This is the latest installment in our Market Snapshot series. Today, we’ll round out the infield by taking stock of the situation at the hot corner.
Teams In Need
There aren’t many committed contenders with glaring holes at third base, which is rather interesting given the number of quality options on the open market this year. Of course, there are still quite a few teams that can and arguably should pursue upgrades at the hot corner.
It seems reasonable to expect the 2019 season to feature another shoot-out between the Yankees and Red Sox in the AL East. Both have talented young players at third, in Miguel Andujar and Rafael Devers, but have at various points faced questions regarding their commitment to those options. Somewhat similarly, the Braves and Phillies could perhaps justifiably rely on existing players (Johan Camargo/Austin Riley and Maikel Franco/J.P. Crawford) but surely also like the idea of improving.
The central divisions have several potential destinations to watch. The White Sox are an interesting opportunistic buyer, while the ALC-rival Indians could choose to utilize star infielder Jose Ramirez at second or third base, putting them in play here as well. It’s not clear what the Twins will do with Miguel Sano, but it’s certainly possible they’ll prefer to have another player at third base. On the NL side, it’s arguable that the Cardinals ought to be looking at the hot corner as a place to improve, though the organization still has alternatives on hand and may not wish to commit for too long a stretch with a slate of intriguing prospects nearing the majors. Meanwhile, the Pirates will at least need a platoon partner for Colin Moran, while the Brewers were comfortable moving Travis Shaw off of third base this year and could conceivably do so again over the longer haul.
Several other organizations could be looking to add as well, though none figure to be big spenders. The Padres are in a bit of an odd spot. There’s a slate of internal possibilities — including some top prospects nearing the majors and still-wandering defender Wil Myers — but it’s also possible to imagine scenarios where they seek a gap-filler or even pursue a significant player. The Diamondbacks, depending upon their approach to the winter and the health of Jake Lamb, could be a factor. Meanwhile, the Royals, Orioles, and Marlins aren’t committed to anyone at the position — Brian Anderson is a factor at the hot corner and the corner outfield for Miami — but also won’t be prioritizing near-term performance.
Free Agents
Potential Regulars: Manny Machado is easily the top asset in this class — if, that is, he’s really willing to consider signing as a third baseman as opposed to insisting on playing shortstop. Still, it’s arguable that Josh Donaldson is an even more interesting player to watch. The former star is entering his age-33 season on the heels of an injury-plagued campaign, but showed flashes of his former brilliance in a late-season run with the Indians (.280/.400/.520 in 60 plate appearances) before a disappointing-but-brief postseason showing.
Mike Moustakas represents a solid option for those teams looking to plug in a steady piece at the hot corner — and willing to overlook his well-established OBP limitations. Organizations with greater interest in moving players around, however, may look elsewhere. Eduardo Escobar and Marwin Gonzalez are not substantially younger than Moustakas, and aren’t quite the power threats, but also have much more experience at other spots around the infield. They are also both switch-hitters. Either player could conceivably end up seeing significant action at a given position, perhaps third base, or moving around the field.
A few other veterans also represent quite notable factors on the market, though it’s somewhat difficult to tab any as clear options for everyday duties at third. Adrian Beltre is generally seen as being likely either to re-up with the Rangers or retire, but he’d be an interesting target for some clubs if he decides to test the market. Meanwhile, Asdrubal Cabrera and especially Jed Lowrie have legitimate cases to continue receiving consistent playing time, though it’s not yet clear whether teams will view them as regulars at one position — in Lowrie’s case, especially, second base seems likelier than third — or more as heavily-used utility pieces.
Timeshare/Utility/Reserve Options: David Freese has hit enough that the Dodgers will need to seriously consider his $6MM option. Otherwise, he’ll be a popular veteran target. Josh Harrison will also draw interest in the likely event that his own option is declined; though he’s more of a utility option at this point, his ability to play third will increase his appeal. Several other bounceback candidates — Logan Forsythe, Jung-ho Kang, Sean Rodriguez, Pablo Sandoval and Luis Valbuena — will be available.
Depth Options: Ryan Flaherty, Chase Headley, Jose Reyes, Andrew Romine, Danny Valencia
Trade Targets
Nobody would draw more rental interest than Nolan Arenado, who has drawn at least some speculation as a target, but there’s no real reason to think the Rockies will be willing to listen after a season in which they reached the postseason. He’s likely the only star player who’s even a hypothetical trade piece, and perhaps the only true regular as well.
It could be that the Rangers will listen on Joey Gallo or Jurickson Profar, though both have graded better defensively at other positions and have rather clear paths to significant playing time in Texas. Neither seems likely to be targeted as an everyday option at the hot corner elsewhere. The aforementioned Franco is a possible buy-low candidate if the Phillies go in a different direction, while there are some clubs that might consider utilizing Sano at the hot corner if the Twins decide to cut bait. If they move, this pair will likely hold the most interest for rebuilding teams that can take a chance on the upside.
Otherwise, conceivable part-time trade candidates include Derek Dietrich and Martin Prado of the Marlins, Eduardo Nunez of the Red Sox (assuming he picks up his club option), Yolmer Sanchez of the White Sox, Jedd Gyorko of the Cardinals, Yangervis Solarte of the Blue Jays, and Tommy La Stella of the Cubs.
More interesting trade possibilities could certainly also open up once the free agent market begins to resolve itself. Contenders that choose to invest in high-end veterans, after all, may find themselves with quality younger players that can be utilized as assets to acquire other pieces.
xabial
Chase Headley! Haven’t heard from him, since he got dumped by the Padres. He’s a class guy, but what are the chances we see him again 2019? Consummate Pro w/ Yanks
.115 (6-for-52) with no home runs and four RBIs, for Pads, should not signal the end of your career. Refuse to accept it.
#Fantasygeekland
I doubt anyone would want to give him a big league deal. No contender would (what would your reaction be if NYY signed him), no rebuilding teams would want him because they want to get younger.
xabial
As back up to Andujar/Voit (plays 1B and 3B, to increase versatility, would’ve no problem) but not gonna lie; really liked wht Hechavarría provided as back up, .250BA… elite Def over Headley. Hope Yanks re-sign Hechavarría #1 option, but wouldnt mind if they sign Headley to MiLB as a back up.
Phanatic 2022
I wouldn’t mind hardly either but then bird is in the minors. Can have 3
#Fantasygeekland
Definitely will get an MILB deal, but will need to prove something in aaa
Mark from CT
Definitely will NOT get an MiLB contract. He was over the hill 2 yrs and $26 million in salary ago. Yankees really stuck it to AJ “good hair” Preller on that one.
xabial
Jeff, couldnt you add Adeiny Hechavarría to this list? At min. UTIL; he always subbed for Andujar in playoffs for def at 3B.
billysbballz
Why wasn’t Echeverria added X?
jb19
I’m really interested to see where Marwin Gonzalez signs. I read the other day that he should accept $8-$10MM/yr for 4 years. If that’s the case, Houston should offer him that and be done w it. I think Marwin is a valuable piece to that Astros team.
iverbure
I would imagine Marwin is looking at a Zobrist like deal. While the game is trending younger, it’s also put emphasis on increased versatility since mlb won’t limit the number of RP you can carry. Having a guy who can legitimately play 3 or 4 positions well is even more valuable now than just a couple of years ago. 14 mil x 4 or 5 seems in the ballpark to me.
jb19
I 100% agree. But everytime I’ve posted that on this site, people disagree. Zobrist is the best comp. zobrist is the better hitter but was also 4 years older at the time of his deal. Marwin is better defensively than Zobrist as well… he gets into the QO territory imo. Boras is his agent and if you are looking at a guy that may command $14-$18MM for 4-5 years, then it may be worth the risk for 1 year at $18MM especially if you’re in conetention mode. Like the Astros are.
sufferforsnakes
Indians need to leave Ramirez at 2B and play Yandy Diaz at 3B.
seanm
Anyone else wants David Freese sign with Rangers?
echozulu88
I’m sure that fan base would love that. Fond memories
ASapsFables
The White Sox will probably kick the tires on Manny Machado as a 3B option. I don’t see any of these other FA’s as likely targets to fill their potential need at 3B as they continue their rebuild.
With top prospect Nick Madrigal likely to debut on the South Side sometime in 2020, I can envision Yoan Moncada sliding over to 3B for the 2019 season with Yolmer Sanchez moving back to his best position at 2B and keeping it warm until Madrigal arrives. If Moncada plays well at the hot corner along with some much needed improvement in his bat then he figures to be their future core player at 3B. If not, the White Sox could make a run at FA Nolan Arenado next offseason.
I don’t see the organization with a solid internal option for 3B down in their minor league system. I like Jake Burger’s bat but his future position may have to be at 1B. He was already considered a borderline candidate defensively at 3B when the White Sox selected him with their first pick in the 2017 June Draft. His two subsequent achilles injuries this past year have made the chance of him sticking at the hot corner even less likely.
its_happening
I suggested White Sox should be a dark horse for Machado. They have some young arms and grab a bat or two along with the developing young players and they could improve in that weakened AL Central. Plus Chisox “should” have the money to spend on a 26 year old.
stymeedone
Still, it will be interesting to see if Machado will be willing to wait to contend. He’d fit on the Tigers, too, and they have an opening at SS.
Mark from CT
Tigers. Lol.
ASapsFables
The White Sox will have one of the lowest payrolls in MLB this offseason once they opt out of James Shields contract next month which is a no-brainer. They have Jose Abreu and Avisail Garcia in their final arbitrations seasons, a few more players eligible for arbitration along with Tim Anderson and Nate Jones on cheap contract extensions. Everybody else will be playing for the MLB minimum.
Theoretically, the White Sox could throw max contracts at Manny Machado, Bryce Harper and Clayton Kershaw and still have zero luxury tax worries for the foreseeable future. It would be uncharacteristic for owner Jerry Reinsdorf to do this but he is 82-years old and likely to sell the team sooner rather than later with his son desiring to keep the Bulls. A strong push in FA the next two offseasons, continued improvement of their young core at the MLB level along with the promise of many near-ready elite prospects just could have the White Sox contending as soon as 2020. Reinsdorf could give White Sox fans a hell of a going away present if he opens up his wallet, which also might add some additional value to his franchise before he sells it. Perhaps even more importantly to “The Chairman”, he will have an opportunity to cement his legacy as Chicago’s most successful sports owner with additional championships to the 6 he already possesses as owner of the Bulls and the White Sox.
ncaachampillini
Optimistic are we? Why not trade for Trout and DeGrom while they’re at it.
It would be the shocker of all shockers if one of those two free agents signed on the South Side. They certainly would have money but the Sox are at least 2 years away from thinking about contending so I just don’t see those guys choosing them.
billysbballz
Wow Cubs huh? Are they reading away any of the outfielders they currently have to make room for Harper?
ASapsFables
Nah, boy wonder Theo will be the enact his own version of the sign-and trade. Sign first, trade later. lol
Mark from CT
Why on earth would a premium player like Machado want to play for the second best team in the most boring flyover city in America? Machado and Harper have LA and NYC written all over them. They haven’t waited for free agency just to disappear into US Cellular Field or whatever they’re calling that pile these days.
ASapsFables
I’ve heard Chicago called many things, good and bad. But boring? lol
I’m sure there are some pretty dull flyover towns in IL but Chicago is not one of them. I’d also venture to say that there are few cities in CT or the USA as dynamic as the Windy City be it above or within.
It’s called Guaranteed Rate Field these days which is laughable as a name. The stadium itself is not as bad as advertised and the concessions are among the best in MLB, way better than what they serve at the Wrigley Field. Fortunately for Cub fans they have plenty of great dining and drinking options just outside the ballpark.
As I have already noted in this thread, I believe Bryce Harper winds up on the North Side of your most boring flyover city while Manny Machado chooses his faves in the Bronx. I’m not seeing the Dodgers as a player for Machado with Corey Seeger and Justin Turner locked in at SS and 3B. All of these teams could probably afford either Harper or Machado with some careful manicuring of their payrolls in regards to future luxury tax issues. The White Sox and Phillies, both large market teams, are among the few who would have zero problems signing both. The Phillies might be a year or two ahead of the White Sox in their rebuild process but the team on the South Side of Chicago just might have the better opportunity for long term success with their elite young talent along with residing in MLB’s weakest division as we post. If either team was fortunate to sign both players, it would certainly expedite their window as serious championship contenders.
Mark from CT
Nice reply – and touche on CT! 🙂 Agree that Phila and ChiSox could really get a jump start on rebuilding this offseason, given their very low payrolls!
stubby66
I would really love to see Moustakas back in Milwaukee on a 2 or 3 year deal because I think there would be enough at bats at first, second and third for Shaw plus you aren’t guaranteed of what Aguilar is at first. By then you figured that Erceg and Huira will be ready for majors plus all stats aside he is a proven winner
Lanidrac
Why is everyone so down on Jedd Gyorko? He’s an above-average starter both offensively and defensively and someone the Cardinals should seriously consider keeping as their starting third baseman.
drewster1013
I agree he is an above average player that the cardinals should at the very least keep for a depth utility guy who can give them some pop and good defense off the bench and for spot starts but I think that they will most likely move on from him due to the increasing pressure from the fan base about improving but who knows with mozeliak and his indecisiveness
cygnus2112
Jedd’s valuable but when he gets past 425-50 AB’s, he gets overexposed & starts to break down physically which makes him the perfect infield utility player IMO…
yankeetbv1
Hopefully the Yankees win the offseason, getting either Machado or Harper or both, along with Patrick Corbin.
cygnus2112
I really wish KC with its excess amount of international spending money could match up with Miami and do a package deal that includes said resources, a member (possibly H. Fillmeyer or even J. Junis) of its young pitching core, and possibly a young position player like K. Gutierrez for Brian Anderson who’s a regional product and with his line-drive approach, would play great at the K like other previous third baseman like Joe Randa, Kevin Seitzer, etc…