The Red Sox entered Sunday with the majors’ best record (24-9) and second-ranked run differential (plus-62), feats that are all the more impressive when you consider they’ve received almost no offensive production from their catchers. Boston’s backstops, Christian Vazquez and Sandy Leon, have combined for a hideous .169/.226/.202 line with no home runs in 134 plate appearances. That amounts to a wRC+ of 15, which falls well short of 29th-place Baltimore’s mark (41).
Given the dreadful starts Vazquez and Leon have gotten off to at the plate, it stands to reason the Red Sox will give the catcher-capable Blake Swihart an opportunity to grab the reins at some point. There aren’t any signs that’s going to happen, however, as Evan Drellich of NBC Sports Boston wrote earlier this week.
Although Swihart was a first-round pick (26th overall) in 2011 and was once among the game’s most heralded catching prospects, he hasn’t been able to establish himself in Boston. The switch-hitter looked to be on his way when he amassed 309 PAs and batted a respectable .274/.319/.392 (93 wRC+) as a rookie in 2015, but he has only come to the plate 106 times since then. Of course, there were obvious causes for Swihart’s lack of MLB time from 2016-17, including nagging ankle problems, major questions about his defense and poor production at Triple-A Pawtucket last season. Meanwhile, at the big league level, Leon enjoyed a breakout year in 2016 to grab hold of the Red Sox’s catching job that season. And while Leon took sizable steps backward last year, Vazquez stepped up, thus earning himself a contract extension prior to the current campaign.
Despite the struggles Vazquez and Leon have endured this year, the Red Sox clearly trust those two more than Swihart, who has transitioned to a utility role. The 26-year-old has barely played in the field, though, and has only caught one inning (in a blowout loss to Texas this past Thursday). Although Swihart has been working on bettering his behind-the-plate skills with Red Sox catching coordinator Chad Epperson and retired catcher Jason Varitek, as Drellich details in his piece, pitching coach Dana LeVangie noted that the best way for him to improve is by actually seeing game action at the position.
“He needs to play through failure, he needs to play through success, he needs to get comfortable,” LeVangie told Drellich. “And the only way to do it is to play. And for him to figure it out behind the plate, the only way to get more comfortable is more reps. He can get better in every facet.”
If Boston’s not going to be the team that gives Swihart a shot at catcher this year, he may wind up on another roster soon, Drellich points out. When on-the-mend second baseman Dustin Pedroia returns from offseason knee surgery in the coming weeks, Swihart’s time with the Red Sox could end, given that he’s out of options. Boston has turned down opportunities to trade Swihart in the past, but it might have to either deal him or expose him to waivers soon. For his part, Swihart’s not asking for a trade.
“I don’t think that you do that,” he told Drellich. “That’s my agent’s job to call and do that, you know? Me personally, the player, this is all I know, is the Red Sox. I know there’s other teams that probably tried to call and there’s stuff moving. But I’m not the type of person that’s just going to walk in and say, ‘Hey, I’m not playing, so get rid of me.’ I mean, I want this team to win, and when I’m here, I want to be able to help contribute any way I can.”
Swihart perhaps has the ability to contribute not only at catcher, but in both the corner infield and outfield. The problem is that the Red Sox are set in all of those areas, with Hanley Ramirez and Mitch Moreland at first, Rafael Devers at third and an enviable group of corner outfielders (Mookie Betts, Andrew Benintendi and J.D. Martinez). The club’s embarrassment of riches at those spots has made it that much more difficult for Swihart to emerge as a factor in the majors – evidenced in part by his meager 25 PAs this year – though it’s possible he’ll soon have a chance to return to his natural position with another franchise.
Drellich names Texas as a possible fit for Swihart, which makes sense considering the Rangers have had interest in him the past. Further, they’ve clearly been in the market for a competent backup to Robinson Chirinos, having added Carlos Perez and Cameron Rupp in recent weeks. The Mets have also come up as speculative suitors for Swihart, thanks largely to starting catcher Travis d’Arnaud’s season-ending elbow injury and the fractured left hand backup Kevin Plawecki suffered a few weeks ago. New York hasn’t found anything resembling a solution behind the plate in those players’ absences, as fill-ins Jose Lobaton and Tomas Nido have combined for a mere eight hits (two for extra bases) in 70 PAs.
Regardless of whether he ultimately hooks on with the Rangers, Mets or someone else, it does appear Swihart’s days with the Red Sox are on the verge of concluding. If so, it would bring an end to what has been a disappointing Boston tenure for a player who once looked as if he could be its first long-term answer at catcher since Varitek retired after the 2011 campaign.
(poll link for app users)
Houston We Have A Solution
I say no.
If the Rays fall in the standings I could see Swihart being included as a buy low piece in a deal for Wilson Ramos given his ability to play multiple positions, which the rays love. He certainly wouldnt be the center piece in a deal for Ramos, who’s on his last year of his contract, but would certainly be an intriguing piece for them to add as a 3rd piece.
joshua.barron1
The Red Sox already have two catchers? Trade their 3rd catcher for another catcher?
Solaris601
I’d make that deal if I was BOS, and then just DFA Leon.
dlevin11
Good call. Ramos instead of Leon would be an improvement offensively and Leon could be traded for a prospect
RedRooster
Is this the same Blake Swihart that was a guaranteed future first ballot Hall of Famer?
PopeMarley
Part of the core-four.
Bald Vinny
No…. you’re thinking of Jorge Mateo, Clint Frazier, Dustin Fowler, Blake Rutherford, Chance Adams, and Kaprielian. All no doubters too valuable for Gerrit Cole and others….
xabial
The Yankees are 14-1 over the last 15 games and the starting rotation’s ERA is 2.01. During this amazing stretch they swept the Twins, swept the Angels, took 3 out of 4 from the world champion Astros and took the series from CLE, with 1 game to be played.
Update: They’re 15-1, Starting rotation ERA is even less than 2.01, after Germans 6 no-hit innings against Cleveland, come from behind victory today, after falling behind 4-0 after 8 Innings.
Worry about your Red Sox.
Bald Vinny
And how’s that bullpen? Seems to be blowing games every night.
Sheev Palpatine
Bald vinny your a yankee fan! How dare you
Bruin1012
Listen Xabial the Yankees are playing great ball right now and just like I said when the Red Sox got off to there incredible start it won’t last. The Yankees have a very good team but they aren’t as good as they have played in there last 15.
The Red Sox don’t need to be worried about the Yankees they don’t need to be worried about any team because they have a very good team. It will be interesting season which should be a battle all the way till the end. So no Xabial as a Red Sox fan not worried at all about the Yankees just looking forward to some great baseball this year.
RedRooster
Not a Yankees fan so try again
Bocephus
Of those players you so absurdly mentioned..Fowler, Rutherford, Kaprielian, and Mateo weren’t in the Yankees organization during the Cole rumors smart guy!
Bald Vinny
Says the guy who can’t finish reading a sentence. “And others”
Bocephus
“and others” you mean the ones you mentioned that were used to acquire Sonny Gray, David Robertson, Todd Frazier, and Tommy Kahnle. If you’re gonna play at least have some correct facts tough guy.
vwnut13
“All no doubters too valuable for … others”
Uh, if they were all traded, then they clearly weren’t too valuable to be traded.
Bald Vinny
Where did Frazier and Adams go, besides down the loo?
vwnut13
Wait a minute, four of those players were traded, and traded well before any Gerrit Cole talk.
Miguel Andujar and Gleyber Torres were two of the main players that Pittsburgh wanted for Gerrit Cole. You could say they are performing quite well for the Yankees.
And let’s not forget, Henry Owens and Blake Swihart were off the table in Cole Hamels trade talks.
Bocephus
Yea why let the facts get in the way.
jdgoat
I’m pretty sure Frazier was a big part of the Cole talks but the Pirates rejected that deal. And the Yanks were right about not budging on Torres
xabial
Torres singlehandedly won today’s game with a 3R HR in bottom of 9th with the game tied at 4-4 —2 HR, 6 RBI the last 2 days.
xabial
last 3* days.
pasha2k
Wait till he’s been through the league before he’s ready for the HOF.
Gomez Toth
It was actually Vazquez who, on WEEI radio the day before his first game with Boston, was declared to be nothing less than The Best Catcher In The History Of Baseball. The praise I heard that day was so grossly over-the-top I couldn’t help but be reminded of the good ol’ days, when John Harrington controlled one the Globe’s “greatest” sportswriters via the regular application of free, and massive, doses of liquor.
natesp4
You guys gotta chill. He was a very good catching prospect who if he reached his ceiling would be an above average catcher for many years. Literally no reputable source ever said he was guaranteed to be even an all star.
bobtillman
His bust is right next to Rob Refsnyder’s………
vwnut13
What’s funny is that Refsnyder has a higher wRC+ than Swihart, Vazquez, and Leon added together.
User 4245925809
Old Ref has made the rounds via the waiver wire hasn’t he? Can’t field a lick. he’ll end up in Indy ball before long.
Leon and vazquez have ALWAYS been glove 1st guys which most want 1st as a catcher who call a great game and steal strikes, which both are tremendous at.
Steven Chinwood
Johns here all week folks, enjoy the show..
Oh and try the veal…
CowboysoldierFTW
Prospects fail all the time. That’s why I never label anyway a future anything.
jdgoat
On a team that’s destined to contend for a World Series, I don’t think there’s anyway you can carry him on your roster. They’ll be guys added at the trade deadline and they’re going to need to make room for them somehow
Caseys.Partner
Send Swihart to Texas. He can be Cole Hamels personal catcher.
stubby66
I wouldn’t mind the Brewers making a trade for him like Maybe Perez, Wilkerson and Olzcack for Swihart
muskie73
Blake Swihart’s bat does not play well enough for any position other than catcher and the switch-hitter probably lacks the defensive skills to be a starting catcher.
Catchers Devin Mesoraco, Travis d’Arnaud, Mike Zunino and Austin Hedges all had similar prospect rankings with varying degrees of success at the MLB level. We may have seen the best of Blake Swihart.
You are wrong
It doesn’t? You sure about that?
muskie73
ZiPS, Steamer and FanGraphs Depth Charts project Blake Swihart with wRC+ of 60, 70 and 65:
fangraphs.com/statss.aspx?playerid=13176&posi…
pepesilvia
Pretty simple trade him to the Mets for Matt Harley and Jose lobaton
pasha2k
That’s all the Redsox need is another cry baby.
just my opinion
As far as swihart trade at all goes I can’t see them trade for anyone without options or prospects…isn’t that the point of the possible need to trade when Pedroia and holt return ?
If it’s because he has no options and there would be no roster spot I can’t see any trade other than prospects really?idk
soxski
I am dumb founded that after 30 games Cora has not sat Leon and tried Swihart behind the plate. I was also disappointed that they resigned MM. I thought Sox had enough to back up Hanley with Blake Holt Nunez and Sam Travis. Plus Sandy had one hot spurt that lasted 30 games. Outside those 30 games he has been deplorable at the plate. I truly believe Blake would push Vaz on offense. Blake will hit 280-300 w 10-15 homeruns and XBH a plenty. Currently 8 9 in JBJ and catchers are both becoming close to automatic outs. Please dont jump and say Keon hit a HR on Sunday. It’s his 5th orv6th hit if the season. By June 1 of JBJ and Catchers have no production you have to consider letting JDM, Holt or Blake pick up the reps to provide more offense. I know everyone will call for JDM in left MM at 1B and Hanley to DH. MM is a 220 hitter. He is better suited playing vs pitchers he can hit. Someone like Servino makes Mitch an automatic out. He cant get around. There is close to 20 games left for JBJ Vaz and Sandy to get closer to 250 avg. Should they fail it will be a poor choice no matter how good defensively they are to keep them playing wo being able to contribute at the plate. I also feel pitching Pomerantz on Tuesday is a mistake. He has been awful and he will get exposed Tuesday Boston will need to hit Servino and score 8 runs if Drew pitches.
just my opinion
I actually like mm but I definitely agree as far as Leon goes I’m a Vazquez fan and think he needs a backup to spell him and like u say push him sandy does not do that much anything else