Rays left-hander Blake Snell and Mets right-hander Jacob deGrom have won the Cy Young Awards in their respective leagues, the Baseball Writers Association of America announced on Wednesday night.
Snell received 17 of the 30 first-place votes, with the other 13 first-place nods going to Astros ace Justin Verlander. In the end, Snell narrowly edged out Verlander on the weighted ballot system, with 169 total points to Verlander’s 154. Cleveland’s Corey Kluber finished a distant third, followed by Chris Sale, Gerrit Cole, Trevor Bauer, Blake Treinen, Edwin Diaz and Luis Severino, in that order (full voting breakdown here).
As for deGrom, his closest competition was Washington right-hander Max Scherzer, though in the end, voting didn’t prove to be close. DeGrom toppled Scherzer in a landslide, taking home 29 of the 30 first-place votes (with Scherzer securing the other). Philadelphia’s Aaron Nola and Colorado’s Kyle Freeland finished third and fourth, while Patrick Corbin, Miles Mikolas, Josh Hader, Mike Foltynewicz and Jon Lester rounded out the voting (full breakdown here).
Snell, a former top prospect, broke out in his first full season as a big leaguer and thrust himself into the ranks of the elite with a dominant 2018 campaign. The No. 52 overall pick by Tampa Bay back in 2011, Snell solidified himself as an MLB-caliber starter last season with 24 starts of 4.04 ERA ball, but he overpowered opponents in 2018, pitching to a 1.89 ERA with 11.0 K/9 against 3.2 BB/9 in 31 starts. His 180 1/3 innings trailed Verlander’s 214, but Snell’s per-inning dominance proved to be enough for him to take home tonight’s hardware. No pitcher in baseball tallied more than Snell’s 21 victories.
Looking forward, while the Rays are more experimental with pitching roles than any club in the league, there’s little doubt that Snell will be handled like a traditional front-of-the-rotation workhorse. Soon to turn 26, Snell is under club control for four more seasons and won’t even reach arbitration eligibility until next winter. One can only imagine that the Rays would love to lock Snell up to a long-term pact, but a historically dominant campaign has unequivocally raised the asking price for the newest Tampa Bay ace.
DeGrom has received Cy Young votes in two prior seasons but had never finished in the top five. With an MLB-best 1.70 ERA, 11.2 K/9 and 1.9 BB/9 in 217 innings this past season. deGrom can now add a Cy Young trophy to a list of accolades that also includes 2014 Rookie of the Year honors and a pair of All-Star nods.
The Cy Young victory for deGrom only further serves as a data point that voters have increasingly moved away from placing any real value on a pitcher’s win-loss record when assessing his value; for all of his individual dominance in 2018, deGrom received virtually no run support and was saddled with a 10-9 record that was far from indicative of his consistent excellence.
His future is a bit less certain than that of tonight’s co-winner, as deGrom is under the Mets’ control for only another two seasons. While he’s previously expressed interest in signing a long-term deal with the Mets, deGrom’s agent, Brodie Van Wagenen, was the surprising pick to be named the new general manager of the Mets. He’ll need to determine a new representative before any extension talks can begin in earnest, as Van Wagenen has fully severed ties to all clients and all duties from his former agency, CAA Baseball.
For the time being, deGrom will take his Cy Young season to the negotiating table in arbitration as he negotiates what should be a sizable raise over 2018’s $7.4MM salary. MLBTR contributor Matt Swartz projects deGrom to earn $12.9MM this winter.
RedRooster
Who’s the one clown that voted Scherzer for first place?
Steve Adams
John Maffei, San Diego Union-Tribune. Individual ballots can be viewed on the BBWAA website (under the “full breakdown” links provided in the post).
RedRooster
So the writer from my team? That’s embarrassing.
troll
you own the padres?
darkstar61
Funny thing?
Scherzer didn’t even face the Padres this season, while deGrom dominated them twice (15.1 IP, 1.17 ERA, 0.976 WHIP)
So the decisions not even influenced by San Diego games anecdotal evidence
jkurk_22
He can say that. Don’t be dumb
TJECK109
Fantasy baseball
jleve618
I can’t stand when people criticize that. It’s common nomenclature.
johnnyz123
4.00 ERA over last seventy five innings against Japanese ball players.
TeddyBallgameYazJimEd
That was the first question I had after reading this…
Whoever it was should just be plain embarrased ..even as a Red Sox fan and an American League follower I realize deGrom was not just the best pitcher in the National League but in all of baseball.
johnnyz123
He has a lifetime 1.35 ERA and 1.10 WHIP. That makes him more than qualified to throw a screwball on the inside near a car wash. He also plays jai-lai.
NotaGM
Scherzer is now a clown? hmm led league in many categories. glad you not voter. id trade for him in a heartbeat.
I guess I’m a troll now for being honest…on stats
LH
It’s really not too bad, I would’ve chosen DeGrom, but Max K’ed 300+ this year and dominated nearly every game he pitched again. He’s won it the last two years and had a season on par with those past couple years.
RedRooster
Scherzer had himself a cute little season but let’s be honest, this one should have been unanimous.
Ezra77
Chris Sale should have won
c1234
He want even a finalist
phantomofdb
Sale had a great season. Snell had a better one.
davidcoonce74
Sale didn’t even qualify for the ERA title. I agree he was the best pitcher in the AL (besides Edwin DIaz), but there just wasn’t enough there.
lasershow45
Not enough innings.
Mattimeo09
Sale got beat by Kluber. Again
tomrogic
But sale has a ring
thefenwayfaithful 2
Even as a Sox fan if Snell didn’t win after the season he put together, I was going to be upset. I drafted Snell very late on my fantasy team and remember saying, “How the heck is Snell still available and why did I let him go for 2 rounds? Was I not paying attention? This guy is going to win a Cy Young one day.”
No I did not expect it to be 2018, but I was not surprised when he started putting up gem after gem. Stuff-wise, this guy is among the best in the AL. He reminds me of Eovaldi (if you’re also a Sox fan) but with a better repertoire and more movement on his fastball. When the Sox traded for Sale, I mentioned multiple times to turn around and try to get Snell before he became a guy who is untouchable.
All of this happened a year or 2 faster then I expected, but the end result is no shocker. Well deserved Blake Snell!
johnnyz123
Chris Sale bats left-handed though.
Jimcarlo Slaton
Who are the clowns who gave Freeland and Mikolas 3rd place votes.
Citizens Bank Park is very hitter friendly. I thought Nola might receive a couple 2nd place votes… Most voters still love the ‘K’, it seems.
c1234
Whoever gave Lester a vote is a bigger clown
stevewpants
Probably same guy that gave maddon a vote in MOY voting
BlueJayFan1515
Lester sure didn’t have a bad season, but I agree lol, how is he in the Cy Young voting?
mike127
Do you remember when MLB put a kibosh on Tyler Chatwood’s contract because it had an incentive clause that would give him more money if he received a vote for Cy Young. That was the biggest waste of everyone’s time, huh???
bigkempin
Nola likely did deserve some 2nd place votes but at the end of the day you can’t really argue with the results. DeGrom was the clear Cy with Scherzer/Nola being the 2A/2B Cy’s. Mikolas was also deserving of a 3rd place vote. After DeGrom/Scherzer you can’t really argue against a few pitchers getting a 3rd place vote.
turner9
I cant believe Cora didn’t beat out Snell. Dont they know the sox won the WS
MeowMeow
This comment is beautiful.
baseballhobo
Kate Upton will be complaining any moment now.
RedRooster
At least this time Snell actually had a good case. Porcello beating Verlander two years ago was just a mockery.
matt4baseball
Sad for Verlander
shoreoriolesfan
Yea I think he will sleep pretty well tonight lol
its_happening
Maybe not with a newborn. Probably hasn’t slept well since the birth.
Dennid
Well played
MetsYankeesRedSox
Great picks!!
Both earned it.
HalosHeavenJJ
Tremendous years by both men and who I thought deserved the awards. Snell’s second half was simply amazing.
I wouldn’t have had an issue with Sale winning, either, but in a close competition, I’ll take the guy who put in more work.
JrodFunk5
Then the same should apply to Verlander vs Snell. Verlander has now been cheated out of the Cy three times
JrodFunk5
On second thought I would’ve voted for Snell too.
kingken67
No, Verlander didn’t get cheated. Yes he pitched more innings but had an ERA over half a run higher than Snell. That’s too big a gap to overlook based only on innings pitched.
davidcoonce74
ERA yes but not FIP.. Snell got pretty lucky with his defense. (Although I am sanguine about SNell over JV. Snell’s selection isn’t egregious, like Porcello’s was a few years ago)
thefenwayfaithful 2
He also got an MVP with numerous position players deserving. I don’t think he’s too broken up about it. His wife is probably more upset.
RedKing22
Very impressive season by Miles Mikolas coming back over from Japan and getting Cy Young votes. Props to him.
WestCoastSoxFan
Wow. The voters got it 100% right.
forgiveusbillybuck
Interesting that TB Chapter writers had Verlander down at 4th and 3rd with their votes. Snell is deserving of their no. 1 picks but points would have been closer.
jjd002
What did he do to the Tampa writers because I believe they didn’t even vote for him (or way low) when Porcello stole the award from him?
johnrealtime
yeah that’s a shady move to try and make sure snell won. makes a mockery of the voting process
lasershow45
Severino got SCREWED! Always voting against the Yankees!!!!
Bubba 5
You’re joking right??
mb22
Has to be a joke .. Severino was legitimately the worst SP in baseball for two months of the season after getting off to a ridiculous start .. if the season ended in June, he’d have won it
xabial
Litmus test:
ROY He wanted Ohtani over Andujar
Ofc he’s joking! 🙂
lasershow45
Man I’m a Red Sox fan! Of course I’m kidding!
snotrocket
Snell was better in every measurable way.
Gordon Shumwhey
Andujar should have won CY Young, but MLB is biased against the Yankees as usual! 27 RINGS BRO!!!
WestCoastSoxFan
Wow, Chris Sale has finished 6th, or better, in all 7 seasons where he’s been in MLB.
ChiSoxCity
White Sox should have gotten more for Sale.
jleve618
Maybe the red sox could have thrown in some stock options.
metseventually 2
jake.
Blah blah blah
DeGrom.
heater
Both most deserving! Glad to see that an award for individual performance was given for just that instead of the old “well his team didn’t make the playoffs” thinking. Both guys fun to watch.
Danny B.
Agreed.
matt4baseball
Congrats to Snellzilla, All at 26 yrs and he’s only going to get better. As a Rays fan I hope we don’t trade him now.
Joeypower
Sooner than later! Lol
jdgoat
Did Chatwood get his CY young vote that gives him an increase in incentives?
stoth15
this is too funny
Danny B.
Whomever that moron was that didn’t vote for DeGrom, should be fired for stupidity.
hiflew
Even if you want to discount wins, which is weird considering the award is named after the guys with the most wins, Scherzer outdid him in strikeouts by a hefty margin. It should have been a whole lot closer. There are more stats than just ERA.
Danny B.
Yea because getting 31 more K’s qualifies a pitcher to get a cy young vote. DeGrom outdid Max is many categories. Better ERA, opponent OPS. Scherzer allowed 13 more HR’s then DeGrom did. DeGrom had 29 straight quality starts to end the season, an MLB all time record, Scherzer never came close to that to streak. Should have been unanimous.
AmaralFan1
DeGrom and Scherzer both had 28 quality starts in 2018. They tied for the MLB lead.
DodgerBlue83
29 consecutive games allowing 3 ERs or less. Twice he didn’t reach the minimum innings to qualify for a qualjty start.
AmaralFan1
So 28 quality starts.
hiflew
Why bother getting facts correct as long as they are popular. Seem a perfect response for America in 2018.
baseball1600
But there’s no way Scherzer was better than DeGrom. Even if he had a couple of stats where he was better in, DeGrom dominated all of the NL offenses with ease. You’re a fool to call Scherzers season as good as or better than DeGroms.
hiflew
Just because I disagree with you does not mean I am a fool. Perhaps you should look into the benefits of making an argument without insulting your opponent.
darkstar61
There are more stats than just Wins and K’s too
deGrom had the 2nd lowest FIP of the last 30 years (below just 1999 Pedro)
hiflew
Then I guess we need to rename the award. Cy Young is remembered for being the wins leader, not the FIP leader. I guess we can just call it the Millennial Participation Award since it doesn’t really matter if you win or not as long as you have fun and look good.
metfan4ever
YES, you get it HIFLEW. WIN THE GAME.
deSynmatzvey
the award is given to the best pitcher in each league. deGrom was easily the best pitcher in the National League. deGrom won the Cy Young award.
jdgoat
How are you possibly going to punish pitchers hiflew for things that are out of their control? Degrom just had one of the best seasons in recent memory, but since he played on a bad team, he’s automatically not allowed to win Cy Young unless he hits four homers himself?
darkstar61
hiflew,
So best pitcher = not deserving
But pitcher who saw his team score the most runs for him allowing him to get Wins = should win
Seems silly and pointless to base the award off how good his team’s hitters are, but whatever
So your 2018 NL awards should be Scherzer & Miles Mikolas as co-CY winners then
And last year in the AL it should have been Kluber, Carrasco & Jason Vargas all sharing the award
davidcoonce74
Wins are a team stat. Maybe we should just have a “wins” award for pitchers. It wouldn’t mean anything. Lits of pitchers have led the league in wins without being particularly good.
imgman09
I like DeGrom but he Pitched No meaningful Games,that’s why Scherzer got votes,just saying and don’t care.Hey a least somebody on the Mets is worth something,LoL
bucketbrew35
Hate to break it to you but Scherzer didn’t pitch any meaningful games either. The Nats were underachieving dogsh*t all year.
xabial
Scherzer lost but he’s still Hall of Fame career.
Danny B.
No denying that but DeGrom is still the better pitcher.
elscorchot
This year
Harry pness
You post generic comments that everyone agrees w/ that isn’t necessary to be commented on. Do us a favor and stop looking for upvotes. Go get yourself an Instagram if you want people to “like” your stuff
xabial
I’m fan of Scherzer and wanted him to win. Or at least have closer race. I take solace in the fact, he’s got the HOF thing going for him
Just once wish I could post without getting attack
Harry pness
Who “TF” is denying scherzer is not a HOFer?? You are the most annoying person on here and is on the same tier as Casey’s sidekick. Lol at you for having more than one account
Harry pness
How many times do you edit your posts. Over or under 10
xabial
How many times are you off topic putting all this energy into actively hating someone in a comment section? Over or under 10
Harry pness
Just you: over 10. Deservingly so. Everyone else on here is cool, they aren’t on here commenting on every. single. post.
baseball1600
Lol couldn’t agree more Harry. There’s almost no point in his comments. Either it’s utter stupidity or blatantly obvious statements that everyone can agree with. Just no point in acknowledging most of his comments.
Harry pness
He just wants to be liked by the internet people!
3rdStrikeLooking
Harry, I laughed out loud!! And upvoted!!! (In the middle of slapping random down votes to chatty cathy)
3rdStrikeLooking
Hilarious!
Harry pness
Next xabial will say miggy is a HOFer on a discussion topic of the rule 5 draft for the tigers
baseball1600
Will probably talk about how the Yankees are a playoff team when they sign Corbin.
Hit4me
You sound like a real winner who trolls others to get people on the internet to like them. Registered just to down vote you.
xabial
Hit4me, Whatever you say Harry
baseball1600
Well looks like xabials alt army has 1 more name added to its list.
Harry pness
Lol i love the internet. At least he referred me as a real winner. His mother, looking at his web history, would be proud he didn’t use any curse words
SixFlagsMagicPadres
Thank you for pointing out the antics of a troll. This guy’s pointless posts just to get likes are always very annoying to see, especially since they are in virtually every article.
xabial
I don’t think you know the meaning of “troll”
You’re the guy who said he only posts in Padres’ articles because of trolls, and you’re contributing to their cause. Hmu when Padres get out of perpetual mediocrity (Thats trolling)
Harry pness
Xabial your 5th account “Hit4me” just had a ratio 1:9. Don’t cry too loud. Your mother, aka roommate, will hear ya and think your beating off
c1234
Harry, he’s probably going on to his alts asap now so the ratio doesn’t look too bad
xabial
Most bizarre wierdest thing anybody has ever had a problem with me here:
“Posting obvious posts for likes.”
That’s like telling somebody you hate them cuz you agree with opinion. Get bent or banned
baseball1600
All you do is restate the article, add a few extra words, and post it. And it happens every single day. I haven’t gone a day without seeing your name pop up somewhere with generic posts that have no meaning or insight. Whenever you do try and make a point, you just like dumb and cause outrage in the comment section. Many have just accepted that you’re a troll, constantly doing the same thing over and over again on a daily basis. You’re the meme of MLBTR.
xabial
Get over yourself. Nowhere did Steve say Scherzer was a HOF in this post. contribute nothing, and think your opinion is everything
baseball1600
Wow! The article didn’t state the Scherzer has had a HOF career! I’m so glad you brought it upon us and shared it, as if no one already knew. How about you get over yourself, troll.
baseball1600
How long until more “commenters” register just to downvote any of xabials critics. I’ll give it 10 minutes.
xabial
Yea Scherzer’s a special talent and the 29 of the 30 first-place votes didn’t do him justice. Restating he’s HOF so he gets more love, he’s one of my favorite players, hope he wins a ring
Have no clue why you guys are infatuated with likes and dislikes. U Only ones who bring it up
3rdStrikeLooking
What part of stfu dont you understand? Need something in parenthesis??
baseball1600
Here’s an example of Xabials utter stupidity. Has Scherzer not won several Cy Young’s before? Is it injustice to give votes to the SP with far better stats? If anything, this was a down year for Scherzer considering his previous years of dominance. This wouldn’t qualify as even a top 3 season for him.
Harry pness
“Restating he’s HOF so he gets more love”
Because career stats are factored into a season award race?
Que the billy madison moderator line
DarkSide830
Harding needs to have his voting ability removed. No reason to have voted Lester 4th simply because he had 18 wins.
Harry pness
Both deserving
xabial
And I’m the one who posts “generic comments”?
Just stop replying to my posts. We get you don’t like me.
jd396
They have pallets of generic posts on sale at Costco this month.
jrwhite21
good looks, jd
3rdStrikeLooking
Stfu.
Harry pness
Xabial your mother won’t like seeing her roommate lashing out on the internet
imindless
Now trout for mvp, if voting has shown playoffs dont matter or impact players performance.
NOPelicanFangirl696969
This is the one time i side with the sox, betts deserves mvp this year
xabial
This. Or JD if he won the triple crown.
andrewf
So Miggy deserved to be MVP over Trout in 2012? Lack of defense and baserunning wasn’t all that important for you. Part 1 is ok
jjd002
He still wouldn’t deserve it, just like Miggy didn’t deserve it over Trout.
warboner
JD only if he wins 2 triple crowns
BronxBomber7
Now why couldnt these writers get ROY right? MOY and Cy Young? Perfect votings. ROY? Clown show.
jd396
Seems like Snell over Verlander is one of the closer voting results we’ve had recently.
baseball1600
Porcello over Verlander was a lot closer. And more bs.
xabial
Someone else already made this comment above. Please stop w/ blatant obvious posts for likes.
metfan4ever
I’m a Met fan and used to pitch. How does a pitcher win a cy young when on the same team you have a 13 & 4 pitcher, a 12 &a 7 pitcher(who won 9 in a row) with the same line up & the 10 & 9 guy wins a cy young. A pitcher Wins Games or loses games(except for errors). It’s the same line up, same team. It’s attitude. How come the other teams pitchers don’t give up runs when deGrom pitchs. Why do the Same hitters hit for Thor & Wheeler But not for deGrom. It’s attitude
HubcapDiamondStarHalo
Ah, so you and a writer from San Diego are the two people in the world who didn’t think deGrom should win.
petrie000
You can pitch terribly and still ‘win’, and pitch great and lose… Because it all comes down to who gets the most run support on average… Wins as a stat has little to do with the pitcher himself
metfan4ever
1 or A few game ya but Thor pitches right after deGrom, so most of the time it’s the same team the Mets are playing against, with the same line up, and there is a big difference from 4 loses to 9. And run support- It’s the same Met Hitters. Which superstar hits for Thor/Wheeler that doesn’t play when deGrom pitches. It’s game management. Same bullpen–the same team and 2 other pitchers win(Thor/Wheeler) has a better win lose. Do you care if you win 1 to 0 or 11 to 10.
xSpecBx
Some of it depends on who they play against. What was the average runs per game scored by the Mets when DeGrom was pitching? Im guessing it was pretty low. And just because a team scores 15 runs one game doesn’t mean they’re going to do the same thing the following game.
metfan4ever
If it a few game yes but 4 loses to 9 loses. What do the Met Hitter do for Thor that they can’t do for deGrom. And is it something deGrom does that makes that happen—have you ever pitched, I pitched in college. Nola pitches in a hitter park-that should could for something-DeGrom doesn’t pitch in a hitter park, same one that Thor/Wheeler pitch in.
a dawg
If the Mets score 2 runs in every degrom start he’d be a 20 game winner
Out of place Met fan
Well a very oversimplified answer, (and as a “former pitcher” I am sure you already know) rotations generally line up. So the best pitchers are typically squaring off against one another. So while deGrom faces Nola, Wheeler vs Velasquez isn’t generally going to lead to the same run suppression.
metfan4ever
Out of place- 1)that doesn’t happen for a full season, 2)but teams like the,Marlins(play them 18 times)/pitt/cinn/atl(18 times)/cubs/sf/sd/col don’t have a Nolan 3) nats/la/az have 2 very good pitchers. 4) Nola/scherer also would be faces #1s(going by what you posted) It should translate into more than 10 wins
kodion
You used to pitch.
Just an example: Start. Go 7+ innings, 3 hits, no runs, get taken out. Your “relief” allows 3 runs to tie the game, but get the final out before the offense walks it off. The reliever who got the last out ends up getting credit for your win.
Does that work for you?
If you can’t see past wins and losses, you might want to try reading more of the details in the articles, or in the links they contain, posted on this site.
metfan4ever
kodion—Thor/wheeler have the SAME relief pitchers coming in for them & they have more wins. No I can’t get past win/loses. With what you post we should still have harvey. Did the red Sox win a W/S because of 7 innings. And if relievers are not closing out his games but closing out Thor/Wheeler games then again it maybe something deGrom does that makes it that way-it’s the same releivers. Also what great bullpen do Nola/Scherzer have does that work for you
dboas123
both pitchers earn their Cy Young awards. They played on teams with terrible offense and never wavered from the job they signed to do.
warboner
the Rays had an average offense, not terrible
carlos15
Verlander finishing that close to Snell is a joke. Snell should have gotten every first place vote.
metfan4ever
Every time Verlander pitches the other team is up for it, when Tampa comes to town, the other team is not as up. It’s called playing to your competition.
Kennon Riley
Verlander had superior statistics in virtually everything except ERA and HR/9. Verlander even had a lower FIP/xFIP than Snell. It’s a joke that Snell received as many first place votes as he did.
I’m more intrigued at how Gerrit Cole/Corey Kluber didn’t get a single first place vote. I didn’t think it should have been a two-horse race, but so be it.
simschifan
Whenever I see Blake Snell I always think of how much he looks like Jay Baruchel
Ejemp2006
Am I counting right? Did Verlander get left off a ballot again? Also, in an argument against Snell, the Rays always take him out before he faces the lineup a third time so his stats are inflated. Snell also pitches in the Trop which gives the biggest home field advantage in the majors.
Danny B.
Let me make this clear before I provide this hypothetical, I DO NOT want to trade DeGrom. Now, with a cy young in hand, would it be smart for the Mets to capitalize on his success and trade him for Kris Bryant & Javier Baez? The Cubs wouldn’t say no to the best pitcher in baseball.
metfan4ever
Cubs will not give both up.
simschifan
By giving up half of their actual offensive contributors? Yes they would say no, it would be like him going to the Mets part two
Steve_gravy
Good for them both. Glad to see new players winning. For deGrom I feel like it is overdue.
butch779988
They got both of these right this time.
LH
DeGrom deserves it but nobody in the league plays harder than Max Scherzer. Most fun player to watch in the League in my opinion.
Kennon Riley
It’s interesting that the only thing that mattered in this year’s AL Cy Young ballot was ERA.
GrandpaBaseball
Max deserved the CY Award IMHO. No disrespect for DeGrom but wins is what really counts, not ERA or any other stats. What a shame the Cyber Geeks are taking over. 5 to 6 innings a game is weak at best, give a team 4 guys that pitch 200 innings plus and are winners then you’ll see the team make the playoffs.