While many simply point to the Yankees’ payroll as the reason for their success, general manager Brian Cashman has spent over a decade quietly assembling an analytics department that rivals any in baseball, as Marc Carig and Eno Sarris detail in a fascinating piece for The Athletic (subscription required). Current assistant GM Michael Fishman was hired as the Yankees’ first full-time analyst in 2005, and today, New York has an estimated 20 employees on their analytics team. This ties them with the Dodgers as the largest such staff in baseball by Carig and Sarris’ count, though they note that teams are notoriously secretive in providing any details about their information-gathering practices. The increased focus on analytical data has impacted all levels of the baseball operations and scouting departments, with the results apparent in how the Yankees have built their outstanding bullpen, all their pitchers’ high velocity and spin rate on their four-seam fastballs, and in the sheer number of current Major League players that the Yankees originally signed or drafted.
Here’s more from around the AL East…
- We could know more about Buck Showalter’s future with the Orioles today, as The Athletic’s Dan Connolly (Twitter link) reports that the manager is expected to meet with ownership and the “sense is” Showalter will be offered some type of job to remain with the franchise. It isn’t clear if that job would be a front office role or if Showalter could continue on as manager in the wake of Baltimore’s 115-loss season.
- Questions also surround the job status of Orioles executive VP of baseball operations Dan Duquette, though Duquette didn’t give any hints about his situation, simply telling Dan Connolly (subscription-only piece) “that’s an appropriate question for ownership.” Though Duquette’s contract is up at the end of October, he is still proceeding as if he’ll still be with the organization in 2019. For instance, Duquette is considering joining at least five other Orioles talent evaluators in attending the showcase for top Cuban prospects Victor Victor Mesa, Victor Mesa Jr., and Sandy Gaston on Friday. The O’s have been heavily linked to these youngsters due to the space in the team’s international bonus pool, which Connolly estimates as roughly $6MM available to be spent.
- Hard-throwing Ryan Brasier has become a key contributor to the Red Sox bullpen, posting a 1.60 ERA, 4.14 K/BB rate and 7.8 K/9 over 33 2/3 frames for the AL East champs. It has been quite the showing for the unheralded 31-year-old, who had just nine innings of MLB experience (with the Angels in 2013) prior to this season. As The Athletic’s Chad Jennings (subscription required) writes, it was less than a year ago that a homesick Brasier was pitching in Japan and intent on returning to North America for the 2018 campaign. He sent e-mails to all 30 MLB teams over the offseason in search of a job, finally landing a minor league deal with the Sox, and then excelling after his contract was selected in July.
bobtillman
Brazier, Joey Wendle, Max Muncy, etc……with all the analytics, some decent players are falling through the cracks……minor-league free agents, Rule 5-ers, and the like…..keeps a GM busy…..
GaryWarriorsRedSoxx
Showalter and duquette both gone today.
bobtillman
And both will have jobs by the end of the month….O’s fans should consider that…..
ronfromcal
Maybe not. I see Buck staying with the organization. Possibly next GM?
deweybelongsinthehall
Cashman gets kudos for the deadline trades with with ST. Louis and Toronto. Regardless of next year, they wouldn’t be hosting tonight’s game without those moves. As a Sox fan I hate posting such positive feedback but it is what it is…
jbigz12
Cashmans deadline deals were all pretty solid. His offseason trades maybe not so much. He gave up 2 good prospects for drury. At least he managed to salvage that into Happ at the deadline but solak and widener would’ve fetched Happ and then some. But it happens. No one is going to make all the right moves.
pasha2k
Cashman is excellent , coming from a red Sox fan, he is Descartes n fast moving, everything we wish we were. DD did a a good job just not not the the best he could have.
southbeachbully
The Drury deal didn’t work out more because of his migraines and less because he couldn’t hit but I do agree with you that that was one of his few mistakes. I was all set for them to start the year with Andujar as the everyday 3b. Both Widener and Solak are perfect examples of being good prospects that weren’t recognized by the industry as top 100 talents but then had great seasons following a trade. Widener is raked as the Dbacks top 5 prospect and I think Solak is in the back end of the Rays top 10 (7-10). Solak would’ve been blocked by Torres so I’m ok with that. Widener would’ve been nice to keep. But so far, with a flurry of trades using prospects, those two are the only ones that the Yanks have reason to regret thus far.
jbigz12
I don’t know if it was migraines alone on drury. They certainly set him back severely but hes been an alright big leaguer but certainly not a sensational one. They were hoping for a jump that obviously didn’t happen. You take chances on guys sometimes but that one obviously didn’t pan out. Solak and widener weren’t helping this years team anyway but I never really saw what they did in drury. And obviously the two prospects have done nothing but boost their stocks since. The other deals appear to be inconsequential for the Yankees but it’s too early to say that for sure. You can call it a loss on the drury deal because he’s already out of Town and the 2 prospects they dealt currently have more value. Part of the game though. It happens.
southbeachbully
I agree with you for the most part. Again, I felt the trade was unnecessary. However, Drury never made it out of ST and had less than 100 AB in the majors. Went sent down he of course tore AAA pitching up. He MAY have been a good buy low guy but his health just got in the way.
xSpecBx
Drury didn’t really get much of a fair shake either. Unfortunately with Miguel Andujar making a splash Drury just became an extra part that didn’t fit. From what I understand, Drury was someone that Cashman had coveted for a while and fit well when he was acquired, but just didn’t work out with the medical issues.
dust44
I really liked the Drury pick up. Sucks he had his health issues. I envisioned him playing the Neil Walker role being able to play multiple positions when someone was banged up. Never bought him as a long term solution at any one position tho
joshua.barron1
As a fellow Sox fan, the reason they finished second to us in the division is they lacked the veteran leadership that they had last year to keep the young guys accountable. Frazier, Headley, Castro, Girardi. I said that in the winter when they acquired Stanton, who is NOT that guy.
its_happening
Also have to consider how loaded Boston is. Starting with Betts and Martinez and all the way down. If Boston’s pitching holds up they will be very tough to beat in the playoffs. They are lethal.
deweybelongsinthehall
Don’t forget Betts had a down year in 2017 batting in the middle of the order without Papi and Bogie was hurt. Bogaerts is the unsung hero. As many big clutch hits as Betts and JDM. Three headed monster this year.
jbigz12
You don’t think the Sox were just a better team over the course of 162 games? JDM and Mookie are 2 of the 3 best hitters in the American League. Or the fact that the Yankees got zero production out of 1B For most of the season. Gary Sanchez let’s a ball go behind him every day. Sonny gray was a horrific starter I think all of that contributed more than having Matt Holliday or Joe Girardi sitting on the bench. They’ve fixed a lot of the holes now but when you’re competing against a team that is also stacked that adds up over the course of a long season.
southbeachbully
Veteran leadership had nothing to do with finishing second. They still had the two most important vets left in Sabathia and Gardner. Effective pitching depth in the back of the rotation was the issue. Germain, Loisaiga and Adams are all talented but the Yanks just couldn’t give them enough time to figure things out. I mean, the Yanks did win 100 games and usually that’s enough to run away with the division. Who would the AL would have 4 teams win 97+ games?
Adam6710
For god’s sakes… the Yankees won a hundred games.
Since 2000 only 22 teams have managed that (out of 540 possible seasons). That puts them in the top FOUR PERCENT.
There is no reason for the Yankees or their fans to lament 2018. The reason they finished second is that the best team in the majors was also in their division.
I mean, really– would they have been a better team with Headley’s veteran leadership but without Andujar’s elite bat? Give me a break.
Meanwhile two of those rookies that weren’t “held accountable” put in all-star campaigns, and will be #1, #2 or #3 in the ROY voting.
Meow Meow
Watching Yankees fans bemoan an objectively excellent season just because the Red Sox fared better was my favorite theater of the season.
SaberSmuckers
Honestly wish there was a way to follow commenters on this site.
You bring something to table, unlike the weird Cereal and three team fella.
And I’ve been a Yankees fan since ‘83.
xSpecBx
Yankees got beat up by bad teams that they should have won against. That is the difference.
deweybelongsinthehall
“Weird” cereal? In what way? We sometimes agree, sometimes don’t but his posts “weird”? Not in my book. Only defending because there are others who “weird” would put be a mild term. I just don’t think we should be attacking others. Argue a specific post? Absolutely. Just not an attack on the person.
Draven_X_23
Yup, the Yanks do spend a lot of money. I wonder if having a lot of money makes it easier to have a 20 person analytic department.
southbeachbully
Those 20 people are not adding up to millions. Any team can do what they’ve done as far as their analytics department. In fact, if explained properly to even the cheapest owner, they would learn that it can actually save them money especially when you resist signing declining star FA in favor of younger and cheaper options that might produce the same amount of on-field value.
mikeyank55
The Red Sox payroll was higher than the Yankees.
Bruin1012
Yup first time in at least 20 years.
Bruin1012
Actually I can’t remember when the Red Sox had a higher payroll then the Yanks until this year.
deweybelongsinthehall
This year only because the Sox bit the bullet in 17 whereas the Yankees and Dodgers reset their luxury tax threshold this season. All three will spend next year as the game changes to shorter term higher per year value contracts. Such is more in line with front loading the deal as compared to the historical back loaded deals.
Cam
I don’t think the personnel side of analytics will be all that expensive – Teams are notorious for paying pennies on the dollar to lure in interns for “bulk work”. Rather, a lot of money would go into their proprietary systems, and the likely upkeep of them.
Anecdotal, but a thought nonetheless.
Michael Trent
Agree
Michael Trent
I think Buck did a pretty good job here. If he is out and it’s a total rebuild, then they should also hire a new GM. That way that person can put people in place and everyone is on the same page and the same philosophy is going on through out the organization…..
cito's mustache
That article at The Athletic is the reason I have a subscription. Just a fantastic deep dive by Eno Sarris and Marc Carig. And I’m not even a Yankees fan!
KD17
Wow, reading through this I didn’t see one mention of the key reason the Yankees didn’t compete with the Red Sox this year!! Girardi!! Yankee fans don’t seem to understand how much he meant to the organization. For years you won the division with less talent! In the post-Jeter and last years of Jeter you competed with next to no talent. When the current group of players first came up you competed during rebuilding years. Only one reason: Girardi!!
Now both teams have sub par managers but because Toronto and Baltimore were so incredibly bad both teams won way more games than they would have with 5 competitive teams in the division. The 100+ wins wasn’t greatness, it was a really really bad division. That’s why Houston is the team to beat. They didn’t get 38 games against Toronto and Baltimore, they earned their 100 wins.
So don’t be fooled by their records, the Red Sox and Yankees are just above average teams that got to play allot of games against pathetic teams. Cora and Boone didn’t do anything. Cora mismanaged his pitching, set line-ups incorrectly like tonight when JD batted 4th not 3rd. He’s an idiot whose only managerial skill is to mimic what Houston did last year. And guess what, that’s not going to work in the playoffs. Boone is no better. All those years when Girardi had less than us and he competed, this year Boone had more than us and didn’t. Girardi made guys like Sanchez and Judge perform and when things got ugly he always seemed to lift the team up and get them to rebound. When things went bad this year, there was some spiraling that Boone couldn’t stop. Sanchez didn’t perform. The team didn’t crush weak opponents. I think with the weak league Girardi could have beat our record or maybe forced Cora to not take September off.
NY has lots of talent but is missing the key ingredient they shed last year. Boston is loaded with talent and has a manager who knows what to say to get guys to perform but has no clue how to set a line-up, handle a pitching staff or rest players. It looks to me like this rivalry will be fairly evenly matched until the front offices fire Cora and Boone!!
luclusciano
You sure? Boston was the team to beat this year. And that’s hard to say as a Yankee fan.
Pretty sure Houston has Texas and California in their division, about par with the blue jays.
Girardi was not the answer for why they did not win. Pitching is the reason. As it was most years he managed as well.