The Red Sox moved on from manager John Farrell following the team’s exit in the American League Division Series, putting Boston in the hunt for a new skipper for the first time since 2012. The decision wasn’t entirely unexpected — many reports had suggested that Farrell could be on the hot seat if the team endured a second consecutive exit in the Division Series, and Farrell was put in place by former general manager Ben Cherington as opposed to current president of baseball operations Dave Dombrowski.
Dombrowski will now have the opportunity to make his own hire and install a manager of his choosing in the dugout. And although Boston’s managerial post was vacated more recently than the Tigers, Mets or Phillies, it’s seemed as if the Sox are choosing from a more limited field of candidates than the other clubs seeking a new skipper. Reports have indicated that Astros bench coach Alex Cora, Diamondbacks bench coach Ron Gardenhire and recently dismissed Tigers manager Brad Ausmus are the the three likeliest candidates to replace Farrell. Dombrowski did tell reporters yesterday that he’s still deciding whether to interview others, but each of the three apparently leading candidates has reportedly had an interview.
[Related: The Red Sox’ Managerial Search]
Ausmus, of course, is no stranger to Dombrowski after managing the Tigers for four seasons. Dombrowski hired Ausmus while serving as general manager of the Tigers and worked with him until August of 2015 when Dombrowski was dismissed from his post and replaced by longtime assistant GM Al Avila. Ausmus doesn’t have the managerial experience that Gardenhire has, but he’s managed a team more recently and is likely more in tune with analytical data. MLB Network’s Peter Gammons reported that Ausmus also thoroughly impressed the Sox when he interviewed there in 2012 and would’ve been their skipper had they not been able to pry Farrell away from the Blue Jays. He’s also been tied to the Mets’ post.
Gardenhire managed the Twins for 13 seasons, giving Dombrowski an up-close look as arguably his Tigers’ top division rival. Though he’s viewed more as an “old school” baseball mind, Gardenhire is renowned for his ability to connect with players and maintain a clubhouse. He managed the Twins to a winning record over his 13 years at the helm and won the American League Central in six of his first nine seasons. Charley Walters of the St. Paul Pioneer Press has called him one of the “final three” for the job (via Twitter). Gardenhire is also reportedly a candidate for the Tigers.
Cora, meanwhile, has never managed at the big league level but has managed in winter ball and is Houston skipper A.J. Hinch’s right-hand man. He’s probably the most analytically inclined candidate of the bunch and has been touted as a future big league manager for years now. He’s been popular already, drawing interest from both the Mets and the Tigers in their respective searches for a manager. Evan Drellich of CSN New England has written that Cora is the favorite, and Ken Rosenthal of The Athletic has also suggested as much (on Twitter).
All that said, let’s open this up for debate (link to poll for MLBTR mobile app users)…
Joe Siegler 2
I voted for other. Name? Gabe Kapler.
Michael Birks
He would be great to have on the coaching staff for sure
Gret1wg
Joke!
Ken Kiely
Other… an even more intriguing option.
Wally Backman. They would love him in Boston.
mrnatewalter
It should be Cora, but something tells me Dombrowski is going to stick with history and hire Ausmus.
Michael Birks
I think you’re onto something
GaryWarriorsRedSoxx
It’s going to be Gardenhire.
He already said he wants experience. And he knows if he hires Ausmus he’ll get run out of town. Gardenhire is the clear choice… bet the farm on it.
thegreatcerealfamine
Shouldn’t he be ran out of town anyway…
RedSoxClover
It isn’t Gardenhire . Sounds like he’s going to the Tigers .
GaryWarriorsRedSoxx
Well either the Tigers grabbed Gardenhire first before the Red Sox could or it looks like the Sox settled on Cora, which totally contradicts what Dick Dastardly said in interviews. Smh.
GaryWarriorsRedSoxx
So the Tigers grabbed Gardenhire before the Red Sox could, or more likely it looks like the Sox settled on Cora. Totally contradicts what Dave D said in interviews.
bradthebluefish
You can want experience but not force the issue. If the best candidate doesn’t have managerial experience, you can’t pass it up.
WFG1
If he does hire Ausmus to re-create all the lack of success they had in the huge Midwest baseball market of Detroit then both will be run out of Boston in less than 3 years
Solaris601
Agree. I don’t see why Ausmus is considered to be at the head of the class of candidates for teams with vacancies immediately following his unsuccessful, underachieving run with Detroit. Apparently failure is an option.
Tahoe725
Yea bc what happened in Detroit was all Ausmus’ fault…SMH
redsox 1976
If they don’t said by monday before the world séries begin that mean is Cora!! If Houston is elimenated from playoffs Monday is the day we now who the manager is!!
mafiaso316
Other,,,, Gabe Kapler
Gret1wg
The Author of “Sunning your Boys”, wake up
Joewielo
Dave Martinez
bigjonliljon
Good call
GaryWarriorsRedSoxx
He’s not even getting an interview. LOL.
Michael Birks
How about Cora as manager, and they over pay Gardy As bench coach?
Brixton
I do believe you can only hire away coaches from other teams if theyre under contract if you give them a promotion
ellisburks
If the other team allowes it, it can be a latteral move. Sox are letting all their coaches explore other opportunities.
Brixton
Mets – Kevin Long
Red Sox – Ausmus
Phillies – Callaway
Tigers – Alex Cora
thickage
Curious why you think Cora, the highly touted candidate for division winner Boston, would pick basement dwellar Detroit?
Brixton
if he gets hired by the Sox, then cool, good for him. But just because hes a candidate doesn’t mean he can choose which one hires him. Ausmus has the DD connection, and has been just as rumored. As for Cora, he just needs a way in at this point. Hes a good baseball mind who is new school, something that the Tigers could attempt to use as they get younger
cwsOverhaul
Ozzie Guillen is a solid manager, though too vocal for some owners’ tastes.
ellisburks
He was a bad manager. used guys with OBP under 300 at the top of the order. Bunted in bad situations. He had good teams which made him look better.
cwsOverhaul
In case of leadoff, not really. Podsednik and DeAza were above throughout his tenure. Juan Pierre had poor 2011 as table setter. Rosters were ok, but not great. Wire to wire in 2005 and winning organization’s only World Series in last 100 years a feather in cap. Spanish a plus. Not saying he is a great, but worth teams interviewing.
Rbase
Other: Hensley Meulens.
He seems like a good guy to be around the current core and with an experienced bench coach he could be a good manager (although that is never a 100% certainty).
titurriria
Bob Geren or Tim Wallach
Caseys Partner
Pete Mackanin.
He’s great with young players like Mookie Betts, Xander Bogaerts, Andrew Benintendi and Rafael Devers. Pete also speaks Spanish.
Dumbest managerial firing in the history of MLB.
Brixton
yes, because his work with spanish players like Maikel Franco, Joely Rodriguez, Odubel Herrera, Yacksel Rios, and Jesen Therrien turned out great, right?
JDaddy
Bobby V deserves another chance
Tahoe725
Cora is a huge risk never having managed. Managing in WBC and winter ball is no comparison. Ausmus deserves another chance outside of the Detroit mess that was given to him. He also pushed for analytics his whole time there but they wouldn’t listen until now. Cora doesn’t have me convinced. If I were him, I would use the training wheels at Mets where pressure not quite as high and losing isn’t a shock. If does well, then he can go from there. Again it’s the giving a Ferrari to a 16 yo comparison
rocky7
Not a Mets fan, but how can you possibly say that managing in New York would be a low pressure job.
You obviously live outside the NY area. NY teams are always expected to win.
The commentators and writers, and their are scores of them, are relentless with their second guessing and questions.
Cora may indeed not be the right choice, but whoever managers the Mets or any New York team has to deal with more press than anywhere in the country.
LeylandsLung
“Ausmus deserves another chance outside of the Detroit mess that was given to him.”
What are you talking about? Ausmus was handed a Division Champion team that was capable of winning it all. He was lost and the proof was that they kept Gene Lamont around to teach him. He was a terrible hire by DD.
Tahoe725
Poll is not very reliable when you can vote as many times as you have time for
hawkny11
Lets not forget that Tito Francona had a losing record in Philadelphia as manager of the Phillies for three years before coming to Boston.
Tahoe725
Sorry but my statistician brain has to let you know this poll is flawed. Total votes for each person actual fluctuates down which shouldn’t happen. It should go up or stay the same. Suspect poll
sddew
I love Cora and have followed his path, but I don’t think he’s a fit for the Red Sox current team and the Boston media as a first-time manager. I think Cora would be more of a fit for a team in the rebuilding stage where he can teach the younger players and they can all grow together. Hence the reason why I voted for Ausmus as the choice, although I think highly of Gardenhire as well.
mcmillankmm
My choice would be Gardenhire, he coaches for 4-5 years then they hire Varitek
rmullig2
How about they get Remy’s kid out of jail and make him the manager. I’m sure he could enforce clubhouse discipline and the players would think twice before attacking the media.
pepesilvia
What about David Ortiz? Let him pinch hit or DH when needed as well. So sure could have used his bat this year.
vinscully16
Why do people consider Jason Varitek a reasonable option as manager? He played for the Sox and wore that ridiculous “C” on his jersey – so what? Dombrowski again hiring Ausmus just doesn’t sit right with me, expand your horizons DD and hire Ronald Clyde Gardenhire.
kiddhoff
I vote Tim McCarver. Im tired of listening to his ‘expert’ analysis. Let’s put that knowledge to use.
robb2103
David Ross!
dlevin111
Kevin Cash!
anarchoburrito
I think the fact that Cora has a WS ring with the Sox is going to factor in more than folks are betting on. He’s experienced the Boston cultural and media landscape at the height of its insanity (a pennant race) and has strong connections to members of the front office past and present because he played with them, not to mention Pedroia. Plus the guy spent a good chunk of his playing career watching Francona work and pulls a lot from his playbook, something else that would pull sway in Boston.
redsox 1976
Cora will be the choice!! Change is good!! See Lovullo in Arizona and Robert in L.A
neo
Red Sox need someone with fresh perspective, outside the baseball establishment. Someone like Donald Trump Jr. maybe? Or James Fallon would also have fresh ideas. Time to break the curse of the Big Papi. Is Kevin Millar available for bench coach?
Gwynning's Anal Lover
Chip Hale!
jeremy 13
how about Jason Varitek as manager and then have Big Papi as hitting coach
jeremy 13
Tony LaRussa
neo
Jose Canseco! And Wade Boggs as hitting coach, Roger Clemens as pitching coach and Pedro Martinez as bench coach.
The Genius
Drake Larouche clubhouse leader ready to take the next step
Pops
Buck Showalter’s bench coach, John Russell.
redsoxrob9418
47 years I’ve been a Sox fan, painful to watch the team get destroyed by an idiot like dumbo….. he is heading down the Same road he did before the tigers fired him and ownership is letting him, go figure