3:40pm: The Brewers announced that Suter does indeed have a UCL tear. He’s been placed on the 10-day DL for now, and right-hander Jorge Lopez has been recalled from Triple-A Colorado Springs in his place.
3:15pm: Brewers left-hander Brent Suter, who left yesterday’s start after three innings due to a forearm strain, has been diagnosed with a torn ulnar collateral ligament in his left elbow, tweets Ken Rosenthal of The Athletic. He’s likely to require Tommy John surgery.
[Related: Milwaukee Brewers depth chart]
Suter, 28, has been through a tough stretch recently, struggling to a 7.58 ERA over his past four starts (19 innings). Whether his elbow was at the source of those troubles isn’t clear, though the soft-tossing Suter hasn’t experienced much in the way of a noted velocity drop in that time.
Those four outings have ballooned Suter’s ERA from 4.15 to 4.80, but he’s been a largely serviceable piece for Milwaukee for much of the 2018 season. From April 27 through June 21, Suter logged a tidy 3.47 ERA over the life of 57 innings, and he’s posted excellent K/BB numbers all season long (84 strikeouts, 19 walks in 101 1/3 innings). He’ll drop out of a rotation that should see both Freddy Peralta and Junior Guerra return this week, joining Chase Anderson, Jhoulys Chacin and Wade Miley in manager Craig Counsell’s starting five.
If Suter requires Tommy John surgery, he’ll obviously miss the remainder of the 2018 campaign and much of the 2019 season as well. It’s a blow to the Brewers’ pitching staff and to Suter’s future as he looks to solidify himself as a regular big league contributor, though he seems likely to be retained and accrue MLB service time on the 60-day disabled list both this year and next. Suter will finish out the season with one-plus years of MLB service and won’t be eligible for arbitration until after the 2019 season, at which point he’s a lock to be a Super Two player so long as the Brewers keep him on the roster.
Milwaukee has already been linked to upgrades in the rotation and in the infield, and the loss of Suter would only further the possibility of the team adding some rotation depth. That said, it’s also unlikely that a prolonged absence for Suter will spur the Brewers’ front office into action and prompt a significant rotation upgrade.
imindless
Brewers fans be like we should trade for degrom!
sameichel
Add another to the ever increasing list of people to undergo TJ this year
Cat Mando
sameichel…….Still not close to the record. in 2012 there were 46 TJS
mackows2
Team isnt good enough to warrant a move like that
Solaris601
Their play the past 2 weeks has not been what you’d expect to see from a contender. Everybody goes through a bad stretch, but losing Suter is definitely not gonna help.
Snake65
As a Mets fan they make me sick year in and year out. Injuries and bad moves. So seeing Degrom continue to be a #1 starter with no run support makes me say trade him. I want to see this guy get 2-3 runs a game and be a 29 game winner
iverbure
Wins for pitchers don’t matter
jorge78
Even soft tossers tear their elbows. Bummer…..
MrStealYoBase
White Sox trading Shields and Soria for Keon Broxton looking better and better
murphy
LOL shields.
Los Calcetines Rojos
since about May he’s been a very useful back of the rotation starter with some atrocious defense behind him. Should be a cheap option versus more expensive options such as Happ or dare I say Degrom. Coupled with Soria and I’m sure the Brewers would consider it very much
murphy
for a team that want’s to win and doesn’t have a ace on that team shield won’t get them over the hump.
It’s either trying getting the likes of Degrom, Archer ( I know, I know overhyped on here) or wait until the august waivers and pick up someone like shields.
Ry.the.Stunner
Shields has a higher FIP than ERA, so I don’t think you can blame atrocious defense.
yankeemanuno23
LOL Calcetines ? Really Dude Are you from Spain ?
In the Caribbean and Latin Am it’s called “medias” rojas? Ponte las pilas !
dkramer
Why in the world would they do that? Pretty sure they have their sights set on slightly better players than that. Happ would be a perfect fit
Los Calcetines Rojos
far cheaper trade package and coupled with bullpen help is why they would do that. He’s an innings eater and one the brewers will surely need with Suter gone. Obviously nothing is stopping them from getting Happ as well but pitching depth is 100% a major need now
Cat Mando
dkramer……Be careful what you wish for, Happ has been dropping fast. His last 6 starts…..31.1 IP – 26 R – 21 ER – 7 HR – 6.03 ERA – .279/.336/.488 slash against.
Bocephus
When I stated the Yankees shouldn’t get Happ because he’s trending down, a Blue Jays fan actually posted “so your just gonna ignore the previous two seasons”…well duh, yea.
TennVol
Nice jerry picking starts. Here is one: last night 5IP, 1ER, 0W, 9K. Any fans take that out of a starting pitcher every 5 days?
thegreatcerealfamine
First off you’re the one cherry picking with one start and against the Orioles who didn’t have Machado. The return for Happ should be very minimal.
jdgoat
Still, is 6 starts enough to write off the past two seasons plus the first 3 months of this season? An acquisition of J.A isn’t going to cost too much and if he gets going he’d slot into the top 3-4 of the non- Cleveland and Houston rotations.
It is very likely that this is just a rough stretch that he going through, I don’t know why everyone thinks he’s automatically garbage now
jdgoat
Why wouldn’t you want to acquire him? Even with his recent struggles he’d slot into the three spot in the Yankee rotation.
thegreatcerealfamine
No he wouldn’t, that’s Tanaka or CC’s spot guy. No thanks they can trade him to the Brewers.
jdgoat
If he were to go to NYY, I’d rank it Sevy, CC, then Happ. Happ has both a lower ERA and Fip than Tanaka as well as a better track record.
I do think they should go after a guy who will bump down Sabathia though. Happ probably isn’t the best fit but he is easily an upgrade in that rotation.
Steven Chinwood
Oh cause he’s a Blue Jay everyone should just ignore everything and dwell on his past. It doesn’t work that way like Bo and Cat said “trending down” and “dropping fast”. The dumbest thing was teams rewarding these players for what they did in the past and not looking forward.
Cat Mando
Frank Waller…….there is a difference between cheery picking and pointing out a trend/pattern. Even the writers on MLBTR and other outlets have mentioned his sudden downturn.
BTW…the stats I posted included last nights game. If I was cherry picking with a motive I would have ignored that game to make him look worse.
jdgoat
That’s their opinion Steven. That also ignores, i don’t know, I’m gonna say J.A’s 12 other good starts. They are correct he is trending down, just like almost every other player does at some point in the season.
Tim Newport
I would like to see Broxton go to the White Sox..keep him on a big league roster (sort of) and give him more playing time. But let’s make him a gift to the south side…please keep those pitchers where they are. We’re still trying to recover from Matt Albers.
Melchez
As long as Shield’s arm doesn’t fall off, he will be a decent trade candidate. Starters are dropping like flies.
embalmer
Don’t even bother with trying to acquire Harvey.
joepanikatthedisco
Don’t worry, they won’t.
greekfreak34
This should make Stearns more apt into trading for Archer, not Degrom. The price on Degrom is way too high, but after seeing Archer’s start last night, he would fit in just fine at a cheaper cost. Maybe not Hiura, but package maybe Burnes + Broxton and a few midlevel prospects should get it done. We do need more than a SP though, and hopefully they go and get a 2B and/or utility player (merrifield, Dietrich)
Ricky Taylor
Duffy would be sweet
bigjonliljon
Cubs fans smiling.
simschifan
As a Cub fan no I’m not. Never want to see an injury. Plus this only gives them another reason to try to go all in on Degrom or someone else not as good. They need an ace.
ray_derek
Why would cubs fans be smiling?
ray_derek
Why would Cubs fans be smiling about this?
thesheriffisnear
Nope.
Solaris601
Hey, if the Brewers need a SP, Cubs are no doubt listening on Yu Darvish who MIL kinda wanted last winter, right? 😉
TwinsHomer
One of Eduardo Escobar, dozier and or Kyle Gibson will wind up in Milwaukee. Maybe all three in one trade.
bravesandcrewfan
That’d be a blockbuster I wouldn’t mind
A ground ball pitcher would do great in Miller, and that fixes our infield problem
Burnes, Ray, Broxton ish? Idk, just don’t wanna lose Peralta or Hiura.
afsooner02
Twins will get neither for rentals….not ray either.
augold5
Thats a hefty price for 3 rentals. I could see one of Phillips/Broxton, one of Brown/Diplan, one of Stokes/Ward, Wilkerson, Morrison and Orf. This would clear spots on the 40 man as well as give twins some interesting prospects
BrewBucksVikes
That is actually a pretty fair trade idea.
TwinsHomer
Twins don’t need OF. Gibsons controlled through 2019 and has been as solid as it comes this year. Any trade will have to include young pitching, up the middle infield or catching.
augold5
I could see replacing Woodruff with Phillips/Broxton, but there really isn’t any ML ready IF talent in the Brewers system. Dubon maybe, but he’s out with a torn ACL
TwinsHomer
Burnes and Diplan
augold5
Burnes, Peralta, Hiura, Ray, and Arcia are not going to be traded for any rental who’s not an MVP caliber talent (aka Machado).
TwinsHomer
Gibson isn’t a rental. Lol.
CubsForever5
Brewers need to worry about starting to win again or their gonna keep dropping and nxt thing u kno the bucs will be in second(after our win last night the cards fell to 4th behind the buccos)
simschifan
The pirates are hot right now, they are nowhere near being better than the cardinals or the Brewers.
Connor Williams
Despite the bucos inconsistencies for the statement that they are nowhere near as good as the cardninals is an absurd statement to make the bucs are slowly Creeping up in the wild card race and are in 3rd place in the nl central dont be suprised to see the bucs ahead of the Red Birds come seasons end
Danthemilwfan
I like suter, and he’s worthy I guess of a roster spot at times but he’s not that good. Start Burnes and give him a shot before Nelson or Davies comes back
Dtownbrown608
Nelson’s probably not coming back.
twentyforty
Correct. His career is in serious jeopardy.
brewcrew08
Career? Take it easy. He won’t be back this year I think but he will be ready to go next March.
dewssox79
if the brewers want a front line starter and a RP and a back end guy plus inf help they can pull it off. they have the pieces to do so.
scottstots
Brewers should go after Dylan Bundy
fisher40
He goes down so now I hope they give Corbin Burnes an opportunity to start
downsr30
Chris Archer seems like a natural fit for the Brewers. He would get out of that AL East where it’s easy to get torched by the Red Sox and Indians, and in previous years the O’s and Jays had high powered offenses. I remember watching Greinke go back and forth in KC between being “maybe an ace, maybe not,” to when he came to the NL, he excelled into a true ace. I could see the same thing with Archer.
Ricky Taylor
Cleveland isn’t in the East
And Grienkie had a Cy Young in the AL
downsr30
Meant to put Yankees – typo.
And Greinke was good in the AL, but as I mentioned, he went back and forth, he wasn’t nearly as consistent as he was when he flipped to the NL.
downsr30
Career in AL: 3.80 ERA 1.26 WHIP
Career in NL: 3.03 ERA 1.10 WHIP
Ricky Taylor
Pitchers bat in NL
Ricky Taylor
They had Zack in the bull pen at one point now that I think about it
downsr30
Sooo once again, it plays into my point that Archer would probably have more success in the NL. Thank you for the help.
downsr30
And actually as a starter that year, his ERA was 3.80, as a reliever it was 3.59..
Ricky Taylor
The Royals also gutted the Brewers for Zack too
Cain, Odorizie and Jeffers plus Escobar that had to be painful
Almost forgot you got Bettencourt too
ray_derek
I heard they were interested in Archer, but the Rays didn’t have any interest in Brad Miller. Brewers are trying to find pitching without giving anything up.
MilTown8888
No harm in that if they find a team that will give up pitching for nothing.
iverbure
Ray-Derek that joke still isn’t funny, no matter how many times you post it.
brewcrew08
Yes! Best comment yet Iverbure. He’s posted that at least 10 times. Give it up buddy.
kcbbfan
Duffy has been nails his last several starts. Dayton Moore isnt going to “gift” Duffy away but he would be easier for Stearns to obtain than Bundy, Archer, DeGrom etc etc.
Tim Newport
The Brewers patched together a surprising effective rotation with a bunch of low ceiling try hard guys who are starting to break down. Don’t expect to see last year’s Davies back, and a little break for Guerra probably won’t help him any more than it helped Suter. This is not a recipe for an extended playoff run. Let the young guys fill out the rotation. The Brewers window isn’t closing. There are serious holes on this team that have become apparent to anyone paying any attention. Address them, don’t do a mad scramble to patch up this team for a wild card run.
fisher40
Your right… the Brewers need to give their young pitchers a shot and see what they can do. Burnes, Woodruff and even Hader. They gave Peralta a chance and so far he’s succeeding
stubby66
Don’t care what anyone says but he will be missed a lot. He picked up the team when they needed it and was a leader in the clubhouse and rotation. Plus I don’t know if Miley can be counted on for the rest of the year. If anything Woodruff and Corbin are needed to step up for this rotation.
kla0812
Sell the farm….. asdrubal Cabrera, degrom and syndergard. And then sell someone else’s farm and get schop. Lol. They’ll end up trading for a three or four starter and Dozier, and finish a game out of the playoffs.
Dtownbrown608
I as a brewers fan wana cry reading that cuz you might have just foretold our future
MilTown8888
That’s too bad, I was looking forward to seeing how he develops.
I’m surprised that he’ll qualify as a super2 even though he’ll be out for tj surgery. What’s to stop the brewers from sending him back to aaa in the offseason?
ThatBallwasBryzzoed
It’s blow to a below average pitching staff. If it wasnt for Hippie Josh Hader they would be in 4th place. Woth out without Suter they still dont make the playoffs. 3rd place finish at best.
brewcrew08
3rd place finish at best? Who catches the brewers? Cardinals and pirates who are .500 clubs at best? Hader doesn’t make up over 6 wins this year. How about Cain, Yelich, Jesus contributions. Learn baseball before you talk.
ThatBallwasBryzzoed
Brewers are overrated as hell. Cardinals are the sleepers. Doesnt mean they make the playoffs but the brewers wont.
Learn to realize your team isnt as good as talking head say they are.
brewcrew08
So you’re argument is the talking heads who never talk about the Brewers? Who do the cardinals have? No bullpen, no rotation and maybe 3 reliable bats? There’s a reason they are 4th in the central. Learn to follow baseball before you talk lol. Cardinals are sellers. Just sat Matheny.
brewcrew08
Ask*
stymeedone
I could see Fiers and Iglesias being a fit for Milwaukee. It would solidify SS defensively and allow them to move one of the IF over to 2B, improving the offense there. Fiers offers “playoff experience.”
scottstots
Fiers was a Brewer and I actually would love to get him back and we definitely need an upgrade at short. the only question is what’s the price going to be?
Melchez
Iglesias and Fiers wouldn’t cost much either… maybe a top 10 through 20 prospect and a couple young players not on the teams top 30. Besides, Fiers and Iggy can show off their World Series rings as motivation.
Rich Hill’s Elbow
Hey Brew Crew fans, how bout Escobar/Lynn for Gatewood, Feliciano, and Medeiros?
augold5
I could see two of those three with some lower level prospects, but I don’t think the Brewers are interested in Lynn.
stubby66
Hey does anyone know where Sean Nolin is now?
nste23
Rockies organization