Although outgoing Royal Eric Hosmer is a clear bet to take home the largest contract among first basemen this winter, Travis Sawchik of Fangraphs suspects that career Indians first baseman Carlos Santana will outperform Hosmer for at least the next three years. While Hosmer is younger than Santana and had a better 2017 season by fWAR, Sawchik notes that Santana’s primary skill (his batting eye) is a better bet to age well than any other skill that either player brings to the table. Hosmer has also posted negative fWAR totals in two of his major league seasons; something Santana has never done. Worth mentioning: Santana was worth a total of 21.2 fWAR from 2011-2017, while Hosmer was worth a mere 9.9.
Elsewhere across baseball’s central divisions…
- The offseason for Cardinals’ shortstop Paul DeJong will be an interesting one. As CBS2’s Steve Overmyer reported from New York on Thursday, DeJong has joined renowned scientist Dr. Lawrence Rocks in a lab study about the effects of heat and weather on baseball flight distance. Early returns in the study seem to indicate that while baseballs are likely to travel shorter distances as temperatures get colder, they are also likely to travel shorter distances if temperatures increase past a certain point. “As you decrease temperature, you get less bounce, like an automobile tire on a very cold day – it’s a little more brittle,” Rocks said. “As you increase temperature, the elastomeres get a little mooshy; you get less bounce.”
- While Cubs GM Jed Hoyer has declined to comment on his team’s pursuit of Shohei Ohtani, Patrick Mooney of NBC Sports Chicago suggests a plan of attack for the team in trying to acquire the Japanese ace. While bringing an end to “The Curse” is no longer a selling point (as it may have been to Jon Lester and some others, according to Mooney), Chicago still has plenty to offer as a city. Hoyer will be working hard to put together a more attractive pitch to Ohtani and his agents than the other 29 MLB teams that will be vying for the two-way star’s services.
the_sooch
There’s no “h” in Otani.
fstop13
It has been spelled both ways. It is due to the translation of his name
Sheep8
Why can’t people worry about the content and comment on that instead of nitpick people over small errors? Good correction fstop13
EndinStealth
It’s bc kids use the internet also.
bastros88
because they get paid to write this, it’s unprofessional to see mistakes
joemoes
Well it gets spelled both ways and mlbtraderumors addressed this they will spell it ‘Ohtani’
Sky14
And it’s free for you to read it so quit whinging. Beside the fact they explained in an earlier post that they will spell it Ohtani going forward.
“We have now confirmed, however, that the spelling “Ohtani” is the formal spelling likely to be utilized in his potential transition to the majors.”
travisjanik
You spelled whining wrong. There is no silent g, it’s not like lasagna.
PixelMelonz
But there’s no unprofessional mistake here……
Senioreditor
His uniform in Japan spells it with an “h”.
thegreatcerealfamine
But there’s a “T” in Tool…
xfactr
Heh Heh Heh!
aknott1
Actually in a post yesterday… *Astute readers will note that MLBTR has now adopted a new spelling. Previously, for a variety of reasons, we utilized the anglicization “Otani.” We have now confirmed, however, that the spelling “Ohtani” is the formal spelling likely to be utilized in his potential transition to the majors.
AZPat
It’s true. MLB has a unwritten rule that you can only have a maximum of 2 h’s in your full name. Think about it, can you name one major leaguer with more?
jackt
Rhys Hoskins
dwhitt3
Lol that’s 2
ABCD
Phil Hughes.
AZPat
Very nice. You’re the only one that came up with at least 3. I was hoping someone would get Hugh High.
Polymath
Hubert H. Humphrey threw out a first pitch.
Hannibal8us
Joel Hanrahan
dwhitt3
Only 2
dynamite drop in monty
Hal Newhouser
wintwins11
Some of you people have fallen victim to counting
AZPat
Pose a theory, however idiotic, to stat conscious folks and they’ll move mountains to find the answer. I knew I could rely on my MBLTR brethren.
stevebaratta
Toby Harrah. Spell it backwards if you like.
ABCD
Hugh High.
AZPat
You did get it. Nice job, your son would be proud of you.
brucewayne
That’s so not true at all!
AZPat
And your not really Batman. You think I’m makin’ this stuff up
pt57
Heath Hembree
AZPat
Nice. For that you get to graduate to pt58.
JKB 2
There is an H in Otani its Ohtani as explained on this site yesterday
brucewayne
The correct spelling has an H
AZPat
Actually its 오타니, but who’s got time for that.
dwhitt3
Lol
AR
Make the Cubs great again.
simschifan
Have they stopped?
themed
They were never great. 1 in a 100. Now back to nothingville.
gray
Agreed.
ncaachampillini
Yeah 3 straight NLCS’s sure is nothing. Gonna be at least 6 straight before this team starts declining.
chitown311
All Cubs starting pitchers had career years in 16(besides Arrietas 1.77 Non steroid ERA). Starting pitching is what they don’t have and why they will overpay for it, and why they will never win in the foreseeable future because of bad contracts. Give Theo I handy if you want, but don’t forget why he was able to walk into in Boston, and especially don’t forget how he left that franchise when he walked away from it.
simschifan
Again 3 straight nlcs appearances one World Series basically the same team. Tell me again how they are not great.
simschifan
And again another nitwit who thinks Arrieta was on steroids. Do you not understand how much testing they do now? Go watch your boring ass White Sox idiot.
Chris4Sale74
Thank you! About time someone else see this other than me. He is a good GM, but give me Cashman or Friedman any day of the week
jdgoat
Since when is 3 straight CS appearances with a World Series championship not great?
jdgoat
Chitown311 is a troll who takes pit shots at the Cubs in every post.
xfactr
Disgruntled White Sox fan.
whosyourmomma
Wow, awfully confident. Especially considering they need to trade more assets or spend heavy in next couple seasons to fill gaps.
whosyourmomma
Name calling aside, if you honestly think Arrieta did not get on PEDs you’re either need your eyes checked or brain examined (possibly both). He was one of more obvious ones in recent years. Oh but tell me more about his Pilates and veggie shakes, etc.
whosyourmomma
Name 5 “superstars” who have been suspended while “in their prime” the past 10 years. They get guys like A rod and Manny on their way out. Big Papi had one of his greatest years as like a 40 year old, seriously!?!?
Mlb got Dee Gordon last year which is just ridiculous. It’s ll about money & fans want to see the stars (if you don’t realize or accept that you’re foolish). Mlb PED policy is one of the biggest jokes in sports!
Logjammer D"Baggagecling
Arrieta was never on PEDs or steroids. Where the hell do you come up with that? That’s ridiculous. That’s like saying Barry Bonds is the home run king. Everyone knows Hank Aaron is still the true home run king.
themed
Try winning and competing for over 20 years. Year after year with 2 or 3 world Championships and a couple runner ups. Now that is greatness. Not tanking on purpose just to get top draft picks. That’s not great at all.
JKB 2
Hi Chitown311. Cubs have three straight NLCS appearances a pennant and world series championship the past 3 seasons.
No go cry to your mommy and deal with it
ABCD
Vaey good. All the Cardinal Wayers harumphed in agreement.
simschifan
Are you a doctor who collects the pee specimens? You have no proof anyone is on steroids. Even myself hating the Doyers defended a Doyer fan saying power hitting center fielder Chris Taylor isn’t on steroids. Just appreciate someone actually has talent.
AZPat
I think it’s a bit early to decide on the greatness of these Cubs. However, for Cubs fans the 2016 team will be one for eternity.
sufferforsnakes
I really hope the Tribe re-signs Santana. But if they don’t, an infield of Ramirez at 3B, Lindor at SS, Kipnis at 2B, and Diaz at 1B would work for me.
Polish Hammer
Yeah that .679 OPS plays so well at 1B…SMH
Michael Birks
I hope the Red Sox try and sign Santana instead of spending all that money on Stanton
leprechaun
Cubs, Rangers or Dodgers it’s that simple guys.
thegreatcerealfamine
Go Note Dame!!!
Chris4Sale74
A Notre Dame AND a Yankees fan? You have excellent taste indeed!
thegreatcerealfamine
Who can’t get the Notre Dame correlation?
calikid13
DeJong is a character. I love the guy
bradthebluefish
Red Sox should go for a 1B/DH committee between Hanley Ramirez and Carlos Santana.
slider32
I think Ohtani goes to the Yanks, they have a rotrating DH spot waiting for him and right field is perfect for his swing. They are also looking for a front line pitcher, and this team is young and on the verge of greatness. He would also make a lot of money in indorsements.
NuckBobFutting
It’s not about money for him, it’s where he feels comfortable and can be a two way player
simschifan
It’s not about the money, but he’s right he’s going to the Yankees
bubba 66
Take your “h” and shove it
I ain’t reading here no more ……….
bubba 66
He’ll be a so so pitcher or average hitter in MLB
jrwhite21
Oh back so soon?
tim815
Which is a great deal against the cap for league minimum.
justin-turner overdrive
Carlos Santana, age 32 in 2018: 23.0 fWAR in 1116 games
Eric Hosmer, age 28 in 2018: 9.9 fWAR in 1048 games
Hosmer is the most overrated player in baseball by far. Santana might be the most underrated. Whoever gives Hosmer $100M will regret it, he’s a 5/80 guy at most. Santana actually deserves 5/100.
stevebaratta
I can’t believe any MLB club would let him be a 2 way player. If he’s an expensive ace pitcher, would you want to risk him to injury as a position player?
Polish Hammer
DH
tim815
He’s not an expensive pitcher.
He will be making league minimum. The same as some reliever your team calls up from Triple-A.
And, no. I don’t count the posting bonus in my figuring.
Mikel Grady
I trust this site. I’ll order my cubs jersey wirh Otani on back
simschifan
Isn’t happening, at least I really hope not.
brucewayne
This site actually said its being spelled with an H . So….
jpoe1535
Sabermetrics got these guys confused. No one would rather have Santana over Hosmer… because Hosmer is better. Offense, defense and on the bases. Essentially Santana is only good for his 90 walks every year. The rest is a toss up
ABCD
But those extra 40 walks per year are worth well over a win.
ohiocat5908
Santana is better defensively and has a more consistent bat year to year. There is more certainty with what Santana will give you. Hosmer could very easily throw up his fourth 0 or – war year again next year.