This is the latest edition in MLBTR’s Three Needs series. Click to read versions on the Tigers, Reds, Pirates, Giants and Mets.
The Braves were among baseball’s absolute worst teams in each of the previous two seasons, finishing near the bottom of the majors in both wins and run differential. While they’re still below average in those categories (22nd in winning percentage, 19th in run differential), there has been progress this season. At 67-80, the Braves should surpass the 70-victory mark for the first time since 2014. That would obviously be a baby step, but moving forward with a healthy Freddie Freeman and the game’s No. 1-ranked farm system give the Braves legitimate reasons for hope heading into 2018. A productive offseason from general manager John Coppolella probably wouldn’t transform Atlanta into a playoff contender overnight, though pushing toward the .500 mark next year wouldn’t be an unreasonable goal. Here’s how Coppolella could make that happen…
1.) Acquire a front-line starter:
This is certainly a lot easier said than done, but the Braves’ actions indicate that they’re motivated to add a top-caliber starter. They’ve attempted to trade for Chris Sale, Chris Archer, Sonny Gray, Jose Quintana and Michael Fulmer, to name some high-profile hurlers, dating back to last season. Sale, Gray and Quintana have since switched teams, taking them off the table for Atlanta, but Coppolella could still try for Archer and Fulmer, among others.
Fulmer, the Braves’ primary target at this year’s non-waiver trade deadline, seems more likely than Archer to end up on the move in the offseason. The Tigers are at the very beginning of what should be a long rebuild, after all, so it would behoove them to listen to offers Fulmer. Considering how strong their pipeline is, the Braves may be in better position than anyone else to land Fulmer, who will enter his age-25 season and final pre-arbitration campaign in 2018.
There are a couple potential free agents to keep an eye on, too, with two-way superstar Shohei Otani reportedly set to emigrate from Japan and fellow countryman Masahiro Tanaka a possibility to opt out of his contract with the Yankees. As a 23-year-old ace who won’t significantly cash in because of the new collective bargaining agreement, most teams will kick the tires on the flamethrowing Otani during the offseason. The Braves could be among those clubs, though they’re in an especially disadvantageous position from an international spending standpoint. Where Otani will sign is extremely difficult to forecast, especially when factoring in his offensive prowess. For instance, will he strongly consider heading to the National League, where his only at-bats are likely to come on days he pitches and in pinch-hitting situations? That’s not a concern with Tanaka – who, unlike ace-caliber free agents-to-be in Yu Darvish and Jake Arrieta, is on the right side of 30. Set to turn 29 in November, Tanaka won’t come cheap, as vacating his pact with the Yankees would mean leaving $67MM on the table.
Whether it’s one of the above starters or another high-end type, the front of the rotation is certainly an area worth addressing for the Braves. The club’s starters rank 22nd in the majors in fWAR (6.7) – a good portion of that (1.5) came from now-Yankee Jaime Garcia, whose final Braves start was back on July 21 – and 23rd in ERA (4.89).
2.) Upgrade at third base:
The performance of Johan Camargo has prevented third base from being a complete disaster this year for Atlanta, but continuing to count on him would be a gamble. While the 23-year-old rookie has given the Braves respectable production (.303/.336/.474 in 225 plate appearances), it’s smoke and mirrors to a large degree. Camargo’s .373 batting average on balls in play isn’t going to last, and his success has come in spite of a K/BB ratio (.23) that’s well below the league average (.40). Further, as Statcast shows (via Baseball Savant), Camargo’s expected weighted on-base average (.299) pales in comparison to his actual wOBA (.347).
Fortunately for the Braves, there will be more proven options available in free agency. The length of a potential commitment they make at the hot corner could depend in part on how far away the Braves think prospects Kevin Maitan and Austin Riley are. For example, if they’re counting on either to come up in the next couple years, that could rule out Royals slugger Mike Moustakas, who will easily score the largest contract among impending free agent third basemen. Less expensive choices will include Todd Frazier, Eduardo Nunez and, if he’s willing to move from shortstop to third, Zack Cozart. Frazier or Cozart would provide some punch to a Braves lineup that ranks 27th in ISO (.152), while Nunez would give a team in need of a baserunning boost a notable jolt in that area. Nunez also happens to be an above-average hitter, and the Braves don’t have enough of those.
The trade route could also be a viable avenue, with Chase Headley (Yankees), Jed Lowrie (Athletics) and Asdrubal Cabrera (Mets) standing out as Band-Aid types who might end up on the block in the offseason.
3.) Improve the corner outfield:
Center fielder Ender Inciarte has been terrific during his two years as a Brave, but they haven’t given him adept complements in either season. That’s going to change sometime soon when all-world prospect Ronald Acuna comes to the majors, but the Braves could still use at least one better corner outfielder in the meantime.
While Matt Kemp and Nick Markakis would’ve made for an appealing duo several years ago, their days as decent starters appear long gone. Those two have combined for just 0.4 fWAR this year, making them the main culprits behind the Atlanta outfield’s 29th-place ranking in that category (2.1). The Braves’ nine non-Inciarte outfielders have combined for minus-0.6 fWAR. Even including Inciarte’s production, 26 individual major league outfielders have matched or bettered the output of the Braves’ group of 10.
All of the above is to say that the Braves need to stop living in the past with at least one of the Kemp-Markakis tandem. The problem is that they may be stuck with the pair. Kemp, who will turn 33 next Saturday, is owed $21.5MM per year through 2019. The Braves would likely have to swallow nearly that entire sum to have any hope of moving him. It would be easier (but still difficult) to deal the soon-to-be 34-year-old Markakis, who’s the better and cheaper of the two (he’s due $10.5MM in 2018, the final season of his contract). Continuing with Markakis as a regular until Acuna debuts at some point in 2018 wouldn’t be catastrophic – at least he still gets on base – but adding another corner man should still be a priority.
Among impending free agents, Jarrod Dyson stands out as a clear upgrade who wouldn’t require the Braves to break the bank. Dyson will turn 34 next summer and doesn’t offer much as a hitter, which are concerns, but the current Mariners center fielder is outstanding on the bases and with the glove. It just so happens that the Braves need help in those areas.
Alternatively, Andrew McCutchen (Pirates), Avisail Garcia (White Sox), Brett Gardner (Yankees) and Stephen Piscotty (Cardinals), to name a few, may be worth looking into as possible trade candidates.
[RELATED: Braves News & Rumors On Facebook]
ilikebaseball 2
Does it really make sense to trade away top young talent for a starter heading into arbitration in a year (Fulmer) and the ML team has yet to make any really strides on the field? 65-75 wins you’re really in crapshoot territory depending on a lot of other factors than just the talent on the field.
Why shoot yourself in the foot before the race has begun? Why go through a rebuild and acquire young talent and then trade it away before you even see what you have? The Cubs signed some big talent in Lester and saw on-field success and then traded, while Astros waited for its talent to produce a winner before giving up a ton of young talent. Good models to follow.
bigcubsfan
Yaarggggggggggg ahoy mat3y how goes the hunt for treasurers?
UpUpnHeaHea
Don’t forget Fulmer is out with an arm injury !!
darkstar61
“The Braves need to stop living in the past…”
Could have just put a period there and made it #1
ATL_ranger
I think the braves are rather forward thinking seeing as they only have kemp because he was a better option than a guy who beat women
ReverieDays
Tanaka isn’t a front-line starter.
bravesbornandbred
I’m pretty sure Matt Kemp is owed $21,5 million a year in each of the two following years.
The $18 million figure is what the Braves are out of pocket after accounting for the money sent over from the Padres (which had previously been received by the Padres from the Dodgers). That $10 million amortized over the time the Braves have Kemp works out to roughly $3.5 million a year, but the actual amount due Kemp has never changed.
Contract details:
baseballprospectus.com/compensation/cots/national-…
Baseball Reference salary breakdown ($2 million signing bonus amortized over the 8 year deal increases annual salary hit by $250K):
baseball-reference.com/players/k/kempma01.shtml#br…::none
Spotrac shows actual salaries, less money sent by SD, and partial season salaries paid by trade partner (adjusted salary is amount due by current team):
spotrac.com/mlb/atlanta-braves/matt-kemp-469/
willi
I don’t care if Kemp is owned a penny , at this stage of his career he needs to get moved too an American League Team ASAP !
kbarr888
The Padres made out like a Bandit…..I think. It’s a little confusing, but here’s what I think happened.
In December of 2014…..the Padres got Kemp and $32 million. They paid him his salary for 1.5 years (basically, the $32 million that they got from the Dodgers).
Then, in July 2016…..they turn around and trade Kemp and 10.5 million to the Braves. They actually paid $10.5 million to have Kemp for 1.5 years (about $7 million/yr)….plus they escaped paying another $36 million in payroll for Kemp (Kemp’s salary – $64.5 million over the next 3 years…..minus Olivera’s salary – $28.5 million over the same time frame)
Am I missing something? Great Deal For The Padres…..
AndThisGameBelongsToMySanDiegoPadres
You’re missing that they would be better off if they had never traded for Kemp in the first place
black69
Yeah….they took on and cut Olivera. Add that $28.5 million to the $10.5. It’s $39 mil. That’s what they paid for 46 homers over 254 games.
black69
So, yea, they made out like a bandit. They got caught, and now they’re paying the price.
agentx
Dyson will be a popular lower-cost speed-and-defense name this coming offseason, but won’t it be likely to get more value for less money out of Leonys Martin if he’s non-tendered or even Maybin?
Phillies2017
If you want honesty, the Braves are better off waiting for Allard and Soroka- both could be ready next year.
bravesfan
That’s might thought exactly. I see no need to go grab a front line starter quite yet. Our pitching is by far our weakness, but it’s not just the starters, it’s easily the bullpen as well.. our system appears to have a lot of guys knocking on the door. Let’s wait it out. No need to spend a lot on pitching quite yet.
coachfred64
A change at manager and a dose of reality are 2 more of their needs. Markakis needs to go regardless of whatever other moves are made…Ron Washington should be elevated to manager.
Brooks5Robinson
I agree 100% on wash being manager. He has a way of getting guys to have fun.
stymeedone
Other than the pundits speculation, there has been no indication that Fulmer is on the market. The Tigers already have that talented starter that the Braves lack, which can only increase the speed of the rebuild. The Tigers have the financial resources the Braves lack, and their worst record in baseball to World Series rebuild only took 3 years, last time. Plus, with their TV contract coming up, a long term rebuild does not seem to be an option. If Fulmer is to be moved, it will probably be after the TV contract is signed, because it looks much quicker to contention with him than without him. I just don’t see him being moved over the next year.
The White Sox moved both Sale and Quintana after showing their ineptness to build around them. That does not make it a trend, or even a wise decision. Considering the front office that made the decision to do so, why would any other front office choose to copy them?
RunDMC
These are all needs but I’d suggest 3(b) would be bullpen. ATL ranks 25 of 30 (13/15 NL) in bullpen ERA. There are a slew of young guns in waiting led by AJ Minter who should be up come spring training, but Johnson still has another year with Viz looking like the closest thing to a closer despite less hiccups than Johnson. There’s still a lot of questions with Blair, Wisler they’re using costly roster spots to allow them to step up before making a decision rather than rostering more experienced bullpen arms. Our backend pen is okay, but the setup is a nightmare. We don’t need a Venter/O’Flaherty as much as we don’t need Krol and others.
UpUpnHeaHea
Newsflash: Minter is with the team now !!
RunDMC
You’re right, I meant being an impact player, which he is not really able to do considering this is his cup of coffee now (@ 8.2 IP).
southi
Unfortunately the Braves still (to my knowledge) haven’t allowed Minter to pitch on back to back days due to medical reasons. Unless I’ve missed it, Minter hasn’t done so his whole professional career. He has however pitched quite well and has not walked anyone in 10 games now since coming to Atlanta.
41em
I agree with those three as the Braves’ top needs. Given how poorly Wisler, Blair and Foltynewicz have developed, and given how iffy Newcomb and Sims still are; finding a front line starter is their biggest need. I just hope the Braves stop throwing money at veteran, mediocre starters.
The Braves’ front office needs patience while their prospects develop. 2019 is a much more realistic goal for being a contender than 2018. By 2019, Austin Riley will likely be ready to take over at third and Gohara, Soroka, Allard and others will likely become quality starters.
Unloading Kemp and Markakis while paying down their contracts is a worthy expenditure. Acuna will be ready in 2018 and even someone like Lane Adams would be a decent alternative to Kemp, as Adams can at least run and field his position (though I hope the Braves find a better left fielder via trade).
JFactor
Is playing Freeman at third not a real option for them? I know he played there a bit this year, but hasn’t in awhile.
RunDMC
Adams has come back down to earth, which was the reason for the move. Without that, there really is no reason. The whole idea was a ruse to sell high on Adams, and no one has bitten (or will bite based on how ATL overvalues Matt Adams). Until he fields and hits southpaws better, he’s not even a DH.
CT
That experiment ended very quickly when they realized Matt Adams is not good enough at 1st, to warrant Freeman moving to 3rd.
JFactor
Thanks.
Couldn’t they land a 1B if the 3B market doesn’t generate them a reasonable player this off-season? Is Freeman capable of being a long term 3B, or would they rather not mess with him?
RunDMC
Why would you risk moving Freeman over to 3B when we have more long term depth at 3B (Riley, Maitan, Camargo) and short term looks to be easier to fill with Mous being the top option?
Braves fan 4
I don’t agree with dmc much but in this I do
RunDMC
Go have a Dos Equis on me.
Matt Galvin
Ruiz at 3B. Alex Jackson in OF?
WAH1447
That’s got to be a joke
ffjsisk
The Braves need to sign 2 starters, and not the Dickey, Colon type. My preference is Arietta and a second tier guy like Lynn. If/when these young guys develop you can make trades to open up spots for them. Kemp needs to go for sure, he is starting to look like Cecil Fielder. I’m scared to see what another offseason does to his body. Trade Markakis too, use whatever salary savings you get to sign Moustakas. Trade surplus minor league pitching for a young left fielder. I know that’s a lot of salary to add but with the new park I’m sure the Braves can afford to bump it up. A lineup with Ozzie, Acuna, Dansby, Freeman, Inciarte, Moustakas and Flowers is very competitive. Make a move or two in the pen and you can compete.
terry g
In order to trade Kemp and/or Markakis they’ll have to eat most of their salary. The little salary they save won’t even come close to what they need to add Moustakas.
willi
Move them both , Regardless ,or stop complaining about Bad Defensive Play .
afenton530
Pull a Pirates and trade a good prospect with the two outfielders to someone for nothing then spend some cash
chesteraarthur
“I know that’s a lot of salary to add but with the new park I’m sure the Braves can afford to bump it up.”
I don’t think a new stadium lets you add ~ 50m+/yr
ffjsisk
You obviously don’t realize that we will not have to pay Dickey, or Colon 18 million, and Markakis at 10.5. Thats 28 million saved. Not to mention Jaime who we dumped earlier. There will be money.
southi
Dickey is almost as sure a bet to have his cheap option picked up as Tyler Flowers is to his picked up.
chesteraarthur
Where did Markakis go with no salary offset? Did you look at the cost increases in contracts and arbitration? It comes pretty close to offsetting the loss of bartolo money. So no, I do realize that they wont be paying Bartolo. However, I also realize that they will be paying certain players that they retain more in 2018 than they did in 2017.
Those things aside, you are also just completely ignoring the fact that they will be adding that money for more than just 2018.
acmeants
Agree. Dickey has given a decent return and Flowers is the leagues best at framing pitches.
ffjsisk
The only significant arb case is Folty. And you have lost your mind if you think they will have to pay more than a couple million on Markakis. Someone will take him for 1/8. Even if you pay 35 of the 40 Kemp is owed that’s 2.5 off the books for each of the next 2 years. Bartolo, 10. Dickey, 8. Jaime, 11.5. No significant arb case, FF salary only increases 500,000, what specifically am I missing? Oh, and you can always trade Tehran and save more money. I need a specific arb case or escalator that prohibits the Braved from increasing payroll.
acmeants
I like Archer as the ace, although Arrieta isn’t far behind.
Zach725
I wouldn’t mind if they signed Frazier to a 2 yr deal with a mutual option. That takes care of 3rd base, and you can still give camargo plenty of playing time. I think they are stuck with Kemp for now, which means Markakis is likely to be moved. I think they should go after Alex Cobb and get some legit relief pitchers too. That gives you a lineup of
1 Inciarte
2 Albies
3 Freeman
4 Frazier/Kemp
5 Frazier/Kemp
6 Acuna
7 Flowers
8 Swanson
acmeants
Braves have more than three needs starting with manager. Time to give Ron Washington the reins. After that they need an ace at the front of the rotation. They need to replace one of the corner outfielders. Really don’t care which one, but if they can work a deal with an AL club where he can DH, Kemp is the obvious. They might get said team to take on salary if it’s a salary swap or they include a couple of good prospects who sit behind Swanson, Albies, Inciarte or Freeman on the depth chart. Acuna will be there soon and I think they can hold on with what they’ve got he comes up. Jace Peterson can go as well. Kick Teheran, Jim Johnson and most of the bullpen to the curb. They have lost too many games that the Braves could have won if they had been able to hold leads and close games. They would be over 500 this season if the bullpen had been decent.
dwilson10
If the O’s consider moving Machado this offseason, I wonder if the Braves would push hard for him? The only thing is they would have to give up at least Albies, Allard or Soroka, Gohara or Wentz, and probably another lower player or 2.
billdale
I’d love to have Machado too, but his contract is up after the 2018 season and would cost quite a bit. That’s a move we make if we have more established SP, but I don’t think it would be wise to expend resources to go after a guy when we aren’t really “competitors” yet. Maybe they pursue him after he hits FA and make him a franchise guy? I think they would stick to home grown talent over a FA though.
southi
Machado is a great player but giving up a ton of talent to acquire him for only one season won’t be a smart move at all for the team.
acmeants
I’ll keep Albies and Gohara, thank you.
deweyj
It does seem at times the braves can not make up there mind which way to go we have some some pitchers who will never make it except for bullpen at best our assessment of talent makes you wonder we need and ace period Julio would be much better as a 2 or 3 not sure why we can’t see that
acmeants
Julio would be much better in a different uniform. He is woefully inconsistent.
mlb1225
I think a move to The American League for Kemp would benefit him. His defense has been on a steady decline, but his offense has still been above average. If it weren’t for hamstring issues throughout the year his offensive numbers would probably look better. A place where he can DH, more than play outfield would help him. I could see The Yankees showing some interest in the off-season, since Matt Holliday’s contract is up after the year, and The Astros, because Beltran’s contract is going to expire as well.
acmeants
Kemp has actually made some spectacular plays as long as the ball is in front of him. He doesn’t have the legs to go back on the ball or get much lateral movement.
BNC
Reporter: What’d you do this year Nick Markakis?
Nick: You know, played every day, got 160 hits, 75 RBI, got paid a fair salary and still had everyone trying to run me out of town.
chesteraarthur
And played sub par defense with a below average offensive output. A 750 ops with bad defense does not make a good corner outfielder. But continue to only look at things that fit your narrative!
bravesfan
The irony chesteraarthur is you continue to find stats to fit your narrative, yet make out like when others do it they are complete idiots. You sir, are a giant troll and need to accept the fact that your stats are underwhelming when it comes to supporting your argument. I’m not a giant markakis fan at this point in his career, but the guy is a good dose of consistency in a lineup that hasn’t necessarily had much to hype about. Sure, he’s prob not the ideal fit for a corner outfield and he’s not flashy, but he’s holding the fort down are a reasonable enough price.
astros_fan_84
Braves fans should be so happy. The rebuild is over. Whether they contend in 2018 or not, they are set.
I endured a long rebuild. My advice: enjoy the upcoming success. Too many of these commenters are bitter.
HiHeat45
Make Ron Washington the manager
garrog1949
Trade with Tigers,,,,,,,,,,,,Kemp,I.Anderson,Ruiz,Muller and Demeritte FOR Fuller,Candelario and G.Moreno. Cancellation is a high ceiling 3B. SP=Gohara,Fuller,Newcombe,Folty,Fried,Teheran.
lesterdnightfly
“Cancellation” is what your proposal deserves.
bravesfan
Yea, I don’t think this is a good offer for either team involved. I think we are overpaying, and the only reason we might not be is cause kemp is in the deal. He is what makes this offer worth less. Tigers are gonna take on an aging fool when they themselves are trying to rebuild. With that said, tigers could actually get more for fulmer. and that’s why I don’t think the braves should go after him. Not worth it to me… my opinion.
Smoltzy16
Braves biggest need…..a better TV contract.
(1) 2 quality SP’s. I’d prefer Lance Lynn & Alex Cobb. (2) Elite bullpen help. We need an anchor that can bridge the gap between the rotation and the back end of the bullpen. (3) Move Kemp to the Yankees along with Foltyniez & 10mil.
Lynn
Teheran
Cobb
Newcombe
Gohara
bravesfan
This is was almost the most insightful input I’ve seen in these comments. Better TV contract,,, YUP! I like how you phrase your #1, QUALITY SP. that’s truly all we need at the moment. No need to go spend a fortune or trade the entire system for flat solid pitching. Yes, we need a true ace, but I honestly believe one of these prospects will eventually develop into that. #2, you’re 100% right that he bullpen is a mess. I disagree with you moving Folty, cause I think he would be a really good bullpen piece. But we need to go get some strong arms to fill the 7th and 8th innings. #3, yes we need to move Kemp. I have no clue how… but to me, he and adams should be move. we will definitely have to eat some cash
Gary Rogers
Trade with Yankees///////??Kemp, F oltynewicz,Muller,Ruiz and R.Sanchez for C.Frazier and Acevedo. Pick up Darvish and go after Otani.
bravesfan
Not really the worse offer ever… but it’s not that great. Braves won’t go get Darvish, You can bank on that. lol