we already know, that it is his fault. Thanks Captain Obvious Epstein.
chitown311
I agree, but this isn’t a one-year issue. That franchise is soaked with Heywards and Darvish’s contract for the next 5 and 6 years, respectively.
ChiSox_Fan
Well if Heyward can hit 2 HRs per game (like he did today) over rest of contract, Cubs will be OK.
chitown311
K.
twentyforty
2016 World Champion Jason Heyward…get it right. Stooge.
lowtalker1
You blame a guy that built a winner and got rid of that curse. He tried to keep it going but the pieces either got old broke or didn’t live up to their contracts. You cannot win everything
chitown311
If you believe in a “curse” then I feel sorry for you, and anyone that watches “The curse of oak island” on a weekly basis
retire21
There is an island in the North Atlantic…
Cubguy13
Theo is taking responsibility and you are criticizing him for it? If he didn’t take responsibility then you would criticize him for that too. Can’t please some people
Priggs89
He didn’t criticize Theo at all. He pointed out (correctly) that everyone already knows Theo is to blame for a lot of this mess.
ChiSox_Fan
Theo should resign or be fired!
That would show accepting responsibility.
jorge78
For some weird reason Theo is bad at the big free agent contracts, both in Boston and Chicago. Granted, he ended title droughts in both cities but the collateral damage is heck…..
theoepsteinhof
Jorge78 is right on. Theo excels at talent evaluation & development but so far has been lacking in identifying the FA fits. Many others were after the same FA (Chatwood, Darvish, Heyward), but after choosing Chi., have come up far short of earning their salaries.
chitown311
Maybe, just maybe, instead of choosing CHI, they were bad to begin with???
rondon
Maybe, just maybe, you’ll come up with an original thought? Not holding my breath.
Priggs89
There really weren’t that many teams in on either Heyward or Darvish, whether it be because of the price (Heyward) or other reasons (Darvish)… And NOBODY was in on Chatwood at that ridiculous price.
ncaachampillini
There were definitely other teams in on Heyward including the Cardinals who offered him more (almost $200 mil). He had come of a 5+ WAR season. And when the Cubs played and beat the Cards in the 2015 NLDS he was absolutely the most intimidating guy in their lineup that series.
I have no idea what happened to his bat the second he came North to join the Cubs. And yeah I wish they weren’t saddled with the contract now. Helped win them a World Series though so something positive came out of it.
Now had they not rallied from the the 3-1 deficit to the Indians to come back to win the World Series AND now been stuck with Heyward’s contract and Darvish and Chatwood and no longer have Gleybar and see Eloy and Cease down on the South side and be off to a 2-6 start? Were all this to be true it might cause some mental breakdowns and be enough to crush some souls.
But they got that World Series title and when they traded for Q it was to try and help get a second title. You need to take chances and some work out (arrieta, strop, Hendricks trades and Fowler 1 year 2016 contract) and some don’t (everything above).
You just don’t want to be a one year wonder (2005 White Sox who didn’t sniff the playoffs in the two years prior to or after that title). You do what you can to build sustained success and making the playoffs 4 years in a row qualifies as just that.
All that said yes this is a horridly putrid start to the season. Just fact correcting the initial pursuit of Heyward.
And no I unfortunately cannot defend the Chatwood signing.
chitown311
But….they ARE one-year wonder. 1 NL pennant. That’s it. After fans like yourself were chanting “dynasty”. You claim playoff appearances as success? Woluld you consider last years playoff experience a success? K.
ncaachampillini
What are you talking about? That 100% makes no sense.
You can’t win the World Series without making the playoffs can you? All you can do is do everything in your power to get back to the playoffs as many times as possible to give yourself a chance to win it all.
White Sox got there once, won it, and went away. That is the literal definition of a one hit wonder.
Phillies I believe made 2 straight WS and won the second. Royals I believe were identical. Their winning ways didn’t last long but getting there twice was a huge accomplishment.
Braves went to the playoffs like 14 years and only won 1 WS. Shows that even if you get in it’s still hard to get that title.
So do I count making the playoffs a successful season? In some years like ‘89 or ‘98 yes. In other years when you are set up for further success and you lose in the playoffs like ‘84, ‘03, ‘07, ‘08, ‘17 and ‘18 no.
I’d call ‘15 a success because they got over the hump that was the Cardinals and got to the NLCS and got them the experience. Helped lead them to the title in ‘16. Sort of like the Bulls taking a few years to finally surpass the Pistons in the playoffs before coming out on top.
If you even try to argue the Sox one playoff appearance in the 5 years between 2003 and 2007 is the same level as the Phillies, Royals or Cubs recent runs you’re full of it. Yes all four of those teams have the same 1 title but getting into the dance more times than not is better. The Braves 1 WS title but giving themselves a chance 14 years in a row makes their run better than all the teams I’ve mentioned.
And of course cubs fans were hoping for a dynasty especially once they won the title while their core players were so young. Haven’t gotten another title yet so no sane Cubs fan would claim that. Sox fans sick of hearing how the Cubs won the most games in baseball over the last four years while at the same time hearing how the White Sox lost the most games in baseball over that same time just want to find a way to claim the Cubs haven’t accomplished anything.
k.
rondon
Or you can claim the White Sox, which is like keeping that appt to have a red hot stick poked in your eye.
jasonpen
Jon Lester, Ben Zobrist, David Ross, Dexter Fowler, and John Lackey were all free agent signings that played a huge roll in the 2016 WS season…
Priggs89
Lester is the only one in there that was a “big free agent contract.”
grecoisu
Zobrist has just been the World Series MVP.
ABCD
If you’re gonna count Chatwood, you have to count Zobrist.
justacubsfan
Fowler was acquired via trade then slapped with QO. His market dried up and he came back. Hardly would call it a major FA signing. More of a re-sign than anything
Roasted DNA
I know Theo is trying to shut down the noise but all of this goes back to forcing Hickey out. The love affair with Maddon is done.
Theo didn’t want Maddon sending him a list of pitchers to go after.and flat out rejected Hickey’s plan to strengthen pitchers.
Bye Maddon.
Gonna be a tough year and the heralded farm system will finally get a chance to surface.
twentyforty
Tough year? Based on what, one week? No wonder most of you rubes like the NFL…your attention span is that of a macaw.
justacubsfan
Also, with Theo, he has to go out and pay top dollar/prospects for pitching. Chapman, Quintana, Darvish, chatwood, morrow, soler for 1 year of wade davis, he’s always paid market rate or higher.
andrewf
The main problem with a reliever like Frank Herrmann is that he’d have to be playing for a team that has a pitcher friendly park or a NL team due to his flyball tendencies.
Soapbox
Rangers interest in Dan Straily. I’m not sure the Rangers are interested in anything other than their new Stadium.
Fred K. Burke
The success the Cubs have enjoyed over the past 3-4 season is starting to level off. True, Mr. Epstein has had some failures with the signings of Darvish, Chatwood and Morrow. This is haunting the organization financially big time. I left off Heyward from the list of failures simply due to the fact that most all metrics were pointing upward on this player at the time he was a free agent. No one could have seen this alarming drop off in offensive production coming. At least I sure didn’t. Additionally, some players have simply not been able to meet or reach their expectation level for one reason or another. Weather the expectations were unrealistic to begin with or not.. There’s money coming off the payroll this off season. It will be interesting to see what overall direction the Cubs take. As Mr. Epstein stated “This is the season of reckoning.”
thecoffinnail
The only hope the Cubs have is Epstein seeing the writing on the wall like when he was with the Red Sox. He will probably jump ship and head to a team like Texas. A big market team hungry for a championship and looking to rebuild. Maybe then Hoyer can find his version of the 2012 Dodgers and package Heyward/Darvish with someone like Rizzo or Bryant and unload those contracts.
Epstein has to be the most overrated GM in the history of baseball. He gets high draft picks year after year and ownership allows him to spend whatever he wants on international prospects and is seen as a genius? Cashman took him to the cleaners on the Chapman trade. He could have had Andrew Miller easily for Schwarber. Instead he gave up a blue chip high end prospect for 3 months of a reliever. I am sure the White Sox would have handed him Sale for Gleyber and Eloy. Instead he gave up the rest of his farm for a solid yet unspectacular pitcher in Q. All he knows how to sign in free agency is either superstar top free agents or bottom of the barrel looking for a major league contract veterans. He got really lucky with Arrietta but he was considered a very good prospect until the Orioles messed with his mechanics. There is still hope on the horizon for the Cubs but the only way they get back to where they were is by getting rid of Epstein and Maddon. They should bring in a proven big market GM with a championship or two and a solid veteran manager. Ed Wade and Joe Girardi would be my choices. Wade doesn’t have the rings although he should have gotten one. Gillick was just in the right place at the right time. Similarly to Cashman in the late 90’s. Those rings rightfully belong to Gene Michael.
Fred K. Burke
Your thoughts and insights are interesting. Can’t argue with with your trade proposals but what’s done is done. The bottom line with Chapman is Theo simply devalues the cost of signing high cost relievers due to the overall of volitivity that position. He could have resigned Wade Davis, but Davis wanted a longer term that that Theo did not want to give. So, he signed Brandon Morrow and we know how that worked out so far. Right or wrong that’s his decision.
Let me say this. Theo and Jed are two totally different personalities who have different visions and philosophies, Baseball is no different than any other business. Jed would likely be considered by the Ricketts family should Theo decide to move on himself or otherwise,
As far as Joe Maddon, It’s been well documented across MLB circles that anything short of a World Series would be the end of Joe’s tenure. Right now with the roster as currently constructed it is a huge challenge to reach that goal
It won’t be Joe Girardi or Ed Wade to manage the Cubs in 2020. The replacement is already on board in Mark Loretta.
jimmertee
The Jays were never going to sign Straily. They checked in until they heard the price or term. The Jays are in bargain hunting mode, dumpster diving.
I hear the Reds and Jays are talking about a 5 Jays for 1 Red trade with Refsyder coming back to Toronto. Too cynical?