Rather than exercise a player opt-out clause in his previous contract, Justin Upton chose to avoid free agency by agreeing to a new five-year, $106MM contract to stay with the Angels. Upton’s enjoyment of his time in Anaheim certainly played a role in his decision to remain, though as he told reporters (including the Orange County Register’s Jeff Fletcher), he was also wary of a long wait on the open market. “I kind of got a little taste of it two years ago when I was a free agent,” Upton said. “I kind of understood the way the trend was going. At the end of the day, if you can avoid it, avoid it, because things are definitely changing.” Upton tested free agency in the 2015-16 offseason and had to wait until mid-January to land a deal, though he did eventually land a very healthy six-year, $132.75MM commitment from the Tigers. Upton’s presence would’ve certainly created a big ripple effect in this winter’s free agent class, though it’s also possible to think that he would’ve been one of the many other top names still looking for new teams as Spring Training camps open.
Some more Halos news…
- Angels owner Arte Moreno met with the media (including MLB.com’s Maria Guardado) at the opening of his team’s spring camp to discuss several topics, including Mike Trout’s future in an Angels uniform. Moreno said that there isn’t any particular rush to discuss another extension with Trout, though the idea is “always in our minds. We’re always thinking about it. It’s not only him, because we have other players. But if you look at long-term plans, you’re always trying to position yourself properly when it’s time to do it.” Trout’s previous extension (a six-year, $144.5MM deal) runs through the 2020 season and has to already be considered a major bargain, given Trout’s superstar-level play and the fact that he would’ve been a free agent this offseason had he not agreed to that deal.
- With a projected luxury tax payroll of roughly $175MM and an Opening Day payroll of around $187MM in actual dollars, Moreno said his team has some flexibility to add players during the season if necessary. The Angels have consistently spent big money under Moreno’s ownership, and while the results haven’t always matched the expenditures, Moreno said that he would “get out” of owning the team altogether rather than pursue a bare-bones rebuild in the style of the Astros or Cubs.
- Albert Pujols’ last two offseasons were hampered by foot surgeries, so the slugger was happy to simply enjoy a normal winter and focus solely on training rather than rehabbing, he told Guardado and other reporters. Pujols said he explored new training facilities and a regiment focused on agility and flexibility drills, which led to a weight loss of close to 15 pounds. After suffering through easily the worst of his 17 MLB seasons, Pujols is hoping his better health leads to a big rebound year, particularly since the Angels are hoping for him to get more action at first base in order to free up DH at-bats for Shohei Ohtani.
reflect
At the time, I thought Upton’s decision was quite surprising. In hindsight though it was clearly the right one, if not a brilliant move.
AndThisGameBelongsToMySanDiegoPadres
Not really. If there was even a halfway decent chance of Upton having to settle for less in free agency, the Angels wouldn’t have offered to bump his pay. They would have just told him “Go ahead, opt out.
madmanTX
Well, Arte would have said that…right after burning Upton to the media.
gstarrett
Yeah but I don’t think anyone thought the free agent market would turn out this way. Great move from upton’s point of view
AndThisGameBelongsToMySanDiegoPadres
Then the Angels grossly misread the market
ryanw-2
Nope. They cashed in as quickly as they could before having to wait it out longer than usual and then going with another make-shift option in LF. Smart move.
AndThisGameBelongsToMySanDiegoPadres
Not smart if they could have gotten him for cheaper
greatdaysport
For both sides
angelsfan4life
I remember people saying how dumb Upton was for taking the extension. He would have gotten so much money on the open market. Well he definitely did the right decision.
Cat Mando
From the MLBTR link in the above article, here is a trip down memory lane…
“He would have made more money in free agency. It’s how the free market works. Even if he wanted to stay in Anaheim, this contract he ended up getting was the worst case scenario money-wise for him.”
“I wasn’t wrong. Free agency IS the more prudent route. Name one thing Upton would have lost by waiting out free agency. Just ONE.”
“Still not wrong. Upton blew it with this move.”
angelsfan4life
Ask CarGo who turned down an extension with the Rockies. Ask Mike Moustakas. Or Jake Arrieta. Or JD Martinez. Greg Holland who opted out of the second year of his contract. All without contracts.
AndThisGameBelongsToMySanDiegoPadres
Cargo and Arrieta are horrible comparisons. They regressed afterwards. Upton was already basically a free agent so he wouldn’t have had the chance to regress afterwards.
AndThisGameBelongsToMySanDiegoPadres
Still not wrong. Angels wouldn’t have offered him less in free agency when there is pressure from other teams trying to sign him.
You still can’t name ONE thing Upton would have lost by waiting out free agency.
Munsonmanor4
How about piece of mind? The Angels are the 5th. team he has played for. Maybe he liked it there and didn’t want to go anywhere else. The man is also married and has a child. Maybe he didn’t want to have to uproot them yet again. There are so many factors as to why this was the right move for HIM money be d@mned. I’m guilty as well of thinking of these players as robots and they should just bounce around where I think they should go. If money was the only factor, why doesn’t everyone just sign with the Astros, Rangers, Rays, & Marlins? After all, FL and TX doesn’t have state taxes so they get to keep more of their salary.
AndThisGameBelongsToMySanDiegoPadres
He could have still signed there in free agency, mmmkay genius? And he would have gotten more money from the Angels with 29 other teams bidding on him. They aren’t going to be bringing their best to the table if no one else is allowed to negotiate with him.
AndThisGameBelongsToMySanDiegoPadres
That’s not true. If he wouldn’t have gotten that much money in free agency why did the Angels offer him that extension in the first place?
angelsfan4life
The Angels haven’t had a every day left fielder since GA. His last season with the Angels was 2008. Upton did have an opt out, adding a year, ensures that he wouldn’t opt out.
AndThisGameBelongsToMySanDiegoPadres
And they grossly misread the market if the other comments on this article are any indication. If the market for sluggers is really that weak the Angels should have called his bluff.
CobiEven
Are you arguing both sides?
thecoffinnail
TheWestCoastRyan, Yes, they should have.. Any other team would have.. You are trying to simplify things like you always do.. In most things in life there is an X-Factor involved that isn’t always mentioned.. When it comes to the Angels that X-Factor is Arte Moreno. Upton was the player he wanted and when he sets his sights on a certain player he usually signs him.. He has shown year after year that he will not be outspent for the player he views as the missing piece. Another X-Factor you are leaving out is Upton’s agent. If he was represented by Scott Boras instead of Larry Reynolds the chances of him hitting the open market are a lot higher. You should try to stop being so steadfast and stubborn in your baseball analysis.. Also, try to remember that players are people too and there are always reasons that are entirely their own and private that are weighed when deciding on whether to sign a contract or not..
AndThisGameBelongsToMySanDiegoPadres
No I’m not. I’m dismissing the claims of people who think that this deal made sense.
AndThisGameBelongsToMySanDiegoPadres
Well first off, congratz on not being condescending like you usually are. If the Angels could have gotten him cheaper this was not a good move for them.
ryanw-2
They said it was dumb because they’re dumb. The Angels finally got their left fielder locked up for 5 years instead of having to wait it out into ST and risk another band-aid in LF. And Upton stayed where he was comfortable and happy. It was a great move for both sides.
xabial
This. Angels get LF locked in for the foreseeable future, and Upton cashes in after a career high .901 OPS with 35 home runs and 109 RBI in 152 games this season between Detriot and Anaheim.
xabial
My personal favorite perk, Upton got, is upgrading that 20 team partial No trade clause to full NTC lol.
Also backloads contract, to help team build around Trout, and tacks one more year at $17.5 million, to existing four year $88.5 million contract, he was opting out of. This is win-win deal all around, and takes Upton through his ages’ 30-34 seasons.
timyanks
last season
xabial
I stand corrected, but isn’t it 2017-18 MLB offseason? 😉
HalosHeavenJJ
Upton had an offer of over $100 million and the chance to finally stay in one spot. Plus he gets to train near his off season home.
That’s a great offer. He took it. Good for him
dynamite drop in monty
I need a refill
lowtalker1
People think they are worth more
Owners are getting more wise
Not paying for what you did but what you’ll do
FriendOfBoras
Upton could have gotten waaaay more if he went the free agent route. Terrible decision on his part, one he will definitely regret when he’s broke in 10 years.
ryanw-2
Because you know Upton personally and what’s best for him and what makes him happy. Shed some light.
realgone2
Ignore this fool. He’s just a troll and for some reason the jerk off is still allowed to post here.
matthew102402
Cron to rays.
jmgreenia24
A rather prescient decision made by Upton.
AndThisGameBelongsToMySanDiegoPadres
It was either a bad decision by Upton or by the Angels
wrigleywannabe
or good by both
AndThisGameBelongsToMySanDiegoPadres
Nope. If Upton could have milked the Angels for more money it was bad by him. If Upton would have struggled in this year’s market it was bad by the Angels.
ryanw-2
Neither. Angels got what they needed and Upton stays where he’s happy. End of story.
AndThisGameBelongsToMySanDiegoPadres
Upton could have stayed where he’s happy for more money. NOW end of stofy.
madmanTX
“Badly”. You left it out–the Angels have consistently spent money badly under Moreno. Look at Wilson, Pujols and Hamilton. Pujols is a shell of his former self and Moreno ate Hamilton’s deal. Moreno turned on Wilson and showed his true self. Then what happened with Dipoto. All that payroll is gonna buy the Angels 3rd place..,maybe.
xSpecBx
I was thinking something similar when I saw how much money they have on the books. Seems like an awful lot spent for not much in terms of results. Even more surprising when you think how they have Ohtani for basically nothing and trout (while still a hefty AAV) still on a below market deal.
halos and quacks
Trout is making 34 mil this year. Highest in mlb
thegreatcerealfamine
Yea the Angels gave the extension to an unreliable player in Upton,signed a who knows in Ohtani,and signed a SS to play third who’s injury prone big time. Not to mention their walking wounded pitching staff. Don’t give them third just yet cause I believe the A’s will finish ahead of them…
Ichiro51
“Get more action out of him” He’s 38 with foot injuries. Not gonna happen. I’d rather have his bat than his glove at this point.
soxski
I’m surprised agility and flexibility are new concepts 2 MLB Players when I played high school and D2 college baseball I always spent the first 90 days with high calorie, high Wright lifting along with an hour of Pilates followed by jumping drills and parachute srings. From December through March I used a HTVV low weight high reps moving from excersise to excessive to mimic cardio with gliding movement machines, …. I thought did we of 3 yoga routines andandIlates for core and flexibility my first 90 days I bulked up to gain strength I weighed 230 by December 1 By the time the season started I weighed 210 and ripped. By the end of the season I weighed 190-195. Now I am 48 and do nothing but Pilates and CVT training. I am 175