The Rockies optioned right-hander Jon Gray to Triple-A Albuquerque today, as noted as MLB.com’s Thomas Harding (Twitter link) and other reporters. Outfielder Raimel Tapia was promoted in the corresponding move.
Though Gray has struggled this season, the demotion still counts as a surprise on a number of levels. Formerly one of the game’s top prospects, Gray posted solid numbers in 2016 and then took another positive step with an even better performance (3.67 ERA, 9.1 K/9, 3.73 K/BB) over 110 1/3 innings in an injury-shortened 2017.
The hope in Colorado was that Gray would further establish himself as the front-of-the-rotation arm that the franchise has long sought after, though instead, Gray ran into some rough waters. Over 92 innings, Gray leads the league in both hits and earned runs allowed, to go along with an ugly 5.77 ERA. He is allowing more hard contact (34.4%) than in either of the past two seasons, while his home run rate is a career-high 15.5%. One can’t blame Coors Field for Gray’s issue, as his home and road ERAs are basically identical.
These numbers notwithstanding, there is a lot more evidence that Gray’s 5.77 ERA is the product of terrible luck. Looking at his ERA predictors (3.07 FIP, 2.77 xFIP, 3.14 SIERA), one would think that Gray was enjoying a breakout season. He owns a 11.6 K/9 and a 4.1 K/BB rate, and while his hard contact percentage is up, the quality of that contact translates to only a .301 xwOBA. His xOBA is .342, however, and Gray has been similarly snake-bitten by a whopping .386 BABIP as well as a low 63.1% strand rate.
The Rockies are hoping Gray will be back sometime in July, as MLB.com’s Jon Paul Morosi tweets that the “team views this as a reset” in the midst of what surely must be a frustrating stretch for the 26-year-old. Antonio Senzatela and Jeff Hoffman are the likeliest Triple-A candidates to fill Gray’s place in the short term, with rookies Sam Howard and Harrison Musgrave also longer shot options.
joshua.barron1
Why though? Dude is a stud
justin-turner overdrive
Dumb teams respect ERA more than FIP.
hiflew
Until they change the way MLB awards victories from who actually scores the most runs to who SHOULD have scored the most runs, I think it is more relevant.
Besides, it is a lot better for him to go down to the minors and get his head together instead of him losing his confidence while being unlucky and just washing out.
hiflew
Another big factor is this could give them an extra year of arbitration. He had 2.062 service time. If he is down for a month or two, they could get to the point of gaining an extra year of service.
Domino427
Well I typed out a long, detailed comment, and it didn’t take.
Here’s the TL;DR version: check out his stats with runners on vs. bases empty. It’s unbelievable the difference.
Something’s wonky there, either with his mechanics or his head.
hiflew
Okay I guess I am wrong and they are going to award playoff appearances championships based on alphabet soup stats rather than who scored the most runs. I just don’t understand why this generation feels the need to overly complicate such a simple game.
iverbure
I dunno why dinosaurs ignore them, used to be some GMs that did and that’s why they’re no longer GMs.
juicemane
The time you have…I’m so jealous
jbigz12
“Dumb teams respect ERA more than FIP.” FIP is great and all but runs on the board are still the ones that count. Stranding runners is a skill and it’s not all luck based. A demotion might do his some good and it could/probably should be a very brief one.
diddlez
Stranding runners is hardly a skill. His 63% strand rate is VERY unlucky.
jdgoat
It also has to deal with your defenders though. A team with crappy D stats are going to positively impact pitchers advanced stats.
diddlez
“A team with crappy D stats are going to positively impact pitchers advanced stats.”
I would absolutely love to hear you explain this one.
jdgoat
Diddlez, I could be wrong, and please correct me if I am, but that’s literally what fip is, isn’t it. I thought FIP is what a pitchers ERA would be if they had a league average defence behind them which they didn’t rely on.
diddlez
FIP completely removed defense from the equation and factors in only strike outs, walks, and home run.s
hiflew
The only problem with that is that the stat works great in a vacuum, but not in reality where ground balls and fly balls actually do exist. And some pitchers know exactly where to pitch you to make you ground out to second base. That skill is just as good as a strikeout. Yes, the second baseman could mishandle the ball, but so could the catcher in a strikeout.
jbigz12
How is stranding runners hardly a skill? Stranding the runners you allow on base has a good deal to do with your ability. Obviously your defense comes into play and can negatively impact that but a guy who gets hit with Runners on: .307/.385/.506 and Bases Empty: .266/.304/.417. You think that’s luck? That’s a guy who struggles pitching with men on base. Now he has a .386 BABIP so has he been a little unfortunate but the difference in his numbers w runners on and no one on tells me there is more to the story.
jdgoat
I’ll say this JTO. I’m a big believer in advanced stats. But Gray has the largest gap between his park adjusted ERA and park adjusted FIP in history. I simply don’t know what to believe here. Writing off his poor performance simply because he has a good fip doesn’t seem smart.
Domino427
I haven’t watched him this year, but the data seems to suggest a combination of bad luck and awful situational pitching.
It could also be an issue with pitching from the stretch. Look at his numbers with men on base vs. bases empty.
Runners on: .307/.385/.506
Bases Empty: .266/.304/.417
That’s a substantial difference.
It’s even worse looking at advanced metrics. K/BB goes from 7.45 to 2.06. FIP goes from 1.91 to 4.67. HR/9 from 0.84 to 1.40.
There’s something wonky there, either in his mechanics or his head.
GoRockies
He has struggled very much and not even just at Coors, he has allowed 3+ runs in 12 of his 17 starts. 5.77 ERA
acarneglia
Wow
RedKing22
He’s really struggled this year and has recently seen a dip in velocity. Maybe they send him down to help him get back on track.
Solaris601
He’s won 7 games and has 119 Ks, but it’s hard to hide that 5.77 ERA. Hopefully he’ll get back on track pitching for the Isotopes in July.
angels fan 3
Wow
bigballerbrand99
I like this. He hasn’t earned a rotation spot. Go make him prove it, rather than just giving it to him. A rare good move by Bridich and Co.
GoRockies
Agreed
justin-turner overdrive
Lowest FIP of his career at an elite 3.07. Rockies are dumb af for this one.
GoRockies
He has already walked more guys, and has giving up more runs then he did last year
diddlez
His BB/9 is a reasonably low 2.8. His ERA is not relevant to how well he has ACTUALLY pitched this season. If you want to make any negative comment then talk about his hard hit contact rate instead of “earned runs”.
GareBear
FOs look at advanced stats but players asks players and they still are very traditional. Trout said Runs Scored is the stat he most bases his success off of. If his ERA is getting in his head than let him reset in the minors for a week or two. I love advance stats but they are not gospel
uvmfiji
That’s ok, I get my analysis from the comments section.
hiflew
So every comment but one has nothing but down ratings here? What is the point of the up/down system anyway? The only thing it does is feed the trolls.
jdgoat
People downvote even the most factual or well thought out ideas if it goes against there team. I wouldn’t even pay attention to them if I were you.
hiflew
That is my point. If no one is going to pay attention to them, why have them there?
iverbure
I really pay attention to them. If I get a lot of downvotes it means I said something true that made people get out of their fantasy world.
walls17
Colorado has one of the worst front offices in baseball
Ironman_4life
Signed , Orioles fan .
iverbure
I think you meant worst ballpark. Fans act like everything is the same when the game is vastly different in Colorado.
dipsanddingers
Good pinch of cope will get him back on track
Ironman_4life
Sometimes all it takes is a different pitching coach to find a flaw that the other missed. Hes good. He will be back soon.
RedRooster
They should trade him to the Padres. Getting out of Coors Field would be best for him. Maybe the Padres could package some of their Rule 5 eligible prospects like Gettys and Olivares for him?
chesteraarthur
How nice of the Padres to make an offer like that…
reneaguerra
“Stranding runners is hardly a skill” I’d like to know how many of you stat geeks have stood on a mound against major competition & sacked up with men on base? Especially the dude that made that comment.
jakec77
I’ve always assumed everyone here at least reached AA, or played in Japan.
reneaguerra
politicsNbaseball
Agreed, that might be the most asinine comment I’ve ever read on here
Arnold Ziffel
Could he be tipping pitches? I think he needs this to get his head together. Most of his starts he is great for most of the time, but 1 inning he gets crushed. He has best stuff on team
lowtalker1
From ace to disgrace
stansfield123
If I was a contending team, I’d put Gray in the rotation right now. Sending someone with those stats down based on small sample ERA is just dumb.
Solaris601
Half a season is a small sample?
stansfield123
Yes.
DockEllisDee
hoping he somehow gets a solid opportunity with a different organization, Colorado is like a black hole for pitchers. Even with a struggling organization I would have to think he’d be in a better situation
grandpaboy
Ian Happ for Gray? Just asking for a friend…
simschifan
No friggin way! We have enough old Colorado pitchers that were a “product” of Colorado air.
hiflew
If the Cubs wanted Gray they should have picked him over Kris Bryant like most mocks suggested. 🙂