It has been a month since we broke out the top 60 remaining offseason trade candidates in baseball. Since that time, several of the players from that list have indeed been dealt, while situations have also changed for some others. With a few weeks left for transactions to proceed before Spring Training opens, we’ll take a quick look at how the trade market appears to have changed.
Starting Pitchers
Market Changes: The Astros nabbed Gerrit Cole from the Pirates, taking one of the most obvious and best trade candidates off the market and filling an opening with a contender. That said, multiple organizations are still in play for one or more starters. The possibility of achieving greater value via trade is, perhaps, one of the many reasons that the top starters have yet to reach deals.
Top Remaining Trade Candidates
- Chris Archer & Jake Odorizzi, Rays: Tampa Bay has moved one significant veteran (see below), suggesting the team is as open as ever to swapping out older/more expensive players for younger ones, though there’s hardly an indication that a full-scale rebuild is underway.
- Michael Fulmer, Tigers: He has come up here and there in rumors, though there’s still no reason to believe Detroit is willing to move its best asset for anything less than a haul.
- Danny Duffy, Ian Kennedy & Jason Hammel, Royals: Similarly, we’ve heard of teams asking about Duffy, but Kansas City has evidently not embarked upon a concerted effort to trade him. The other two players would be salary dumps, though the Royals could just keep them and hope for improvements while also being assured of filling up some innings.
- Zack Greinke & Patrick Corbin, Diamondbacks: Moving Greinke’s contract would be a challenge, but still-simmering chatter on Arizona’s interest in J.D. Martinez suggests it is still plausible. Meanwhile, we’ve heard Corbin come up as another player who could be moved to open payroll space.
- Dan Straily, Marlins: Dealing the righty would hurt for a pitching-needy team, but it has to be on the table.
- Danny Salazar, Indians: We keep seeing Salazar’s name arise and Cleveland is said to be willing to deal him, but the team likely won’t do so unless that facilitates the filling of another need.
- Julio Teheran & Brandon McCarthy, Braves: There’s still no indication that Teheran is being discussed, but he feels like a plausible chip in the right circumstances. It also seems possible that McCarthy could be passed along, though odds are he (and also just-acquired starter Scott Kazmir) will be viewed as necessary veteran depth entering camp.
Relievers
Market Changes: Three top lefties have departed the potential trade market, none via trade: Zach Britton suffered a serious injury, while Brad Hand and Felipe Rivero have signed extensions that almost certainly indicate they won’t be dealt this winter. There just aren’t any comparable hurlers to be had, so those developments seem to favor the remaining southpaw free agents. Veteran relievers Joakim Soria and Luis Avilan were also traded recently.
Top Remaining Trade Candidates
- Alex Colome, Rays: Colome still seems the likeliest of the game’s top young closers to be dealt. Nothing has come together to this point, but he has appeared frequently in the rumor pages.
- Kelvin Herrera, Royals: The asking price is said to be high; perhaps the Royals would be willing to take the risk of carrying Herrera to the trade deadline if offers aren’t sufficient.
- Brad Ziegler, Junichi Tazawa & Kyle Barraclough, Marlins: While the Fish have created some breathing space in the payroll, moving some of the money owed to Ziegler and Tazawa would surely still hold appeal. It’s likely that Barraclough will be held, but nothing’s bolted down in Miami.
- Shane Greene & Alex Wilson, Tigers: We haven’t heard much chatter surrounding this duo, but the Tigers must listen to any offers on any players.
- Arodys Vizcaino, Braves: Likewise, it has been crickets on Viz all winter, but it’s still imaginable a team would take a look if other possibilities don’t work out.
- Dellin Betances, Yankees: Entering the winter, it was at least reasonable to wonder whether New York would decide to move on after a tough 2017 season for Betances. We haven’t heard much indication of that, though it’s still possible that he changes hands, particularly with the Yanks counting pennies.
- Raisel Iglesias, Reds: The odds are starkly against a deal with Cincinnati reportedly asking for the moon, but it’s possible to imagine interested clubs circling back if other things don’t work out.
Outfielders
Market Changes: Yesterday’s Andrew McCutchen deal was significant for this sector of the market, as it filled a void in San Francisco and took a name out of contention for other teams. But there’s still a need up the middle for the Giants, while other teams have not yet addressed their own needs.
Top Remaining Trade Candidates
- Christian Yelich, Marlins: While the asking price is understandably steep, the Marlins are no doubt aware that it may be a good time to cash in on Yelich, who has indicated he’d prefer to be moved.
- Billy Hamilton & Adam Duvall, Reds: At one point, Hamilton seemed all but gone. That’s no longer the case, but it’s still imaginable that either of these players is shipped out.
- Randal Grichuk, Cardinals: Even with Stephen Piscotty traded, the Cards have an overloaded outfield mix.
- Avisail Garcia, White Sox: Signals are that the asking price is too steep for a deal to come together, but Chicago’s front office is surely still picking up the phone on Garcia.
- Domingo Santana & Keon Broxton, Brewers: With the Brew Crew still looking to add a starter, nothing can be ruled out. Of the team’s many intriguing outfielders, Santana and Broxton stand out as possible trade pieces in certain scenarios, and each has been floated in rumors thus far.
- Aaron Altherr, Nick Williams & Odubel Herrera, Phillies: Now that the Phillies have pushed Rhys Hoskins into the outfield, there are two openings left and three arguably deserving candidates to fill them. Any of the trio could conceivably be moved in a deal to acquire a starter. Of course, this mix of players could also coexist on the roster, with the Phils sharing time and playing matchups while seeing how each develops.
- Corey Dickerson, Rays: His name has at least been floated as a possible trade chip, though we’ve heard no rumblings of talks.
- Kyle Schwarber, Cubs: There’s just no indication that a Schwarber deal is likely to occur this winter.
- Jackie Bradley Jr., Red Sox: Despite some early rumblings, all recent signs point to JBJ staying put in Boston.
- Jacoby Ellsbury, Yankees: The Yanks would love to find a taker for some of Ellsbury’s salary; unsurprisingly, that hasn’t been easy to pull off.
- Shin-Soo Choo, Rangers: Ditto.
- Yasmany Tomas, Diamondbacks: And ditto again.
Infielders
Market Changes: Two notable players have changed hands, with Evan Longoria going to the Giants and Yangervis Solarte joining the Blue Jays. Those swaps seemingly take the acquiring teams out of the market for other infielders.
Top Remaining Trade Candidates
- J.T. Realmuto, Marlins: With the valuable Realmuto expressing his displeasure with the situation in Miami, it’s easy to imagine a swap, even if we still haven’t seen public indication that talks have advanced.
- Josh Harrison, Pirates: We’ve seen Harrison’s name in the rumor mill a fair bit, but there’s still no clear word as to whether he’ll be moved. Trading Cole and Cutch certainly could be interpreted as making a Harrison swap more likely, but that isn’t necessarily the case. The club likely values the flexibility of the two option years in the infielder’s contract. Another Bucs veteran who might conceivably be dangled is backstop Francisco Cervelli, as a commenter points out.
- Manny Machado, Orioles: It has been a bit of a roller coaster all offseason on Machado, with some reports still suggesting the O’s would like to get a deal done and others indicating that the team will stand by a lofty asking price.
- Jed Lowrie, Athletics: The market for Lowrie has been quiet, but teams in need of an option at second could still check down to him.
- Nicholas Castellanos & Jose Iglesias, Tigers: Neither player seems particularly likely to be targeted as a contender’s first choice, but both could hold appeal in the right situation. Detroit is prepared to move any veteran if it can achieve interesting young talent.
- Scooter Gennett, Reds: We haven’t heard much discussion of a Gennett deal, perhaps because Cincinnati values him after a strong season but perhaps also because other teams are wary of his track record and inability to hit lefties.
- Cesar Hernandez & Cameron Rupp, Phillies: There just isn’t much reason for the Phillies to rush into a deal involving Hernandez, particularly after freeing some infield playing time for younger players by trading shortstop Freddy Galvis. Though Rupp seems to be lining up for a timeshare behind the dish, he could still be parted with to clear the way for a new backstop duo in Philly.
- Jose Abreu, White Sox: As with Garcia, the ask seems high and not designed to ensure a deal is completed.
- Starlin Castro, Marlins: Though Miami no doubt likes the idea of marketing the four-time All-Star to a skeptical fan base, it surely also sees the appeal of shedding a chunk of his salary, which was absorbed in the Giancarlo Stanton swap. Castro has given indication he’d like to be traded.
- Chase Headley, Padres: With Solarte shipped out, the Pads may line up this old favorite at the hot corner. But he’d surely also be available if another team comes calling.
- Jurickson Profar, Rangers: While his name hasn’t arisen much, it still seems reasonable to think Texas is willing to make a deal on the former top prospect.
- Yasmani Grandal, Dodgers: With little chatter emerging about Grandal, perhaps the Dodgers simply feel they are best served carrying two quality catchers into the 2018 season — which, really, is hard to argue with.
- C.J. Cron & Luis Valbuena, Angels: Both these players can coexist on the roster, at least if you squint. But with Albert Pujols expected to command time at first while sharing the DH slot with Shohei Ohtani, and an infield otherwise loaded with everyday types, Cron and Valbuena aren’t the most comfortable fit.
- Jason Kipnis, Indians: After a near-deal to the Mets fell apart, leaving the Indians unable to free up cash to land Santana, Cleveland seemingly settled on moving Kipnis back to his accustomed second base.
- Brad Miller, Rays: Having moved Longoria, the Tampa Bay infield has more openings. On the other hand, that also indicates all bets are off for trade candidates, and the Rays may prefer to move on from Miller if they find a decent deal and feel they can better reallocate his anticipated salary.
- Martin Prado, Marlins: Miami could just hang on to the veteran and hope he rebuilds his trade value a bit, or it could cut its losses if another team is willing to take on at least some of the obligations remaining.
- Javier Baez, Addison Russell & Ian Happ, Cubs: Increasingly, it feels like this group of players will stay put. On the other hand, all it takes is one phone call and the Cubs are still looking for a starter.
partyatnapolis
can’t believe we still have a top 60 on january 16th lol
jacobsigel1025
It’s trade candidates not free agents but yeah this offseason is just about the slowest ever
Sean Steib
The free agent list isn’t much different. The biggest names are still out there and the movement been slow. Eric Hosmer had a 7yr deals offered over a week ago and that talk went dry it seemed.
VABlitz
If he had a deal for 7 years, he should have taken it. Let me guess his agent is Scott Boras. I wonder what the stickler was…did they want an eight year, no trade, or more money?
bobbleheadguru
Anything with a pulse is on the table for the Tigers.
They could not even afford $5MM for 1 year for Granderson, which would have at least generated some goodwill.
Absurd that my 1/2 season ticket prices did not even go down by $1/ticket. I canceled after 12 years of buying tickets.
Disco Dave
7 year ichiro would have been a better/cheaper vet for the tiges imo… I thought about grandy man but couldn’t get it to make sense at that price. I had full season in the tiger den for a decade and am not considering any commitment until they get real on the pricing.
H.E. Pennypacker
It’s not that they couldn’t afford Granderson, it’s that they don’t have a need for him. Mahtook / Martin / Castellanos / Reyes make up the OF on the MLB club and they have youngsters in Gerber, Jacoby Jones, Hill, and Cameron to call up in a pinch. Granderson would have been a waste of money and wouldn’t have brought u much back in a July trade.
trace
Obviously time for more expansion teams.
Sean Steib
Why, this list of players who have teams, but move with the right asking price.
luclusciano
To just put more teams into this slooooooow offseason? Why is it obvious? Honestly asking
dugdog83
Sarcasm people
joew
Really don’t think Harrison is available. I think he was in talks with the Yankees with Cole primarily in trying to get Torres and/or Andujar which clearly wasn’t an option. but i guess it boils down to what ever is offered.
greg91305
The Pirates are foolish if they don’t move JHay now. If this is a rebuild “FO says it’s not” then you’ve gotta move all expensive pieces that can get prospects in a trade.
KermitJagger
He might be the piece that nets the best return yet given his contract and position flexibility. He is also probably the most expendable of the three (w/ Cole & Cutch) that is the most expendable given that 3B looks to be set w/ Freese, and Moran, Frazier and eventually Kramer at 2B and Mercer/Newman at ss w/ SRod playing the JHay role of super sub (albeit not as well as JHay).
I don’t know what JHay returns but catching and (better) starting pitching prospects are clear needs.
Pingleja
Agreed. The time is now to get another SP prospect with a target of around late 2019/ start of 2020.. If they can get a guy in that range and another lottery ticket, you take it. Harrison is valuable for a few years, I think they risk it and move him at the deadline to a team that doesn’t know they’re contenders yet or someone filling an injury hole and get a better value. 2B and SS are unneeded on most of those teams right now.
ThatBallwasBryzzoed
Lol javy Baez is like Bryant and. Rizzo untouchable. He shouldn’t moved for less than 3 players. At least 2 of them ML player ready.
Priggs89
Thanks. I needed a good laugh this morning.
One Fan
Then you better keep looking Priggs. Nothing to laugh at yet
kbarr888
A lot of people will laugh at that comment about Baez…..but the truth of the matter is…….
The Cubs seriously value his versatility in the field and the potential that remains in his Bat. He could play anywhere but pitcher or catcher ( and it wouldn’t surprise me if he could suit up at the latter). Sure he still swings at too many balls outside the strike zone, but his defensive prowess is obviously Elite.
wrigleywannabe
Wrong. He is not an outfielder and his work at 3rd is atrocious.
He still boots too many routine plays and to say his swing needs work is the understatement of the year.
They have enough versatility without him. He’s been discussed in trade talks and not for blockbuster deals.
brucewayne
Then the Cubs
brucewayne
and their fans are the only ones who value Baez that much. He’s almost as over rated as Heyward!
jdgoat
Baez is not untouchable
wrigleywannabe
that’s why they discussed him with teams, right?
themed
Untouchable huh? This is another example of cubs and cub fans overrating players. They are not near as good as you think. Keep holding on to them though.
wrigleywannabe
in his defense, ever team has fans who do that
TJECK109
I’d have to think the Pirates will also make Cervelli available.
Jeff Todd
Probably should have included him, yeah. I added mention under Harrison’s blurb.
sandman12
According to the objective formula of Baseball Reference, Darvish, Cobb, Archer. and Straily all project for around the same performance for 2018. Given Straily’s younger age and very cheap control, I’d think Miami would be flooded with offers.
timyanks
why do you list some of those 60 and say they aren’t going to be traded? they aren’t trade candidates.
Jeff Todd
Most of the guys on this list won’t be traded, so it’s all a matter of degree. The ones who are listed and noted as lower-likelihood are notable in some other respect, either b/c their team would really like to shed their salary or b/c they are big targets for other teams. Sometimes, low-likelihood deals come together, and everyone named is at least a plausible trade piece in my view.
marinersblue96
Corbin is an interesting name listed. Relatively small salary at $7.5 million. Dipoto should be pretty familiar with him. Sounds like someone he would be interested in as he seems to dislike FA signings.
bravesfan
Both braves starting pitcher need to go, cubs have some nice pieces that would look good in a braves uniform. Maybe even for 3B. Not saying Tehran is a good one for one swap… but maybe throw a decent prospect in the mix and braves could get Baez ?
Mjm117
Baez is untouchable like Rizzo and Bryant. Silly Bravesfan.
Braveslifer
Braves looking for short term help at 3B and Josh Harrison fits that description, plus he’s a versatile player. Maybe a good match…
Padres Armchair GM
What would the phillies want for odubel herrera? Hes signed to a team friendly contract and fits the padres rebuild nicely as he isnt a FA till 2024 assuming his club options are exercised.
Hed pair nicely defensively with margot.
Pingleja
SP help is their main goal. Padres really don’t have much of that. Don’t think they give up Lamet for him
bleacherbum
Much rather have Altherr as a Padre fan, would cost a lot less in terms of prospects and I believe he still has slot of untapped potential, he was starting to break out a few years ago before getting hurt. Wouldn’t mind seeing him get a shot in LF if the whole Hosmer signing/Myers move to LF doesn’t happen.
I think it’s a moot point though however because if the Padres wanted either outfielder (Herrera/Altherr) they probably would have done a package with Galvis and one of those two especially given the fact that they gave up their #12 prospect in Del Los Santos to get Galvis.
Adding one of the outfielders would have made that trade more expensive in terms of prospects for SD but you got to figure it will be more expensive doing seperate deals with PHI.
seaver41
What is Houston going to do with Derek Fisher?
dudeness88
platoon in LF. he should get plenty of time this season.
Ejoey
Bang for the buck in relievers, Shane Greene is somebody that should be looked at.
muskie73
Perhaps Jacoby Ellsbury would waive his no-trade clause for a trade to Arizona, where he reportedly lives in the offseason:
Three years of outfielder Jacoby Ellsbury at $68.5 million
$11.25 million in cash
for
Three years of misfielder Yasmany Tomas at $46 million
The Diamondbacks get a modest upgrade in left field at a net annual cost of about $3.75 million. For luxury tax purposes the Yankees would save about $6 million annually, dropping from Ellsbury’s AAV of nearly $22 million to Tomas’ AAV of about $11.4 million. Because of luxury tax implications Tomas’ lower AAV is worth more to the Yankees than to the Diamondbacks.
Steamer600, which assumes 600 plate appearances for each hitter, projects 2018 WAR of a negative 0.1 for the 27-year-old Tomas and 0.8 for the 34-year-old Ellsbury. ZiPS projects Ellsbury with a 2018 WAR of 1.3 in 473 plate appearances.
The Diamondbacks can’t afford Tomas’ glove in the field but the lefty-masher could find a home in the American League as a designated hitter. Tomas, who has three options remaining, has played third base and in the outfield.
michaelw
No body wants over paid old Ellsbury even with that little cash added. What part dont you Yank fans get? Get over it your stuck with him.
muskie73
LOL at the suggestion that I’m a Yankees fan.
Under the proposal, the Yankees would be stuck with Yasmany Tomas, whom Steamer projects with a negative WAR despite a contract that will pay Tomas $46 million over the next three years (on top of the Yanks sending the Diamondbacks $11.25 million in the deal)..
slider32
Ellsbury and prospects trade would work for Greinke. Kennedy fro Ellsbury would work also.
stymeedone
@slider
It better be for some good prospects, because Grienke has value, and Ellsbury does not. Dont see the Yankees wanting to take on that contract, regardless.
brucewayne
I thought that was the best trade scenerio I’ve heard so far for Ellsbury. But it’s still gonna be hard to get rid of him.
thickiedon
I’ve been wondering about an Ellsbury/Greinke deal also. Greinke fits what Yanks have been yearning for this offseason.
Padres Armchair GM
Very interesting idea to swap tomas for ellabury. I like it.
Both arent worth their contract and arizona upgrades while yankees save 11 mill.
They wont get much better offers than this.
If anything the yankees want to clear his contract entirely which would have to include prospects just for arizona to take on that salary.
stymeedone
Arizona is also at its budget limit. Not going to happen.
daveineg
Yet another reference by Mr. Todd about Scooter Gennett’s inability to hit lefties despite the fact that he still managed somehow managed to hit 27 HR, drive in 97 runs and post a slash line of .295/.342/.531 despite having more than 20% of his plate appearances against LHP.
Gennett over the last two seasons has hit .254 vs. LHP (52 for 205).. Is Scooter a better hitter vs. RHP? Absolutely, not unlike or say 95% of LH hitters. But is he “unplayable” vs. LHP. as Todd believes? Ah no. Scooter got a bad rap for not getting hits in miniscule samples against LHP as a young player.. As a result, he almost never started games against lefties and the few times he faced them it was lefty specialists who were in the big leagues because of their ability to get LH hitters out. Brewers finally allowed him to get more AB’s against them in 2016 and the Reds did the same in 2017. He proved he’s far from an automatic out.
Phillies2017
Phillies better not trade Odubel
Garza Nathan
Send Realmuto to the Astros for Derek Fisher , Francis martes and Cional Perez.
Then flip for the Reliever from the reds Iglasies. Astros go for repeat
wrigleywannabe
that won’t get Iglasies
bravesfan
I’m not sure that would get iglasies either, nor do I think the astros should flip realmuto. Nor do I think that offer for reality would get realmuto… lol
Padres Armchair GM
Realmuto would start with kyle tucker and go from there.
If the astros are unwilling to include kyle tucker or forrest whitley it would cost
Bukaukas, Derek Fischer, Martes or Paulino or Perez, and JD Davis.
3 years for a top 5 catcher isnt cheap and will cost you, more than you’re offering.
If the astros find that too steep they can look elsewhere for catcher help.
Zach725
Would be very surprised if the braves trade Viz. Have had bullpen issues and Viz is one of the best options out of the pen.
bravesfan
Yea I think you’re right. It’s more of a he would bring back a decent return thing more than anything. I don’t think the braves trade him. They have the freedom to set the price tag high, and during the off-season no team is gonna meet that price tag. Understandable from both sides
mike156
I’m intrigued by the idea that more teams would rather give up talent than dollars–that is to say trade away prospects for players under team control rather than sign FA’s.
HarveyD82
take jhey and cervelli.
GarryHarris
There’s no reason to build and stock a bomb shelter. I started watching the Tigers in the early 1970s and witnessed all the local stars like Al Kaline, Norm Cash, Earl Wilson, Jim Northrup, etc. eventually fade. Eventually, just as today, the Tigers had to rebuild. At that time, the losing never seemed to end. Except for Dick McAuliff (Ben Oglivie) and Mickey Lolich (Rusty Staub), that generation brought very little in return when leaving the organization. The Tigers built up a system in 4 years that sustained them for 15. The Tigers are still in the tear down stage and they seem to be doing it with an eye on the future.
AndThisGameBelongsToMySanDiegoPadres
Wait a second. How do the Hand and Rivero extensions mean they won’t get traded? Idk if Huntington operates that way but Preller will trade Hand right now if the price is right.
stymeedone
He didnt get what he wanted before, and now that Hand is signed, he’s going to cost even more. So a trade would appear to be less likely.
AndThisGameBelongsToMySanDiegoPadres
Perhaps, but he certainly isn’t off the market.
Solaris601
I think a win-win trade here would be if CLE dealt Danny Salazar to MIA for Kyle Barraclough straight up.
FOmeOLS
Houston:
What about Peacock and McHugh?
The Astros have a fantastic rotation now, and don’t need either one, which is a great problem to have.
They should be very desirable trade chips, and Houston should be happy to move them.