The Brewers announced that they’ve designated catcher Andrew Susac for assignment today in order to clear a spot on the roster for righty Matt Albers, whose previously reported two-year deal with the team is now official.
Susac, 27, was once one of baseball’s very best overall prospects, ranking in the Top 100 on multiple lists prior to the 2015 campaign and frequently appearing on the Giants’ organizational rankings. He went to Milwaukee in a 2016 swap that sent lefty Will Smith to San Francisco, though, and has struggled in both organizations over the past couple of seasons.
In 274 MLB plate appearances, Susac has batted just .232/.299/.396 with an alarming 82 strikeouts against 23 walks. He’s been more effective in his Triple-A career, hitting at a .247/.338/.425 clip, and strikeouts haven’t been nearly as much of an issue for him there. Durability, on the other hand, has been a major factor for the former second-rounder (Giants, 2011); Susac has appeared in more than 100 games just twice in a season, and he’s totaled just 142 games over the past two seasons combined. In his young career, Susac has already dealt with wrist, trapezius, finger and shoulder injuries on separate occasions.
With Manny Pina, Stephen Vogt and Jett Bandy all on the 40-man roster, the Brewers seemingly feel set on catching depth. It’s possible that Susac clears waivers and remains in the organization, though he does have a minor league option remaining, so he could hold appeal to another organization that is thin at the position.
Solaris601
Giants will bring him back on a minors deal. You can take that to the bank.
The Oregonian
I’d actually like that. Depth at a position we need more of, unlike Blanco.
noramiles458
just as Micheal responded I am amazed that any body able to get paid $4334 in 4 weeks on the internet
follow this link….
………………………………. bit.do/ussdmake-hare45
Kenleyfornia74
Of course they will
bleacherbum
Yup, just like Blanco and Hector Sanchez. This is the offseason for returning to your former team. Chase Headley goes back to SD, Jay Bruce goes back to NYM, Lorenzo Cain back to MIL, Tyson Ross and Chris Young back to SD, Giants have top waiver priority, bet your bank account that they claim him.
Marytown1
Yo back to the Crew too
johnmillerjones
This trend will continue with Darvish going to the Rangers, Alex Avila to the Tigers, Logan Morrison to the Marlins, Eduardo Nunez to the Yankees, and Jake Arrieta to the O’s (lol jk)
Kenleyfornia74
You forgot the best player to return home Matt Kemp. Best player in their original stint with the club that is
bleacherbum
Yeah I totally spoofed, and Brandon Moss back to the A’s. A lot of homecomings this offseason.
bleacherbum
@solaris601 he was designated for assignment and the Giants have first waiver priority since he was designated by an NL club. So they can’t get him on a minors deal, they would have to give him a 40 man spot. Only way the could have signed him to a minors deal is if he was released by MIL. If the Giants don’t claim him I could see the Padres snagging him to be Hedges back up. All they have is a bunch of non-roster invitee’s behind him on the depth chart.
lowtalker1
They got two on the 40 man behind hedges
Torres isn’t ready to back up and the other dude meh
AndThisGameBelongsToMySanDiegoPadres
Yes. I’m sure he wants to be trapped behind Buster Posey again
mikeyst13
Trapped? He couldn’t even make it out form behind Manny Pina, Jett Bandy, and eventually Steven Vogt last year. I think he’d be happy just making an Opening Day roster somewhere no matter who he was “trapped” behind.
agentx
“I’m gonna take you to the bank, Senator Trent…”
Bocephus
Doubt it he’s 27
jchiaratti
They can’t just bring him back on a minor league deal… it doesn’t work like that… they can claim him and option him back to AAA, but they can’t just “bring him back on a minors deal”
srechter
Yankees? He seems like an obvious upgrade over Austin Romine.
mikeyst13
Not sure his career .232/.299/..326 line for a guy thought of to be an offensive first catcher is an obvious upgrade over anyone, but if there is 1 Romine may be it.
srechter
Exactly. Sad but true.
Deke
But hasn’t he spent most of his time as a backup catcher? That slash line isn’t all that terrible for someone who maybe starts every 5th start. From memory when he was playing regularly with SF he wasn’t all that bad. After/If he clears waivers I think he’d make a good depth piece for SF.
mikeyst13
His most regular playing time came in 2015 when he slashed .218/.297/.368 while only throwing out 17% of runners. 2014 with some decent playing time every 3-4 days late in the season he did slash .273/.326/.466, so there is still some promise, but his swing and miss rate has always been super high.
Bocephus
Yea sure he is
mrnatewalter
Remember when Giants fans freaked out for giving him and Bickford up for Smith? Good times.
pustule bosey
I still don’t like that they gave up bickford – but I guess this year we will hopefully see smith do something and I’ll feel better about it
jlittle15
Braves
ralph 3
Barves are more than fine at catcher.
bjtheduck
Is it still too soon to say both teams lost that trade?
BusterMove
Yes because Smith can contribute this year.
mikeyst13
And Bickford still has some upside if he can avoid suspension
bigcubsfan
The Cubs are looking for backup catchers. I could see a Cubs-Brewers trade. Something like Susac as the centerpiece plus Yelich, some pitchers and the Cubs give them Jason Heyward. Fair trade?
AndThisGameBelongsToMySanDiegoPadres
BAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!
Tommy Ciaccio
oof…
Kenleyfornia74
You tried so hard to sneak that in
bigcubsfan
Theo Epstein calls me: “You’re hired as our new assistant GM”
pustule bosey
maybe if they threw in baez and bryant and I don’t know lester maybe?
AndThisGameBelongsToMySanDiegoPadres
Is he out of options? He definitely burned option years in 2016 and 2017 but idk about 2015.
pdxbrewcrew
Right in the article it says he has one option remaining.
AndThisGameBelongsToMySanDiegoPadres
They put that in after I posted my comment
Matt Pilatzke
Padres (over Rocky Gale) seem like the most logical choice but the Giants do have a tendency to value guys they are familiar with which is why then to extend their players more than most teams.
bleacherbum
Agree 100%. I would be highly surprised if he is playing for someone other than San Francisco due to familiarity or San Diego due to lack of depth behind Hedges.
GenoSeligPrieb
Even if the Brewers get an ace or a #2 SP, the fact that no one in management appears to be in on a REAL catcher, is gonna bite them in the beehind, probably at the worst possible time. Pina? Vogt? Bandy? Who are we? The Padres?
mikeyst13
Last season as a platoon the Brewers Catchers ended up #14 in Avg, 15 in HR, 13 in hits and #5 in 2B. Pina hit .279 and the stretch that he was out of the lineup hurt those overall stats or they could have been higher. Vogt only hit .254 after coming over, but slugged .508. Who exactly is available for them that is going to put up numbers better than that? I agree an upgrade would be nice, but they can’t just pluck one out of nowhere. Not a lot of “real” catchers available out there outside of Realmuto, and that’s not happening.
redsfan48
Reds should claim him (with the intent of optioning him to AAA if Mesoraco is healthy), and DFA Stuart Turner.
Solaris601
Mesoraco and healthy rarely appear in the same sentence. Reds better load up on the minor league signees sooner than later.
stretch123
Marlins should pick him up and trade Realmuto. Cash in when the value is high…
greg91305
Pittsburgh Pirates would be wise to pick him up.