10:40pm: Zaidi’s contract is a five-year deal, tweets Baggarly.
9:39pm: The Giants have formally announced Zaidi’s hiring.
“I am delighted to return to the Bay Area and to join one of the most storied franchises in the game,” Zaidi said in a statement. “I have watched the Giants from afar and I have great respect for the organization’s culture and many accomplishments. I am excited about this new opportunity and I’m looking forward to getting right to work.”
9:30pm: Andrew Baggarly of The Athletic tweets that Zaidi will be formally introduced at a press conference at 1pm PT tomorrow afternoon.
8:41pm: Dodgers general manager Farhan Zaidi has accepted an offer from the division-rival Giants to become their head of baseball operations, reports Henry Schulman of the San Francisco Chronicle (via Twitter). MLB.com’s Jon Morosi reported earlier today that the Giants had offered the title of president of baseball operations.
The addition of Zaidi brings an analytical/data-oriented approach to the Giants organization and marks a departure from the team’s longstanding pairing of Brian Sabean — who remains with the organization in an advisory role — and recently dismissed general manager Bobby Evans. That’s not to say that the Giants are completely without an analytics department, but they did come with the reputation of carrying a more traditional scouting-focused front office group. Under Zaidi, an MIT grad with a Ph.D in economics from UC Berkeley, they’ll surely beef up the implementation of more modern, data-driven decisions from a roster construction and in-game standpoint.
Early suggestions at the time of Evans’ dismissal were that the Giants would hire both a president of baseball operations and a general manager. Zaidi, presumably, will have autonomy in selecting a GM to work alongside him, though as the new president, he’ll have final say on all baseball operations matters. The bump in title was a necessity in luring Zaidi away from Los Angeles — teams generally only let their execs jump to other organizations if the offer includes a promotion — but he’s been reported to be among the organization’s top choices for the past few days.
By taking this position, the 41-year-old Zaidi will be returning to his old stomping grounds; Zaidi broke into baseball across the bay as a member of the Athletics front office, rising from a baseball operations analyst to the position of assistant GM over a more than decade-long run with the organization. While in Oakland, he aided the A’s with statistically-focused player evaluation in the draft, free agency and on the trade market, arbitration cases, contract negotiations and advance scouting.
Zaidi will be tasked with rejuvenating a Giants roster that has become stagnant as its young core has grown older. The Giants thrived earlier this decade, winning three titles in a five-year span on the backs of brilliant showings from Buster Posey, Tim Lincecum, Madison Bumgarner, Matt Cain and Pablo Sandoval, among others. That once-elite core has withered with time, and while Bumgarner and Posey remain prominent figures in the organization, each has been slowed by injuries in recent seasons. That’s true elsewhere on the roster, as well; Brandon Belt and Joe Panik, in particular, are among the Giants position players who’ve struggled to remain on the field, while high-priced pitchers Johnny Cueto, Jeff Samardzija and Mark Melancon have each been felled by health troubles as well.
The divergent paths that could be taken under Zaidi and a newly structured front office will make the Giants one of the more fascinating teams to watch this offseason. On the one hand, CEO Larry Baer has voiced a desire to aim to be competitive every season — an attitude that likely pushed Evans and Sabean to load up on veterans last offseason. But the additions of Andrew McCutchen and Evan Longoria didn’t restore the organization to prominence, and Longoria’s contract now joins those of Cueto, Samardzija and Melancon as undesirable commitments that’ll be tough for the Giants to escape.
However, that desire to remain competitive comes from ownership, and if going for it in 2019 is something of a mandate, then perhaps Zaidi & Co. will seek to supplement a flawed roster as best they can. San Francisco has been mentioned as a possible landing spot for Bryce Harper for the past year-plus, and the team’s successful effort to dip under the luxury tax barrier this past season only makes them a more logical landing spot if ownership is willing to commit the money.
Conversely, though, if Zaidi and the eventual San Francisco GM ultimately conclude that a more long-term outlook needs to be taken, that narrative would quickly change. Should that be the case, the Giants could go in the extreme opposite direction, making Bumgarner available on the trade market while also dangling lefty Will Smith. Complementary pieces like Sam Dyson, Hunter Strickland and Panik could all generate varying degrees of interest. Giants leadership would have its work cut out should they try to move many veterans beyond that group, however. Posey, Melancon and Brandon Crawford all have full no-trade clauses, while Samardzija, Belt and even Bumgarner all have limited no-trade clauses in their respective contracts.
For now, it’s unclear exactly how the Giants will proceed — only that the manner in which the organization has typically operated will likely be changing, as will the general composition of the team’s front office, scouting staff and analytics department.
Ernie Riles
Great news for Giants.
Haha3121`
Oh yeah!
xabial
Nice early birthday present for Zaidi who turns 42 this week.
dandan
What day? I’m the 15th so I’m just curious.
csamson11
Wiki says the 11th, but happy early birthday to you!
lonestardodger
And 3…2…1 until the Dodgers go for Chaim Bloom
campos101214
He’s next GM G men. Sorry
Kenleyfornia74
Bloom would have the same position with the Dodgers/Giants. The choice is obvious if he even wants to leave to be a #2
kc38
Bloom is already a #2. Not gonna let him leave for same position
wadlez
Bloom is not a GM.. He would be if the Dodgers /Giants hired him…
selw0nk 2
I remember when he used to work with the A’s before going to the Dodgers.
selw0nk 2
All these Giants fans downvoting my post because I’m an A’s fan. Lol
pustule bosey
spoken like an A’s fan, blaming the giants for everything.
Jean Matrac
I doubt that the downvotes are for just being an A’s fan. I suspect it’s more about your post being about you and offering zero insight into Zaidi being hired by SF
restingmitchface
Nah I’m pretty sure it’s because he/she is an A’s fan. It is what it is.
semut
I’m a dodgers fan & downvoted that post because it was pointless. Not to mention it was, what, 3 or 4 years ago? Not exactly a mindblowing feat to remember when zaidi was with the a’s
jkurk_22
Why do the posts have to have a point? If you want to talk pointless, the entire comment thread on any and all articles is pointless. The only reason people comment is because they want to feel heard. Not because commenting actually provides any real substance to life or anything really. It’s like me worrying about what you or others on here will think about this post. I don’t know you or anyone on here. Caring what any of you think is a wast of my life
arc89
the big change between A’s and giants will be they might start trading between teams again. Zaidi and Beane are friends. Sabean said in a interview he didn’t want to trade with A’s. Its been about 20 years since they made a trade with each other.
Dodgethis
Wrong. Commenting provides co text. Journalists are selling a point of view, not facts. If you want to know what’s really happening read the comments.
wiggysf
I suspect it’s because there are a bumch of trolls on this site who downvote every post.
restingmitchface
Yup
Balk
Wiggysf, you hit the nail on the head there. If the fa player another fan wants on there team is talked about going to a different team, they get there panties in a bunch and say “why would a player want to play for you?” Lol, because of money is why!!! Lol. Trolls!
xabial
What does that make Sabean? His boss or Co-President?
casey
scout/adviser. stepping down.
xabial
Interesting office dynamic.. Seems like a sacrifice on Sabean’s part. Thank you for answering.
casey
I’m not sure he had much of a choice, but I’m sure he will have some input.
Jordan 5
Escort him out of the building now!!!!
benintendiimpersonator
Gonna try to obtain Machado twice in the year
DarkSide830
lol
sameichel
More like him and Bryce in the same year
azcrook
Machado is a non-issue as far the Giants are concerned……
restingmitchface
Congrats to Zaidi. While I can’t wish his team any luck, I hope he has a great deal of personal success. Great hire by the Giants.
Niles
Big blow for my Dodgers. We’ve lost three components in two days. They should respond by hiring Bloom or Ng. Kim Ng originally interviewed for the GM spot in 2005, which was given to Colletti. But Bloom has ties with Friedman, so it should be interesting.
walls17
didnt Ng work for the dodgers?
derail76
Yes, she did. She was out when Friedman was in if I remember right.
derail76
Quick search says she worked for the White Sox and Yankees to. The Dodgers are all for firsts, and she’d make sense as the first female GM in any sport.
Kenleyfornia74
If its not a demotion Josh Byrnes could just be an easy in house replacement GM.
restingmitchface
Byrnes seems like a possibility. I think the LAD will move quickly and we’ll know pretty soon. I’m guessing they go in-house but not Byrnes.
jasonthebuc
Josh Byrnes is Sr. Vice President of Baseball Operations.That would be a serious demotion to become GM.If anything,as Friedman’s chief lieutenant, he will probably have a big say,and a lot of input,in who the next GM is.
MetsYankeesRedSox
Big blow for sure but the biggest blow?
You still have Dave Roberts.
BlueSkyLA
Think about why that happened.
FrankTheTank999
Good. Get him outta here.
bobtillman
….meanwhile, Danny Bonaduce named Orioles’ President of Baseball Operations…..
xabial
Angelos is stingy with GM title never gave it to Duquette you think he’ll go above that for the next hire? Lol
SFGiants4ever
I thought his kids were taking over the team, am I wrong?
JayRyder
Wow. . . I know the team. I know how they roll. . . Give up hope for future playoff runs. Not in a million years…
Balk
What the hell are you talking you about. That is the most craziest post I’ve seen
Slevin
No that would be your lame multiple posts about the “Giants signing Harper”, and than instantly competing.
Balk
Slevin, I have yet to read anything you ever post kid that has any truth to it. You’re a fool. Only a fool thinks that Harper won’t sign for the most money, and if the Giants offer the most money he’ll sign. Already making some great changes within this organization and with the market size of this club, and history of winning, who wouldn’t want to play for the Giants? Let me guess, you know the free agents personally, and you know where they will sign right? Lol, So next time I say something on a post keep trolling on by weirdo. No one agrees with your kid talk.
Slevin
How’d that workout with Stanton? The Giants were less of a train wreck last offseason to attract someone. The Giants will have a top five pick in the 2020 draft…Sparky.
Balk
Stanton wasn’t a free agent there kid. If he was that would’ve been a little different there huh? Keep making your know it all post weirdo. Go troll on your teams posts. Your opinion means nothing here. Zero insight on reality of how baseball works. You sound like a hater. Go on now little guy. Go spend time learning how to use that Beebee gun in your pic. Lol
Slevin
This guy is gonna sell, sell, and sell! Do yourself a favor after that and get your meds adjusted, it’s been over a month..Sparkster.
Balk
Just keep talking kid, sounds like you need some meds. Now stop getting your panties all in a bunch and comment on your own teams future. Do some research before you speak. You obviously know nothing about this organization. The front office has already stated they are in win now mode goofball, You sound like a punk kid. Get…your iq is getting lower by the second
Slevin
Did you watch Mad Dog today spanky? Henry Shulman of the San Francisco Chronicle was on and used the words “Giants are definitely in rebuild mode”, and on top of that said “this indeed will be Bochy’s last year”. Now I kinda think Shulman knows quite a bit more than someone of your ilk. Breakout the tissues cause the sale starts at the winter meetings..hope you’re a Warriors fan spanky(that name just seems more appropriate)
Balk
Any fool who listens to mad dog and a commentator instead of the front office is more of a fool then you little girl. In fact if you watched hot stove the same guy you’re talking about said the exact opposite. GIANTS don’t rebuild girl, now go put your diaper on and crawl to your next troll. You’re boring me. Damn dude, you’re like a wet piece of toilet paper stuck to my ass. Move on and watch the Giants unfold another World Series girl.
Balk
Slevin or whatever that is, do you know how to read? Cause if you actually read this article up top it tells you what the front office is wanting. Might help you better understand things, but you have to know how to read, not troll.
Slevin
Put on your tutu so you can dance to that music in your head…Spanky.
Balk
That’s what I should do, bend you over my knee and spanky you! Lol! Now off into the world you go, go troll some more now.
Dodgethis
You must be a democrat slevin, to be that willfully delusional.
restingmitchface
lol
Balk
Plug this dude in and let’s get to work now. Real question is the front office is in a win now mode. Let’s see what he plans to do.
baseball1600
Don’t know what’s happening to Sabean. If he steps down and retires, he will be greatly respected by all the Giants fans in the world. I don’t know how life would be without watching guys like Lincecum or Cain pitch, or screaming at Santiago Casilla to get the god dang pitch in the strike zone. Either way, it was a great run and even if we don’t ever win again in my lifetime, these years I will always be grateful for.
cowman707
Well said. Sabean deserves so much respect for what he’s accomplished. It was a great ride and I’m thankful that it happened in my lifetime. I don’t think they could have found a better candidate to be his successor
Jean Matrac
Sabean was a winner for the Yankees as well. He headed the scouting dept. when they drafted/signed Jeter, Rivera, Posada, J.T. Snow, and Pettitte.
Balk
I think Sabean is right next to this new guy. I believe he wants to go back and scout. Grab those Matt Cain’s and Poseys out there.
Psychguy
Gee, and I thought he bled Dodger blue. Amazing what $$ can do. All business professional sports is such a sham. Branding only serves to make more $$ for ownership, it’s a fallacy to believe in fan-team relationships.
pustule bosey
it’s not money, it is a promotion. He gets to move to a place where he can really call the shots.
empirejim
I’d bet you he gets a nice raise to call those shots. Thinking money wasnt an important factor seems rather blind….
baseball1600
It’s not like the Dodgers haven’t gotten their GM from the SF FO before..
restingmitchface
You do realize that Zaidi came to the Dodgers from the A’s under similar circumstances, right?
I hate the Giants as much as anyone but this man deserved the job and I’m happy for him.
NaiveYouAre
We hate the Giants around here, but they got a good one! I love to bash the “geek squad,” but even I have to admit, frick and frack actually built a winner…well maybe not a WS winner, but a playoff squad year in and year out. Great hire by the Giants. I think they got the better of the two geeks. Things are about to get interesting in the west!
Haha3121`
I don’t think we should sign Bryce Harper? Why should we? He wants too much money and he batted below 250. Our park is hard to hit an HR
baseball1600
We always struggle against COL and AZI. Harper would demolish in those parks, just saying.
jdgoat
He didn’t hit .250? Is he even going to get a major league offer this offseason?
giantsphan12
Lol
heater
Signs with DET on split deal and they stash him in Toledo til Sept callups.
Psychguy
Great… more analytics… more micromanaging.
Haha3121`
That’s how the game is moving. We need analytics.
Senioreditor
I think the Giants can use a bit of analytics right now.
Haha3121`
Yeah, we need to be more modern.
restingmitchface
Teams have gotten smarter across the board since 2014.
Keep in mind, I don’t think the Giants are a poor organization. I do ascribe SOME of their WS success to good luck, but then again, I’d rather be lucky than good. That said, the formula that got them to 3 WS is outdated af. It’s unacceptable that a major market organization fall behind the times like they did.
restingmitchface
Downvotes are so passive-aggressive. If people disagree, why not say so?
SFGiants4ever
So, I can’t speak for everyone, and I didn’t bother to give a thumbs down, but I would say your comment about “the formula that got them 3 WS is outdated”. That formula was: have really good pitching, some hitters like Posey, Sandoval, (eventually Pence) and mix in some others and rely on that pitching to give up less run then you score. …Pretty sure the really good pitching formula still works really well.
Haha3121`
That’s how the game is moving. We need analytics.
jekporkins
Good work, Giants. Now let’s see what this guy is made of. Will hopefully be an interesting off-season.
xabial
5 year deal! This guy even gets to pick his own manager if Bochy retires after 2019. It’s a new era in Giants’ baseball
xabial
Tho I’m not a SFG fan, I’m excited to see how it unfolds.
Slevin
Why?
lucienbel
Not to speak for Xabial, but I’m not a Giants fan either but am interested as well. Zaidi has some interesting choices to make right out of the gate about what to do with this team. I could see the roster changing pretty dramatically over the next year or two. Which I for one think will be petty interesting.
Palmerpark
We have a guy that has worked with Billy Bean that’s a good thing – hopefully he can get out of the crappy contracts all over the field 3B, 1B, Pitchers. He’s got a lot to clean up before he can move us forward. Like to NG hired as GM.
JJB
You’re saying he worked for the openly-homosexual “Ambassador of Inclusion” for Major League Baseball? Double diversity points!
SFGiants4ever
The Giants aren’t getting out of the Longoria, Samardzija, Melancon, or Belt contracts. Belt has the most value of the 4, but if he is healthy he’s also valuable for the Giants as a hitter and one of the best defensive 1B in the league.
They can’t afford to dump more salary by trading prospects with them, they gave up probably their best pitching prospect to TX last season for a salary dump.
Balk
They aren’t getting out of Crawford either, he has full no trade. I believe Belt is the toughest one to try and move. So that pretty much leaves Bum, Strickland, Smith, Dyson, Panik. I think if they are going to try and move anyone it will be them.
Kennypowers999
Dodgers aren’t going to do anything next season anyway. They won’t get Harper nor bullpen help. They let him go and keep the dumass who thinks the Dodgers lost because of offensive. News flash freedmen bullpen was also the problem and Dave Roberts to, and Clayton but you brought both them back so our season next is already over.
puigpower
Yikes this post.
restingmitchface
“Freedman”
O Conchobhair
Free d’ man. Just free him y’all lol
Kenleyfornia74
Imagine scoring 6 runs in 36 innings at home and thinking you did not lose the series because of offense.
George Ruth
Maybe the Dodgers will get someone who will work to improve the bullpen & not running a M A S H Unit.
opranger
Amen!
steelerbravenation
He wants to get right to work so get a MadBum over here to the ATL
Haha3121`
He gonna get us Craig Kimbrel
opranger
Good riddance, the Giants deserve what they get!
ElysianPark
Kim Ng was gone before Friedman came.
Kingman#26
Excited for the move, clean house!
empirejim
Good hire for the Giants, they definitely needed a change. No great loss for the Dodgers, Zaidi was pretty much a meh GM.