2:07pm: The Braves announced that they’ve signed McCann to a one-year deal worth $2MM. As agent B.B. Abbott explained to Ken Rosenthal of The Athletic (Twitter links), McCann’s priority this winter was to return to Atlanta.
1:08pm: It’s a one-year deal for McCann, tweets MLB.com’s Jon Morosi.
12:56pm: The Braves have agreed to terms on a contract with free-agent catcher Brian McCann, reports Mark Bowman of MLB.com (via Twitter). It’ll be a homecoming for the Jet Sports client, who is from the Atlanta area and spent the first nine seasons of his Major League career as the Braves’ primary catcher.
McCann, 35 in February, signed a five-year, $80MM contract with the Yankees prior to the 2014 season and spent three years in the Bronx before being traded to the Astros in the 2016-17 offseason. After a solid first season in Houston that saw McCann hit .241/.323/.436 with 18 home runs and win a World Series ring, the 2018 season proved difficult for the veteran receiver. McCann slashed just .212/.301/.339 through 216 plate appearances. Injury troubles plagued McCann throughout the year — most notably a knee issue that required surgical repair over the summer.
In his return tour with Atlanta, McCann figures to share time behind the dish with 33-year-old Tyler Flowers. The pair could form a fairly straightforward platoon, as McCann has remained rather productive against right-handed pitching even into his mid-30s (with the exception of this past season’s injury-marred results). Flowers, meanwhile, has been a nuisance for left-handed pitchers, hitting them at a .278/.387/.444 clip over the past five seasons. The exact division of labor behind the plate may not even be fully determined until Spring Training, however.
Despite his knee troubles, McCann still managed to halt 32 percent of stolen-base attempts against him in 2018. He’s long been considered a plus pitch framer, though he graded out below average in that regard last season, per Baseball Prospectus. His blocking numbers, too, have declined in recent seasons. For the Braves, though, the hope will be that better health and perhaps a lighter workload can help McCann restore some of his offensive and defensive prowess. At the very least, he’ll bring nearly a decade and a half of experience working with pitchers to a young Atlanta rotation — an asset in which Braves decision-makers assuredly see plenty of value.
Big Green Egg
Sweet!!!
mattblaze13
I knew it would happen!!!!!
bravesfan
Think a lot of people predicted this would happen… think this takes us completely out of going after JT? I know it’s wasn’t a good shot to begin with, but got to think this ends it
LetsGetRickarded
Not really. They can still move flowers and make McCann a backup. Depends what McCann is getting paid
swanhenge
I’d say it takes ATL out of the JT chase. Platoon setup w Flowers seems like a decent play here. Good move and they still have a truckload of prospects to help add in other areas.
chipperfan 2
I think the Marlins are just asking too much for JT hence the free agent signing of McCann. Plus we got our right handed power bat in Donaldson to protect Freddie. I like the moves. Now on to signing some pitchers!
thefenwayfaithful 2
That’s what I’m getting out of this as well. Within the division and with a team with a farm system as impressive as the Braves, it wouldn’t surprise me to see the Marlins ask for a little bit more from the Braves then other organizations to begin with.
I think holding onto their assets for other positions and pitchers was the right move here.
cboyer
Interesting signing
elmore80
Let’s get Gattis back. Good bench guy and a 3rd catcher. Matt Adams or Duda for LH bench.Camargo will get lots of playing time. Good bench.
Rumncoke
hmmmm
Yanks2
Still can’t believe the Yankees signed this guy to a multi-year 75 million dollar contract. Rather have Romine full time
HubcapDiamondStarHalo
Do remember, they did so after the ’13 season when McCann was considered one of the best catchers in MLB.
walls17
That signing was hailed as a great one by virtually everybody at the time. He just didn’t perform well. Yankees got a top 100 prospect out of it though
bigkempin
At the time McCann was one of the best C’s in baseball. The contract really wasn’t a huge overpay for those 3 years. He averaged .235/.313/.418 23/75 good for a 99 OPS+ and over 5 WAR total. The 2 prospects that NY got back are also top 100 prospects now and HOU got a WS title. Overall i’d say it worked out good for McCann, NY, and HOU.
bravos14
I hope he’s healthy enough to play every other day for an entire season.
bleacherbum
Sweet, feel good baseball story. Good stuff.
xabial
Underrated C. Don’t make them like McCann anymore.
Leader every sense of the word. Ecstatic he returns home.
antibelt
Underrated? How? Multiple All-Star games, large Yankee contract. World Series Champ. Who’s called him otherwise? Another typical Xabial comment.
xabial
Another typical MLBTR comment. Attacks user, not address my genuine baseball comment.
He was injured last year, and wasn’t going to play regardless, prob due to vesting option. (No buyout)
Furthermore, he provides power from Catcher, a rarity these days, leadership for young ATL squad
SoCalBrave
Calling McCann an underrated catcher is ignorant at best.
xabial
Game-7 of 2017 ALCS, begs to differ. Clutch, underrated and leader.
xabial
Not to mention, no such thing as a bad one-yr deal
3rdStrikeLooking
Do you need ointment for the burn? Anti is spot-on.
Need to go to your burner accounts and start upvoting yourself?
xabial
Thank you for adding to intelligent discourse.
Must suck to be a human being this miserable.
Btw, only ones who talk votes, are the ones manipulating them. Don’t need votes to see.
MetsYankeesRedSox
Antibelt
The male version of Eileen
SoCalBrave
I haven’t heard anyone call McCann “washed up” or a “has been”. It’s pretty much a known fact that McCann is a valuable asset to any team. I don’t know where you get underrated from. Everyone agrees that he still smashed righties, calls a great game and plays adequate or better defense, while being a leader in the club house.
johnrealtime
I think he’s saying that his current value is underrated, not his overall career. which is fair because many on here have said he’s done
xabial
Yes! 2018 was not indicative of current value
Why can’t I be a fan of McCann, the player? Underrated as can be. Feel privileged to have seen him play, even before Gary’s emergence, and subsequent trade to Astros. (Where he helped them win their 1st ever championship)
Just once wish could post w/o rude people. love all of you except 3rdSL <3
MetsYankeesRedSox
McCann better catcher than Sanchez
Kennon Riley
As an Astros fan, I really wanted him to go back to Atlanta. We all know it’s the end of the line for Big Mac and the McCannonballs.
I’m happy for him. And yes, he’s a leader. Solid signing for them.
ripping and tearing
Yah! I can wear my Brian McCann shirts again.
HubcapDiamondStarHalo
Unless they change his number…
Jake C.
Nope he’ll be keeping his number and taking it from Culberson.
ffjsisk
Mac is a definite downgrade from Zuk at this point. Not at all what I was hoping for.
citizen
hope the braves got a cyber monday deal on this.
Danny B.
Thank God!!! No Realmuto in Atlanta. Still have hope of the Mets trading for Realmuto.
pinstripes17
Not gonna happen my man
Danny B.
Probably not but at least he won’t be a Brave. I’m a glass half full kind of guy.
YankeesBleacherCreature
My bet is the Red Sox get him if the Marlins will part for a higher quantity of prospects. They don’t really have any elite ones. That team would be crazy to beat. Just a Yankees fan chiming in.
realgone2
Cheap skates
Bosin Rag
…can lead to unfortunate ankle injuries. Spring for the expensive ones.
bkfansler2
Even if it’s just so he can retire a Brave, I’m ecstatic. Will be great to see him in the right jersey again.
slowcurve
GM’s shouldn’t value nostalgia like us fans do. I’m happy to have McCann back for the warm-fuzzy reasons, but as a pure baseball move, it’s questionable at best. If they can still flip Flowers and some pitching prospects for JT then I’d be “ecstatic” like you.
steelerbravenation
Damn everybody needs to face the facts the Braves are not getting Realmuto. They kicked the tires and didn’t like the price. The job will be Contreras in 2021.
Flowers/McCann-2019
Flowers/Contreras-2020
Contreras/Flowers-2021
bradthebluefish
McCain has 1.0 WAR last and is being singed for $2MM. That’s a steal even with injury concerns.
FloridaMan1988
Meh
R.D.
Nice second option but really wanted yasmani
mj-2
I love McCann for what he brought to our organization but this is a joke of a signing
Bringing in an aging veteran catcher when you have a lot of money to spend and Grandal avalaibke who is arguably a perfect fit for your current needs
I get passing in Grandal for Realmuto if a deal could be swung but passing for McCann makes zero sense
We may as well have just resigned Suzuki
This is a lateral if not backward move
And I say all of this with great respect for McCann (I truly mean that but he is on the wrong side of his career now)
fw-
I agree. This is a real head scratcher. Makes me think they’re going to throw a bunch of cash at someone.
54scooterb
Yep Josh Donaldson turns out.
steelerbravenation
Ok and you get stuck with Grandal cause you signed him long term & Contreras comes up and is an all star but you don’t got him anymore.
The front office knows who are keepers and who are overhyped sometimes you have to fall back til somebody is ready McCann will be a fine timeshare with Flowers could Suzuki been better yes but he priced himself out of ATL. Plus McCann’s leadership is undeniable I believe he will be a godsend for the young pitchers and he is professional which the youngsters can learn from him & the way he handles himself.
Can see them do the same thing with Markakis until Pache is ready. They have the depth pieces in Culbertson & Camargo to have a couple older guys that won’t play everyday. Would like a LH pinch hitter for the bench have not had one since Eric Hinske.
ripping and tearing
I like it.
I think they use the money they would have spent on a catcher to bring Kimbrel back too.
mj-2
No they won’t
Kimbrel is still good
You can expect a reunion with Kimbrel in 2023
PinstripedPride
Ugh, That makes another goose egg on my prediction list. I had Yasmani Grandal pegged for Atlanta.
astros_fan_84
Bryan McCann as a backup can’t be too bad. If he’s terrible, they’ll DFA him and make a trade in July.
TennVol
Hmm, $2M is pretty cheap for him. Good signing by AA.
Knowthemarket
I imagine every one of my fellow Braves fans wanted to see JTR in a Braves uniform, but we should all see this as good news. This could be the Braves telling Miami there offer is solid so we are prepared to move on.
Or this could be the Braves ACTUALLY moving on and the offer is no longer on the table to Miami, though I can think of worse bench bats than Flowers and McCann, and having an extra couple of catchers is a good thing.
Grandal would cost the Braves a second round draft and with the penalties hitting them now and in the future for their international violations, drafts are more important than usual.
Mjm117
There has to be an offer before it can be removed from the table.
Braves mgmt better hope this works out.
Knowthemarket
It’s very likely there was an offer. Just because you and I don’t know anything about it doesn’t mean anything. The Braves don’t announce offers to free agents and potential trade partners. Look at how this ce out. There weren’t even any rumblings preceding the Braves moves to aquire Donaldson and now McCann.
And how badly can this go wrong. The contract us for 1 year/$2m. This isn’t the kind of contract that would stop the Braves from bringing on someone like Ramos.
Mjm117
There aren’t much, if any, Financial risks with McCann or Flowers.
But if they struggle offensively/defensively, while the Braves, once again, contending for postseason play…desperation will set in for better C play. Very viable “if”
Especially if all the good(Grandall, Ramos, JTR) are signed/dealt elsewhere.
ShadowRD
At 2MM, im not sure why everyone is calling a bad deal, braves are not hoping a .260 20 homers 85 rbi season from him, is just a back up catcher
Zkirton
It was being called a bad deal prior to the 2m dollar part coming out. I love this deal bmac is a great club house leader that alone is worth the money. Great deal AA!
its_happening
Good signing for $2-mil and a backup catcher. Very good.
SoCalBrave
Another silver lining to this signing is that he won’t go to the Phillies. I thought that the Nats would sign him because he’s the type of clubhouse leader they sorely need. I’m glad they didn’t.
southi
While I seriously had hoped for better in the catching department I can’t complain too much. McCann was signed cheap and he does have potential. Hopefully catching part time in Atlanta revitalizes him some in 2019.
SoCalBrave
The Braves just doubled their hugs per at bat average.
zachgwest
What a steal!!!! Braves looking good adding depth… always liked Alex knew he be busy always is…
RBI
I love this signing! Braves get more power, bunches more leadership, improved D over Suzuki, and a left-handed bat for their C platoon. Checked all the boxes. And, most all Braves get a real hero returning home.
gelo
I love to see a veteran player return to the team that brought him up.
bshane229
Look kids, this signing here tells me they got something bigger brewing. They are deciding not to give away the farm for the Marlins catcher and will do a big deal with a team like Cleveland. Its coming.
doxiedevil
Nice move, 2 million is nothing these days { for baseball at least } and BMac will be great for young starting staff. Good power for the bench when flowers is catching.
This makes sense, imagine Braves will will still look at another catcher for the minors.
FriendOfBoras
Lady’s and gentlemen, the 2019 world champion Atlanta braves.
HubcapDiamondStarHalo
Not unless they upgrade the pitching by a reasonably significant amount.
-Another Braves fan
brandons-3
Aside from it being cool to have McCann back, the Marlins are freaking idiots for limiting their possible Realmuto return by refusing to deal him to an NL East club.
If packages were similar, sure, you’d prefer not to trade a player in division, but to state beforehand you won’t is asinine.
Your job is to get the best package possible back for Realmuto, regardless of where he goes. Especially considering their subpar returns thus far on Stanton and Yelich, you’d think they’d be more desperate to get a haul for Realmuto divisions be damned.
Mjm117
They never said they won’t. They prefer not too was their exact quote. Big difference.
Braves want JTR…they must provide a viable offer.
brandons-3
When the price is firmly Acuña Jr., I’m happy with McCann.
Look up any report you want, the Marlins did not want to trade him within the division. They made that clear enough that too potential suitors opted for catchers in their mid-30’s.
Enjoy a subpar return.
steelerbravenation
Definitely see either a MadBum, Gray or a Kluber/Carrasco deal coming. AA had everybody fooled with the whole we gonna makes moves thru trades and not free agency 2 acquisitions & neither one was a trade.
steelerbravenation
Went from a suspect bench to maybe the best bench in baseball after today
bhambrave
For just $2M, this is a good dollars and cents deal. I can also see a potential marketing plan, especially if they bring back Kimbrel as well. Maybe a nostalgia marketing plan can increase attendance by 500,000, and assuming an average ticket price of $40, that’s an additional $20M in ticket revenues alone, plus concessions, parking, etc. That would be enough to pay their payrolls plus. Admittedly I’m just pulling these attendance numbers and ticket prices out of my hat, but I think the principle is valid.
ONEBIGGIE
Mac and Donaldson, hell yeah!
Grade_1_teacher
This was a good signing. McCann is no longer a regular but he will work wonders with the Braves’ young pitchers. Nice move, AA!
kiddhoff
McCann will probably function as a 3rd catcher and maybe play 1b a couple of times. My guess is he was signed to be a valuable late inning PH, and a mentor of sorts
steelerbravenation
I am not say McCann can’t be a good pinch hitter but I really don’t see it. Catchers play their careers with a lot of responsibilities other than just hitting I don’t know how easy an adjustment it could be to just sit around and wait to be called on to hit. I don’t see Lenny Harris or Eric Hinske in him.
Erie4312
Camargo, Pache, Riley, Gohara, allard for Haniger and Diaz
1. Inciarte
2. Acuna
3. Freeman
4. Haniger
5. Donaldson
6. Albies
7. Swanson
8. McCann/flowers
sign big 3b nxt year
Diaz as closer
SoCalBrave
The Mariners won’t trade Diaz by himself if they don’t get Wright or Soroka. They would probably ask us to take Cano and also add Albies and Wright to your list.
Erie4312
Camargo, riley, pache, wright,
M’s get 3b, SS, CF, and possible TOR guy of the future
Camargo is MLB proven with 270 ba 20 HR in first season while missing a month
cheap and long contract
Altanta Barves
This signing only benefits McCann personally. It sets the Braves back. Not a good move by AA.
ONEBIGGIE
Personally I really don’t care…